AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Motions
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Motions
Attorney(S)

RYAN DEKEYSER, THOMAS COOPER, HARLEY GRANIUS and CARLO LANTZ, on behalf of themsel v. s and others similarly situated, Plaintiffs,

MEMORANDUM OPINION ORDER

JOSEPH GOODWIN, District Judge

Pending before the court is the plaintiff's Motion to Remand Case to the Circuit Court of Putnam County. For the reasons discussed below, this Motion is GRANTED. This case is REMANDED to the Circuit Court of Putnam County.

I. Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed the Complaint in the Circuit Court of Putnam County on August 3, 2009. (Notice Removal [Docket 1], Ex. 1 ("Compl.").) This case is one of over a hundred parallel personal injury actions (collectively, the "Parallel Litigations"), filed by the plaintiff's counsel, seeking damages based on defendant Monsanto Company's ("Monsanto") alleged unlawful disposal of dioxin and furan waste material at its Nitro, West Virginia plant site, and the defendants' alleged failure to control this contamination. The plaintiff asserts that exposure to the contamination caused the plaintiff to develop cancer.

The Complaint states that the Nitro plant was owned and operated by the former Monsanto Company — "Old Monsanto" — "until its pupation into one of more of the herein named defendants," including "New Monsanto," approximately "sometime during and after . . . 1997." (Compl. ¶ 19.) This Order will simply refer to "Monsanto" rather than distinguish between the company's iterations.

According to the plaintiff, Monsanto owned and operated a chemical plant near Nitro from approximately 1934 to approximately 2000. (Compl. ¶¶ 3-4.) The plaintiff alleges that Monsanto produced an agricultural herbicide — 2, 4, 5 — trichlorophenoxyacidic acid ("2, 4, 5-T") — "which was heavily contaminated with dibenzo dioxins and dibenzo furans." The plaintiff further asserts that, beginning in 1949, Monsanto "began to dispose of dioxin-contaminated waste . . . in a manner which caused dioxins/furans to escape into the atmosphere contaminating the air in and around the areas" where the plaintiffs live. ( Id. ¶ 4.) More specifically, the plaintiff claims "[t]he production of dioxin contaminated 2, 4, 5-T continued 7 days a week 365 days a year from 1949 to approximately 1971 at the Monsanto Nitro Plant. During this entire time period, dioxin-contaminated wastes were burned, 7 days a week, in an open 20 feet by 40 feet pit on the plant site as well as at off-site dumps . . . causing dioxin/furans-contaminated particulate matter to contaminate the air and property in Nitro and surrounding areas." ( Id. ¶ 31.)

The plaintiff brings claims against each of the defendants — Monsanto; Pharmacia Corporation; Flexsys America Company; Flexsys America L.P.; Apogee Coal Company, LLC; and Solutia Inc. — "as successors to the dioxins/furans related legacy liabilities" of Monsanto. ( Id. ¶ 5.) In relevant part, the plaintiff alleges that defendant Apogee Coal Company, LLC ("Apogee") is a successor to the liabilities of companies that owned or controlled Monsanto's waste disposal site. The plaintiff further maintains that contaminated waste from Monsanto's Nitro plant was "disposed of and burned all with the permission and knowledge of such predecessor companies." ( Id. ¶ 74.) The plaintiff asserts that Apogee is a West Virginia corporation, and that when the Complaint was filed, Apogee's principal place of business was Charleston, West Virginia. ( Id.)

The defendants removed the Parallel Litigations to this court on December 13, 2009, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1332 and 1442.

The plaintiff subsequently filed the Motion to Remand on June 19, 2010

II. Standard

A Notice of Removal need only contain "a short and plain statement of the ground of removal"; the pleading standard is the same as that imposed on a plaintiff in drafting an initial complaint. Ellenburg v. Spartan Motors Chassis, Inc., 519 F.3d 192, 199-200 (4th Cir. 2008). But when challenged, "`[t]he party seeking removal bears the burden of demonstrating that removal jurisdiction is proper.'" Id. (quoting In re Blackwater Sec. Consulting, LLC, 460 F.3d 576, 583 (4th Cir. 2006)); see also Dixon v. Coburg Dairy, Inc., 369 F.3d 811, 816 (4th Cir. 2004) ("The burden of demonstrating jurisdiction resides with `the party seeking removal.'" (quoting Mulcahey v. Columbia Organic Chems. Co., 29 F.3d 148, 151 (4th Cir. 1994))). Congress intended to "restrict removal and to resolve all doubts about the propriety of removal in favor of retained state court jurisdiction." Marshall v. Manville Sales Corp., 6 F.3d 229, 232 (4th Cir. 1993). Courts must construe removal jurisdiction strictly "because of the `significant federalism concerns' implicated." Dixon, 369 F.3d at 816 (quoting Mulcahey, 29 F.3d at 151). "Therefore, `[i]f federal jurisdiction is doubtful, a remand [to state court] is necessary.'" Id.

III. Analysis

The defendants argue that removal of this case is proper on two separate grounds. First, the defendants assert that complete diversity of citizenship exists between the parties. The parties agree that the plaintiffs are citizens of West Virginia, and that all of the named defendants, except Apogee, are citizens of other states. The parties disagree, however, over the citizenship of defendant Apogee. Furthermore, the defendants assert that even if Apogee is a West Virginia citizen, the plaintiff's inclusion of Apogee as a defendant constitutes fraudulent joinder, because the plaintiff lacks any basis for asserting the facts underlying the claim against Apogee.

Second, the defendants assert that removal was proper under the federal officer removal statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1442. That statute permits removal of actions against "[t]he United States or any agency thereof or any officer (or any person acting under that officer) of the United States or of any agency thereof, sued . . . for any act under color of such office." 28 U.S.C. § 1442. Defendants assert that Monsanto's Nitro plant was engaged primarily in the business of manufacturing 2, 4, 5-T on behalf of the federal government and that removal under § 1442 was proper.

The defendants also asserted that the plaintiff's right to relief "necessarily depends on resolution of a substantial question of federal law," Christianson v. Colt Indus. Operating Corp., 486 U.S. 800, 808 (1988) (quoting Franchise Tax Bd. v. Constr. Laborers Vacation Trust, 463 U.S. 1, 27-28 (1983)), which establishes federal jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331. After this ground was challenged by the plaintiff's motion to remand, the defendants abandoned it.

