AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a student's petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a writ of certiorari to quash two orders dated 31-12-75 and 11-5-76 passed by the Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad (Board of High School and Intermediate Education U.P., Allahabad). The petitioner, Ajai Kumar Srivastava, had appeared in the Intermediate Final Examination 1974-75 (Mathematics Group), roll number 157667, examination centre Niblet Islamia Inter College, Bara Banki. The result was published in a special issue of the Pioneer at Lucknow on 6-7-76 showing the petitioner as having passed in Second Division.

After publication, the Board directed the principal of the petitioner’s college to withhold his marksheet and issued a charge-sheet alleging suspicion of use of unfair means in answering Question No. 6 (Ga) of Physics 1st Paper — the petitioner’s solution arrived at the correct result but omitted one step. The petitioner replied that the omission was due to inadvertence and shortage of time, not copying. A Screening Committee concluded that unfair means had been used; that finding was accepted by the Board’s Sub-Committee, and the petitioner’s result was cancelled (the opinion contains a reference to cancellation on 31-12-1976 and also refers elsewhere to the impugned orders dated 31-12-75 and 11-5-76). The petitioner’s representation to the Chairman was rejected (rejection dated in the opinion as 11-6-1976). The petitioner filed the present petition in the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, in exercise of Article 226, can issue a writ of certiorari to quash the Board's orders cancelling the petitioner’s examination result for alleged use of unfair means.
  2. Whether the Board’s decision cancelling the petitioner’s result was supported by any direct or circumstantial evidence sufficient to justify such a drastic step.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The cancellation of the petitioner’s result on the ground that unfair means were used was not based on any evidence whatsoever.
  • The omission of one step in the solution could have occurred by inadvertence or shortage of time and did not necessarily indicate copying or use of unfair means.
  • The Board had earlier decided to release results of other candidates who omitted one or two steps in solving questions of the Physics 1st Paper of 1975, but it discriminated against the petitioner by cancelling his result.
  • The petitioner’s seat location made copying unlikely; none of the examinees seated near him were charged; he was not caught red-handed and no unauthorized material was recovered from him.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The Screening Committee had concluded that the petitioner had adopted unfair means in solving Question No. 6 (Ga) of Physics 1st Paper, and that finding was rightly accepted by the concerned Sub-Committee of the Board.
  • Accordingly, the Board maintained that cancellation of the petitioner’s result was proper (as set out in the counter-affidavit).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Board of High School and Intermediate Education U.P. Allahabad v. Ghanshyam Das Gupta (AIR 1962 SC 1110) Establishes that the Examination Committee of the Board acts quasi-judicially when dealing with cases of examinees using unfair means. The Court relied on this and similar authorities to confirm that it has supervisory jurisdiction by certiorari over the Board's quasi-judicial actions where circumstances justify interference.
Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. Allahabad v. Bagleshwar Prasad (AIR 1966 SC 875) Supports that the Board acts quasi-judicially and that certiorari may lie; also cited for the proposition that the High Court may quash an order not supported by any evidence, subject to consideration of probabilities and circumstantial evidence. The Court applied this principle to determine whether the Board's cancellation was supported by any evidence at all and to remind that the High Court's role is supervisory, not appellate.
Board of High School & Intermediate Education U. P. v. Kumari Chittra Srivastava (AIR 1970 SC 1039) Affirms the quasi-judicial character of the Board in unfair-means cases. Used with other authorities to frame the scope of the High Court’s jurisdiction to issue certiorari in such matters.
Prabhat Kumar v. Board of High School & Intermediate Education U. P. (1971 All LJ 1391) Supports the view that the Board's actions are quasi-judicial in the context of unfair-means proceedings. The Court cited this as part of the body of authority establishing the nature of the Board's functions and the availability of certiorari.
Mushtaq Husain v. Secretary Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. (AIR 1973 All 537) Again supports the quasi-judicial nature of the Board in handling unfair-means cases. Relied on as part of the precedential framework permitting judicial review of Board decisions in appropriate cases.
Triambak Pati Tripathi v. Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. Allahabad (AIR 1973 All 1 (FB)) Reiterates that the High Court does not sit in appeal over decisions of the authority but may quash an order not supported by any evidence after considering probabilities and circumstantial evidence. The Court invoked this authority when applying the test of whether the Board's conclusion was supported by any direct or circumstantial evidence.
Swarn Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1976 SC 232) Explains the limits of certiorari: certiorari corrects errors of jurisdiction; the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction is different from appellate jurisdiction and generally cannot reopen findings of fact derived from appreciation of evidence. The Court used this principle to define the boundary of its review: it would not act as an appellate court but could intervene if the Board's order lacked evidentiary support or involved illegality resulting in substantial failure of justice.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded step-by-step as follows, relying only on the material and authorities reflected in the opinion:

  1. Jurisdiction: The Court confirmed that it has jurisdiction under Article 226 to issue prerogative writs, including certiorari, against persons and authorities within its jurisdiction for redress of substantial injury caused by contraventions of law or illegality in proceedings (para. 4).
  2. Scope and Limits: The Court recalled authorities (notably Swarn Singh) stating that certiorari is supervisory, not appellate, and that findings of fact from appreciation of evidence are generally not to be reopened in writ proceedings (paras. 5–6).
  3. Test to Apply: The Court cited precedents (Bagleshwar Prasad, Triambak Pati Tripathi) emphasizing that while the High Court does not sit in appeal, it may quash an order which is not supported by any evidence after considering whether probabilities and circumstantial evidence justify that conclusion (para. 8).
  4. Application to Facts: The Court examined whether the Board's decision cancelling the petitioner’s result was supported by any direct or circumstantial evidence. The Court summarized undisputed factual material in the petition and the counter-affidavit: the petitioner’s seat position made copying unlikely; no candidate near him was charged; he was not caught red-handed; no unauthorized material was recovered; there was no allegation of mass copying at the centre; and no direct evidence was placed before the Screening Committee (para. 6).
  5. Consideration of Examiner's Conduct: The Court noted that the examiner who marked the petitioner’s copy awarded 2 out of 2½ marks for the question and did not report suspicion at the time, implying that if the examiner had suspected unfair means, the examiner should have reported and the Board should have withheld the result before publication (para. 7).
  6. Central Basis of the Board's Decision: The Court identified that the sole circumstance relied upon by the Board’s sub-committee was the petitioner’s omission of one step in the solution to Question No. 6 (Ga) and observed that such an omission could be due to inadvertence (paras. 8–9).
  7. Conclusion on Evidence: The Court concluded there was "absolutely no material" before the committee to conclude that unfair means were adopted. Consequently, the Board’s decision caused substantial injury and was illegal and unjust (para. 9).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition is allowed. The Court issued a writ of certiorari quashing the two disputed orders dated 31-12-75 and 11-5-76 and directed the opposite party to declare that the petitioner had passed the Intermediate Final Examination (Mathematics Group) of 1974-75 in Second Division. The petitioner was awarded costs against the opposite party (para. 10).

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate consequence is that the Board's two orders withholding and cancelling the petitioner’s result are quashed, the petitioner’s result must be declared as passed in Second Division, and the petitioner is entitled to costs from the Board.
  • Broader implications: The opinion applies existing precedents to delineate the supervisory role of the High Court in reviewing quasi-judicial decisions of examination authorities; the opinion does not state that it creates any new precedent beyond applying established principles. The decision turns on a factual finding that the Board's cancellation was unsupported by any direct or circumstantial evidence in the record before it.

    Ajai Kumar v. The Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad Opposite Party.

    1. This is a student's petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issuing a writ of certiorari quashing the orders dated 31-12-75 and 11-5-76 passed by the opposite party, namely, the Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad or the Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. at Allahabad, The petitioner has further prayed for issuing any other appropriate writ, order or direction against the opposite party for declaring the petitioner's result of Intermediate Final Examination, 1975 which examination he is said to have passed, in Second Division.

