ORDER
After careful consideration of the parties' briefs and the record on appeal, and following oral argument, it appears to the Court that:
(1) In this appeal, Stephen Heck challenges his criminal conviction for the murder of his girlfriend, Cynthia Amalfitano. For the reasons stated below, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
(2) Heck and Amalfitano began dating in 2020, just before the pandemic.1On Saturday, September 23, 2023, the pair planned to travel to Amalfitano's Rehoboth
1
2
Beach condominium for a weekend getaway.2Before leaving for the beach, Amalfitano had texted Heck, "okay sweetie see you in a bit."3
(3) Amalfitano did not report to work on the following Monday. Amalfitano's boss contacted her family to check on her because she had not requested the day off.4Her sister, Sandra Saienni, tried calling Amalfitano and Heck, but neither answered their cell phones.5Heck eventually called back but hung up without saying a word.6
(4) Amalfitano's sister-in-law, Donna Galliani, went to Amalfitano's New Castle County residence to look for her.7Galliani went to the rear of Amalfitano's home and knocked on the back door, but no one answered.8Galliani found this odd because Amalfitano's Jeep was sitting in the parking lot.9Galliani tried to open the back door, found it unlocked, and walked inside.10Galliani found no sign of Amalfitano.11She discovered Amalfitano's two dogs unattended, which was strange
3
because one of the dogs never left Amalfitano's side.12Galliani also found Amalfitano's luggage lying on the coffee table.13Galliani went back outside to dial 911, but before she could dial, she spotted a New Castle County Police Department ("NCCPD") vehicle passing by. She flagged it down.14The police searched Amalfitano's residence; they too found no sign of Amalfitano.15But they did find a black purse containing Amalfitano's wallet and cell phone.16NCCPD initiated a missing-persons investigation.17
(5) After calling Heck's cell phone several times with no answer, NCCPD went to his house.18Upon arrival, the police saw Heck walking toward his car, a grey Subaru.19As they approached him, the police noticed that he was shaking, his forearms were covered with scratch marks, and he had some additional scratch marks across his forehead.20The police asked Heck if he knew of his girlfriend's whereabouts.21Heck
4
responded by stating that Amalfitano was not his girlfriend.22The police found Heck's statement "concerning" as they had been told otherwise by Galliani.23After this encounter with Heck, the police considered him a person-of-interest in Amalfitano's disappearance.24
(6) The police continued their search for Amalfitano by collecting security camera footage from Amalfitano's New Castle County and Rehoboth Beach neighbors. The Rehoboth footage showed that on Sunday, September 24, around 7:12 p.m., Heck and Amalfitano loaded their belongings into Heck's Subaru and left the beach house.25 At 10:55 p.m., Heck arrived at Amalfitano's residence without her.26Heck can be seen carrying one of Amalfitano's dogs into the residence.27Then, on Monday morning, Heck is captured on video leaving the residence in his Subaru.28
(7) The security footage did not account for the gap of time from when Heck and Amalfitano left the beach house to when Heck arrived at her residence. To determine what happened during this interval, NCCPD obtained Amalfitano's cell-site
5
location information ("CSLI") from her cell phone carrier.29Amalfitano's CSLI confirmed that her cell phone traveled from her beach house to her residence on Sunday evening.30And for one hour and thirty-seven minutes—from approximately 9:15 p.m. until 10:52 p.m.—Amalfitano's cell phone was "relatively stationary" near Carousel Park.31
(8) On Tuesday morning, September 26, NCCPD searched for Amalfitano in Carousel Park.32Before long, NCCPD discovered Amalfitano's lifeless body in a ditch.33Due to the battered condition of her body, the police converted their missing- persons case into a murder investigation.34
6
(9) The police obtained search warrants for Heck's residence, vehicle, person, and cell phone contents.35In searching Heck's residence, police found records showing that Heck had previously been arrested for domestic violence against Amalfitano.36 When searching Heck's person, police found Heck's cell phone in one of his pockets.37 And when searching Heck's Subaru, police found "reddish-brown" stains throughout its interior.38These stains were subjected to two types of presumptive serology tests to determine whether the stains were blood.39The two tests were the Bluestar latent bloodstain test (the "Bluestar test") and the reduced phenolphthalein blood test ("PPB
7
test").40Both tests indicated that the stains possibly contained blood.41The police took DNA swabs of the stains. DNA testing on swabs confirmed the presence of Amalfitano's and Heck's DNA.42
(10) NCCPD also prepared a warrant application, supported by a 50-paragraph affidavit of probable cause, for Heck's CSLI. The affidavit contained information about the neighbors' security footage,43information derived from Amalfitano's CSLI and cell phone contents,44the results of the serology and DNA testing,45and Heck's history of domestic violence against Amalfitano.46Notably, one averment stated:
8
"persons who own and/or possess cellular phones often times have the phones on and/or near their person during the course of their travels throughout a given day."47
(11) The court granted the search warrant for Heck's CSLI.48The CSLI confirmed that Heck's cell phone had traveled with Amalfitano's cell phone from the beach house, to the vicinity of Carousel Park, and then back to Amalfitano's residence.49Heck's CSLI not only corroborated the camera footage from Amalfitano's neighbors but it also confirmed that Heck's phone remained at Amalfitano's residence overnight.50The police arrested Heck and charged him with Amalfitano's murder.51