As explained below, both of the defendants' removal arguments fail. Remand of this case to the Circuit Court of Putnam County is therefore warranted.

A. The defendants have not established that Apogee is not a citizen of West Virginia.

Federal diversity jurisdiction requires that every defendant be completely diverse from every plaintiff. 28 U.S.C. § 1332. The "crucial date" for the determination of Apogee's citizenship in this case is the date the Complaint was filed — August 2, 2009. See Mullins v. Beatrice Pocahontas Co., 489 F.2d 260, 261 (4th Cir. 1974). Diversity jurisdiction here depends on whether Apogee was a West Virginia citizen on August 2, 2009.

A corporation is "a citizen of any State by which it has been incorporated and of the State where it has its principal place of business." 28 U.S.C. § 1332(c)(1). The parties agree that for purposes of determining jurisdiction, Apogee's citizenship is determined by the citizenship of its sole corporate member, Magnum Coal Company ("Magnum"). Magnum is incorporated in Delaware. Its "principal place of business" however is in dispute. The plaintiff's Complaint alleges that Apogee is a West Virginia corporation, and that on the date the Complaint was filed, Apogee's principal place of business was located in Charleston, West Virginia. (Compl. ¶ 74.) In their Notice of Removal, the defendants claim that Magnum [and thereby Apogee] "is a citizen of Delaware and possibly also a citizen of Missouri, . . . not West Virginia." (Notice Removal ¶ 14.)

Defendants present two arguments to support their assertion that Magnum (and thereby Apogee) is not a West Virginia citizen. First, they argue that Magnum might qualify as an inactive corporation without a principal place of business. In that circumstance, Magnum should only be considered a citizen of its state of incorporation: Delaware. Second, they argue that if Magnum does have a principal place of business, it is in Missouri, not West Virginia. I will address each argument in turn.

1. Magnum is not an inactive corporation.

The defendants, citing Athena Automotive, Inc. v. DiGregori, 166 F.3d 288, 291 (4th Cir. 1999), argue that Magnum might qualify as an inactive corporation, and, as such, "might appropriately be considered a citizen only of its state of incorporation, Delaware." (Notice Removal ¶ 14.) To qualify as an inactive corporation, a business must "cease[] all operations," and enough time must pass for "the continuing impact of its business" to dissipate. Athena Auto., Inc., 166 F.3d at 291. "[A]s a general matter, an `inactive' corporation (that is, a corporation conducting no business activities) has no principal place of business, and is instead a citizen of its state of incorporation only." Midlantic Nat'l Bank v. Hansen, 48 F.3d 693, 696 (3d Cir. 1995).

To support their argument that Magnum is an inactive corporation, the defendants state that Magnum has no employees and "serves merely as one of several intermediary entities" through which another company "owns and controls its national mining operations." (Notice Removal ¶ 13.) The facts do not support this argument. The defendants admit that Magnum holds a lease of office space in Charleston, and collects payments from a coal purchaser. Furthermore, the defendants concede that, unlike the plaintiff in Athena Automotive, Magnum was not totally inactive at the time the Complaint was filed, stating that Magnum's presence in West Virginia "since January 1, 2009, has been . . . to the almost total exclusion of any substantive activity." ( Id. ¶ 13 (emphasis added).). Nevertheless, the defendants request the court to "apply the same principles to reach the same result," due to Magnum's "dearth of activity." ( Id. 6 n. 7.)

I decline this invitation. Magnum continued to conduct some business activities at the time the Complaint was filed, and thus was not an inactive corporation. Magnum was therefore a citizen both of its state of incorporation, Delaware, and its principal place of business. I will now address defendants' second argument, that Magnum's principal place of business was located outside of West Virginia.

2. The defendants have not demonstrated that Magnum's principal place of business is outside of West Virginia.

A corporation's principal place of business is "the place where a corporation's officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation's activities." Hertz Corp. v. Friend, 130 S. Ct. 1181, 1192 (2010) "And in practice it should normally be the place where the corporation maintains its headquarters — provided that the headquarters is the actual center of direction, control, and coordination, i.e., the `nerve center,' and not simply an office where the corporation holds its board meetings." Id.

The defendants argue that Magnum's principal place of business at the time the Complaint was filed (insofar as Magnum had a principal place of business) was Missouri. As evidence, the defendants offer the following:

• On July 23, 2008, Magnum became a wholly owned subsidiary of Patriot Coal Corporation, which is headquartered in St. Louis, Missouri;
• Magnum's corporate records are kept in St. Louis, Missouri;
• The written consents, which have supplanted Magnum's shareholder and directors' meetings, are in St. Louis, Missouri;
• Seven of Magnum's ten corporate officers, and two of its three directors, had offices exclusively in St. Louis, Missouri.

(Resp. Opp'n Mot. Remand [Docket 24], Ex. V, Affidavit of Lawrence I. Bell, July 2, 2010 ¶¶ 1, 4, 5, 6, 7.)

The defendants assert that Magnum's presence in West Virginia since January 1, 2009, "has been in form only — it held a pre-2008 lease of office space in Charleston, West Virginia but did not pay the rent and did not occupy the space." (Resp. Opp'n Mot. Remand 12 n. 3.) According to the defendants, "[a] signature of a lease left over from an earlier time and a bank account set up strictly to collect on a single, old debt do not make [. . .] the locus of decision making and control center of corporate affairs" in West Virginia. ( Id. at 13.)

The plaintiff rejects the defendants' assertion that Magnum's principal place of business was Missouri. The plaintiff submits that in April 2009, Magnum admitted in another case before this court that its principal office was located in Charleston, West Virginia. Furthermore, the plaintiff asserts that Magnum certified to the West Virginia Secretary of State, in its Annual Report filed March 17, 2010, that its principal office is in Charleston, West Virginia. (Mem. Supp. Mot. Remand [Docket 20] 4, 6 (citing Answer to Amended Complaint ¶ 3, McNeal v. Brook Trout Coal, LLC, No. 09-306 (S.D. W. Va. Apr. 6, 2009)).) The plaintiff also argues that the defendants have not explained what Magnum's principal business activity is, or how that activity is directed or controlled. (Reply Resp. Opp'n [Docket 27] 3.)

