Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76(e) of the Transfer of Property Act.11.
  • S. 12, U.P Agriculturists' Relief Act,
  • S. 12, Agriculturists' Relief Act.
  • Section 12 of the Special Act.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 76(e) of the Transfer of Property Act.11.
  • S. 12, U.P Agriculturists' Relief Act,
  • S. 12, Agriculturists' Relief Act.
  • Section 12 of the Special Act.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion: Revision under S. 12, Agriculturists' Relief Act

Factual and Procedural Background

On 23 April 1920 a mortgage with possession was executed by Ram Samujh Singh and Ram Dutt Singh (under the guardianship of Dilao Kuar) in favour of Ajodhya Singh and Ganpat Singh in respect of two plots, identified in the record for the purposes of this revision as plot No. 569 (second/third settlement figures also recorded). The mortgage was for Rs. 190.

Ram Dutt Singh filed an application for redemption against ten persons including Ajodhya Singh, Amrej Singh, Mata Prasad Singh, Dalpat Singh, Ganpat Singh, Jokhai Singh, Mahadeo Singh, Ram Samujh Singh, Vidya Kuar and Rajpati Kuar. Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar died during the pendency of the revision and no substitution was made.

The defence in respect of plot No. 569 was that Mahadeo Singh had no connection with the mortgagees and was in possession as a tenant paying rent of Rs. 6 per annum; the Assistant Collector framed the material issue whether Mahadeo Singh was the tenant of plot No. 569 and held that Mahadeo had an interest in the mortgaged property and was in possession as a mortgagee, and decreed redemption.

On appeal the District Judge held there was no reliable evidence that the mortgage money came from joint family funds and therefore Mahadeo was not a joint mortgagee; the appellate judge concluded that the mortgagors should not be entitled to actual possession of the plot without determination of Mahadeo's tenancy. Aggrieved mortgagors filed this revision application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Mahadeo Singh is a tenant of plot No. 569 (i.e., the factual question of tenancy).
  2. Whether the mortgagors are entitled to actual possession of plot No. 569 after redemption as against Mahadeo Singh.
  3. Whether the revision application abates because two parties impleaded (Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar) died during the proceedings without substitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants / Mortgagors

  • The sole ground of the revision was that Mahadeo Singh, being the uncle of Ajodhya Singh and farming in a joint Hindu family with him, could not confer any tenancy rights so as to defeat the applicants' right to present possession after redemption.
  • With respect to the deaths of two impleaded parties, the applicants argued that the revision should not abate because the real contest was between the mortgagors and Mahadeo Singh (and not between the mortgagors and the deceased mortgagees), and the deceased parties were only pro forma impleaded.
  • At a late stage they sought to argue that if Mahadeo was permitted into possession by the mortgagees, the mortgagors should be restored to possession and the factual question whether Mahadeo was a pre-mortgage tenant or let in by the mortgagees should be investigated (this was sought to be raised for the first time in revision).

Respondent / Mahadeo Singh (and related factual positions)

