Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 8 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act provision
  • provisions of Rule 25 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Rules
  • provisions of Sec. 49(2) of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act
  • Sec. 24 of the Oudh Courts Act provision
  • authority.7. Sec. 6 of the Amendment Act
  • Sec. 2 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act.
  • Sec. 18 of the Land Revenue Act,
  • Sec. 2 of Act XIX of 1957
  • provisions of Rule 84(b),
  • U.P Land Revenue Act
  • Land Revenue Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 8 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act provision
  • provisions of Rule 25 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Rules
  • provisions of Sec. 49(2) of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act
  • Sec. 24 of the Oudh Courts Act provision
  • authority.7. Sec. 6 of the Amendment Act
  • Sec. 2 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act.
  • Sec. 18 of the Land Revenue Act,
  • Sec. 2 of Act XIX of 1957
  • provisions of Rule 84(b),
  • U.P Land Revenue Act
  • Land Revenue Act
Smart Summary

Legal Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a petition for a writ of certiorari under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India by the petitioner, Babu Ram, seeking quashing of an order that dismissed his election petition challenging the election of opposite party no. 1 to the office of Pradhan, Gaon Sabha Raseora, District Sitapur.

Out of two rival candidates (the petitioner and opposite party no. 1), opposite party no. 1 obtained a majority of votes and was declared elected. The petitioner instituted an election petition for setting aside that election. The election petition was presented to the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO), Sitapur, but was transferred to Sri Harish Chandra, Judicial Officer and Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, Sitapur. An order dated 28th June 1956, passed by opposite party no. 2, dismissed the election petition. The present writ petition challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Sub-Divisional Officer competent to entertain an election petition for the office of Pradhan to a Gaon Sabha within his jurisdiction had the right to transfer that petition to another Assistant Collector of the First Class designated as an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, and whether such an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer had jurisdiction to decide the election petition.
  2. Whether a plea of want of jurisdiction (challenge to the tribunal's competence) may be raised in a writ petition under Articles 226/227 if no objection to jurisdiction was taken before the original Election Tribunal.
  3. Whether the retrospective amendments made by Act XIX of 1957 — specifically the addition of clause (ss) to Section 2 of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act (defining "Sub-Divisional Officer" to include an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer) and Section 6 validating prior acts of Additional Sub-Divisional Officers — validate the past acts and orders of persons designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officers.
  4. If the Amendment is retrospective and valid, whether there existed any "appropriate authority" competent under any enactment to appoint or designate an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer such that past transfers and orders by such a person could be validated.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Additional Sub-Divisional Officer (an Assistant Collector of the First Class designated as such) had no legal existence as a jurisdictional authority for entertaining and deciding the election petition; hence the transfer and subsequent adjudication by that officer were without jurisdiction.
  • Even after the retrospective amendment (Act XIX of 1957), the petitioner's counsel argued that the position of the opposite party did not improve because the amendment does not indicate who the "appropriate authority" is for appointing or designating an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, and therefore the amendment cannot validate prior designations made without lawful authority.

Opposite Parties' Arguments

  • The opposite parties contended that no question of jurisdiction was raised before the Election Tribunal, and therefore this Court should not permit raising a plea of want of jurisdiction in the writ petition. They relied on precedent(s) to support the proposition that a plea of jurisdiction omitted before the original tribunal should not normally be raised later in a writ petition.
  • After the filing of this writ petition (and similar petitions), the State Legislature amended the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act (Act XIX of 1957). The opposite parties relied on these amendments — specifically the new clause (ss) in Section 2 and Section 6 of the Amendment Act — and argued that by the retrospective effect of these provisions, orders passed by an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer prior to the commencement of the Amendment should be held valid and thus cure any jurisdictional defects.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kedar Nath v. Shri S.N. Misra, 1957 A.L.J. 379 Held that a Sub-Divisional Officer competent to entertain an election petition did not have a right to transfer it to another Assistant Collector designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officer (negative on the competence to transfer). The court relied on this Full Bench decision to conclude that opposite party no. 2 (the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer in the present case) had no jurisdiction to decide the election petition.
Gandhinagar Motor Transport Society v. State of Bombay, A.I.R. 1954 Bombay 202 Principle that if a plea of jurisdiction has not been taken before the original tribunal, a plea of want of jurisdiction should not ordinarily be allowed to be raised in a petition for a writ of certiorari. The court acknowledged reliance on this authority by the opposite parties but discussed distinctions and exceptions to the rule, concluding that where a point goes to the root of jurisdiction it may be entertained even if not raised earlier.
Basant Singh (Applicant) v. Janak Singh (Opposite Party), A.I.R. 1954 All. 447 Similar to Gandhinagar Motor Transport — that omission to raise jurisdiction before the original tribunal ordinarily precludes raising it later in a writ petition. The court cited it as part of the authorities supporting the general rule, but again considered subsequent authorities drawing a distinction for cases where objection goes to the root of jurisdiction.
Bhagirathi v. The State through Smt. Raziya, 1955 A.L.J. 6 (Full Bench) Held that provisions of Section 49(2) of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act do not go to the root of the jurisdiction of the bench, and if no objection has been taken to the constitution of such a bench in accordance with Rule 84(b), it is not open to parties to raise that point in a writ petition under Articles 226/227. The court cited this Full Bench decision to explain the distinction between objections that go to the root of jurisdiction and those that do not; the present court concluded the present objection (competence of Additional SDO) would go to the root and so could be raised.
S.C. Prashar v. Vasantsen Dwarkadas, A.I.R. 1956 Bom. 530 Drawn distinction that if a point goes to the root of jurisdiction it can be raised in a writ petition even if not raised before the tribunal; relies on broader authorities including English cases. The court expressly agreed with the observations in this Division Bench case and applied the distinction to hold that the competence of the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, if shown to go to the root of jurisdiction, could be considered by the High Court in the writ petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by sequential legal analysis based only on the material in the opinion:

  1. Jurisdiction to transfer: The court observed that a Full Bench decision in Kedar Nath v. S.N. Misra had already decided negatively the question whether an SDO competent to entertain an election petition had a right to transfer the same to another Assistant Collector designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officer. On that basis the court found that opposite party no. 2 (the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer who heard and dismissed the election petition) had no jurisdiction to decide the matter.
  2. Late objection to jurisdiction — general rule and exception: The court recognized authority (Gandhinagar Motor Transport Society and Basant Singh) for the proposition that ordinarily a plea of want of jurisdiction not raised before the original tribunal should not be permitted in a writ petition. However, following later authorities (including the Full Bench decision in Bhagirathi and the Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in S.C. Prashar), the court accepted the distinction that if an objection goes to the root of jurisdiction it may be raised for the first time in a writ petition. The court concluded the competence of the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, if established, would go to the root of jurisdiction and therefore the plea could be entertained notwithstanding that it had not been taken before the Election Tribunal.
  3. Examination of the statutory amendment (Act XIX of 1957): The State's amendment added clause (ss) to Section 2 of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act defining "Sub-Divisional Officer" to include an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer, and Section 6 sought to validate earlier orders and actions of Additional Sub-Divisional Officers by deeming them as valid retrospectively.
  4. Validity and effect of the amendment: While the court acknowledged that the Legislature may enact retrospective amendments and that the amendment prima facie could be valid, it examined whether the amendment actually cured the defect in the present case. The court noted that the amendment did not identify the "appropriate authority" empowered to appoint or designate an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer. The court considered analogies where statutes expressly provide for appointment of additional officers (e.g., Sec. 24 of the Oudh Courts Act, Sec. 8 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act, provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code, and Sections 13 and 14A of the U.P. Land Revenue Act for Additional Commissioners and Additional Collectors).
  5. Lack of statutory basis for designation: From these comparisons, the court reasoned that where appointment of additional officers is contemplated the Legislature makes express provision for such appointments. In the absence of any provision in the U.P. Land Revenue Act or other enactments (aside from the U.P. Panchayat Raj Act) empowering an "appropriate authority" to designate Additional Sub-Divisional Officers, the court concluded there was no lawful method by which an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer could have been validly appointed or designated in the present circumstances.
  6. Conclusion on amendment's efficacy: Because the amendment did not indicate who the "appropriate authority" was and there was no supporting provision in other statutes authorizing such designations, the court found that the retrospective amendment (Sec. 2 clause (ss) read with Sec. 6 of Act XIX of 1957) did not validate the appointments/designations of any persons as Additional Sub-Divisional Officers for the purposes of this case. Consequently, the amendment was practically infructuous in the present writ petition.
  7. Result applied to facts: The court held that the Sub-Divisional Officer, Sitapur — in whose jurisdiction the Gaon Sabha lay — was the only competent authority under Rule 25 of the U.P. Panchayat Raj Rules to entertain and hear the election petition and that he had no authority to transfer it to a person designated as an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer unless that designation had been lawfully made by an authority competent to do so. Because the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer lacked jurisdiction, the order dated 28th June 1956 dismissing the election petition was quashed and the petition was to be deemed pending.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The order dated 28th June 1956 passed by opposite party no. 2 dismissing the petitioner's election petition is QUASHED, and the election petition is to be deemed pending.