Magnum's admission in April 2009 that its "principal office" was located in Charleston, West Virginia does not prove that Magnum is a citizen of West Virginia. The admission pertains to "all times complained of" in the complaint in that case. The original complaint in that case was filed December 8, 2008; the amended complaint was filed March 5, 2009; and the complaint concerns contracts that were entered into prior to February 2007. Magnum's admission in April 2009 is irrelevant to this case.

Magnum's corporate filings merit closer scrutiny. In Magnum's 2011 Corporation Annual Report, filed on March 17, 2010, it lists its "Home State" as Delaware and its charter type as "foreign," but its "Principal Office" as located in Charleston, West Virginia. It also lists its President and one of its two Directors as Paul H. Vining, with an office in Charleston, West Virginia. (Reply Resp. Opp'n, Ex. 1.) Magnum's Vice President, Secretary, Treasurer, and second Director are listed with Missouri addresses. The 2010 Limited Liability Company Annual Report for a "Magnum Coal Sales LLC" lists the same Charleston, West Virginia "Principal Address," but also lists West Virginia as its "Home State" and its charter type as "domestic." ( Id. at 3).

The relationship between Magnum Coal Company and Magnum Coal Sales, LLC is unclear. The filings suggest that the former, at least, is subject to some control from Missouri. Nevertheless, both listed the location of their "Principal Office" as Charleston, West Virginia. The term "Principal Office" suggests that Magnum is directed, controlled, and coordinated from that location. The forms allow companies to list a "Principal Office," "Mailing Address," and, crucially, a "Local Office," strongly suggesting that "Principal Office" refers to the company's overall "nerve center," and not simply its principal in-state office.

The burden of establishing federal jurisdiction falls on the party seeking removal. See Dixon v. Coburg, 369 F.3d at 816 (citations omitted). The defendants have failed to establish the state in which Magnum's principal place of business is located. Although Magnum appears to be subject to some control from Missouri, the defendants have not explained what Magnum's principal business activity is and how and where such activity is effectively directed, controlled, and coordinated. At most, they have demonstrated that there is ambiguity surrounding Magnum's principal place of business — ambiguity that must be resolved against the defendants. See id.; Maggio-Onoranto Assocs., Inc. v. AEGON N.V., 104 F. Supp. 2d 518, 522 (D. Md. 2000). Considering all the evidence together, the defendants have not met their burden of establishing diversity jurisdiction.

3. Apogee Coal has not been fraudulently joined.

Having determined that the defendants have failed to show complete diversity, I must now address their argument that Apogee was fraudulently joined. To succeed in demonstrating fraudulent joinder, the defendants must show "that the plaintiff cannot establish a claim even after resolving all issues of law and fact in the plaintiff's favor." Hartley v. CSX Transp., Inc., 187 F.3d 422, 424 (4th Cir. 1999) (citation omitted). The removing party must demonstrate either "outright fraud in the plaintiff's pleading of jurisdictional facts" or that "there is no possibility that the plaintiff would be able to establish a cause of action against the in-state defendant in state court." Marshall v. Manville Sales Corp., 6 F.3d 229, 232 (4th Cir. 1993) (internal quotation marks omitted).

The plaintiff's claim against Apogee is premised on the allegation that Apogee is a successor to the liabilities of companies that owned or controlled Monsanto's waste disposal site, and that contaminated waste from Monsanto's Nitro plant was "disposed of and burned all with the permission and knowledge of such predecessor companies." (Compl. ¶ 74.) The defendants argue that the plaintiff lacks a basis to assert the facts which underlie its claim against Apogee, insofar as "Plaintiffs' Counsel lacks a reasonable evidentiary foundation for asserting that anyone . . . was burning dioxincontaminated wastes at any time" at Monsanto's site near Nitro, West Virginia. (Notice Removal ¶ 20.) The defendants note that similar complaints filed by plaintiff's counsel, in Carter v. Monsanto Co., No. 3:08-cv-1359 (S.D.W.Va. Nov. 21, 2008), and Bibb v. Monsanto Co., No. 3:08-cv-1358 (S.D.W.Va. Nov. 21, 2008), do not mention the burning of dioxin-contaminated waste; the defendants also state that they are "unaware of any evidence of burning . . . unearthed through discovery in the related class actions upon which this allegation could properly be premised." ( Id. ¶ 21.) The defendants further assert that because plaintiff's counsel did not sue Apogee in the Bibb litigation or in a similar personal injury case recently filed in another federal court, Spaulding v. Monsanto, 1:09-cv-9470, they "[do] not actually believe that there exists a valid claim against Apogee." ( Id. ¶ 21, 9 n. 11.)

The plaintiff asserts in the Motion to Remand that there is evidence that the dumping of wastes "`caused large explosions and unusual chemical reactions'" at the site. (Mem. Supp. Mot. Remand 10 (quoting Order Denying Apogee Coal Company's Motion for Summary Judgment, Carter v. Monsanto, No. 00-C-300 (Cir. Court Putnam County, W. Va. Nov. 13, 2008)).) The plaintiff also argues that plaintiff's counsel's failure to sue Apogee in other cases is irrelevant. Nevertheless, the plaintiff points out that plaintiff's counsel "zealously (and successfully) opposed Apogee Coal's motion for summary judgment" in Carter "— when doing so was not necessary in order to maintain that matter in state (as opposed to federal) court." (Mem. Supp. Mot. Remand 11.)

The defendants have not met their burden of demonstrating fraudulent joinder. Whatever discrepancy might exist between evidence of "large explosions and unusual chemical reactions" and the Complaint's allegations of "burning" is insufficient to justify a finding of "outright fraud." If the allegations in the plaintiff's Complaint are true, the plaintiff will certainly be able to establish a cause of action against Apogee in state court. Furthermore, I agree with the plaintiff that it is irrelevant which defendants are being pursued in other litigation.

The defendants have failed to establish that diversity jurisdiction exists. The only possible remaining basis for this court's jurisdiction is under the federal officer removal statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1442. As laid out below, that jurisdictional basis is also faulty.

B. There is no causal nexus between any government control of the manufacturing of 2, 4, 5 — T and the defendants' waste disposal practices at the plant in Nitro.

