Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 304, I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 304, I.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Palok Basu, J. delivered the opinion in an appeal filed by Kewal Krishna against the judgment and order dated 8-4-1978 of the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Saharanpur. The trial court had convicted the appellant for murder under Section 302, Indian Penal Code, and sentenced him to imprisonment for life, and additionally sentenced him to six months' rigorous imprisonment under Section 323, I.P.C., both sentences to run concurrently.

The prosecution's case, as recited in the opinion, is that on 28-8-1977 the appellant assaulted and killed his wife Smt. Vinod Kumari, who was about nine months pregnant, and caused fatal head injuries. An F.I.R. was lodged by Parvesh Kumar (P.W.3), who, together with other witnesses, brought the appellant to Police Station Mandi with a blood-stained "Sonta". Police investigation included preparation of panchanama, seizure of blood-stained clothes and other blood-stained articles, and sending the dead body for post-mortem. The post-mortem concluded that death was due to head injuries resulting in coma and that the uterus contained a full-term dead male baby.

After investigation and committal proceedings, the case proceeded as Sessions Trial No. 442 of 1977 in the court of the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Saharanpur, where the appellant was convicted and sentenced as above. The appellant appealed to the court which heard counsel for both sides and examined the record before dismissing the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction under Section 302, I.P.C. (murder) and the concurrent sentence imposed by the Sessions Court were supported by reliable and admissible evidence.
  2. Whether the appellant's plea of insanity (mental illness) at the time of the offence was established so as to exculpate or mitigate his criminal responsibility.
  3. Whether the prosecution case suffered from want of motive such that the conviction should be reduced or converted to an offence under Section 304, I.P.C.
  4. Whether the appellant was falsely implicated (claimed enmity) and whether the ocular witnesses' testimony could be trusted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant denied the prosecution case and contended he was falsely implicated due to enmity.
  • The appellant pleaded insanity (mental illness) at the time of the offence and produced defence witnesses (D.W.1 Tara Chand, D.W.2 R. Sharma, and D.W.3 Dr. S.N. Deo) to establish that he was an outdoor patient at the Mental Hospital, Shahdara, between 9-7-1977 and 8-8-1977 and that a certificate of fitness dated 8-8-1977 was issued.
  • It was suggested (on the appellant's behalf) that due to absence of cogent evidence of motive, the court might convert the charge to Section 304, I.P.C., instead of upholding conviction for murder under Section 302.

State / Prosecution's Arguments

  • The prosecution relied on the testimony of three eyewitnesses (Parvesh Kumar P.W.3, Ladika Ram P.W.4, and Kartar Devi P.W.5) who witnessed events, described the appellant armed with a blood-stained Sonta, and identified injuries on the deceased.
  • Prosecution relied upon physical and medical evidence: seizure of blood-stained weapon, clothes and articles; medical examination of a witness (Kartar Devi) showing injuries; and the post-mortem report (P.W.1 Dr. R.K. Arora) concluding death due to head injuries and the presence of a full-term dead male foetus.
  • The prosecution contended that the defence plea of insanity was not established and that the ocular and medical evidence supported conviction for murder under Section 302, I.P.C.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a step-by-step assessment of both the prosecution and defence evidence and reached its conclusion for the following reasons (as set out in the opinion):

  1. Assessment of ocular testimony: The Sessions Judge placed "implicit reliance" on the testimony of the three eye-witnesses (Parvesh Kumar, Ladika Ram, and Kartar Devi). The appellate court found no reason to disbelieve their evidence, noting the absence of any apparent motive to falsely implicate the appellant and observing that cross-examination did not discredit their testimony.
  2. Circumstantial and conduct considerations: The court noted the appellant's behaviour at the scene — remaining inside with the dead body, holding a blood-stained Sonta, and refusing to come out until the police arrived — as consistent with consciousness of guilt and showing calculated conduct rather than incapacity.
  3. Physical and medical evidence: The prosecution's seizures (blood-stained clothing, weapon, and articles) and the post-mortem findings (multiple severe head injuries, depressed comminuted fractures, exposed brain tissue, and the cause of death being coma from head injuries) were accepted as corroborative of the ocular evidence.
  4. Evaluation of the defence plea of insanity: The defence relied on hospital records and testimony that the appellant had been an outdoor patient at a mental hospital shortly before the incident and had received a certificate of fitness on 8-8-1977. The court examined the defence witnesses' evidence, including Dr. Deo's acknowledgement that the ailment could relapse and that without treatment the condition could continue. The court concluded that (a) there was no evidence of treatment after the appellant's arrest, (b) the defence had not proved insanity "to the hilt", and (c) the evidence produced tended to contradict rather than support the claim of insanity.
  5. Rejection of mitigation based on lack of motive: The court rejected the submission that absence of motive warranted reducing the offence to culpable homicide not amounting to murder (Section 304). It reasoned that the nature and severity of the appellant's actions — beating the mother-in-law, forcing her out, bolting the room, and killing the pregnant wife along with the unborn child — demonstrated culpability consistent with murder, irrespective of a clearly proved motive.
  6. Conclusion on guilt: Combining reliable eyewitness testimony, corroborative physical and medical evidence, and the failure of the insanity defence, the court sustained the trial court's finding of guilt and the sentence imposed.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The appellate court dismissed the appeal.

