AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an order of the Civil Court of the City of New York, New York County, entered on or about December 15, 2000. The order granted the respondent's motion to dismiss the holdover petition filed by the appellant landlord and denied, as moot, the landlord's cross motion for leave to conduct disclosure and for payment of interim use and occupancy. The landlord initially prosecuted an illegal sublet holdover proceeding, which was discontinued by consent, and subsequently commenced a nonprimary residence holdover proceeding against the tenant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the tenant's CPLR 3211 motion to dismiss the nonprimary residence holdover petition should be granted.
  2. Whether the landlord's prior prosecution of an illegal sublet holdover proceeding, discontinued on consent, was inconsistent with the current nonprimary residence claim.
  3. Whether acceptance of a single unsolicited rent payment by the landlord during the window period constituted an intent to relinquish the landlord's right to proceed on nonprimary residence grounds.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent moved to dismiss the holdover petition on the basis that the landlord's prior illegal sublet holdover proceeding and acceptance of rent nullified the nonprimary residence claim.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the prior illegal sublet proceeding, discontinued on consent, did not negate the nonprimary residence claim.
  • The landlord argued that acceptance of a single unsolicited rent payment did not demonstrate an intent to relinquish rights under the nonprimary residence holdover proceeding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rent Stabilization Code [9 NYCRR § 2525.6(a)] Supports the landlord's nonprimary residence claim despite prior illegal sublet proceeding. The court found the landlord's prior illegal sublet holdover proceeding did not invalidate the nonprimary residence claim under this regulation.
Leroy Realty Corp. v. Hendricks, NYLJ, Apr. 22, 1997 (App Term, 1st Dept) Supports the landlord's right to proceed with nonprimary residence holdover despite prior actions. The court cited this case to affirm that the landlord's prosecution of an illegal sublet proceeding does not preclude a nonprimary residence claim.
Sullivan v. Brevard Assocs., 66 N.Y.2d 489, 495 Establishes that acceptance of rent can indicate intent to relinquish a known right. The court held that the record did not establish as a matter of law that the landlord intended to relinquish rights by accepting a single unsolicited rent payment.
Goldman v. Becraft, NYLJ, July 13, 2001 (App Term, 1st Dept) Addresses the significance of rent acceptance during the "window period" between termination and proceeding commencement. The court relied on this precedent to conclude that acceptance of a single unsolicited rent payment did not nullify the nonprimary residence proceeding.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the tenant's motion to dismiss the nonprimary residence holdover petition under CPLR 3211 and determined it should have been denied. It reasoned that the landlord's prior prosecution of an illegal sublet holdover proceeding, which was discontinued by consent, did not conflict with the current nonprimary residence claim. The court relied on the Rent Stabilization Code and relevant case law to support this position. Furthermore, the court examined the landlord's acceptance of a single unsolicited rent payment during the "window period" and concluded that this did not demonstrate an intent to relinquish the landlord's rights under the nonprimary residence holdover proceeding. The court declined to address the landlord's application for leave to conduct disclosure and for payment of interim use and occupancy, as these matters were not previously considered by the lower court, leaving the landlord free to renew those applications in the Civil Court.

Holding and Implications

The court affirmed the order as modified, reinstating the holdover petition and denying the tenant's motion to dismiss the nonprimary residence holdover petition.

This decision reaffirms that a landlord's prior discontinued illegal sublet proceeding does not invalidate a subsequent nonprimary residence holdover claim. Acceptance of a single unsolicited rent payment does not, as a matter of law, constitute relinquishment of rights in such proceedings. The case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this decision. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing law to the facts, and the landlord retains the right to seek further relief regarding disclosure and interim use and occupancy in the Civil Court.

WEST WAVERLY EQUITIES GROUP, Appellant, v. JUDITH LIEFF, Respondent.

OPINION OF THE COURT

Per Curiam.

Order entered on or about December 15, 2000 modified by denying tenant's motion, reinstating the petition, and remanding the matter to Civil Court for further proceedings consistent with this decision; as modified, order affirmed, with $10 costs to petitioner-appellant.

Tenant's CPLR 3211 motion to dismiss the nonprimary residence holdover petition should have been denied. The landlord's short-lived prosecution of an illegal sublet holdover proceeding — discontinued on consent — was not inconsistent with the landlord's present nonprimary residence claim ( see, Rent Stabilization Code [9 NYCRR] § 2525.6 [a]; 26 Leroy Realty Corp. v. Hendricks, NYLJ, Apr. 22, 1997, at 25, col 4 [App Term, 1st Dept]) and did not "nullify" the previously served termination notice underlying the within nonprimary residence proceeding. Nor does the record establish as a matter of law that landlord "intended to relinquish a known right" ( Sullivan v. Brevard Assocs., 66 N.Y.2d 489, 495) when it accepted a single, unsolicited "rent" payment from tenant during the so-called "window period" between termination of the tenancy on nonprimary residence grounds and commencement of the within nonprimary residence proceeding ( see, Goldman v. Becraft, NYLJ, July 13, 2001, at 18, col 2 [App Term, 1st Dept]).

In reinstating the petition, we do not pass upon the landlord's application for leave to conduct disclosure and for payment of interim use and occupation, matters not reached below. Our disposition is without prejudice to the landlord's right to renew its application for such relief in the Civil Court.

PARNESS, P. J., GANGEL-JACOB and SUAREZ, JJ., concur.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

WEST WAVERLY EQUITIES GROUP v. LIEFF
(Nov 14, 2001)