Title 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1) permits removal for suits against federal officers and persons "acting under" them, for their acts "under the color of such office." The defendants assert that Monsanto's Nitro plant, "[f]or many years within the time period pertinent to this case . . . was engaged primarily — and at times exclusively — in the business of manufacturing 2, 4, 5-T for inclusion in the military defoliant Agent Orange." (Notice Removal ¶ 24.) According to the defendants, Monsanto was compelled by the United States government to satisfy orders for 2, 4, 5-T, pursuant to detailed and precise specifications. The defendants argue that "[i]n light of the fact that Plaintiff seeks to hold Monsanto liable for injuries allegedly resulting, at least in part, from work performed by Monsanto at the behest of the federal government, there is removal jurisdiction over this action under 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1)." ( Id. at ¶ 39.) The plaintiff argues that the federal government's involvement in the manufacture of 2, 4, 5-T is not relevant to this case, because the claims in the Complaint rest solely upon the defendants' waste disposal practices.

The shadow of prior litigation hangs over this issue. This court has considered the question of federal officer removal jurisdiction in two class action litigations very similar to this case: Bibb v. Monsanto Co., No. 3:08-cv-1358 (S.D.W.Va. Nov. 21, 2008), and Carter v. Monsanto Co., No. 3:08-cv-1359 (S.D.W.Va. Nov. 21, 2008). In Bibb, this court found that the plaintiffs alleged that they suffered harm from "the collective and continuous operation of the Nitro Plant in producing 2, 4, 5-T, including production, disposal, and any other process that was part of the plant operation, [and] led to the emission of the dioxins/furans." (Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Plaintiffs' Motion to Remand at 27, Bibb v. Monsanto Co., No. 3:08-cv-1358 (S.D.W.Va. Dec. 19, 2008).) This court found that "plaintiffs' claims include those based on production processes controlled by the federal government," and concluded that removal would have been proper had it been timely effected. ( Id.) In Carter, however, this court concluded that the plaintiffs' claims arose solely from the defendants' disposal of 2, 4, 5-T waste, which occurred without federal involvement. Carter v. Monsanto Co., 635 F. Supp. 2d 479, 497 (2009). This court thus remanded Carter to state court, because there was no "causal nexus between the federal control over the manufacturing at the Nitro Plant and the acts underlying the instant action." Id. This court held that defendants could "not establish a basis for federal officer removal unless the defendants disposed of the 2, 4, 5-T waste under the direct and detailed control of the federal government or in furtherance of a specific request by a federal officer." Id.

The defendants argue that this case is distinguishable from Carter because the plaintiff's injuries allegedly arise from "generalized, airborne dioxin" rather than the "waterborne dioxin contamination" at issue in Carter. (See Mem. Opp. Mot. Remand at 18). The crucial issue is not the type of contamination, but whether the plaintiff alleges harms caused by processes controlled by the federal government or harms caused by processes controlled by the defendants alone. Carter, 635 F. Supp. 2d at 495 — 97. The defendants have offered no allegations that the disposal practices at issue in this matter were "under the direct and detailed control of the federal government," or that they result from actions "in furtherance of a specific request by a federal officer," alleging only that the disposal practices created a different kind of contamination than the practices at issue in Carter. Id. at 497.

Both the Carter plaintiffs and the instant plaintiff focus solely on injuries caused by the defendants' disposal practices. (Compl. ¶ 2.) Accordingly, no causal nexus exists in either Carter or in this case between the federal government's control of manufacturing and the actions underlying the plaintiff's Complaint. The defendants' removal under § 1442 was improper.

IV. Conclusion

For the reasons discussed above, the plaintiff's motion to remand is GRANTED and this case is REMANDED to the Circuit Court of Putnam County, West Virginia.

The court DIRECTS the Clerk to send a copy of this Order to counsel of record and any unrepresented parties.

ENTER: September 29, 2010

vidence. The only Daubert issue presented is whether the experts' reasoning or methodology underlying their opinions is scientifically reliable. Here the declarations offered, to the extent they contain expert opinions, do not clearly fall below the standard enunciated in Daubert for admission of expert testimony. This Court cannot rule that these declarations would be inadmissable and, therefore, will consider them for purposes of the cross-motions for summary judgment.

1. Dr. Mark Roberts

Dr. Roberts is a Principal Scientist and Director at the Center for Occupational and Environmental Health of Exponent, a scientific research and consulting company. On behalf of Waupaca he submitted two declarations. (Dkt. 176 and Dkt. 248.) His first declaration states that "there is no peer-reviewed, published literature that provides support for a policy of mandatory showering or clothes doffing after work with silica in the foundry setting." (Dkt. 176 ¶ 64.) To be sure, Dr. Roberts' opinion as to the absence of peer-reviewed literature is not subjected to scientific testing or submitted for peer review or publication. But the Supreme Court in Kumho Tire Co., Ltd. v. Carmichael noted that whether Daubert's specific factors are reasonable measures of reliability in a particular case is a matter the trial judge has "considerable leeway" to determine. 526 U.S. 137, 152 (1999). The goal is to ensure that an expert employs procedures and analysis in a way that is similar to how an expert in the given field would operate outside of court. Here, the expert offered an opinion as to the lack of "peer-reviewed, published literature" in an area. Such an opinion does not, itself, need to be tested or peer-reviewed. Dr. Roberts' opinion that showering is recommended but not required is likewise relevant and reliable, as is his medical opinion that the dose makes the poison. The remainder of the opinions in Dr. Roberts' declarations are not clearly inadmissable and will be considered for the limited purpose of the cross-motions for summary judgment. Dr. Roberts' declarations support this Court's denial of Plaintiff's motion for summary judgment but do not conclusively support granting Defendant's motion for summary judgment. Because of, and despite, Dr. Roberts' declarations, a key factual issue remains in this case: whether the nature of the work performed by the employees requires the donning, doffing and showering for which they seek compensation at the various Waupaca plants.

2. Bryant Esch

Mr. Esch is the Environmental Coordinator for Waupaca. He declares that the company does not require employees to shower and/or doff their uniforms on-site after work. (Dkt. 178 ¶ 25.) His declaration also describes silica testing performed at the Waupaca foundries. Plaintiffs take issue with Esch's declaration to the extent that Esch opines that the Waupaca's engineering controls and respiratory protection program has lowered the risks from silica exposure. Esch's opinions are not wholly unsupported; rather they are based on his education, training, and experience at Waupaca. As such, Esch's opinions are not clearly inadmissable and are appropriately considered for purposes of the pending cross-motions for summary judgment.