Holding (core ruling): The conviction and concurrent sentences imposed by the trial court (life imprisonment under Section 302, I.P.C., and six months' rigorous imprisonment under Section 323, I.P.C.) were upheld.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant remains convicted and is ordered to serve the sentence awarded by the trial court; the appellate court found no basis to overturn or reduce the conviction.
  • No broader legal change: The opinion upholds the trial court's factual findings and legal application in this case. The court did not announce any new legal principle or cite precedent to alter existing law; it applied established standards for assessing ocular evidence, corroboration by medical and material evidence, and the demanding standard of proof for insanity pleas.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not include information from any external sources.

    Kewal Krishna v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .

    Palok Basu, J.:— This appeal has been filed by Kewal Krishna against the judgment and order dated 8-4-1978 passed by the IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Saharanpur, convicting the appellant and sentencing him to imprisonment for life under Section 302 and to six months rigorous imprisonment under S. 323, I.P.C Both the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

    2. The prosecution case is that Kewal Krishna was married to Smt. Vinod Kumari. One child was already about 2 years old and on 28-8-1977 Smt. Vinod Kumari was carrying the second child which had reached about 9 months of its existence. Kewal Krishna had come to stay with the in laws in Pratap Nagar Colony within Police Station Mandi, distt. Saharanpur. It is said that on 28-8-1977 at about 5 p.m Parvesh Kumar brought his brother-in-law i.e the appellant Kewal Krishna along with a blood stained Sonta to the Police Station Mandi, Saharanpur along with some witnesses. An F.I.R was lodged by Parvesh Kumar (P.W 3) to the following effect (Translated into English by the Court):

    “I Parvesh Kumar live in Pratap Nagar Colony, Saharanpur. My brother-in-law (Bahnoi) Kewal Krishna Suri is employed in Anti-Biotics Factory, Rishikesh to whom my sister Vinod Kumari was married. He had come to stay at ours with my sister. Due to strike in the factory, both were staying at ours. Quite often my brother-in-law used to be annoyed with my sister and we used to pacify him. My sister, brother-in-law and their two years' old son Avanish Kumar and my mother Kartar Devi were in the house. At about 4.30 p.m I had gone to ease in the latrine. I heard shrieks of my mother ‘Bachao, Bacho’. I came out quickly and saw that the door of the room was closed from inside and my mother was knocking on it asking to open the door and from inside the room the shrieks of my sister ‘Bachao, Bachao’ were coming out. My mother told me that since I had gone to the latrine, Kewal Krishna started beating Vinod Kumari and when she went to save her inside the room she was beaten and pushed out of the room whereafter the room was locked from inside and beating of Smt. Vinod Kumari continued. We shouted at which Ladika Ram, Jagdish Prasad, Harbansh Lal Malhotra and Yograj etc arrived where all attempted to get the door opened but failed. We climbed the adjoining room and from the ventilator peeped inside and saw that Kewal Krishna was standing with the Sonta in his hand and when we asked him to open the door he said unless the Police would arrive he would not open the door. Shortly Dewanji and three police constables of the Police Outpost arrived and after great persuasion Kewal Krishna opened the door. We found Smt. Vinod Kumari lying on the floor drenched in blood, having several injuries. Kewal Krishna was standing with the Sonta in his hand which was smeared with blood. His clothes were also stained with blood. My sister was pregnant and the period was almost complete. I got my brother-in-law arrested by the Police, took the Sonta and asked him why did he do this upon which he said she was my wife. I have killed her because she did not heed to what I was saying. My brother-in-law has killed my sister by causing her injuries because of mutual misunderstanding. We have brought-him to the Police Station having arrested him with the help of the police people along with the Sonta”.

