FRANCIS T. COLLINS
Synopsis
Claim was dismissed as untimely. Motion for the issuance of subpoenas was denied.
Case information
| UID: |
2015-015-086 |
| Claimant(s): |
ANDRE RAND |
| Claimant short name: |
RAND |
| Footnote (claimant name) : |
| | | Defendant(s):
THE STATE OF NEW YORK |
| Footnote (defendant name) : |
| | | Third-party claimant(s):
| | | Third-party defendant(s):
| | | Claim number(s):
122053 |
| Motion number(s): |
M-86969, M-87126 |
| Cross-motion number(s): |
| | | Judge:
FRANCIS T. COLLINS |
| Claimant's attorney: |
Andre Rand, Pro Se |
| Defendant's attorney: |
Honorable Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General By: Anthony Rotondi, Esquire Assistant Attorney General |
| Third-party defendant's attorney: |
| | | Signature date:
November 2, 2015 |
| City: |
Saratoga Springs |
| Comments: |
| | | Official citation:
| | | Appellate results:
| | | See also (multicaptioned case)
| Decision
Defendant moves (M-86969) to dismiss the instant claim pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (2) and (7) on the grounds it is untimely and, to the extent it may assert a cause of action for medical negligence, fails to meet the pleading requirements of Court of Claims Act § 11 (b). In a separate motion, claimant moves (M-87126) for the issuance of trial subpoenas.
Claimant served a notice of intention to file a claim on November 26, 2012 in which he set forth the nature of the claim as follows:
"The incident of claim occurred, originating from a
negligent instantaneous incident, stemming from August 16, 2012, South Mess Hall evening meal departure: [For such totally unnecessary observable fact(s) or event - - claimant sustained FOUR (4) broken ribs, i.e. (to information knowledge, one in two sections), etc.]" (defendant's Exhibit A, pp. 1-2).
The quote has not been corrected. --------
No further details concerning the incident are alleged in the notice of intention.
A claim was filed in the Office of the Clerk of the Court of Claims on November 26, 2012 and, according to the defendant, a copy was received in the Office of the Attorney General by certified mail, return receipt requested on December 7, 2012 (see defendant's Exhibit B, copy of claim date-stamped by the Attorney General's Office). The claim alleges claimant was injured on August 16, 2012 when, while he was on line in the mess hall of Great Meadow Correctional Facility, a staff member responding to an incident "rammed through the line . . . [and] shoved claimant some footage along staff member's rushing path; simultaneously [and maliciously] slammed claimant's right side into the angle corner edge of a stainless steel table, bolted to the floor" (defendant's Exhibit B, ¶¶ 3-4). Claimant alleges he sustained four broken ribs as a result of the incident. Claimant also alleges that "staffers declined too [sic] transport claimant to 'Albany Medical Center' " for tests (id. at ¶ 11) and that the claim accrued "on the actual date of the unexpected occurrence [August 16, 2012], Incl. the process, subsequent too [sic] claimant's release from the Hosp. on (Aug.27th) . . ." (id. at last page of claim).
Defendant contends in support of its dismissal motion that the claimant's notice of intention was untimely served and, in any event, fails to comply with the pleading requirements of Court of Claims Act § 11 (b) in that it fails to allege how the incident occurred. As a result, defendant argues that the notice of intention was insufficient to extend the claimant's time to serve and file a claim, and the claim served on December 7, 2012 was therefore untimely under Court of Claims Act § 10 (3). Defendant raised as an affirmative defense that neither a claim nor a notice of intention were served within 90 days following accrual of the claim as required by Court of Claims Act §§ 10 (3) and 11 (a).
A negligence claim for personal injuries is required to be filed and served within 90 days after the claim accrues unless, within such time, the claimant serves a notice of intention to file a claim in which event the claim is required to be filed and served within two years after accrual of the claim (Court of Claims Act § 10 [3]). " 'Because suits against the State are allowed only by the State's waiver of sovereign immunity and in derogation of the common law, statutory requirements conditioning suit must be strictly construed' " (Long v State of New York, 7 NY3d 269, 276 [2006], quoting Lichtenstein v State of New York, 93 NY2d 911, 913 [1999] [other citations omitted]). The notice of intention in the instant matter was clearly insufficient to meet the pleading requirements of Court of Claims Act § 11 (b) in that it failed to allege "the manner in which the claimant was injured and how the State was negligent . . . or enough information so that 'how the State was negligent can be reasonably inferred' " (Rodriguez v State of New York, 8 AD3d 647, 647 [2d Dept 2004] [citations omitted]; see also Cendales v State of New York, 2 AD3d 1165, 1167 [3d Dept 2003]; Sega v State of New York, 246 AD2d 753, 755 [3d Dept 1998], lv denied 92 NY2d 805 [1998]). Moreover, the notice of intention was served on November 26, 2012, more than 90 days after the claim accrued, and was untimely in any event.
While the claim, filed on November 26, 2012 and served on December 7, 2012, did sufficiently allege the manner in which the claimant was injured on August 16, 2012, it was not served and filed within 90 days after the claim accrued and was thus untimely.
To the extent the claim makes passing mention of the State's refusal to transport claimant to Albany Medical Center for treatment and alleges, inconsistently, that claimant was not released from the hospital until August 27, 2012, these allegations are insufficient to state causes of action for either medical malpractice or medical negligence (cf. Kagan v State of New York, 221 AD2d 7 [2d Dept 1996]) and fail to permit an inference of the date any such cause of action accrued (see Court of Claims Act § 11 [b]; Toxey v State of New York, 279 AD2d 927 [3d Dept 2001]). Even if the claim accrued upon claimant's release from the hospital on August 27, 2012, however, the fact that it was not served until December 7, 2012 renders it untimely under Court of Claims Act § 10 (3). Claimant's contrary contentions notwithstanding, nothing filed with the claim or submitted in opposition to the motion establishes that the claim was served prior to December 7, 2012, the date it was received in the Office of the Attorney General (see Court of Claims Act § 11 [a] [i]).
Based on the foregoing, defendant's motion to dismiss the claim is granted and claimant's motions for the issuance of subpoenas is denied as academic.
November 2, 2015
Saratoga Springs, New York
FRANCIS T. COLLINS
Judge of the Court of Claims The Court considered the following papers: Motion No. M-86969
1. Notice of motion dated July 8, 2015;
2. Affirmation of Anthony Rotondi dated July 8, 2015 with exhibits A-C.
Motion No. M-87126
1. Notice of motion sworn to July 28, 2015;
2. Opposition of Andre Rand sworn to July 28, 2015 with exhibits.