3. Frederick Kohloff

Mr. Kohloff is the Director of the Environmental Health and Safety Division of the American Foundry Society. His declaration includes his opinion that foundries are not required, by state or federal law or industry standards, to have employees shower or don and doff clothing due to the presence of silica. (Dkt. 179 ¶ 5.) Notwithstanding Mr. Kohloff's opinion, the fundamental issue remains whether the nature of the work performed requires donning, doffing, and showering. His opinion is adequately supported by his professional position and experience and the opinion is, therefore, not clearly inadmissable.

4. Dr. Jeffrey Fernandez

Dr. Fernandez is an engineering consultant whose declaration relates to the time it takes Waupaca employees to shower and don and doff PPE. His opinion is that it takes between six and seven minutes for an employee to shower and about two and a half minutes to don and doff PPE. (Dkt. 180 ¶¶ B-D.) Plaintiffs contend that Dr. Fernandez did not conduct a time study to calculate all off-the-clock time under the USDOL's "continuous work-day" test. Dr. Fernandez's opinions are, however, based on his detailed observations at several Waupaca plants and, as such, are not clearly inadmissable for purposes of the present cross-summary judgment motions.

Finally, local rules disfavor motions to strike in the context of briefing a motion for summary judgment. Civil L.R. 56(b)(9). Thus, this Court will not strike any of the declarations for purposes of the cross-motions for summary judgment, analyzed in detail below. Plaintiffs may, however, renew their motions prior to trial should any of the Defendant's expand on the opinions described above.

C. Compensability of Time Spent Donning/Doffing and Showering

Plaintiffs contend that summary judgment is appropriate on their claim that the time spent donning and doffing PPE and showering after their shifts is "work" under the FLSA, and that such time is compensable as it does not fall within the preliminary/postliminary exception contained in the Portal-to-Portal Act. Waupaca disagrees and argues that because these activities are not "work" and nothing required these activities to occur on the premises, Plaintiffs' time spent donning, doffing and showering is not compensable.

The parties have treated the issue of whether donning, doffing and showering is "work" for purposes of their FLSA claim separately from the issue of whether time spent on such activities is compensable. Because the two issues appear intertwined in this case and compensability is dispositive to the FLSA claim, the following analysis will focus on whether the time is compensable. See, e.g., Pirant v. United States Postal Service, 542 F.3d 202 (7th Cir. 2008) (court analyzed claim for credit of time spent donning and doffing gloves, work shirt and shoes under the Portal-to-Portal Act's exclusion from compensability of preliminary/postliminary activities without separate consideration of whether the activities were "work").

Under the FLSA, employers must pay their employees a wage for all their "work." Spoerle v. Kraft Foods Global Inc., 527 F. Supp. 2d 860, 862 (W.D. Wis. 2007) (citing 29 U.S.C. §§ 206, 207). Although the statute does not define "work," the Seventh Circuit has defined the term as "physical or mental exertion (whether burdensome or not) controlled or required by the employer and pursued necessarily and primarily for the benefit of the employer and his business." Musch v. Domtar Indus., Inc., 587 F.3d 857, 859 (7th Cir. 2009) (quoting Jonites v. Exelon Corp., 522 F.3d 721, 726 (7th Cir. 2008)). The Portal-to-Portal Act of 1947 amended the FLSA to exclude from compensability any time spent performing "preliminary" or "postliminary" activities, which "occur either prior to the time on any particular workday at which such employee commences, or subsequent to the time on any particular workday at which he ceases, such principal activity or activities." 29 U.S.C. § 254(a)(2). If an activity that would otherwise be preliminary or postliminary is "integral and indispensable" to the employee's principal activity, the Portal-to-Portal Act's exclusion from compensability does not apply as such activity is itself a "principal activity." IBP, Inc. v. Alvarez, 546 U.S. 21, 29-30, 37 (2005). As the employer, Waupaca bears the burden of proving that an exception applies to the general rule that "work" is "compensable" under the FLSA. See Bleichner v. Spies Painting Decorating, Inc., No. 08-057, 2009 WL 281145, at *7 (W.D. Wis. Feb. 3, 2009).

According to Plaintiffs, given the risks of exposure to a variety of hazards, including respirable crystalline silica, their donning/doffing PPE and showering are integral and indispensable to their principal activities working at Waupaca's plants. They liken this case to Steiner v. Mitchell, 350 U.S. 247 (1956), where the Supreme Court held that time spent changing clothes and showering by employees of a battery plant, a plant in which they were exposed to various forms of lead and sulphuric acid, was integral and indispensable to the principal activity of battery production, and therefore compensable under the FLSA. The Supreme Court noted that the production employees in Steiner routinely worked with lead metal, lead oxide, lead sulphate, lead peroxide and sulphuric acid, and that in general these chemicals "permeate[d] the entire plant and everything and everyone in it." Id. at 249. Given the fact the battery plant employees made "extensive use of dangerously caustic and toxic materials," id. at 248, they were compelled by the circumstances to change clothes and to shower in the employer's facilities. The Steiner Court contrasted these conditions with

"changing clothes and showering under normal conditions," which are noncompensable preliminary and postliminary activities.

But from Waupaca's point of view, the conditions of the battery plant discussed in Steiner are far removed from what its employees face in its six plants. For example, the employer in Steiner required its employees to shower on site at the end of the day, and Waupaca maintains that it has no such policy. 350 U.S. at 25. Waupaca claims that not only does it not require its employees to shower on site, but it need not even provide showering facilities. In other words, Waupaca's argument boils down to a claim that the conditions under which Plaintiffs work are "normal," and therefore noncompensable under Steiner. See Pirant v. United States Postal Service, 542 F.3d 202, 208-209 (7th Cir. 2008) (where Postal Service employee was not required to wear extensive and unique protective equipment, but only a uniform shirt, gloves, and work shoes, the time spent donning and doffing such items was akin to changing clothes under normal conditions and therefore noncompensable); Musch v. Domtar Indus., Inc., No. 07-cv-524, 2008 WL 4735171, at *7 (W.D. Wis. Oct. 24, 2008), aff'd, 587 F.3d 857 (7th Cir. 2009) (because the activities of donning and doffing t-shirts, jeans or bibs, safety shoes and safety glasses occurred under normal conditions, they were noncompensable preliminary and postliminary activities); see also 29 C.F.R. § 790.7(g) (noting that "changing clothes, washing up or showering," when performed "under the conditions normally present" are properly classified as preliminary/postliminary activities); 29 C.F.R. § 785.24(c) ("if changing clothes is merely a convenience to the employee and not directly related to his principal activities, it would be considered as a `preliminary' or `postliminary' activity rather than a principal part of the activity"). Instead, Waupaca asserts that because not all of its employees are required to wear extensive and nonunique PPE, the instant case more closely resembles Pirant, as the postal employee in that case was not required to wear extensive and unique protective equipment.

