8
RUSHING, Circuit Judge, concurring in part and dissenting in part:
I agree with the majority that the district court correctly dismissed Reeves's discrimination claim and correctly granted summary judgment to the defendants on Reeves's hostile work environment claim. But unlike the majority, I would also affirm summary judgment in the defendants' favor on Reeves's retaliation claim. No reasonable jury could find that the defendants' asserted reason for Reeves's negative performance evaluation and termination—namely, his well-documented history of poor work performance, which predated his protected activities and persisted throughout his employment—was a pretext for retaliation. See Foster v. Univ. of Md.-E. Shore, 787 F.3d 243, 250, 252 (4th Cir. 2015) (applying McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green, 411 U.S. 792 (1973)). Accordingly, I would affirm in full.
Shortly after Reeves began his probationary employment at the National Geospatial- Intelligence Agency in July 2019, his supervisors, Gondeck and Cichetti, grew concerned about his performance. In September, Gondeck contacted the human resources department for advice about how to address Reeves's continuing performance problems. On October 10, Gondeck and Cichetti met with Reeves to discuss their concerns. They explained that his work product was "neither timely nor of requisite quality." J.A. 334. Reeves's team members felt "as though [Reeves did] not respect their experiences or opinions" and that he had "been dismissive or condescending towards them." J.A. 334. And his conduct was
"adversely affecting both substantive production and morale." J.A. 334. His supervisors specifically noted that Reeves was not on track to meet his performance objectives and cautioned that they "need[ed] to see immediate significant improvement in the timeliness
9
and quality of the work product and the manner in which [he] engage[d] with [his] teammates." J.A. 335. They explained that they would "take a more direct role in the day- to-day taskings" of Reeves's division, asked him to attend training and coaching, and provided him with specific guidance on improving his performance. J.A. 336. On October 21, Gondeck and Cichetti held a follow-up discussion with Reeves and provided additional examples of his performance deficiencies. They also informed Reeves they would initiate an Ombudsman Facilitated Self-Assessment of his division and its workplace culture. Gondeck and Cichetti met with Reeves again on November 15 to continue providing feedback and guidance about objectives he "was still not performing successfully." J.A. 314. Among other things, they expressed concern about his continuing lack of subject-matter expertise and the "virtually daily" complaints they received from employees and contractors about his "engagement and communication style." J.A. 315. Gondeck and Cichetti received the Ombudsman's report on November 22. Comments from division personnel in the report "confirm[ed] what [Gondeck and Cichetti] were hearing and seeing" regarding the seriousness of Reeves's performance and behavior problems. J.A. 243; see J.A. 318-319. Through January and February 2020, members of Reeves's team continued raising concerns to Gondeck and Cichetti about his leadership, management style, and lack of subject-matter expertise. And as of February 2020, Reeves continued to have "performance issues on a daily to multiple per week" basis. J.A. 381. In April 2020, Gondeck and Cichetti submitted an extensive formal memorandum documenting Reeves's "unacceptable performance and behavior" and recommending his
"removal during [his] trial period." J.A. 303, 305. This 27-page memorandum chronicled
10
Reeves's troubled tenure, including twelve specific scenarios and their impact on the agency. Reeves's supervisors concluded that he "regularly demonstrates poor decision quality, lacks the ability to think critically, refuses to accept responsibility for his work or that of his subordinates, fails to deliver quality work product in accordance with deadlines,
. . . routinely conducts himself in a manner inconsistent with [the agency's] [v]alues, . . . demonstrate[s] complete disregard for . . . feedback and constructive direction," and treats the personnel in his division in an "unwarranted, unprovoked, toxic, and degrading"
manner. J.A. 330.
That was all before Reeves engaged in the protected activity on which he bases his retaliation claim. In May and June of 2020, Reeves complained to human resources that Gondeck and Cichetti allegedly harassed and discriminated against him, and they became aware of his complaints in July 2020. Reeves alleges that the following two events occurred in retaliation for his protected activity.
In October 2020, Reeves received his performance evaluation for the year ending September 30, 2020, in which Gondeck rated Reeves's overall performance as a "1.0" on a scale of 1 to 5—an "[u]nacceptable" rating. J.A. 532. After three phases of agency reconsideration, Reeves's overall rating remained unchanged. In December 2020, the Personnel Evaluation Board met to discuss Reeves's situation and recommended he be removed. After reviewing the documentation, including "examples provided by management about [Reeves's] failure to meet expectations," the director of human resources decided that Reeves's "poor performance . . . warranted removal during the trial
11
period." J.A. 512. On January 15, 2021, the director issued a letter informing Reeves that his employment would be terminated effective January 29, 2021.
Despite the undisputed evidence of Reeves's poor performance predating his protected activity, the majority believes a reasonable jury could find Reeves received an
"unacceptable" rating and was terminated, not because of his deficient performance as the defendants claim, but in retaliation for his protected activity. The majority bases this conclusion on Reeves's assertion that, in July 2019 when he began his job, Gondeck and Cichetti told him he would be fired if he brought "an EEO case." J.A. 141. On these facts, that alleged comment makes no difference. For a full year before Gondeck and Cichetti became aware of Reeves's EEO allegations, they had received constant complaints from Reeves's colleagues and had consistently documented his unacceptable performance. And three months before they were aware of his allegations, Gondeck and Cichetti recommended that Reeves be terminated. Even viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to Reeves, the actions that led to his negative evaluation and termination "began before [his] protected activity, belying the conclusion that a reasonable factfinder might find that [those decisions were] motivated by [Reeves's] complaints." Francis v. Booz, Allen & Hamilton, Inc., 452 F.3d 299, 309 (4th Cir. 2006); see also Barnhill v. Bondi, 138 F.4th 123, 133 (4th Cir. 2025). I would therefore affirm the district court's decision in full.