AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges

THE PEOPLE, Plaintiff and Respondent, v. JOHN MONTANEZ, JR., Defendant and Appellant.

RAYE, P. J.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115. (Super. Ct. No. 13F04910)

The jury watched video surveillance of defendant John Montanez, Jr., sporting gang colors and gang tattoos, fire six shots toward the two victims in the parking lot of the Arden Fair Mall. The jurors found him guilty of two counts of attempted murder and found true various weapon and gang enhancements. On appeal, he challenges the sufficiency of the evidence to support the attempted murder conviction and the gang enhancement, the jury instruction that was given on the kill zone and the failure to give a jury instruction on the lesser included offense of assault with a deadly weapon, and other asserted missteps by the gang expert. In supplemental briefing, he asserts his case must be remanded to permit the trial court to exercise the discretion provided to it by Senate Bill No. 620 (2017-2018 Reg. Sess.).

Finding no prejudicial error, we affirm.

FACTS Attempted Murder

Defendant and Jose Vasquez, both validated members of the Norteño criminal street gang and its subset, Varrio Franklin Boulevard (VFB), were at the mall on the afternoon of July 31, 2013. As they passed K.V., D.S., and D.M., none of whom were gang members or armed, defendant had eye contact with D.S. which, according to K.V., connoted a lack of respect. K.V. noticed that defendant and Vasquez were Hispanic and were wearing red, the color worn by Norteño gang members. Words were exchanged and K.V., who admitted he "had a head of rage," challenged defendant to a fight, saying "I'm going to knock your bitch ass out." They agreed to go outside and the five of them proceeded to the Macy's parking lot. En route, defendant shoved D.S. Their encounters were captured on videotape.

Once they got outside, defendant exclaimed, "Fuck this," and pulled out a gun and started firing. K.V. started "running for [his] life," zigzagging between the parked cars. D.M., scared for his life, ran back towards the mall and then across the street. He later told a detective he believed the guys were trying to kill him. A woman, who was driving out of the parking lot, heard the gunfire, saw males running off, and then noticed another male with a gun fire off a shot and run toward J.C. Penney's.

Although defendant fired six shots, no one was hit. At least three cars sustained bullet damage. During the investigation, D.M. told the police the Hispanic males looked "like Northerners" because they were Mexican and "wearing red." At trial, D.M. denied the incident was gang related. In a statement to police, he said he did not believe the shooter was actually firing at him. K.V. identified defendant as the shooter in a photographic lineup and from a security image the police showed him. Video cameras captured the shooting.

Defendant fled the scene and destroyed and discarded the gun. He lied to the police when he was first questioned.

Defendant testified in his own defense. He disavowed gang membership after high school and denied that the altercations he was involved in in prison were gang related. He claimed he got his tattoos while he was still involved with the gang. He minimized the amount of red he was wearing during the shooting, pointing out that his hat was red, white, and blue. Defendant maintained that one of the three guys tripped him and, in response, he pushed back. He explained that Vasquez handed the gun to him as they walked toward the outside. He admitted firing the gun, but claimed he was scared and nervous and did not intend to hit anyone. He insisted he fired the gun up into the air as he ran away from the group. Although he meant to only shoot into the air, he accidentally shot into some nearby cars.

Further Gang Evidence

Five police officers testified to contacts they had with defendant between 2007 and 2011. During these contacts, the officers observed him in gang clothing, associating with known gang members, or displaying his gang-related tattoos. He admitted gang membership and ownership of a fully loaded handgun.

Detective John Sample testified as an expert on criminal street gangs, specifically Norteño gangs. He provided the jury with the now customary primer on the psychology and sociology of criminal street gangs, including their customary colors, gang signs, turf boundaries, subsets, and common crimes. Central to their mission is to instill fear in the community and command respect. He explained how gang members pay "taxes" to subsidize the upper echelon of the gang hierarchy, particularly those housed in prison. He was careful to describe the relationship between Norteño and its various subsets and to point out that subsets often use the same identifying characteristics, such as the color red and the number 14. Subsets frequently join together to commit crimes, to maintain safety, and as a "power symbol." Membership can be fluid.

