Per the habitual-offender statute, evidence of a conviction or finding of guilt may be proved by "a certified copy of the record . . . by a court of record.2While this case does not involve habitual-offender status, this statute provides the best requirement of what is necessary to prove a conviction. Day introduced a certified copy of the district court's record with the following notations:
WARDLAW, LAURA MICHELLE
Violation 1 Citation hc18-41 Age at Violation 35 Plea: 09-27-18 NO PLEA
5-37-302(b)(1)(A) HOT CHECK<= $1,000 1ST OFFENSE Disp:09-27-18 GUILTY - BOND FOR
Level: MU UNCLASSIFIED MISDEMEANOR Violation Date 07-13-18 (F: $290 R: $103.98 = $393.98) The docket reflects a disposition of "Guilty - Bond For." All parties agree "Bond For"
references bond forfeiture. But "Guilty" on a court disposition record must mean something. And it must relate to the offense listed, Hot Check, because bond forfeiture is not a criminal offense for which one could be determined guilty. Rather, bond forfeiture occurs according to a precise statutory forfeiture scheme.3This court has certainly seen actions arising from bond forfeitures. Those actions relate to a defendant's failure to appear and thus forfeits a posted bond--they do not negate a criminal charge as if it never happened.4
16
In addition to reflecting a disposition of "guilty," the certified record shows a payment of restitution, fines, and fees. A judge may order a defendant to pay restitution if the defendant has been found guilty, pled guilty, or doesn't contest an offense.5No provision of Arkansas law permits restitution to be ordered without one of those dispositions. And as we have said, "there can be no fine without a conviction."6Had it been a bond forfeiture, the county should not have turned the funds over to the city because "where money is deposited in lieu of bail with a county official, after the forfeiture" the county treasurer shall deposit the funds to the credit of the county general fund.7This was not done; instead, the funds were disbursed as if there were a conviction. The certified records support a finding of guilt for the offense.
Summing up the evidence, the circuit court considered: (1) a certified court record identifying Wardlaw as the defendant; (2) an admission by Wardlaw that she was the defendant and that intent to defraud was an element of the crime;8(3) a certified court record showing "no plea" but then a disposition of "Guilty - Bond For"; (4) a certified court record showing payment for restitution and fines; and (5) testimony the city received the funds from the county. This evidence met the preponderance-of-the-evidence standard that Wardlaw was guilty of an infamous crime that prevents her from holding office. The
17
word guilty can only mean guilty,9and a fine and restitution can only occur after a conviction under Arkansas law, whereas a bond forfeiture would have the funds remaining with the county. Thus, the circuit court clearly erred by finding Wardlaw eligible to hold office. Day had a clear and certain right to mandamus relief.
The contrary evidence was based on witness testimony that attempted to overcome the "guilty" language on a certified docket sheet. For example, Wardlaw argued she never pled guilty, never appeared, and only paid a bond that was forfeited. These arguments collaterally attack the entry of a "guilty" disposition. Generally, a defendant who does not appeal cannot collaterally attack a judgment of conviction.10
While I do not condone how the district court entered Wardlaw's guilty plea, Wardlaw bears responsibility. She knew of the charge, paid the amount due, and did not contest it.
The path the majority carves out for criminal charges in district court is troubling when sentencing and dispositions are statutorily based. What now becomes of Wardlaw's hot-check case remains to be seen. If it's not a conviction, is it an acquittal? I think not. I am curious to see how the district court resolves her case and all others like this. I find that the plain language of our certified court records must be given due regard. I worry the majority's decision opens the door to additional collateral attacks on criminal convictions. I am also concerned that district courts may have been collecting fines and fees
18
under the now-mistaken belief that voluntary payments to resolve criminal charges constitute a conviction. If those payments instead constitute bond forfeitures, those payments must be deposited in the county general fund, not remitted to the victim or district court.11The majority's decision could unwittingly open the door to illegal-exaction lawsuits against counties and cities. For these reasons, I respectfully dissent. Harris Shelton Hanover Walsh, PLLC, by: Jacob R. Swatley, for appellant. The Sanders Firm, PLLC, by: Landon T. Sanders, Preston T. Sanders, and J. Locke Adair, for appellee Laura Wardlaw.
Tim Griffin, Att'y Gen., by: Steven Benson, Ass't Att'y Gen., for Arkansas Secretary of State Cole Jester.
Matthew J. Shepherd , P.A., by: Matthew J. Shepherd, for appellees Republican Party of Arkansas; and Sharon Stuthard, in in her official capacity as Secretary of the State Committee of the Republican Party of Arkansas.