  • Mahadeo Singh maintained that he had no connection with the mortgagees and was in possession as a tenant, paying rent of Rs. 6 per annum.
  • The lower appellate court and parties treated Mahadeo as being in actual possession and asserted that he could not be ousted from that possession in these proceedings without determination of his tenancy.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khuda Bakhsh v. Mahanand Tewari, 1947 Oudh W.N 221 Rule on abatement of revision where party dies after admission of the revision and no application for substitution is made within a reasonable time. The decision was cited to explain that revision may abate if no substitution is made; the Court considered the principle but held the present contest was between mortgagors and Mahadeo Singh (a real contest), and that the deceased parties had been pro forma; therefore the contention that the revision abated did not prevail.
Badri Nath v. Ram Chandra, 1939 Oudh W.N 193 Principle that a finding of fact by the lower appellate court cannot be challenged in revision. Used to support the proposition that the appellate court's finding about tenancy evidence is a finding of fact not open to challenge in revision proceedings.
Murli Shukul v. Lalta Singh, 1943 Oudh W.N 169 Similar principle that findings of fact by an appellate court are binding in revision. Reinforced the point that the lower appellate court's factual conclusions stand and cannot be upset in revision.
Ram Chand v. Raj Hans, 3 All L.J. 517 Authorities concerning situations where a mortgagee during the mortgage period had transferred/let part of the mortgaged land (lease) and the remedies of parties in those circumstances. The Court distinguished this authority from the present facts, observing those cases arose under ordinary law and different factual scenarios (e.g., lease by mortgagee) so they were not directly applicable to S.12 proceedings here.
Guari v. Mangla, A.I.R. 1926 All. 463 Case dealing with sub-mortgage/auction purchaser and subsequent occupancy or tenancy claims in relation to mortgaged land. Also distinguished on facts; the Court stated that the cited cases did not correspond to the present situation where a third party claims tenancy in S.12 proceedings.
Jagar Nath v. Srikant Dube, 1949 All.W.R. 205 (Seth J.) Rule that the jurisdiction under S.12, U.P. Agriculturists' Relief Act is a special, limited jurisdiction confined to adjudication upon redemption and does not extend to recording findings on tenancy. The Court expressly followed and agreed with this decision, holding that S.12 proceedings cannot be used to decide the question of tenancy of a person claiming against both mortgagor and mortgagee; accordingly the applicants could not obtain actual possession against Mahadeo in these proceedings.
Ram Kirpal v. Bhagwnti Saran, 1949 All.W.R. 214 (Bhargava J.) A conflicting authority on the question of whether tenancy may be investigated in the course of S.12 proceedings (the Court notes it dissents from Seth J.'s view). The Court noted the dissenting position but preferred and followed the reasoning in Jagar Nath (Seth J.) and therefore did not follow the view in Ram Kirpal.
Bhagwati v. Ram Ugra, Civil Revision No. 544 of 1945 (All.) (unreported) Prior unreported decision addressing similar issues about tenancy claims and S.12 proceedings. Relied on as supporting authority (along with other unreported decisions) for the limitation that S.12 does not permit investigation into tenancy claims which are adverse to both mortgagor and mortgagee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. Abatement / Substitution: The Court considered the effect of the deaths of Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar. While noting the general principle from Khuda Bakhsh that revision may abate if substitution is not made, the Court accepted the applicants' contention that the core controversy in the revision was between the mortgagors and Mahadeo Singh (a real contest) and that the deceased had been impleaded pro forma; accordingly, the absence of substitution did not require abatement of the revision in this instance.
  2. Findings of Fact: The Court treated the appellate court's findings about the absence of reliable evidence that the mortgage money came from joint family funds (and therefore that Mahadeo was not a joint mortgagee) as findings of fact. Citing Badri Nath and Murli Shukul, it emphasized that such findings of fact by the lower appellate court cannot be challenged in revision.
  3. Scope of S.12: The Court identified the precise legal issue remaining — whether the mortgagors are entitled to actual possession against Mahadeo Singh — and analyzed the scope of jurisdiction under Section 12 of the U.P. Agriculturists' Relief Act. Relying principally on Jagar Nath v. Srikant Dube (Seth J.), the Court adopted the view that a court deciding an application under S.12 exercises a special, limited jurisdiction confined to adjudication upon redemption and does not have jurisdiction to determine questions of tenancy.
  4. Application to Facts: Because Mahadeo claimed tenancy against both the mortgagor and the mortgagee (an occupancy claim adverse to both parties to the redemption proceeding), the Court held such a tenancy question was "foreign to a suit for redemption" under S.12 and could not be resolved in these proceedings. The Court therefore denied the applicants' attempt to obtain actual possession against Mahadeo in the present S.12 revision.
  5. Refusal to Remand for Further Fact Finding: The Court rejected the applicants' late attempt to have the question of whether Mahadeo was a pre-mortgage tenant or was let in by the mortgagees remanded for determination, because the mortgagors had not advanced that case in the courts below and should not be permitted to raise it belatedly in revision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision application is DISMISSED. The applicants are not entitled, in proceedings under Section 12 of the U.P. Agriculturists' Relief Act, to obtain actual possession of plot No. 569 against Mahadeo Singh where he claims tenancy against both the mortgagor and the mortgagee.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the mortgagors cannot secure actual possession of the plot against Mahadeo Singh in this S.12 redemption proceeding; the revision is dismissed with costs.
  • The Court expressly followed the reasoning in Jagar Nath v. Srikant Dube (Seth J.) that S.12 jurisdiction is limited to redemption and does not extend to adjudicating tenancy; the opinion therefore applies existing precedent rather than announcing a new principle of law.
  • Because the Court refused to remand the factual question (whether Mahadeo was a pre-existing tenant or was put in possession by the mortgagees), that factual enquiry was left unadjudicated in these proceedings — any such remedy would need to be pursued in a forum competent to determine tenancy or in separate proceedings appropriate to decide occupancy/tenancy rights.

Disposition recorded in the record: "Revision dismissed." (V.R.B.)

    Ram Datt Singh v. Ajodhia Singh

    1. This revision application is filed by the mortgagors and arises out of proceedings under S. 12, Agriculturists' Relief Act. In order to properly appreciate the controversy it will be necessary to set out the pedigree of the parties.

