Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Adodo v Argos Ltd

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant purchased a laptop and mouse pad online from the Respondent for collection from a designated collection point. After taking the laptop home, opening it and activating its operating system to assess compatibility with work software, the Appellant sought a refund within the cancellation period. The Respondent refused, relying on its returns policy and the alleged opening of a digital seal. [1][2]

The Appellant issued proceedings in the County Court, claiming a right to cancel the distance contract under the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013. The claim was allocated to the small claims track. [3][4]

The District Judge initially held that the Regulations did not apply. On appeal, Judge Hedley held that the contract was a distance contract and that the Appellant was entitled to a refund for the mouse pad, but accepted that activating the operating system unsealed computer software and ended the cancellation right for the laptop. The Appellant brought a second appeal. [5][6][7]

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a contract for a laptop preloaded with operating software was a contract for the supply of “sealed computer software” under Regulation 28(3)(b). [8][9][7]
  2. Whether activating the laptop and operating system constituted the breaking of a seal that prevented cancellation. [6][7]
  3. Whether the Appellant’s handling of the laptop was permitted testing under Regulation 34, rather than conduct terminating the right to cancel. [10][11][12]

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • The contract was for the supply of a computer, not sealed computer software, and the Appellant’s interpretation preserved the statutory right to test the computer’s functionality. [13]
  • A consumer purchasing a comparable laptop in a physical shop would ordinarily be allowed to turn it on and test its functionality, including activating its preloaded operating system. [12]
  • The Respondent’s interpretation would deprive consumers of their cancellation rights because a computer could not be properly tested without activating its operating software. [13]

Respondent’s Arguments

  • Activating the operating system broke a “digital seal”, so the laptop fell within Regulation 28(3)(b). [6]
  • The preloaded software could qualify as sealed computer software because it was supplied through the tangible medium of the computer. [14]
  • The absence from Regulation 28(3)(b) of wording requiring the goods to be unsuitable for return indicated a strict-liability regime, regardless of whether unsealing caused actual detriment. [15]
  • The Respondent argued that mandatory information about the computer’s functionality mitigated the consequences of restricting cancellation. [16]

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CG Fry and Sons Ltd v Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government [2025] UKSC 35; [2026] 1 All ER 615 EU-derived legislation is interpreted using ordinary domestic principles of statutory construction, having regard to context and Parliament’s purpose. The Court applied this approach to Regulation 28(3)(b). [17]
Marleasing SA v La Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA Case C-106/89 [1990] ECR I-4135 The Court was no longer bound by the former interpretative principles associated with this authority. The Court noted that domestic statutory-construction principles now governed, subject to the Withdrawal Act. [17]
Slewo v Ledowski Case C-681/17 [2019] 3 CMLR 18 Exceptions to consumer withdrawal rights must be interpreted strictly, particularly where consumer protection is the governing objective. The Court used this reasoning to construe Regulation 28(3)(b) narrowly and to distinguish physical seals from a digital activation process. [18][19][20]
EU v PE Digital GmbH Case C-641/19 [2020] Bus LR 2410 The exceptions to withdrawal rights should be strictly construed. The Court relied on this principle in rejecting an expansive interpretation of the software exception. [20]

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Regulations implement the relevant provisions of Directive 2011/83/EU. Their purpose includes providing a high level of consumer protection and allowing distance purchasers an opportunity to examine and test goods as they could in a shop. [21][22][23][24]

The contract was a distance contract for the sale of goods. The right to cancel generally applied for 14 days after the goods came into the consumer’s physical possession, subject to specified exceptions. [25][26][27][28]

Regulation 28(3)(b) applies to contracts for sealed audio recordings, sealed video recordings or sealed computer software where the goods become unsealed after delivery. The Court held that “sealed” ordinarily means physically closed, secured or protected, and that the goods must refer to the sealed goods forming the subject matter of the supply contract. [29][30][31]

The exception concerns a contract whose specific object is the recording or software itself, supplied on a tangible medium in sealed packaging. It does not naturally describe a contract for a computer that happens to contain operating software necessary for the computer to function. [32][33]

The rationale for the exception is protection against copying, unauthorised use and the loss of royalties. Those concerns may justify denying cancellation for sealed recordings, games or separately purchased software after physical packaging is opened, but they do not justify preventing a consumer from activating operating software to test a laptop’s functionality. [34][35]

The guidance concerning Regulation 34 supports the ability to test a computer’s functionality. Although configuration may cause diminished value and justify a charge for restoring factory settings, it does not itself remove the cancellation right. The Respondent did not establish any such restoration cost. [12][36]

Accordingly, whether activation was described as breaking a digital seal was immaterial. Regulation 28(3)(b) was not directed to that conduct. The provision had to be interpreted narrowly so that it covered physically sealed tangible media containing recordings or software, not operating software preloaded onto a purchased computer. [37][38]

Holding and Implications

Appeal allowed. The contract was for the supply of a computer, not sealed computer software within Regulation 28(3)(b), and the Appellant’s testing of the laptop did not remove the right to cancel. [39]

The Respondent was ordered to refund the price of the computer, with interest accruing from 14 days after the unsuccessful refund request. [40]

The direct effect was restoration of the Appellant’s cancellation and refund rights. The judgment did not identify any broader implication beyond clarifying the narrow scope of Regulation 28(3)(b); no new precedent was expressly stated to have been created. [41][40]

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Adodo v Argos Ltd

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Adodo v Argos Ltd
(Nov 13, 2026)