Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)

WILLIAM H. MARTIN v. FRANK K. ASTON

         The city of Santa Cruz is an independent road district, duly incorporated and empowered to maintain her own streets, and having exclusive control and jurisdiction thereof.

         The Act of the Legislature of the State of California, incorporating the city of Santa Cruz, provides as follows, Stat. 1875-1876, p. 192, § 9: " It shall have power * * * to lay out, alter, open, vacate, improve, cleanse, water, and repair streets." This the city has done.

         The Courts of other States have settled this point. (The State v. Jones, 18 Tex. 874; Goddard, Petitioner, 16 Pick. 503; Taintor v. The Mayor and Common Council of Morristown , 33 N. J. L. 57; Cross v. Morristown , 18 N. J. Eq. 305: Fox v. The City of Rockford , 38 Ill. 454; Indianapolis v. Croas , 7 Ind. 9; Lafayette v. Jenners , 10 id. 79; Town of Ottawa v. Walker , 21 Ill. 608.)

         There can be no doubt from the foregoing that the City of Santa Cruz is an independent road district, having exclusive control of its streets and alleys, and that no part of the general road fund can be expended within its limits. (People v. Townsend , 56 Cal. 633; Knox v. Board of Supervisors of Los Angeles County , 58 id. 59; Wells v. City of Weston , 22 Mo. 384; Cooley on Taxation, 105, 109; Hingham & Quincy Bridge Co. v. Norfolk, 6 Allen, 353; Tilford v. Douglass , 41 Ind. 580; Town of Pleasant v. Kost , 29 Ill. 494.)

         It is in violation of the Constitution of this State in relation to taxation.

         1. Article xi, Section 12, of our Constitution, provides: " The Legislature shall have no power to impose taxes upon counties, cities, towns, or other public or municipal corporations, or upon the inhabitants or property thereof, for county, city, town, or other municipal purposes, but may bygeneral laws vest in the corporate authorities thereof the power to assess and collect taxes for such purposes. (People v. Parks , 58 Cal. 624.)

         2. " All property in the State, not exempt under the laws of the United States, shall be taxed in proportion to its value, to be ascertained as provided by law." (Const., Art. xiii, § 1.)

         That " taxation must be uniform and equal," is no more than saying each district must pay as it is benefited. (Weeks v. City of Milwaukee , 10 Wis. 258; Cooley on Taxation, 104.)

         3. To collect this tax would be taking private property without compensation. (People v. Townsend , 56 Cal. 633; Wells v. The City of Weston , 22 Mo. 384; Cooley on Taxation, 105.)

         If the Board of Supervisors is authorized to levy a roadtax, by Section 2664 of the Political Code of this State, the tax can not be levied or collected from the inhabitants or property within the City of Santa Cruz.

         It is observable of this section that it has been the law since the adoption of the Codes, and has never been repealed or changed.

         It is argued that this section is unconstitutional, in that it violates that provision of Article xiii, Section 1, which provides that " all property shall be taxed in proportion to its value." Such would, without doubt, be the case if the inhabitants and property within the city or town were relieved from taxation. Such is not the provision of the section. It provides, in substance, that the city must maintain its own streets and alleys, and, when it so maintains them, then its inhabitants and property will be relieved from taxation for roads outside of the city. When this is done by a city, the county at large is relieved from the burden of maintaining such roads and streets. (Hunsacker v. Wright , 30 Ill. 147; Board of Supervisors v. Campbell et al. , 42 id. 490; Tilford v. Douglass , 41 Ind. 580; Cooper et al. v. Ash , 76 id. 11.)

         The doctrine of commutation has been passed on in a number of States, the Constitutions of which provide for equal and uniform taxation. (O'Donnell v. Bailey , 24 Miss. 386; Gardner v. The State , 21 N. J. L. 558; Daughdrill v. Alta Life Ins. & Trust Co. , 31 Ala. 91; M. & St. P. R. R. v. Crawford Co. , 29 Wis. 116; Osborn v. N. Y. & N.H. R. R., 40 (Conn. 491.)

         It is argued by appellantthat the City of Santa Cruz does not levy a property road-tax. The record shows that the City of Santa Cruz levies a tax upon all the property within the city for a general fund. That out of this fund so raised in compliance with the Charter of the city, the Street Commissioner has been paid. It is his duty to open, repair, and keep the streets of the city, etc. And he has so done.

         The record shows that a portion of the streets of the City of Santa Cruz are accepted streets. The streets must be kept up and in repair out of the general fund. (Stats. 1875-1876, p. 198, § 23.)

         OPINION          In Bank. The Court:

         Under the Charter of the City of Santa Cruz (Stat. 1875-1876, p. 189, etc.), the Common Council of the city has power to lay out and improve streets within the city, and to raise money therefor by assessment and taxation. The Court below found that all the streets and alleys within the city limits are wholly maintained, improved, and kept in repair by the city. Therefore, according to Section 2664, Political Code, the appellant had no authority to collect taxes for road purposes from inhabitants of or property within the city.

         Judgment affirmed.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Martin v. Aston
(Jan 20, 1882)