    2. On 23rd April 1920 a mortgage with possession was made by Ram Samujh Singh and Ram Dutt Singh under the guardianship of Dilao Kuar in favour of Ajodhya Singh and Ganpat Singh in respect of two plots, 494 second settlement = 569 third settlement and 380 second settlement = 407 third settlement for Rs. 190. The application, for redemption was made by Ram Dutt Singh against ten persons Ajodhya Singh, Amrej Sing and Mata Prasad Singh (the two sons of Nageshwar Singh), Dalpat Singh, Ganpat Singh, Jokhai Singh, Mahadeo Singh, Ram Samujh Singh Vidya Kuar and Rajpati Kuar. Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar died during the pendency of the revision application and their legal representatives were not brought on the record. The reason for impleading persons other than the mortgagees as defendants given in para 8 of the plaint was that as Jokhai Singh and Mahadeo Singh and the sons of Jokhai Singh had acquired the mortgagee rights out of the joint ??? funds and all the descendants of Jagar Nath were members of the joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara and they were in possession of the mortgaged property, they were necessary parties to the suit. In the present revision application we are concerned only with plot No. 569. The material defence in respect of this plot was that Mahadeo Singh had no connection whatever with the mortgagees that he was in possession as a tenant on a rental of Rs. 6 per annum and was entitled to retain possession as such.

    3. The Assistant Collector before whom the suit was filed framed among others the following material issue:—

    (1) Whether Mahadeo Singh is the tenant of plot No. 569?

    4. He held that Mahadeo Singh had an interest in the property mortgaged and he was not in possession as a tenant but as mortgagee. He decreed redemption.

    5. The learned District Judge on appeal held that there was no reliable evidence to show that the mortgage money was advanced from the joint family funds and therefore Mahadeo Singh was not a joint mortgagee of the land in suit. He accordingly held that.

    “the mortgagors-applicants should not therefore, be entitled to actual possession of the said plot without determining the tenancy of Mahadeo Singh”.

    6. The mortgagors aggrived by the decision have filed this revision and the sole ground mentioned is.

    “that Mahadeo Singh having been found to be the own uncle of Ajodhya Singh and farming a joint Hindu family with him in execution of the patta with respect to the plot in suit in his favour cannot confer any tenancy rights so as to defeat the right of the applicant to present possession after redemption”.

    7. As already stated during the pendency of this revision, Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar died and their legal representatives were not brought on the record. Though O. XXII of the CPC, does not apply to a revision application, it has been held that if after the admission of a revision a party dies and no application for substitution is presented within a reasonable time the application for revision abates in the sense that the proceedings shall cease unless good cause for delay is shown. Khuda Bakhsh v. Mahanand Tewari, 1947 Oudh W.N 221. No application for substitution was made in this case and the names were removed, but it is contended on behalf of the applicants that the of vision cannot abate for the contest in the present revision is not between the mortgagors and the mortgagees in which were included Dalpat Singh and Vidya Kuar deceased and therefore there can be no question of conflicting decrees. This contention in my opinion has force. The deceased, who were impleaded as being interested in the mortgaged property were added as pro forma, parties and the real contest is between the mortgagors on the one hand and Mahadeo Singh as a tenant on the other the mortgagees not being interested in this controversy.

    8. The first contention is that there being no patta or other evidence on the record regarding the tenancy of Mabadeo Singh beyond certain entries in the revenue papers, the lower appellate Court was wrong in holding that Mahadeo Singh was a tenant and therefore he should have been treated as a co-mortgagee being a member of the Joint Hindu family. The finding arrived at by the lower appellate Court upon this point is a finding of fact which cannot be challenged in revision. Badri Nath v. Ram Chandra, 1939 Oudh W.N 193 and Murli Shukul v. Lalta Singh, 1943 Oudh W.N 169.) The ground of revision referred to above admits the execution of a patta, though it is now agreed that there was no patta. There is no ground challenging the finding of the lower appellate Court on this point. All that is urged is that the mortgagors' right to present possession after redemption cannot be resisted by Mahadeo Singh claiming to be a tenant. The lower appellate Court merely mentions that Mahadeo Singh is in actual possession and he cannot be ousted from that possession in these proceedings but the Court comes to this conclusion without determining the question of tenancy.