Sample opined that the subset VFB is a gang engaged in a pattern of criminal activity. He relied on two incidents, one in 2011 and one in 2012 to establish the requisite pattern. The first involved a validated VFB member who was found in possession of stolen guns and methamphetamine while in association with two other Norteños and convicted of a gang offense. The second involved another member of VFB who was convicted of being a felon in possession of a firearm. He further opined that the primary criminal activities of Norteños in Sacramento, and VFB in particular, were possession of guns, shootings, attempted murder, and sales of methamphetamine and cocaine. They benefited the gangs by instilling fear in nonmembers.

Sample chronicled defendant's lengthy affiliation with the Norteños, his admission he was a gang member, his frequent association with gang members, and his possession of handguns, a common gang practice. He was arrested in this case wearing red and white shoes, with a red tattoo on his chest, in the company of another Norteño gang member. He recounted two further incidents of gang-related conduct while defendant had been in jail.

Most importantly, Sample opined, based on a hypothetical that mirrored the facts in this case, that a crime like the Arden Fair Mall shooting was gang related and was committed with the specific intent to promote, further, or assist criminal conduct by e police officers who wrote the reports testified at trial and were subject to cross-examination. As to the predicate offenses described in those reports, therefore, defendant's right to confrontation was not abridged.

The prosecution sought to impeach defendant's testimony that he had forsaken his affiliation with the gang years earlier with evidence that he was ensnarled in gang incidents in the jail. No one from the jail, however, testified to defendant's gang-related behavior in jail. We agree with defendant that Sample's testimony about the case-specific facts surrounding his conduct at the jail constituted inadmissible testimonial hearsay in violation of his Sixth Amendment right to confrontation. We disagree, however, that the error was prejudicial.

There is an abundance of evidence that defendant was a member of VFB, that he was in the company of another validated VFB member at the time of the shooting, that he was tattooed with gang indicia, that he was wearing gang clothing at the time of the shooting, and that mere "eye contact" sparked the shooting. Whether or not he had disavowed gang affiliation by the time he got to jail was rather insignificant given that it was his gang affiliation at the time of the shooting that was relevant to imposition of the gang enhancement. As a result, the case-specific statements Sample made about the jail incidents would have been of little consequence to the jurors' assessment whether the crimes were gang related and whether defendant intended to benefit the gang. We conclude the admission of his testimonial hearsay statements was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. (Sanchez, supra, 63 Cal.4th at pp. 698-699.)

B. Misconduct

We need not explore the legal nuances as to whether the gang expert's testimony can be construed as prosecutorial misconduct or whether there would be some other legal pigeon-hole for misbehavior by a gang expert because there was nothing untoward about the detective's testimony that defendant might have flashed a gang sign. In fact, it was defense counsel who repeatedly backed him into a corner and instigated the testimony defendant now challenges.

The problem was this. D.S., one of the two victims, absolutely refused to testify. He was granted immunity and yet he refused to testify. He was held in contempt and yet he refused to testify. But he had made a statement to the police after the shooting that he saw defendant flash a gang sign. The videotape of the purported gang sign was unclear. The detective believed the statement constituted inadmissible hearsay and he avoided it. Nevertheless, defense counsel asked him several times in several different ways whether it was possible the gesture he saw on the videotape was not a gang sign and, if it was not, whether he would change his opinion that defendant committed the shooting to benefit the gang. Pressed again and again, the detective responded, "What you are asking me to do is sort of forget things that I know about the case . . . that aren't on the video that I can't necessarily talk about to the jury."

Defense counsel asked for a sidebar conference. Following a spirited debate, the trial court opined that normally an expert can "testify as to inadmissible hearsay." In fact, the trial court ruled, what Sample was relying on (D.S.'s statement about a gang sign) was admissible evidence. The court also ruled that the tenor of the question during cross-examination was to suggest that defendant did not exhibit a gang sign. The court stated that trial counsel's question "precluded [Sample] from completing his answer," since to provide a complete answer he would have had to refer to D.S.'s statement, thus impinging on defendant's right to confrontation. Defense counsel did not request, and the trial court did not give, the jury any admonition concerning the line of questioning or the detective's response.

Now, however, defendant claims Sample improperly suggested to the jury that he had information outside the evidence presented at trial which supported his conclusion that the hand gesture was a gang sign. Defendant suggests that in this way Sample was attempting to smuggle in extra-record evidence requiring us to reverse the judgment. (People v. Bolton (1979) 23 Cal.3d 208, 212.) Not so for three reasons.