(12) Before trial, Heck moved to suppress the evidence obtained under the CSLI search warrant and the results from the PPB test. Specifically, Heck argued that the CSLI warrant's supporting affidavit did not establish probable cause and that, therefore, the CSLI evidence should be suppressed.52Heck argued that the PPB test should be suppressed because, as a presumptive test, the results were unreliable under
9
Delaware Rule of Evidence 702 ("D.R.E. 702").53The Superior Court denied Heck's suppression motions and proceeded to trial.54
(13) At trial, the State presented several witnesses, including Delaware's Chief Medical Examiner, Dr. Gary Collins. Dr. Collins opined that Amalfitano likely died 12-24 hours before the police discovered her body.55He further opined that this range was only an estimate, and that the jury should not rely on it as a conclusive time of death.56During the State's closing argument, the prosecutor stated "Dr. Collins told you about the estimated time of death, somewhere around 24 to 30 to 12 hours, an estimate."57Heck did not object. The jury convicted Heck of first-degree murder, and the Superior Court sentenced him to life in prison.58
(14) Heck appealed to this Court, raising three claims. First, Heck contends that the Superior Court exceeded its discretion "in denying [his] motion to suppress in relation to the [] CSLI [w]arrant."59Second, Heck argues that the Superior Court
"abused its discretion in denying [his] motion to exclude serology evidence."60Last,
10
Heck claims, for the first time, that the State committed prosecutorial misconduct by intentionally misrepresenting Dr. Collins's time-of-death testimony during its closing argument.61
STANDARD OF REVIEW
(15) We review "a trial court's denial of a motion to suppress after an evidentiary hearing challenging the sufficiency of a search warrant . . . for abuse of discretion."62Our review examines whether the search warrant "set[s] forth facts adequate for a neutral judicial officer to form a reasonable belief that an offense has been committed and that seizable property would be found in a particular place."63 Similarly, we review the Superior Court's admission of evidence under D.R.E. 702 for abuse of discretion.64We review claims raised for the first time on appeal for plain error.65
ANALYSIS
A. The Cell-Site Location Information
(16) The Superior Court did not abuse its discretion when it declined to suppress Heck's CSLI. Absent exigent circumstances, the State must obtain a warrant
11
supported by probable cause to search an individual's CSLI.66"In determining whether probable cause has been demonstrated, there must be a logical nexus between the items sought and the place to be searched."67"The law is well established that probable cause to search a location for—or, in the case of CSLI, to demand—particular items or records is demonstrated where a totality of circumstances indicates a 'fair probability that contraband or evidence of a crime will be found' thereby."68These determinations
"must be premised on the information within the four-corners of the affidavit in support of a search warrant."69
(17) Here, Heck argues that the affidavit supporting the warrant application did not establish probable cause because it failed to demonstrate a connection between Amalfitano's murder and Heck's CSLI.70Focusing on one averment in the affidavit - among fifty - Heck contends that the Superior Court improperly denied his motion to suppress on the basis that Heck was a suspect in the crime and that most people compulsively carry their cell phones.71At oral argument, Heck gave an example of
12
what he believed would satisfy the warrant requirement - "if there was a surveillance photo or surveillance video around the time of the crime or at the time of the crime that showed [the defendant] in possession . . . of the phone . . . ."72
(18) Heck asserts that Dorsey v. State supports his position and controls here.73 We disagree. In Dorsey, police responded to a shooting where the victim was a boarder in one of the defendant's properties.74When the police were unable to find a firearm at the property, they applied for a warrant to search two automobiles owned by the defendant parked outside the property.75The Superior Court denied the defendant's motion to suppress, finding that the automobiles' connection to the crime could be inferred "given the nature of the crime and the items sought by [p]olice."76We reversed the Superior Court because the affidavit of probable cause did not connect the shooting to the defendant's vehicles.77
(19) Heck's situation differs from Dorsey. In the affidavit at issue here, we have an averment that Heck possessed his cell phone before leaving for the beach on
13
Saturday, the day before the murder;78Heck returned Saienni's phone call on Monday, September 25, the day after the murder;79and Heck had his cell phone when the police searched him.80In addition, the record contains video and photographic evidence showing that Heck was the last one seen with Amalfitano around 8:40 p.m., driving back from the beach house on Sunday evening,81and Heck arrived at her residence alone.82These averments establish the requisite "logical nexus" between Heck's CSLI and evidence related to Amalfitano's murder.83Even without the general averment that people compulsively carry their cell phones, there was sufficient probable cause within the four corners of the affidavit to conclude that Heck's CSLI would contain evidence relating to the crime.84Accordingly, we find that the Superior Court did not exceed its discretion in denying Heck's motion to suppress his CSLI.