    2. The undisputed facts of the case, giving rise to this petition, are that the opposite party is a statutory body created under the U. P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921. Its function is to conduct High School and Intermediate Examination in the State. Ajai Kumar Srivastava, petitioner had appeared at the Intermediate Final Examination of the year 1974-75, His subjects were of Mathematics Group. The petitioner's roll number in that examination was 157667 and his examination centre was Niblet Islamia Inter College, Bara Banki. The result of that examination was published in the special issue of the Pioneer at Lucknow on 6-7-76 wherein the petitioner was shown as having passed in Second Division. Immediately thereafter the opposite party directed the Principal of the petitioner's College to withhold his marks sheet. A charge-sheet was issued to the petitioner informing him that he was suspected of having used unfair means while solving question No. 6 (Ga) of physics 1st Paper as the result of that question arrived at by the petitioner was correct, but one step was missing from the solution whereby the petitioner had arrived at that result. The petitioner submitted a reply wherein he pleaded that one step of the solution was missed by him due to inadvertence and shortage of time which was at his disposal and it was not the result of copying or adopting any unfair means. A Screening Committee was appointed by the opposite party to look into the matter. It came to the conclusion that unfair means were adopted by the petitioner in solving the aforesaid question of physics 1st paper. That finding of the screening committee was accepted by the sub-committee of the Board which was constituted for dealing with the cases of candidates suspected of adopting unfair means at the examination. The petitioner's result was consequently cancelled by the opposite party on 31-12-1976. The petitioner submitted a representation before the Chairman of the opposite party which was rejected on 11-6-1976. The petitioner has now come to this court with the present petition.

    3. The main grievance of the petitioner is that the decision of the opposite party cancelling petitioner's result, with a finding that unfair means were used by the petitioner while answering question No. 16 (Ga) of physics 1st paper, was not based upon any evidence whatsoever. It has also been alleged by him that a decision was earlier taken by the opposite party to release the results of candidates who had omitted to mention one or two steps in solving questions of Intermediate physics 1st paper of 1975. As a result of that decision many other candidates, who had committed such mistakes, were already exonerated by the Board, but discrimination was shown by it in the casa of the petitioner. These allegations of the petitioner have been denied by the opposite party. In the counter-affidavit it is maintained that the finding of the screening committee regarding use of unfair means by the petitioner while solving question No. 6 (Ga) of physics 1st paper was correct and the concerned Sub-Committee of the opposite party had rightly cancelled the petitioner's result,

    4. It cannot be denied that this Court had jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution to issue prerogative writs, including a writ of certiorari, to persons and authorities within its jurisdiction for the redress of any injury of a substantial nature by reason of the contravention of any of the provisions of the Constitution, or any enactment or ordinance etc., or by reason of any illegality in any proceedings by or before any authority under any provision referred to in the Article where such illegality has resulted in substantial failure of justice. It has been laid down in Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. Allahabad v. Ghanshyam Das Gupta (AIR 1962 SC 1110), Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. p. Allihaabad v. Bagleshwar Prasad (AIR 1966 SC 875), Board of High School & Intermediate Education U. P. v. Kumari Chittra Srivastava (AIR 1970 SC 1039), Prabhat Kumar v. Board of High School & Intermediate Education U. P. (1971 All LJ 1391), Mushtaq Husain v. Secretary Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. (AIR 1973 All 537) and Triambak Pati Tripathi v. Board of High School and Intermediate Education U P. Allahabad (AIR 1973 All 1 (FB)) that the Examination Committee of the Board of High School and Intermediate Education, U. P. namely, the opposite party of the present petition, while dealing with cases of examinees using unfair means in examination hall, acts quasi-judicially and prerogative write in the nature of certiorari can be issued by the High Court against the said Board where the circumstances of a particular case so justify.

    5. While examining the scope of a writ of certiorari and the limits of jurisdiction of the High Court to interfere with the orders of an inferior court or Tribunal their Lordships of the Supreme Court have observed in Swarn Singh v. State of Punjab (AIR 1976 SC 232) that (at p. 236) :--

    "It is well settled that certiorari jurisdiction can be exercised only for correcting errors of jurisdiction committed by inferior courts or tribunals. A writ of certiorari can be issued only in the exercise of supervisory jurisdiction which is different from appellate jurisdiction. The court exercising special jurisdiction under Article 226 is not entitled to act as an appellate, court. This limitation necessarily means that findings of fact reached by the inferior court or Tribunal as a result of the appreciation of evidence cannot be reopened or questioned in writ proceedings."