First, since the detective carefully avoided telling the jury that D.S. had identified the gesture as a gang sign and he made clear he had not seen defendant make a gang sign if Sample believed it was, it was clear to the jury that Sample was drawing an inference from his experience with gang members. Second, if there was any error or misconduct it was invited by defense counsel. And third, any possible error was not prejudicial. Sample explicitly explained to the jury that even if defendant had not thrown a gang sign, he would have reached the same conclusion that the shooting was gang related and for the benefit of the gang. One gang sign amidst all the gang-related evidence presented in this case had little, if any, significance.

IV Senate Bill No. 620 Discretion to Strike Firearm Enhancements

In supplemental briefing, defendant asserts his case must be remanded to permit the trial court to exercise the discretion provided to it by Senate Bill No. 620 (2017-2018 Reg. Sess.) (Stats. 2017, ch. 682, §§ 1, 2). Senate Bill No. 620 gave the trial court discretion to strike the firearm enhancements imposed against defendant under section 12022.53, subdivision (d). (§ 12022.53, subd. (h).) Respondent acknowledges the legislation, though enacted after defendant's conviction and sentencing, applies retroactively to defendant, but argues remand is not appropriate because the record establishes the trial court would not exercise the discretion provided. We agree.

The court recognized this was no "ordinary" gunfight and defendant's actions posed an extraordinary risk not only to his intended target but to many innocent bystanders who, as events unfolded, were unknowingly shopping in the wrong place at the wrong time. The court disagreed with defense counsel's "analysis in terms of the existence of mitigating factors" and noted the "risk of danger in this case was extreme." "Further, notwithstanding the fact that this may have started out as a mutual combat situation, the conduct ultimately not only posed an extreme risk of danger to participants . . . but also posed extreme risk of danger to just everyday ordinary citizens who happened to be shopping in the mall that afternoon." The court noted "there were bullets sprayed in different locations, many of them ended up in parked cars" and indicated that defendant was not statutorily eligible for probation but even had he been, "probation would have been denied in light of the nature and circumstances of this particular case." Clearly, the trial court was not inclined to show any leniency and it is fanciful to suppose the court would have stricken the firearm enhancement in the interest of justice pursuant to section 1385 had it had the authority to do.

DISPOSITION

The judgment is affirmed.

/s/_________

RAYE, P. J. I concur: /s/_________
MURRAY, J. ROBIE, J., Concurring and Dissenting.

I agree with everything the majority expertly analyzes and concludes in this opinion, except for its analysis and conclusion as it relates to Senate Bill No. 620. As to that issue, the majority concludes "the trial court was not inclined to show any leniency and it is fanciful to suppose the court would have stricken the firearm enhancement" if given the opportunity. (Maj. opn., at p. 34.) I have a fundamental disagreement with the majority's reasoning. I do not believe I or any appellate court has the wisdom to determine what the trial court would have done at a defendant's sentencing hearing if it had been aware of the full extent of its discretion under Senate Bill No. 620. "When the Legislature amends a statute so as to lessen the punishment it has obviously expressly determined that its former penalty was too severe and that a lighter punishment is proper as punishment for the commission of the prohibited act." (In re Estrada (1965) 63 Cal.2d 740, 745.)

With the enactment of Senate Bill No. 620 following defendant's sentencing, the Legislature changed the calculus a trial judge must enter when determining whether a firearm enhancement is appropriate. Because of this change, anything the trial judge said at the time of sentencing is tainted by the policy considerations behind the law then in effect. " 'Defendants are entitled to sentencing decisions made in the exercise of the "informed discretion" of the sentencing court. [Citations.] A court which is unaware of the scope of its discretionary powers can no more exercise that "informed discretion" than one whose sentence is or may have been based on misinformation regarding a material aspect of a defendant's record.' " (People v. Gutierrez (2014) 58 Cal.4th 1354, 1391.)

After taking into account the change in policy and after hearing argument from both sides, the trial court may feel differently than when it initially sentenced defendant to the enhancements. Defendant should not be denied this opportunity. Accordingly, I would remand for the trial court to exercise its informed discretion when sentencing defendant to the firearm enhancements.

/s/_________

ROBIE, J.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

People v. Montanez
(May 3, 2021)