Citation Codes Equivalent Citations citation codes Docket Number CV-25-0783 See more information ... Smart Summary Please sign up to generate summary. OPINION ORIGINAL PDF To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe. Matter of Zero Waste Ithaca v. thaca City Planning & Dev. Bd. Matter of Zero Waste Ithaca v thaca City Planning & Dev. Bd. 2026 NY Slip Op 06600 November 12, 2026 Appellate Division, Third Department Published by New York State Law Reporting Bureau pursuant to Judiciary Law § 431. This decision is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports. In the Matter of Zero Waste Ithaca, Appellant, v Ithaca City Planning & Development Board et al., Respondents. Decided and Entered:November 12, 2026 CV-25-0783 Calendar Date: September 16, 2026 Before: Reynolds Fitzgerald, J.P., Fisher, Mcshan, Mackey And Corcoran, JJ. Pace Environmental Litigation Clinic, Inc., White Plains (Todd D. Ommen of counsel), for appellant. Victor J. Kessler, City Attorney, Ithaca (James F. Kenniff of counsel), for Ithaca City Planning & Development Board, respondent. Cornell University, Ithaca (Jared M. Pittman of counsel), for Cornell University, respondent. [*1] Mackey, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Mark Masler, J.), entered April 28, 2025 in Tompkins County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, to review, among other things, a determination of respondent Ithaca City Planning & Development Board adopting a negative declaration of environmental significance. In December 2023, respondent Cornell University applied to respondent Ithaca City Planning & Development Board (hereinafter the planning board) for site plan approval in connection with a development project to expand the recreational mixed-use athletic facilities available to students on campus (hereinafter referred to as the project). Located in central campus and bordered by other buildings and facilities owned and occupied by Cornell, the project included the replacement and expansion of existing outdoor natural grass and synthetic turf fields with an updated outdoor synthetic turf field and an indoor synthetic turf field with accompanying facilities housed in a nearby 90,000- square-foot building. The planning board reviewed the project over the course of several months at several board and committee meetings, allowing public comment and directing Cornell to provide information in response to issues raised by the public regarding the environmental and health risks associated with synthetic turf due to the potential presence of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (hereinafter PFAS), semi-volatile organic compounds (hereinafter SVOCs), volatile organic compound (hereinafter VOCs) and microplastics found in the component materials. Cornell furnished the planning board with the requested information and, following further discussion, the planning board approved a final version of the full environmental assessment form identifying the relevant areas of environmental and health concerns and concluding that the project did not pose a significant risk of harm to people or the environment. The planning board then issued a negative declaration pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act (see ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) and approved Cornell's application, contingent upon Cornell subjecting the synthetic turf ultimately selected for the project to third-party testing for PFAS. Petitioner, a volunteer not-for-profit organization dedicated to promoting zero-waste policies and advocating against the use of materials that contain pollutants and toxic chemicals, thereafter commenced this proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78. Petitioner alleged that the planning board's determinations were arbitrary and capricious in that they overlooked the documented dangers of certain chemicals used in components of synthetic turf by issuing a negative declaration for the project and concluding that there was no significant risk in that regard, thereby obviating the need for an environmental impact statement (hereinafter EIS) pursuant to SEQRA. Petitioner's subsequent attempt to obtain a temporary restraining [*2]order and a preliminary injunction enjoining Cornell from continuing construction of the project was denied. Oral argument ensued, after which Supreme Court dismissed the petition, finding that the planning board had complied with the requirements of SEQRA in issuing the negative declaration. Petitioner appeals.FN1 "This Court will not disturb a SEQRA determination so long as the lead agency identified the pertinent areas of environmental concern, took a hard look at them and advanced a reasoned elaboration of the grounds for its determination" (Matter of Binghamton Plaza, Inc. v City of Binghamton, N.Y., 228 AD3d 1041, 1044 [3d Dept 2024] 1 [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Schaller v Town of New Paltz Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 108 AD3d 821, 822-823 [3d Dept 2013]). In reviewing such determination, "it is not the role of the courts to weigh the desirability of any SEQRA action or choose among alternatives, but to assure that the agency itself has satisfied SEQRA, procedurally and substantively" (Matter of Save Southard Rd. Neighborhood Coalition v Town of Saratoga Planning Bd., 35 AD3d 1017, 1019 [3d Dept 2006] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citation omitted]; see Matter of Riverkeeper, Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of Southeast, 9 NY3d 219, 232 [2007]), and "[a] court may only annul an agency's determination to issue a negative declaration