In his declaration, which Plaintiffs challenge, Dr. Roberts notes that examples of unique PPE used in the foundry setting include eye protection with colored lenses for work around furnaces, reflective turn-out gear, respirators and insulated gloves. (Dkt. 137 ¶ 37.)

As noted above, the parties dispute what articles of PPE Waupaca's production employees must wear on the job, which counsels against concluding that Waupaca's employees are merely changing clothes (and not extensive and unique protective equipment) under normal conditions. The other significant issue is whether or not the conditions at Waupaca's six plants are "normal." While Plaintiffs make much of the fact that Waupaca's testing of the ambient air at its plants on various occasions exceeds the levels of silica recommended by various authorities, Waupaca claims that this was "worst case scenario" testing and not reflective of what occurs in every part of all of its plants on a daily basis. By Waupaca's estimation, the toxicity of silica, like any substance, is a function of the dose ("the dose makes the poison"). Because it maintains that silica levels in most areas of its plants are normally low enough so as not to be toxic, Waupaca considers the conditions under which its production employees work to be normal. In short, given the state of the record here, disputed issues of material fact preclude me from deciding whether Waupaca's employees are required to don or doff nonunique PPE or shower under other than normal conditions.

Waupaca suggests that no matter what PPE it requires its employees to wear, and even if it requires that they shower after their shifts, if the Court were to find that Waupaca's production employees need not change clothes and shower at the work site any time spent on these activities would be noncompensable as a matter of law. A number of courts have held that unless the law, the employer, or the nature of the work require that a preliminary or postliminary activity be performed on the employer's premises, the time spent on such activity is not compensable. Bamonte v. City of Mesa, 598 F.3d 1217 (9th Cir. 2010); Dager v. City of Phoenix, 646 F. Supp. 2d 1085 (D. Ariz. 2009), aff'd, No. 09-15356, 2010 WL 2170992, (9th Cir. May 28, 2010); see also In re Tyson Foods, Inc., ___ F. Supp. 2d ___, 2010 WL 935595, at *4 (M.D. Ga. Mar. 16, 2010) ("The employees are required to don and doff the sanitary gear, such as smocks and gloves, at the plant and only at the plant, and they are not permitted to wear the sanitary gear home or into the restroom or break room. These circumstances are markedly different from "normal" clothes changing, where the clothes are merely a convenience to the employee and the employee can wear the clothes to and from work.") (citations omitted); Spoerle, 527 F. Supp. 2d at 864 (holding that donning and doffing of safety and sanitation equipment that meat processing plant employees were required to wear but did not have option of taking home was a principal activity). These decisions are consistent with the DOL's interpretation that time spent changing clothes on the employer's premises is only compensable "where the changing of clothes on the employer's premises is required by law, by rules of the employer, or by the nature of the work." 29 C.F.R. § 790.8(c) n. 65; see also Dkt. 174-8, DOL Wage and Hour Administrator's Memorandum No. 2006-2 (May 31, 2006) (confirming its "long standing position" that changing and showering is compensable only "when the employer or the nature of the job mandates that it take place on the employer's premises."). Courts holding that claims for time spent performing an activity that could have been done off the employer's premises are noncompensable frequently cite this interpretation and note the deference it is owed under Skidmore v. Swift Co., 323 U.S. 134 (1944), namely that it is entitled to "respect proportional to its `power to persuade.'" United States v. Mead Corp., 533 U.S. 218, 235 (2001) (quoting Skidmore, supra at 140).

Here, even if the Court were to hold that in order to be compensable an activity must occur on the employer's premises, as Waupaca recommends, factual disputes prevent granting summary judgment to Waupaca on its claim that time spent changing clothes and showering is not compensable because Plaintiffs are free to do so at home. While the parties have divergent views of the recommendations of federal agencies regarding silica exposure and whether or not Waupaca requires its employees to change out of their work clothes and shower before going home at the end of the day, the record before me does not support a finding that the law requires Waupaca's employees to change clothes and shower on the premises. But while the law may not require such activities at Waupaca's plants, I cannot conclude that neither Waupaca nor the nature of the work itself does not require changing clothes and showering on the premises. Although it is undisputed that not all employees change out of their work clothes and shower, Plaintiffs point to the fact Waupaca's Hazard Communication recommends this, along with the presence of locker rooms and showers at its plants, as evidence that Waupaca requires it. After all, it is unlikely that the showers are provided merely for employee convenience, for example for those employees who might want go for a run during their lunch break and shower afterwards.

An even greater dispute exists between the parties on whether the nature of the work requires that Waupaca's employees change clothes and shower on site at the end of the workday. Waupaca provided declarations touching on this issue from its experts, but because Plaintiffs have not taken discovery regarding these opinions, they contend that it would be improper to consider them at this point. Plaintiffs also seek to have the opinions of Waupaca's experts excluded under Fed.R.Evid. 702 and Daubert. Given the disputed issue of material fact, namely whether or not the nature of the work at Waupaca's six plants requires the production employees to change out of their clothes and shower on the premises before leaving for the day, I cannot grant summary judgment in favor of Waupaca on its claim that time spent on such activities is not compensable because it could be done at home.

Because factual disputes prevent resolution of Waupaca's assertion that Plaintiffs' activities need not be performed on its premises, it necessarily follows that I also cannot grant Plaintiffs' motion for partial summary judgment on their claim that their donning, doffing and showering is compensable work under the FLSA.