14
B. The Serology Evidence
(20) Next, Heck argues that the Superior Court abused its discretion by allowing the Bluestar and PPB blood tests and the accompanying expert testimony into evidence.85D.R.E. 702 provides that experts may testify if, among other factors, their
"testimony is based on reliable principles and methods."86D.R.E. 702 ensures that
"any and all scientific testimony . . . is not only relevant, but reliable."87In exercising its gatekeeping role, a trial court evaluating reliability may consider "testing, peer review, error rates, and 'acceptability' in the relevant scientific community."88"The grounds for the expert's opinion merely have to be good, they do not have to be perfect."89"Accordingly, admission of expert witness testimony requires reliability, not infallibility."90
(21) Heck challenges the reliability of the blood tests under D.R.E. 702 because they are only presumptive tests and, in his view, unreliable.91Because Heck conceded below that the PPB test had "been tested," "subjected to peer review," and generally
15
accepted "in the forensic science community,"92his reliability challenge of the PPB test is limited to the error rates.93Heck did not argue at trial that the Bluestar test was unreliable under D.R.E. 702,94so our review of the Bluestar test's reliability is for plain error.95"Plain errors are 'material defects which are apparent on the face of the record, which are basic, serious, and fundamental in their character, and which clearly deprive an accused of a substantial right, or which clearly show manifest injustice.'"96
(22) The Bluestar and PPB tests and the accompanying expert testimony were sufficiently reliable for admission. D.R.E. 702 requires judges to ask a threshold gatekeeping question, "whether the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods,"97not whether the methods supporting the testimony are 100% conclusive. Holding otherwise would replace D.R.E. 702's "reliability" requirement with
"infallibility."98The experts' trial testimony about the procedures they used to administer the blood tests and that the tests are not conclusive is sufficient to overcome Heck's complained-of error. Accordingly, we find that the court did not plainly err or abuse its discretion in admitting the blood tests and the related testimony into evidence.
16
C. Prosecutorial Misconduct
(23) Finally, Heck argues that the State committed prosecutorial misconduct when it remarked in its closing argument about the timing of Amalfitano's death. Heck did not object to the statement during trial, nor did he raise this argument below; therefore, we review for plain error.99
(24) In a plain error review of prosecutorial misconduct, we perform a de novo review to determine whether misconduct occurred.100The State did not commit misconduct here. Heck argues that the prosecutor's statement—that Amalfitano died
"somewhere around 24 to 30 to 12 hours, an estimate" before her body was discovered—was an intentional misstatement of the evidence that bolstered the State's theory of the case. A claim of prosecutorial misconduct may lie where a prosecutor intentionally misstates evidence presented to the jury during trial.101Heck's argument fails because, as read, the set of numbers is incomprehensible as a concrete timeframe. Therefore, the statement was most likely a mistake that was corrected mid-sentence. The lack of a trial objection from Heck supports this interpretation.
(25) Further, even if the statement were intentional, Heck does not satisfy the final Suber inquiry. The fourth step of the Suber analysis requires a showing that the
17
error adversely affected Heck's "substantial rights by jeopardizing the fairness and integrity of the trial process."102Here, Heck remained unprejudiced. If Amalfitano was killed 30 hours before her body was discovered, as stated by the prosecutor, that would mean that she died on Monday morning. This timeline would contradict the State's theory of the case. The State's theory of the case required the jury to find that Heck killed Amalfitano on Sunday night because Heck's CSLI placed him at Amalfitano's residence 30 hours before the police discovered her body.103Moreover, Dr. Collins testified that his time-of-death range was only an estimate and should not be relied upon. The prosecutor's misstatement had no impact on the "fairness and integrity of the trial process."104Thus, we will not disturb Heck's conviction on this ground.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that the judgment of the Superior Court is AFFIRMED.
BY THE COURT:
/s/ N. Christopher Griffiths Justice