where it is arbitrary, capricious or unsupported by the evidence" (Matter of Creda, LLC v City of Kingston Planning Bd., 212 AD3d 1043, 1047-1048 [3d Dept 2023] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; see Matter of Hohman v Town of Poestenkill, 179 AD3d 1172, 1174 [3d Dept 2020]). In meeting SEQRA's mandate, "[a] negative declaration may be issued, obviating the need for an EIS, if the lead agency determines that no adverse environmental impacts will result or that the identified adverse environmental impacts will not be significant" (Matter of Village of Ballston Spa v City of Saratoga Springs, 163 AD3d 1220, 1223 [3d Dept 2018] [internal quotation marks, ellipsis, brackets and citations omitted]; see ECL 8-0109 [2]; 6 NYCRR 617.3 [c] [1]), and a type I action â such as this â "does not, per se, necessitate the filing of an EIS" (Matter of Gabrielli v Town of New Paltz, 116 AD3d 1315, 1316 [3d Dept 2014] [internal quotation marks, brackets and citation omitted]; see 6 NYCRR 617.4 [a] [1]). The record before us is extensive, detailing the various studies and expert examinations and recommendations relied upon by the planning board in identifying and evaluating the relevant areas of health and environmental concern of the project. Over several months of an open and deliberative process, the planning board reviewed engineering and architectural reports prepared by various consultants, several scientific reports, as well as Cornell's application materials, and actively invited public comment thereon. Of note, a memorandum prepared by H & A of New York Engineering and Geology[*3], and submitted by Cornell, examined the risks associated with certain synthetic turf components. To this end, the H & A memo noted two studies conducted by synthetic material producers finding that "fewer PFAS compounds were detected in synthetic turf, and at lower concentrations, than those that are present as a background condition in soil" from the growing prolific use of PFAS in everyday items. In a study that also tested for SVOCs, it was similarly observed that "[m]ost SVOCs were not detected, and those that were detected were below standards and screening levels." The H & A memo thus concluded that "synthetic turf systems are safe for contact by people and will not harm groundwater or surface water." Another report cited five peer-reviewed studies that the use of synthetic turf would not cause adverse effects to human health above safety levels determined by the US Environmental Protection Agency and European Union, and that VOC emissions from synthetic turf were generally not detectable. Other peer-reviewed studies similarly concluded that exposure to rubber infills was not harmful to people or ground water. The planning board further highlighted a federal multiagency research study finding that, due to the small amount of chemicals released from the infill and turf, there was only marginal if any difference in the presence of chemical metabolites in study populations as compared to background samples or the general population. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the planning board called for further information from Cornell, including how it planned to alleviate any potential health concerns raised in public comments. Cornell accordingly submitted additional materials consisting of its own reports and those of various project consultants, emphasizing that "more than 110 technical studies conducted by a variety of trusted scientific authorities, including the US EPA, Washington State Department of Health, US Department of Energy and Environment, and more" have concluded that "[a]rtificial turf has been shown to pose no health risk." In nevertheless addressing the environmental concerns associated with the use of synthetic turf, Cornell articulated its plan for preventing microplastic pollution through a storm water management process â including a filtration system equipped to filter out microplastics down to particles 0.212 millimeters in size â and it further agreed to third-party testing of the synthetic turf ultimately chosen for use in the project for PFAS. The record thus amply demonstrates that the planning board made a careful and deliberate consideration of the relevant areas of health and environmental concern, took the requisite hard look, and made a reasoned elaboration in issuing a negative declaration; thus, we find no basis to disturb its determination (see Matter of Creda, LLC v City of Kingston Planning Bd., 212 AD3d at 1048-1049; Matter of Schaller v Town of New Paltz Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 108 AD3d at 822-824; Matter of Save [*4]Southard Rd. Neighborhood Coalition v Town of Saratoga Planning Bd., 35 AD3d at 1019-1021; Matter of Defreestville Area Neighborhood Assn., Inc. v Planning Bd. of Town of N. Greenbush, 16 AD3d 715, 721- 723 [3d Dept 2005]; compare Matter of Bigelow v Town of Willsboro Planning Bd., 243 AD3d 979, 983 [3d Dept 2025]; Matter of Clean Air Action Network of Glens Falls, Inc. v Town of Moreau Planning Bd., 235 AD3d 1124, 1127-1129 [3d Dept 2025]). The requirements of SEQRA having been met, we will not disturb the determination. Alternative grounds for affirmance advanced by Cornell have been rendered academic in light of our determination. Reynolds Fitzgerald, J.P., Fisher, McShan and Corcoran, JJ., concur. ORDERED that the judgment is affirmed, without costs. Footnotes Footnote 1 Petitioner sought a preliminary injunction pending the instant appeal enjoining the construction and installation of synthetic turf fields at the project site, which motion this Court denied (2025 NY Slip Op 75957[U] [3d Dept 2025]). 2