Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
Edozo Ltd v Valos (UK) Ltd
Smart Summary
Summary of Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff and the Defendant are competitors supplying valuations and related information about real property via software platforms accessed through website GUIs. The Defendant's system (the "Valos Platform") produces template-based reports ("Valos Reports") from "Valos Template Reports" and associated GUIs ("Valos Report Graphics"). The Plaintiff later launched a comparable product ("Edozo Reports Product") accessed via its own GUIs and generated by its platform ("Edozo Platform"). The Defendant alleged that the Plaintiff's product bore unfair similarities and asserted copyright infringement, initially in template reports and GUIs and later in the Defendant's underlying software. Mediation in April 2025 failed. On 29 April 2025 the Plaintiff issued proceedings seeking declarations of non-infringement; the Defendant counterclaimed for infringement. The present application is by the Plaintiff to strike out parts of the Defence and Counterclaim that allege indirect infringement of the Defendant's computer program source code.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether alleged reproduction of the sequence of user-facing steps and modular behaviour ("the Valos Steps" / "the Edozo Steps") can amount to indirect copying and thereby infringe the copyright in the Defendant's source code.
- Whether copyright in a computer program protects the functional behaviour or sequence of presentations generated by the program (the "functionality" or "steps") or is confined to the expression embodied in source code and related literary/artistic forms.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The pleaded case of indirect copying of the Defendant's source code via similarity of user-facing steps is bad in law and should be struck out under CPR 3.4(2)(a).
- Copyright in a computer program protects the skill, judgment and labour in devising source code, not the program's functionality or the sequence/form of user presentations (the Valos Steps).
- The idea/expression distinction and the concept of substantiality mean that general ideas or functionality are not protected by literary copyright in source code.
Defendant's Arguments
- The Defendant relied on pleaded particulars that the Plaintiff's product reproduces the Defendant's "dynamic logic and modularity" (the Valos Steps) in substantial part and that this yielded indirect copying of the Defendant's computer programs.
- Particulars relied on included alleged access, benchmarking, substantive similarities shown in confidential annexes (side-by-side comparisons of steps and screens), admissions by an ex-employee, and other factual matters said to support an inference of copying.
- The Defendant invoked authorities (including Abraham Moon) to support the proposition that intermediary descriptions or representations can transmit protectable literary content through a chain of copying.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Navitaire Inc v easyJet Airline Co Ltd [2004] EWHC 1725 |
Distinction between idea and expression in relation to computer programs; analogy that emulating a program's behaviour does not necessarily infringe if code not copied; "pudding" analogy. |
The court relied on Navitaire to support the proposition that reproducing the external behaviour or interface of software does not automatically amount to infringement of the source code; Navitaire's pudding analogy was approved and applied to distinguish functionality from protected expression. |
| Plix Products Ltd v Frank M. Winstone (Merchants) [1986] FSR 63 |
Indirect copying is possible where an intermediary description sufficiently precise enables reproduction in substantial part. |
The court acknowledged Plix as authority that intermediary descriptions can transmit protected content through a chain of copying, but treated that principle as distinct from whether software functionality constitutes protected expression of source code. |
| Abraham Moon & Sons Ltd v Thornber [2012] EWPCC 37 |
Example where instructions (ticket stamp) were literary works and reproduction via a different "language" infringed copyright. |
The Defendant relied on Abraham Moon as an example of intermediary reproduction giving rise to infringement; the court accepted the authority but did not treat it as resolving the question whether software functionality (the Valos Steps) is protected expression of source code. |
| Kogan v Martin [2019] EWCA Civ 1645 |
Reiteration of the idea/expression dichotomy and the difficulty of fixing the boundary; importance of substantiality. |
Quoted to explain that the idea/expression distinction is a question of degree and that substantiality determines whether an idea has become protected expression. |
