Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-Clause 3 of Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 105, C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sub-Clause 3 of Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 105, C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C

    Bhagwati Prasad Hajela v. Bishambhar Nath Singh Kapoor

    Trivedi, J.:— The applicant is a judgement-debtor and the opposite party is ??? decree-holder. The decree-holder had or ginally applied for delivery of possession through an amin. Subsequently when the case was transferred to the court of Additional Civil Judge it was prayed that possession be effected through a Commissioner. The Additional Civil Judge granted the prayer and an Advocate Commissioner was appointed to effect delivery of possession. The order was challenged in revision, and it was contended that the executing court was not competent to effect delivery of possession through a Commissioner. Reliance was placed on Padam Sen v. The State of Uttar Pradesh 1961 A.L.J 56.. The learned 2nd Additional District Judge dismissed the revision holding that the case referred and relied by the revisionists was distinguishable. Hence this revision.

    2. The question involved in this revision is whether delivery of possession could be effected through a Vakil Commissioner. The learned counsel for the applicant has contended that the power and jurisdiction of the court to issue commission is limited to purposes enumerated in Sec. 75 to 78 of C.P.C His further contention is that Sec 141 of the Civil Procedure Code being limited to suits even power to appoint Commissioner given under Sec. 75 and Order 26, C.P.C will not be available to executing court.

    3. Sec. 141 mentions that the procedure provided in the Code of Civil Procedure in regard to suit shall be followed as far as could be made applicable in all proceedings in any court of civil jurisdiction. Proceedings in any court of Civil jurisdiction refer only to original matters and do not include proceedings in execution vide Dokhu Bhushayya v. Katragadda Ram Krishnayya A.I.R 1962 S.C 1886..

    4. The question, therefore, is whether irrespective of Sec. 76 and Or. 26, C.P.C the executing court had jurisdiction to direct delivery of possession through a Commissioner—Order 21 deals with the procedure for execution of decrees and order. Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C authorises the Court to deliver possession of immovable property. Sub-Clause 3 of Order 21, Rule 35, C.P.C reads as under:

    “Where possession of any building or enclosure is to be delivered and the person in possession, being bound by the decree, does not afford free access, the Court, through its officers, may, after giving reasonable warning and facility to any woman not appearing in public according to the customs of the country to withdraw, remove or open any lock or bolt or break open any door or do any other act necessary for putting the decree-holder in possession.”

    5. This sub-Clause is indicative of the fact that the executing Court is competent to effect delivery of possession through its officers. An advocate is not an officer of the Court till he is appointed a Commissioner and once he is appointed a Commissioner Held becomes an officer of the Court so long as his authority to act as a Commissioner continues. Order 21, Rule 105, C.P.C as amended by this Court is also pointer of the fact that a Commissioner can be appointed for special reasons. It reads as under:

    “Every attachment of movable property under Rule 43, of negotiable instrument under Rule 51, and of immovable property under Rule 54, shall be made through a civil court amin or bailiff, unless special reasons render it necessary that any other agency should be employed, in which case those reasons shall be stated in the hand writing of the presiding Judge himself in the order for attachment.”.

    6. If, therefore, the attachment could be effected through an officer of the court there is no justification why the delivery of possession which is dependant on the passing of the decree cannot be effected through a Commissioner. There is nothing in the General Rules (Civil) or in the Code of Civil Procedure to the contrary. Reliance has been placed by the applicant on the Padam Sen v. The State of Uttar Pradesh wherein it was laid down:

    “Court has no inherent powers under Sec. 151 to appoint a Commissioner to seize account books in the possession of the plaintiff, upon an application by the defendant that he has apprehension that they would be tempered with. The facts of this case are distinguishable from Padam Sen's case.

    7. In Padam Sen's case the question was whether the Court had power to seize the documents or not and if the court had no power to seize the documents the exercise of that power through a Commissioner was equally without jurisdiction. In a case for delivery of possession the Court has power to order delivery of possession and the machinery through which possession is delivered is through an amin. Therefore the power which can be exercised by the court through an amin can equally be exercised by the court through a Commissioner who on his appointment as a Commissioner becomes an officer of the Court for executing orders of the court. The Court below was, therefore, right in holding that the appointment of a Commissioner for delivery of possession was perfectly justified.

    8. As the two revisions are in respect of two tenements of the same building owned by the same Landlord against the same tenant both the revisions are disposed of by one common judgment. For the reasons given above these revisions have no force and are dismissed with costs.

    Revisions dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhagwati Prasad Hajela v. Bishambhar Nath Singh Kapoor
    (Apr 24, 1972)