    3. This F.I.R was lodged at 5 p.m in the presence of P.W 8 Inspector Ram Singh who took up the investigation and left for the place of occurrence along with Chaman Singh S.I (P.W 6). Under the directions of Ram Singh, the said Chaman Singh preferred the Panchayatnama, diagram and chatlan of the body (Ex. Ka-6 to Ka-8). The dead body was sealed and sent through constable Bashir Ahmad and Chandrapal for post mortem examination. Blood stained Kurta, Pyajama and dhoti of the accused were also taken, apart from taking into custody ordinary bloodstained earth.

    4. Apart from those, blood stained pieces of bangles, blood-stained cover of the bed, blood stained nose-pin of the deceased were also taken. Ornaments of the deceased were handed over to Parvesh Kumar in Supurdg A site plan Ex. Ka-19 was prepared and then interrogation of Parvesh Kumar (P.W 3), Ladika Ram (P.W 4) and Smt. Kartar Devi (P.W 5) was done whereafter Smt. Kartar Devi was sent to the hospital for medical examination, where she was examined by P.W 2 Dr. G.S Gupta at 9.45 p.m who found the following injuries:—

    1. Abraded contusion 4 cm × 1 cm left forearm on back in middle with traumatic swelling 8 cm. × 6 cm. around it. Kept under observation. Advised X-Ray.

    (ii) Lacerated wound 1 cm. × 5 cm × skin deep left side elbow.

    (iii) Abrasion. 5 cm ×. 25 cm × on left indes finger on back lower part.

    (iv) Contusion 6 cm × 2 cm on dorsum of right thumb.

    5. In the opinion of the doctor all the injuries were simple (except injury No. 1), caused by blunt object, except injury No. 3 which was caused by friction. Duration fresh. P.W 1 Dr. R.K Arora conducted the postmortem examination on the dead body of Smt. Vinod Kumari on 28-9-1977 at 4 p.m and found the body in the following condition and injuries:

    “(1) Lacerated wound 9 cm × 3 cm × bone deep on right side forehead near the hair line with depressed comminuted fracture of underlying bone with swelling around. Brain tissue is exposed. Whole of the face is covered with clotted blood.

    (2) Lacerated wound 6 cm. × 2.5 cm × bone deep on the right side head 8 cms above the right ear with swelling around. Clotted blood present around.

    (3) Contusion 5.5 cm × 3 cms on the right side face near the jaw.

    (4) Irregular contusion 8 cms × 5 cms on the right side chest upper part near the root of the neck.

    (5) Lacerated wound 1.5 cm × ¼ cm × muscle deep on left upper eyelid.

    (6) Lacerated wound 1 cm × 2.5 cms. × whole thickness of both upper and lower lips on right side with fracture of both upper and lower jaw bones on right side. The two upper incisor teeth on right side and of lower incisor and one teeth of lower right side from their sockets.

    (7) Contusion 5 cms × 3.5 cms on the front right shoulder joint.

    (8) Contusion 12 cms × 3 cms on the upper part of abdomen trans vers ally.

    6. Both the lungs were conjested the heart was empty and its weight was 230 grams. There was depressed communited fracture right frontal and partietal bone. The abdomen was distanded due to advanced stage of pregnancy. The stomach contained about 8 oz. of semi solid substance. The brain was lacerated and congested. Both intestines contained some faecal matter. The gall bladder was half full, its wight was 1 kg and 100 gram. Both the kidneys were conjested and its weight was 230 grams. The uterus contained full time (about 9 months) Dead male baby.

    7. In the opinion of the doctor the death was due to coma as a result of head injuries.

    8. After completing the investigation the charge sheet (Ex. Ka-20) was submitted against the appellant. After due commuttal proceedings the C.J.M Saharanpur commutted the case to the court of Sessions which became subject-matter of Sessions Trial No. 442 of 1977 of the court of IV Additional District and Sessions Judge, Saharanpur. The appellant was found guilty of the charge and convicted and sentenced as stated above.

    9. We have heard Sri D.N Wali learned counsel for the appellant and Sri Shivaji Misra, learned A.G.A for the State and perused the entire record minutely.

    10. During the trial the prosecution has examined three eye-witnesses. They are Parvesh Kumar (P.W 3), Ladika Ram (P.W 4) and Kartar Devi (P.W 5). Reference about other formal witnesses has already been noted above and it may be stated that head constable Laxmi Chand (P.W 7) had registered the case and made necessary entries in the general diary and has proved them.

    11. The accused has denied the prosecution case and has attributed false implication due to enmity. This apart plea of insanity has been taken and in order to justify the said plea D.W 1 Tara Chand, D.W 2 M.R Sharma and Dr. S.N Deo (D.W 3) have been examined.