    9. The only question therefore which falls for determination is whether the mortgagors are entitled to actual possession as against Mahadeo Singh. Reliance is placed on Ram Chand v. Raj Hans 3 ALL L.J 517 and Guari v. Mangla A.I.R(13) 1926 all. 463. The former was the-case of a lease where the mortgagee, during the period of the mortgage, had transferred a portion of the mortgaged land under a lease. The mortgagor was directed to seek his remedy in separate proceedings. He applied to the Revenue Court to have his name recorded in respect of the tenancy plots but be failed. He then brought a regular suit for ejectment of tenants whom the mortgagee had let into possession and that suit was decreed. In the second case that mortgagees had made a sub-mortgage and their mortgagee interest had passed to the auction purchasers and they plea led that they had taken the land from the auction purchasers as tenants and acquired occupancy rights therein. Such is, however, not the case here. Here the land is in the possession of a third person setting up tenancy rights. The learned Judge deals with this aspect in the following words:

    “The argument is that if instead of the original mortgagee themselves somebody else, had obtained a letting of the land and had acquired an occupancy right in the land it could not be said that he was a necessary party to the suit and that he should be ejected. The argument no doubt has some force, but in my opinion it ought not to be allowed to prevail. The mortgagees were bound by their contract to hand over the property to the mortgagor intact…….”

    10. The learned Judge recognised:

    “There is no direct authority on the point either way. But on broad principles I am not at all inclined to let the original mortgagees, profit by an act of their own to the detriment of the interest of the mortgagor whose rights they were bound to guard on general principles recognised in Section 76(e) of the Transfer of Property Act.”

    11. In the present case the mortgage deed places no restrictions upon the mortgagees. Be that as it may, theses cases, are also distinguishable on the ground that they arose under the ordinary law. The present case arises in proceedings under Section 12 of the Special Act. The point is however, covered by a decision of Seth J. in Jagar Nath v. Srikant Dube, 1949 ALL.W.R 205 decided on 23rd December 1948. It dissents from the case of Ram Kirpal v. Bhagwnti Saran decided by Bhargava J. on ??? October 1948, and published in 1949 ALL.W.R 214. The judgment of Seth J. is so clear and exhaustive on the subject that I consider it wholly unnecessary to deal with the point beyond expressing my entire agreement with his view. The learned Judge held that.

    “the jurisdiction of a Court, deciding an application under S. 12, U.P Agriculturists' Relief Act, whether as a Court of original jurisdiction or as a Court of appeal is a special jurisdiction conferred upon it by a special provision of the Statute and is limited within the four corners of that section. It has jurisdiction only to adjudicate upon the question of redemption and no; more. Such Court has no jurisdiction to record a finding; in the question of tenancy.”

    12. The learned Judge followed his previous decision in an unreported case, Bhagwati v. Ram Ugra Civil Revision No. 544 of 1945 (ALL.) decided on 1st October 1948 and an unreported decision of ??? referred to at p. 207 of the report. That was a case in which the mortgagee's father was impleaded on the allegation that his name stood fictitiously recorded as a tenant over some of the plots and that as a matter of fact the mortgagees their selves were in possession of those plots. The mortgagees' father pleaded that he had no connection with the mortgagees and that, be was in possession as a tenant Similarly in the present case Mabadeo Singh does Dot claim any connection with the mortgagees and he claims the right to continue in occupation both against the mortgagor and the mortgagees. He does not claim this right as the representative of the mortgagees. Such a claim which is adverse both to the mortgagor and the mortgagee is foreign to a suit for redemption and in an application for redemption under S. 12 the scope is much more restricted I hold therefore, that the scope of S. 12 does not permit an investigation into the question of tenancy of a person claiming as a tenant both against the mortgagor, and the mortgagee. In Ram Kirpal v. Bnagwati Saran it was found that the mortgagee was in actual possession and he got the name of his nephew fictitiously entered in the village papers in collusion with the patwari. The present is a much stronger case, for here Mabadeo Singh is claiming as a tenant and there is no suggestion that his name is entered in the revenue papers fictitiously in collusion with the mortgagees. I see no reason to differ from the view taken by Seth J. and accordingly hold that the applicants cannot be allowed to have actual possession against Mahadeo Singh in these proceedings.

    13. Last it was contended that if Mahadeo Singh was in possession as a tenant of the plot before the mortgage, then the applicants will have no claim to oust him but if he was let into possession by the mortgagees, then the mortgagors must be restored to their possession and in order to determine this question of fact the case should be remanded. I am not prepared to allow this matter to be gone into at this stage. The mortgagors put up no such case in the Courts below and I cannot allow them to do so at this belated stage. The result is that the application fails and is dismissed with costs.

    V.R.B

    14. Revision dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Datt Singh v. Ajodhia Singh
    (Apr 10, 1950)