Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a revision against an order under Section 152, Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C.), refusing to amend a decree. On 26 July 1901 a mortgage deed was executed by Bhairon Khan (predecessor-in-interest of the applicant) in favour of four persons now represented by the opposite parties. The mortgage deed described the mortgaged property as 25 plots measuring 40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis, situate in village Dhuremau, district Rae Bareli.

In the plaint the property was, however, described as 29 plots measuring 19 bighas. The suit was decreed, the decretal amount deposited and the property redeemed. It is asserted that the plaintiff is in possession of the entire mortgaged property as described in the mortgage deed (40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis). An application was made to amend the decree to correct the erroneous description; the opposite party opposed the application in the court below and the learned Judge dismissed the amendment application under Section 152. The applicants sought revision in this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a decree may be amended under Section 152, C.P.C., to correct a clerical mistake in the decree that originated from an erroneous description in the plaint (i.e., whether Section 152 permits correction of mistakes arising from the parties' pleadings when the decree was copied from the plaint).
  2. Whether, where a lower court refuses to amend a decree in a proper case, this Court in its revisional jurisdiction may correct the decree (including exercise of inherent powers under Sections 151 and 152) and allow the amendment.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The mortgage deed (filed with the plaint) describes the property as 25 plots within an area of 40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis, so the contradictory description in the plaint (29 plots measuring 19 bighas) was a clerical error.
  • Because the decree reflected the erroneous plaint description, the decree should be amended under Section 152 (and, insofar as necessary, under inherent powers) to conform to the mortgage deed.

Opposite Party / Court Below

  • The application to amend was opposed in the court below; the learned Judge concluded that the mistake was not of a clerical nature and refused to amend the decree.
  • No counsel appeared for the opposite party before this Court in the revision proceeding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surajan Singh v. Wazir Singh A.I.R 1923 All. 349. Held that only a mistake of the court itself could be corrected under Section 152 and not mistakes of the parties. The Court contrasted this view with later authorities and treated it as an older line of authority; it noted the divergence of opinion on whether Section 152 is confined to court-made mistakes.
Allahab Dia v. Rahimuddin A.I.R 1924 All. 520. Similar proposition: correction under Section 152 limited to mistakes of the court and not party mistakes. Used by the Court to show existing, earlier decisions that limited the scope of Section 152; the Court considered these when surveying the authorities.
Shiam Lal v. Mt. Moona Kuar A.I.R 1934 Oudh 352. Recognised that besides Section 152 there is inherent power (Ss. 151 and 152) to correct mistakes to do real and substantial justice; allowed amendment of plaint, judgment and decree under inherent power where mistake repeated. The Court relied on this decision to support the proposition that courts possess power to correct mistakes even when those arise from pleadings, and that revisional correction is permissible if a lower court refuses to amend.
Ram Charan Sahu v. Jamna Prasad I.L.R 10 Lucknow 496. Held that courts have duty and power to correct mistakes under Section 152 and inherent jurisdiction (S.151); power is wide enough to cover mistakes made by the parties. Adopted as authority that supports correction of party-made mistakes and the use of inherent jurisdiction to make necessary amendments in the ends of justice.
Ram Chandra Sahu v. Jamna Prasad “It is the duty of every civil court to correct any mistake in any judgment, decree or order or errors, arising therein from any accidental slip or omission... The language of S. 152 is wide enough to cover the correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves...” (as quoted in the opinion) The Court cited this passage to reinforce that Section 152 and inherent powers permit correction of mistakes arising from accidental slips or omissions, including those attributable to parties.
Badri Pande v. Chhangur Pandey A.I.R 1953 All. 102. Illustrates an instance where amendment of plaint and preliminary decree was sought; the judge observed jurisdiction to amend was available. Quoted for the concise statement by the learned Judge: “the Court has jurisdiction to amend the decree as prayed for.” The Court relied on this as supporting precedent for allowing amendment.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by recording the factual discrepancy: the mortgage deed described 25 plots totaling 40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis, while the plaint (and hence the decree) described 29 plots measuring 19 bighas. The decree had been drawn from the plaint and thus reflected the erroneous description.

The Court reviewed the authorities on the scope of Section 152, C.P.C. It observed two lines of authority: older decisions of this Court (Surajan Singh; Allahab Dia) restricting Section 152 to mistakes of the court itself, and contrary decisions of the Oudh Chief Court (Shiam Lal; Ram Charan/Ram Chandra Sahu) recognising a wider power, including inherent jurisdiction under Section 151, to correct mistakes arising from pleadings.

The Court relied upon the later authorities that supported correction of mistakes appearing in judgments and decrees even when the error originated in party pleadings and where the decree was copied from the plaint. It noted the statement that the Civil Procedure Code is not exhaustive and that courts possess inherent powers to do real and substantial justice, permitting amendment of plaint, judgment and decree under Ss.151 and 152 in appropriate cases.

Applying those legal principles to the facts, the Court found the present case analogous to the cited Oudh decisions: the description in the mortgage deed (which was on record) differed from the plaint, producing an erroneous decree. The Court concluded it was proper to correct the decree under Section 152 and inherent jurisdiction, and that the lower court's refusal to amend amounted to a failure to exercise jurisdiction which this Court could correct in revision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Revision allowed. The Court set aside the order of the court below and ordered that the decree be amended as prayed for. The Court made no order as to costs.