Consequences and Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The dismissal of the election petition is set aside; the petition is restored to a pending status for further proceedings by the competent authority (the Sub-Divisional Officer of Sitapur) as indicated by the court's reasoning.
  • Costs: Under the particular circumstances of the case the court made no order as to costs.
  • Broader implications: The court determined that the retrospective amendment (Act XIX of 1957) did not validate the prior actions of persons designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officers in this case because no "appropriate authority" for such designation was specified; the opinion does not purport to set out any novel general rule beyond the application of established principles regarding jurisdiction and the limits of statutory designation of additional officers.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    Babu Ram v. Paragi And Another Opp. Parties.

    Singh, J.:— This is a petition for a writ of certiorari under Art. 226/227 of the Constitution of India for the quashing of an order dismissing an election petition instituted by the petitioner Babu Ram, challenging the election of opposite party no. 1 to the office of Pradhan, Gaon Sabha Raseora, District Sitapur.

    2. It appears that out of two rival candidates, namely the petitioner and opposite party no. 1, opposite party no. 1 succeeded in getting a majority of votes and was declared elected. An election petition was then instituted by the present petitioner for the setting aside of the election of opposite party no. 1. This election petition was presented to the Sub-Divisional Officer, Sitapur but was transferred to Sri Harish Chandra, Judicial Officer and Additional Sub-Divisional Offices, Sitapur.

    3. The question as to whether a Sub-Divisional Officer, who was competent to entertain an election petition arising out of an election of Pradhan to a Gaon Sabha within his Jurisdiction, had a right to transfer the same to another Assistant Collector of the First Class designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officer by some order of the Collector and if such an authority had a jurisdiction to decide it has already been decided in the negative by a Full Bench of this Court in Kedar Nath v. Shri S.N Misra 1957 A.L.J 379.. It is, therefore, clear that opposite party no. 2 had no jurisdiction to decide the election petition.

    4. Another point, which has been raised on behalf of the opposite parties, is that no question of jurisdiction was raised before the Election Tribunal and as such this Court in the exercise of its writ jurisdiction should not permit the petitioner to raise a plea of want of jurisdiction. Reliance has been placed on Gandhinagar Motor Transport Society v. State of Bombay A.I.R 1954 Bombay 202. as also on another case of this Court in Basant Singh…Applicant; v. Janak Singh…Opposite Party. A.I.R 1954 All. 447.. In both of these cases it has been observed that if a plea of jurisdiction has not been taken up before the original tribunal, a plea of want of jurisdiction should not be allowed to be raised in a petition for a writ of certiorari. No doubt the power exercised by this Court in issuing writs is discretionary and if a person has omitted to challenge jurisdiction in an inferior tribunal, he should not be heard on that point in a writ petition. In some later cases, however, a distinction has been drawn between cases, in which the Court was not wholly incompetent to entertain a matter but was debarred from entertaining it on account of territorial or some other similar want of jurisdiction, and cases in which the objection went to the root of jurisdiction in which event the Court was competent to quash the orders in spite of the fact that a plea of jurisdiction was not raised at the earliest opportunity or before the Tribunal. In the Full Bench case of this court Bhagirathi v. The State through Smt. Raziya 1955 A.L.J 6. Malik, C.J observed:

    “After careful consideration, brother Agarwala and I took the view that the provisions of Sec. 49(2) of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act do not go to the root of the jurisdiction of the bench and that if no objection has been taken to the constitution of such a bench by either party in accordance with the provisions of Rule 84(b), it is not open to them to raise that point in a writ petition under Art. 226 or 227 of the Constitution.”

    5. The distinction has been clearly brought out in a later Division Bench case of the Bombay High Court in S.C Prashar v. Vasantsen Dwarkadas A.I.R 1956 Bom. 530.. It is not necessary to reiterate the arguments and the observations made in this case. Reference has been made not only to the other cases of the High Courts in India but also to various cases decided in England. I agree, if I may say so with respect, with the observations made in the above Bombay case. If a point raised goes to the root of jurisdiction but has not been raised before a Tribunal, the plea can be raised and will be considered in an application for a writ. The plea of jurisdiction, which has been raised in this Court about the competence of the Additional Sub-Divisional Officer to enter-lain and hear an election petition would, if substantiated, go to the very root of the jurisdiction and as such there is no good ground for refusing to entertain this plea in this Court. An Assistant Collector of the First Class designated as Additional Sub-Divisional Officer by a Collector has no existence in law and as such has no jurisdiction to entertain an election petition.