D. De Minimis Defense

Waupaca asserts that even if the time spent by Plaintiffs changing clothes and showering is compensable work under the FLSA, it is not required to pay Plaintiffs for such time under the de minimis defense. Plaintiffs seek summary judgment on Waupaca's de minimis defense in this case, contending that such a defense is not available as a matter of law when modern technology permits an employer to track the amount of time spent on compensable work, no matter how short the time.

Any analysis of the de minimis defense is premature, where as here, it is not yet been determined what preliminary and/or postliminary activities are required. For example, the evidence may show that while donning and doffing PPE is required, showering is not mandated by the nature of the work or the requirements of the employer. Under these circumstances it is far from clear that the de minimis defense would not apply.

In Anderson v. Mt. Clemens Pottery Co., 328 U.S. 680 (1946), the Supreme Court noted that while the FLSA requires employers to pay employees for their work, if the amount time spent in uncompensated activities amounts to a mere trifle, it is not compensable.

When the matter in issue concerns only a few seconds or minutes of work beyond the scheduled working hours, such trifles may be disregarded. Split-second absurdities are not justified by the actualities of working conditions or by the policy of the Fair Labor Standards Act. It is only when an employee is required to give up a substantial measure of his time and effort that compensable working time is involved.
328 U.S. at 692. Anderson is the only Supreme Court decision discussing the de minimis defense, and the defense has no statutory basis. Spoerle, 527 F. Supp. 2d at 868. Although there has not been much discussion of the defense by the Supreme Court, a number of Circuits have applied a de minimis rule in FLSA cases. See, e.g., Rutti v. Lojack Corp., Inc., 596 F.3d 1046, 1056 (9th Cir. 2010); 596 F.3d 1046, 1056 (9th Cir. 2010); Von Friewalde v. Boeing Aerospace Operations, Inc., 339 Fed.Appx. 448 (5th Cir. 2009); Sing v. City of New York, 524 F.3d 361 (2d Cir. 2008); Bobo v. United States, 136 F.3d 1465 (Fed. Cir. 1998); Frank v. Wilson Co., 172 F.2d 712 (7th Cir. 1949). The regulation found at 29 C.F.R. § 785.47 also recognizes that in recording hours worked under the FLSA, "insubstantial or insignificant periods of time beyond the scheduled working hours, which cannot as a practical administrative matter be precisely recorded for payroll purposes, may be disregarded."

The Ninth Circuit's decision in Lindow v. United States, 738 F.2d 1057 (9th Cir. 1984), is often cited for its criteria regarding whether the de minimis defense applies. In Lindow, the court explained that "in determining whether otherwise compensable time is de minimis, we will consider (1) the practical administrative difficulty of recording the additional time; (2) the aggregate amount of compensable time; and (3) the regularity of the additional work." 738 F.2d at 1063.

Plaintiffs focus on the first of these three factors identified by the Lindow court, perhaps because they contend that an employer's failure to demonstrate "practical administrative difficulty" means that such an employer cannot enjoy the de minimis defense. See Hoyt v. Ellsworth Co-op. Creamery, 579 F. Supp. 2d 1132, 1149 (W.D. Wis. 2008) (declining to discuss other Lindow factors and finding defendant employer's de minimis defense unavailable where defendant failed to provide evidence of any practical administrative difficulty); see also Kasten v. Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp., 556 F. Supp. 2d 941, 954 (W.D. Wis. 2008) ("Because defendant has admitted that it would incur no additional administrative burden in compensating plaintiffs for time spent donning, doffing and walking, its de minimis defense fails as a matter of law."). The gist of Plaintiffs' argument is that because Waupaca has sophisticated timekeeping software and a system by which it tracks when its employees swipe in and out of work, Waupaca cannot credibly complain about any practical administrative difficulty of recording additional time. In response, Waupaca avers that even though it uses timekeeping software, keeping track of the time Plaintiffs spend donning, doffing and showering would present a number of administrative difficulties. (Dkt. 171 at 80-83 n. 21-24.) Waupaca's concerns mainly relate to its perceived need to keep track of which employees report to or leave work already wearing some or all of their PPE, and the need to limit socializing and lollygagging during donning, doffing and showering. In other words, although technology does allow Waupaca the ability to determine whether an employee is using the correct time station in swiping in and out for the day, and will indicate the exact amount of time elapsed between these events, it does not provide Waupaca a picture of what quantity of this time is actually spent doing compensable work.

I conclude that summary judgment in favor of Plaintiffs on Waupaca's de minimis defense is inappropriate given the administrative difficulties Waupaca maintains it will face in keeping track of the time spent by its production employees donning and doffing PPE and showering after work. The instant case is unlike Hoyt and Kasten in that Waupaca has presented evidence of the administrative difficulties it would face and contested the point in response to Plaintiffs' motion. And given the dispute of fact on the remaining Lindow factors in the record before me, the aggregate amount of compensable time and the regularity of the additional work, removing the de minimis defense from Waupaca at this stage of the litigation would be inappropriate. Dr. Fernandez opines that Plaintiffs spend less than an aggregate of 9 minutes each day donning and doffing PPE and showering. Without providing a number of their own, Plaintiffs dispute this number and wish to exclude the opinion from the Court's consideration. The regularity with which Plaintiffs don, doff and shower at work is also unknown at this stage in the litigation, and Plaintiffs' six declarants sidestep the issue of how often they change and shower at Waupaca's plants. These same reasons also require me to deny Waupaca's corresponding motion for summary judgment in its claim that the defense applies.

E. Waupaca's Affirmative Defenses

In their motion for partial summary judgment, Plaintiffs seek summary judgment on a number of Waupaca's affirmative defenses. This request is contained in their motion for partial summary judgment, but Waupaca argues that Plaintiffs are really seeking to have its affirmative defenses stricken and that this is untimely given the fact they seek this relief approximately 8 months after the Rule 12(f) deadline for motions to strike. Waupaca concedes in its response that it is not asserting a number of the defenses Plaintiffs challenge as to the FLSA claims, but does maintain that its defenses of setoff, failure to satisfy prerequisites to proceeding collectively under the FLSA, and the existence of credits under 29 U.S.C. § 207, are all viable.