    12. The learned Sessions Judge has placed implicit reliance on the prosecution evidence and rejected the defence version and has come to the conclusion that the defence plea of insanity has not been established at all and has further held that the prosecution story about the beating of Smt. Vinod Kumari by the appellant in the manner alleged by the prosecution witnesses is wholly reliable and proved.

    13. There is absolutely no reason whatsoever for the mother in-law, the brother-in-law and an immediate neighbour who is aged about 60 years, to falsely implicate the appellant. In the very nature of the things of action of the appellant in killing his wife is so reprehensible that it disturbs the conscience of any sensible human being. Smt. Vinod Kumari was carrying a child of nine months in the womb and even the first child of the said couple was in the neighbourhood and yet having first beaten his own mother-in-law and thrown her out of the room and then having bolted the same from inside, the appellant committed the heartless crime, There is nothing in the cross-examination of any of the three witnesses to discredit their testimony. None of them has any axe to grind against the appellant. Then sitting tight with the dead body of the wife in front of him inside the room and refusing to come out until the Police comes indicates the apprehension in the mind of the appellant that if he were to come out without police being there, he may be similarly dealt with and may receive injuries at the hands of the witnesses who had arrived and particularly his brother-in-law. That being so, his own instincts of self-preservation were so apparent in his mind that his action in killing his own wife can only be discredited as a well calculated action. There is absolutely no reason to disbelieve that the appellant was caught at the spot along with arm smeared with human blood and then brought to the police station by those witnesses after the police had arrived at the scene of occurrence and had managed to get the door opened after a lot of persuasion. It is, therefore, apparent that the prosecution case is truthful and the learned trial Judge has rightly placed reliance on their testimony.

    14. The defence evidence of the appellant requires consideration now. D.W 1 Tara Chand is clerk in the Mental Hospital, Shahadra. He has said that the appellant was an outdoor patient there from 9-7-1977 to 8-8-1977. D.W 2 Mr. R. Sharma is a Junior Assistant in the I.D.P.L Rishikesh. He has said that the appellant was on duty on 7-7-1977 whereafter he had gone on leave for four days and then he did not come to join. He proved an application dated 14-7-1977 (Ex. 11 along with a medical certificate (Ex. 12), purporting to be an application by the appellant suggesting that he was an outdoor patient in the Mental Hospital Shahadra. The services of the appellant was terminated on 14-11-1977 due to continued absence. D.W 3 Dr. S.N Deo is a Psychiatrist in the Mental Hospital, Shahadra. He has said that the appellant was suffering from mental disease and was and out-door patient in the mental hospital Shahadra between July 9 and August 8, 1977 and he proved that relevant extract as Ex. Ka 3. He also proved the certificate of fitness Ex. Kha 4 dated 8-8-1977. According to the statement of D.W 3 Dr. Deo he had issued the fitness certificate on 8-8-1977 and the appellant was only an out-door patient. He has further said that the appellant was a nonviolent patient and had regularly responded to the treatment. From the statement of Tara Chand D.W 1 it appears that the accused had gone to the hospital for out-door treatment on July, 11, 14, 18, 25, and August 8, 1977. In cross-examination Dr. Deo has said that the ailment could relapse. He has further said that if after such relapsing, the patient does a crime like murder, then the said condition would continue until he is treated again. This statment of the doctor is acceptable for the reason that if any mental aberration had taken place that would not have gone without any treatment and admittedly no treatment whatsoever was extended to the appellant after he was arrested and put behind the bars after having committed the murder of his wife. There is, therefore, not an iota of evidence suggesting that the action of the appellant was accentuated by any mental aberration much less insanity. The law is well settled that if an accused takes the plea of insanity he has to prove it to the hilt. In the instant case not only that the appellant has not been able to prove it; the evidence produced in fact goes contrary to his claim of insanity. It was suggested that since there is no motive in the instant case the case may be converted to Section 304, I.P.C It is difficult to accept this argument. The appellant had caused injuries to his mother-in-law and when she had protested and tried to save her daughter she was thrown out of the room forcibly. Then having bolted the room from inside the appellant rendered the pregnant woman helpless and brought cruel end to her life as also terminated the life of the male child she was carrying for the last nine months in her womb. Therefore, there is no question of doubting the prosecution story even if there is no cogent evidence about motive.

    15. So unhusband like and unfather like are the actions of Kewal Krishna and that too in so much a calculated manner that it has to be held that Kewal Krishna was absolutely alert and in his senses and executed a well planned murder of his wife with a nine month old child in her womb. In view of the aforesaid discussion this appeal fails and is hereby dismissed. The appellant is in jail and he will serve out the sentence awarded to him by the trial court.

    16. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kewal Krishna v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .
    (Feb 27, 1992)