    6. After this writ petition and similar other writ petitions had been filed, the State Legislature has amended the U.P Panchayat Raj Act by Act XIX of 1957. The learned counsel for the opposite parties has relied on these amendments and it has been argued that after the amendments, which have been given a retrospective effect, the orders passed by an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer should be held to be valid. By Sec. 2 of Act XIX of 1957 a new sub-clause (ss) has been added to Sec. 2 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Act. It is as follows:—

    “(ss) ‘Sub-Divisional Officer’ includes an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer designated or appointed as such by the appropriate authority.”

    7. Sec. 6 of the Amendment Act which has also been relied upon reads as follows:—

    “6(a) all orders made (except an order or judgment which has already been set aside before the commencement of this Act), actions or proceedings taken, directions issued or jurisdiction exercised by any additional Sub-divisional Officer, prior to the said commencement, under or in accordance with the provisions of the Principal Act or any rules made thereunder, which would have been validly and properly made, taken, issued or exercised, as the case may be, if clause (ss) had been part of Sec. 2 of the Principal Act, shall be and be deemed to have been as good and valid in law as if the amendments made in Sec. 2 of the Principal Act by this Act had been in force at all material dates; and (b) ……………………………”

    8. On the basis of the above two sections of the Amendment Act it has been argued that an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer can be appointed or designated by the appropriate authority and by the validation made under Sec. 6, the amendment has been given a retrospective effect so much so that the Act would be deemed to have stood amended as at present, from the very beginning. It is no doubt open to the State Legislature to give retrospective effect to any amendment or law and the learned counsel for the applicant has not been able to show any law which would invalidate such an amendment. The amendment would, therefore, be good. It has, however, been argued on behalf of the applicant that the position of the opposite party does not improve even after this amendment. There is no provision made by the Legislature for the appointment of an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer in the Land Revenue Act or in any other enactment except under the U.P Panchayat Raj Act. As pointed out above, a Sub-Divisional Officer has been made to include an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer designated or appointed as such by the ‘appropriate authority.’ This ‘appropriate authority’ has, however, not been indicated in this amendment Act or in the original Act. The learned counsel for the opposite parties has not been able to point out if there was any ‘appropriate authority’ for appointment of an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer in any other enactment also. The words “appropriate authority” will, therefore, be given their ordinary dictionary meaning. It has been urged on behalf of the opposite parties that the State Government is under Sec. 18 of the Land Revenue Act, empowered to place any Assistant Collector of the First Class in charge of a sub-Division and it is this Assistant Collector who is popularly known as Sub-Divisional Officer. On this analogy it has been argued that the State Government or the Collector—if the powers are so delegated to him, can also appoint an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer. I am unable to accept this contention. Wherever the appointment of an Additional Officer has been contemplated, a provision has been made for such appointment in the Act itself. In Sec. 24 of the Oudh Courts Act provision has been made for appointment of Additional District Judges. Similarly in Sec. 8 of the Bengal, Agra and Assam Civil Courts Act provision has been made for the appointment of Additional District Judges. In the Criminal Procedure Code also we find that there is a provision for appointment of Additional Sessions Judges and Additional District Magistrates in Secs. 9, sub-sec. 3 and Sec. 10, sub-sec. 2. In the U.P Land Revenue Act itself there is a provision in Secs. 13 and 14A for appointment of Additional Commissioners and Additional Collectors. It would thus appear that wherever it has been found necessary to appoint additional officers provision has been made for their appointment by the Legislature and it cannot therefore, be argued that the authority, which was competent to appoint Sub-Divisional Officers, would also be deemed to have authority to appoint Additional Sub-Divisional Officers or designate Assistant Collectors of the First Class as Additional Sub-Divisional Officers. There being no provision for appointment or desigation of Additional Sub-Divisional Officers and there being no indication as to who was the ‘appropriate authority’ for such appointments, it will not be possible to appoint or designate Additional Sub-Divisional Officers and the amendment made by Sec. 2 of Act XIX of 1957 does not in any manner validate the appointments of any persons as Additional Sub-Divisional Officers. The amendment is, therefore, practically infructuous so far as the present writ petition is concerned. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Sitapur in whose jurisdiction the Gaon Sabha, of which the Pradhan was elected, lay was the only competent authority to entertain and hear an election petition under the provisions of Rule 25 of the U.P Panchayat Raj Rules and he had no authority to transfer it to any other person designated as an Additional Sub-Divisional Officer unless that designation had been made by an authority competent to do so. The order passed by opposite party no. 2 dated 28th of June, 1956 dismissing the election petition of the petitioner is, therefore, quashed and the petition will be deemed to be pending. Under the peculiar circumstances of this case I, however, make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babu Ram v. Paragi And Another Opp. Parties.
    (Oct 15, 1957)