1. Setoff

Waupaca's thirty-fifth affirmative defense states: "Plaintiffs' claims are barred in whole, or in part, by the doctrine of setoff." (Dkt. 84 at 15.) Waupaca maintains that because it has paid its production employees for non-work time, any amount it may be found to owe for unpaid compensable work time should be reduced by these amounts. Plaintiffs acknowledge that although setoff may be a viable defense in certain FLSA cases, Waupaca's failure to substantiate that it has compensated Plaintiffs for time not otherwise compensable under the FLSA entitles Plaintiffs to summary judgment. (Dkt. 217 at 29.) But in order to survive Plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment on the setoff defense, Waupaca need only designate specific facts showing that there is a genuine issue for trial. In his declaration, Dr. Fernandez indicates that many of Waupaca's production employees are swiping in before their assigned shift commences and taking breaks in excess of the time allowed. (Dkt. 180 at 9-10.) The additional minutes taken outside of Waupaca's provided rest breaks should be considered compensable work time under the FLSA. Five to twenty minute rest breaks must be considered hours worked, 29 C.F.R. § 785.18, and "[u]nder the [FLSA] an employee must be compensated for all hours worked . . . [which] is not limited to the hours spent in active productive labor, but includes time given by the employee to the employer even though part of the time may be spent in idleness," 29 C.F.R. § 778.223. The principles in the two regulations support the conclusion that the "additional" break time is compensable work time. See Kasten v. Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp., 556 F. Supp.2d 941, 953 (W.D.Wis. 2008).

Defendant's setoff defense as to excess break time fails as a matter of law. The undisputed facts establish that defendant has not paid plaintiffs for break time not otherwise compensable under the FLSA. However, Waupaca does have a potential setoff affirmative defense as to whether employees were compensated for swiping in before their assigned shift-a period of time not otherwise compensable under the FLSA. Plaintiffs have filed a motion to strike Dr. Fernandez's declaration, which I denied above, and wish to take discovery on Dr. Fernadez's methods. Against this backdrop I conclude that it would be premature to grant summary judgment in favor of Plaintiffs on Waupaca's setoff defense as it relates to early swipe in.

2. Statutory Prerequisites

Waupaca's twenty-third affirmative defense is that "The Complaint, and each claim purported to be alleged therein, is barred, in whole or in part, because Plaintiffs failed to satisfy statutory and/or other prerequisites to proceed collectively under the FLSA and/or to proceed as a class action under state law." (Dkt. 84 at 14.) Plaintiffs claim this affirmative defense is too vague to alert them as to what it is and the grounds upon which it rests. Waupaca responds by claiming that the "statutory prerequisites" it references are contained in its affirmative defenses 24-33, which apply to both the FLSA claim and state law claims. It also maintains that this defense is viable because it is "axiomatic that Plaintiffs, not Waupaca, have the burden to prove that their claims can be properly brought as a class and/or collective action." (Dkt. 232 at 20 n. 25.) The parties have already briefed and the Court has already decided whether conditional certification of the FLSA class is appropriate, and as Waupaca notes it is likely there will be further motion practice on the issue of certification under Rule 23 for the state class claims. Because Waupaca fairly raised its challenge to Plaintiffs' efforts to proceed in a collective and/or class action in its twenty-third affirmative defense, I will deny Plaintiffs' motion. 3. Credits under 29 U.S.C. § 207

Waupaca apparently believes that there are certain credits available to it under 29 U.S.C. § 207 that could be counted against any award of damages Plaintiffs may receive. Its sixth affirmative defense states: "Plaintiffs' claims are barred, in whole or in part, to the extent that the work performed falls within exemptions, exclusions, exceptions, or credits provided for in Section 7 of the FLSA, 29 U.S.C. § 207." (Dkt. 84 at 12.) Plaintiffs contend that this affirmative defense is inadequately pled and fails to specify how credits would apply. In its reply brief in support of its cross-motion for summary judgment, Waupaca spells out how it believes it could be entitled to credits. It avers that because it pays its employees time and one half for all hours worked on Saturdays and double time for all hours worked on Sundays, regardless of whether the employee has worked more than 40 hours during the workweek, § 207(h)(2) allows it to credit such "premium pay" against any unpaid overtime obligations it may have under the FLSA. Because Waupaca has properly pled a viable credit defense under § 207 and provided factual support for it (Dkt. 244), Plaintiffs' motion will be denied as it relates to Waupaca's sixth affirmative defense.

Plaintiffs filed a motion to strike Joey Leonard's second declaration [Dkt. 244], Waupaca's additional factual propositions [Dkt. 233], and portions of Waupca's reply to Plaintiffs' additional factual propositions [Dkt. 234]. (Dkt. 252.) As the local rules note, such motions are disfavored in the context of briefing a motion for summary judgment. Civil L.R. 56(b)(9). Plaintiffs complain that Waupaca's submission of additional factual propositions and Leonard's declaration along with its reply brief violates Civil L.R. 56(b)(3). The motion to strike will be denied, as the materials Waupaca submitted in reply are permitted by Civil L.R. 56(b)(3).

III. CONCLUSION

Although the Court was optimistic that a stay of discovery and a round of summary judgment motions could efficiently narrow the legal issues in this case, disputed issues of material fact preclude the Court from granting summary judgment to either party. The principal factual issue is whether the nature of the work performed by the employees requires the donning, doffing and showering for which they seek compensation at the various plants. Further development will also be needed on other issues as well. Waupaca has submitted evidence in various declarations on a number of these issues, which Plaintiffs challenge. Because it appears that further discovery is warranted, Plaintiffs will have an opportunity to more fully explore Waupaca's evidence and present evidence of their own on these topics.

THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that Plaintiffs' motion for partial summary judgment [Dkt. 147] is DENIED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Waupaca's cross-motion for summary judgment [Dkt. 169] is DENIED. IT IS ALSO ORDERED that Plaintiffs' motions to exclude the declarations of Roberts, Esch, Kohloff and Fernandez [Dkts. 204, 206, 208, 210] are DENIED. IT IS ALSO ORDERED that Plaintiffs' motion to strike [Dkt. 252] various documents submitted by Waupaca in reply to Plaintiffs' response to Waupaca's cross-motion for summary judgment is DENIED. IT IS ALSO ORDERED that the Clerk set this matter for a scheduling conference.

Dated this 27th day of September, 2010.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

DEKEYSER v. THYSSENKRUPP WAUPACA, INC. (E.D.Wis. 9-29-2010)
(Sep 29, 2010)