Implications: The direct effect is that the decree will be corrected to reflect the property description consistent with the mortgage deed (as sought by the applicants), and the order refusing amendment is quashed. The opinion does not discuss broader doctrinal consequences beyond applying established authorities that permit correction of decrees under Section 152 and, where necessary, the court's inherent powers; no new legal principle or precedent beyond this application is announced in the text.

    Shahzad Khan v. Pt. Sheo Kumar

    V.D Bhargava, J.:— This is an application in revision against an order under Sec. 152, C.P.C refusing to amend the decree in the suit.

    2. The facts of the case are that on the 26th July, 1901 a mortgage deed was executed by Bhairon Khan, the predecessor in interest of the applicant, in favour of four persons who are now represented by the opposite-parties. The plots mortgaged were 25 plots and the area of the plots given in the mortgage deed was 40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis and was situate in village Dhuremau, district Rae Bareli.

    3. In the plaint the property was described as 29 plots measuring 19 bighas. The suit was decreed and the entire decretal amount has been deposited and the property redeemed. It is alleged that the plaintiff is in possession of the entire mortgaged property, i.e 40 bighas, 8 biswas and 14 biswansis. Some mistake cropped up in the decree on account of wrong description in the plaint. The application was opposed by the opposite party in the Court below and the learned Judge dismissed the application for amendment.

    4. Though it was admitted that there was no such mortgaged property in the entire village where the disputed property given in the plaint is situate, yet he came to the conclusion that the mistake was not of a clerical nature and, therefore, he refused to amend the decree. The applicants have come up before this Court in revision and they have alleged that in the mortgage deed itself, which was filed with the plaint, the description of the plots was 25 plots within an area of 40 bighas and, therefore, the mistake in the plaint cannot be said to be anything else but merely a clerical error. Nobody appears for the opposite party to oppose the application.

    5. There is ample authority for the proposition that under Sec. 152 it is open to the appellate court to correct mistakes and do justice in the case. The court can under Sec. 152 amend a clerical error in a decree although the error may have occurred on account of a mistake of the parties themselves in their pleadings and this mistake in the decree was on account of its being copied from the plaint. It has further been held that in such cases it is not necessary to amend the plaint itself. It is enough to amend the decree. There are some old cases of this Court, such as Surajan Singh v. Wazir Singh A.I.R 1923 All. 349. and Allahab Dia v. Rahimuddin A.I.R 1924 All. 520. where this Court had held that the only mistake that could be corrected under Sec. 152 was a mistake of the court itself and not any mistake of the parties. On the contrary there are decisions of the late Chief Court of Oudh in Shiam Lal v. Mt. Moona Kuar A.I.R 1934 Oudh 352. and Ram Charan Sahu v. Jamna Prasad I.L.R 10 Lucknow 496.. In the former case a learned Judge of the Chief Court held that besides Sec. 152 there was ample power to correct mistakes. The learned Judge observed:

    “The Civil Procedure Code is not exhaustive, and therefore, judicial tribunals have always, when necessity arose, acted upon the assumption of their being possessed of an inherent power to act ex dabito justiate, and to do that real and substantial justice for the administration of which alone they exist. Thus where a mistake is repeated in the judgment of the Court and the preliminary and final decree, the court can amend the plaint, judgment and the decree under its inherent power under Ss. 151 and 152.”

    6. He further held that if the court below had refused to amend the decree in a proper case it was open to this Court in its revisional jurisdiction to make the necessary corrections, as a refusal would tantamount to a refusal to exercise a jurisdiction legally vested in the Court under the provisions of Secs. 151 and 152; and the applicant would be entitled to ask the court to amend the decree. That case was very similar to the present case. There also the property as described in the mortgage deed and as described in the plaint differed, and on account of this incorrect description of the property in the plaint the preliminary and the final decrees both contained wrong particulars. The Chief Court allowed the amendment.

    7. In Ram Chandra Sahu v. Jamna Prasad a bench of the Oudh Chief Court held;

    “It is the duty of every civil court to correct any mistake in any judgment, decree or order or errors, arising therein from any accidental slip or omission. This power is granted under s. 152 and under S. 151, the civil Court is vested with inherent power to make such orders as may be necessary in the ends of justice. The language of S. 152 is wide enough to cover the correction of mistakes made by the parties themselves, and the power of the Court to make corrections necessary in the ends of justice is not confined only to powers exercisable under S. 152, but extensive powers could also be exercised under Ss. 151 and 153.”

    8. In Badri Pande v. Chhangur Pandey A.I.R 1953 All. 102. the plaintiff had applied that the plaint and the preliminary decree be amended.

    9. The learned Judge held:

    “the Court has jurisdiction to amend the decree as prayed for.”

    10. I accordingly allow the revision, set aside the order of the Court below and order that the decree shall be amended as prayed for. I make no order as to costs.

    11. Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shahzad Khan v. Pt. Sheo Kumar
    (Jul 30, 1956)