    In Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. Allahabad v. Bagleshwar Prasad (AIR 1966 SC 875) and Triambak Pati Tripathi v. Board of High School and Intermediate Education U. P. Allahabad (AIR 1973 All 1) (FB) it has been further observed that (at p. 7):-

    "In dealing with the validity of the orders passed by the authorities the High Court does not sit in appeal over the decision of the authority concerned. Its jurisdiction is limited and it is true, that if the order in question is not supported by any evidence at all, the High Court may quash it, but the conclusion that the order in question is not supported by any evidence must be reached after considering the question as to whether probabilities and circumstantial evidence do not justify that conclusion."

    To judge the merits of the petitioner's claim we have to see whether or not the decision of the opposite party cancelling the result of the petitioner's examination is supported by any direct and circumstantial evidence,

    6. The uncontroverted allegations of para. 14 of the petitioner's affidavit are that his seat was in Room No. 2 of Niblet Islamia Inter College, Bara Banki which room is adjacent to the principal's room. The petitioner's seat was so placed in that room that there was no chance of copying and none of the examinees seated in any row nearabout the petitioner's seat was charged of copying in physics 1st paper examination. The opposite party has admitted in the counter-affidavit that the petitioner was not caught red-handed using unfair means nor any such unauthorised material was recovered from his possession which could indicate that he had used any unfair means. It is also not alleged by the opposite party that there was mass copying at the centre in the examination of physics 1st paper whereby the result of the entire centre was cancelled. No direct evidence of using unfair means by the petitioner was tendered before the Screening Committee.

    7. The examiner, who had examined petitioner's copy, gave him 2 marks out of the maximum 21/2 marks which question No. 6 Ga of physics 1st paper carried. He did not suspect use of any unfair means by the petitioner in answering that question otherwise he ought to have reported the matter to the authorities then and there' and declaration of petitioner's result ought to have been withheld by the opposite party. After the declaration of petitioner's result and its publication in the Pioneer, convincing evidence of the alleged use of unfair means by the petitioner was required before the opposite party took the drastic decision of cancelling petitioner's declared result, which decision was bound to stigmatize the prospects of petitioner's career for all times to come.

    8. The entire finding of the sub-committee concerned regarding use of unfair means by the petitioner is based upon the solitary circumstance that he had omitted one step in the solution while answering question No. 6 Ga of physics 1st paper. That omission could take place by inadvertence as has been suggested by the petitioner. It cannot be said to be a circumstance of conclusive nature compatible only with the theory of use of unfair means by the petitioner, particularly when the petitioner was not caught while using unfair means nor any objectionable material was recovered from his possession, nor there was anything on record to show that the petitioner had copied out the answer of question No. 6 Ga from a similar answer given by any other candidate which answer had, somehow or the other, become available to the petitioner.

    9. In our opinion, there was absolutely no material before the concerned committee of the opposite party to come to the conclusion that unfair means were really adopted by the petitioner while answering the aforesaid question. The opposite party has thus taken the impugned decision causing substantial injury to the petitioner without having any direct or circumstantial evidence before it in support of that decision. The orders passed by the opposite party on 31-12-75 and 11-5-76 withholding the petitioner's Intermediate Final result and cancelling the same are, therefore, illegal and unjust and should be quashed even if the case of discrimination set up by the petitioner is not taken into consideration.

    10. We consequently allow this petition and issue a writ of certiorari quashing the two disputed orders dated 31-12-75 and 11-5-76 and direct the opposite party to declare that the petitioner has passed Intermediate Final Examination (Mathematics Group) of the year 1974-75 in Second Division. The petitioner shall get costs of this petition from the opposite party.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ajai Kumar v. The Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad Opposite Party.
    (Jul 10, 1978)