| IBCOS Computers Ltd v Barclays Mercantile Highland Finance Ltd [1994] F.S.R. 275 |
Discussion of idea/expression boundary and substantiality (Jacob J quoted). |
Used to frame the analysis that substantiality is the operative issue in deciding whether what was taken amounts to protected expression. |
| Designers' Guild Ltd v Russell Williams (Textiles) Ltd [2000] 1 WLR 2416 |
Lord Hoffmann's explanation of two propositions in idea/expression: (a) ideas not protected if not connected to nature of work; (b) insufficient originality/commonplace ideas not a substantial part. |
Cited to show that protection depends on sufficiency of connection between the subject-matter and the nature of the copyright work; applied to distinguish functionality from protected literary expression. |
| Kleeneze Ltd. v. D.R.G. (U.K.) Ltd. [1984] F.S.R. 399 |
Example referenced by Lord Hoffmann about limits of copyright protection for ideas expressed in a work. |
Referred to in the broader discussion of idea/expression and what copyright will not protect. |
| Kenrick & Co. v. Lawrence & Co. (1890) 25 QBD 99 |
Authority on insufficiency/commonality of ideas to constitute a substantial part. |
Referenced as part of the historical backdrop to the idea/expression and substantiality analysis. |
| SAS Institute Inc v World Programming Ltd [2013] EWCA Civ 1482 |
Held functionality of a computer program and programming language are not protected by copyright; distinction between manuals/specifications and protected expression; role of CJEU. |
The court relied heavily on SAS Institute: functionality (external behaviour/steps) is not a form of expression of the source code and therefore not protected by copyright in that source code; used to conclude the Valos Steps are not protected expression of Valos source code. |
| Nova Productions Ltd v Mazooma Games Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 219 [2007] R.P.C. 25 |
Substantiality analysis in literary copyright and treatment of preparatory design work for software. |
Quoted to reinforce that preparatory design or functional description may be protected as literary expression if reduced to sufficient written form, but functions themselves are not protected; supported rejection of arguments that functional preparatory work alone attracts protection. |
| The Newspaper Licensing Agency v Meltwater Holding BV [2011] EWCA Civ 890 [2012] RPC 1 |
Referenced in the context of interpretation of substantial part and related doctrine. |
Mentioned as part of the body of authority on substantiality and interpretation of s.16 CDPA; used to support the court's statutory approach. |
| Infopaq International A/S v Danske Dagblades Forening (C-5/08) [2009] ECR I-6569 |
Principle that parts of a work must contain expression of the author's intellectual creation to be protected. |
Applied to the statutory test for substantial part: only elements that are expression of the author's intellectual creation attract protection; used to assess whether functionality qualifies. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in stages.
- It accepted that indirect copying (a chain in which an intermediate work reproduces the original) is legally possible, citing s.16(3)(b) CDPA and authorities such as Plix and Abraham Moon for that proposition.
- The court then identified the core legal boundary as the idea/expression distinction and the related notion of substantiality: only expression that embodies the author's intellectual creation (in a qualitative sense) is protected by copyright.
- Analysing authorities (notably Navitaire, Nova and SAS Institute), the court emphasised that copyright in a computer program protects the author's skill, judgment and labour in devising source code and expressed forms (and, where present, preparatory design reduced to literary expression), but does not protect the program's functionality — the tasks it performs or the sequence of user-facing presentations.
- The court accepted the Plaintiff's concession for present purposes that the Edozo Steps reproduced the Valos Steps, but held that those Steps constitute functionality of the Defendant's programs, not the form of expression of the Defendant's source code.
- Applying the cited authorities, particularly SAS Institute (and the Navitaire pudding analogy), the court concluded that reproducing the Valos Steps by independent implementation does not amount to reproduction of the Defendant's source code in a real or legally protected sense; therefore such copying cannot found a claim of indirect infringement of the source code copyright.
- The court noted possible alternative protections available to the Defendant (copyright in the Steps themselves if expressed as literary/artistic works, or patent protection for inventive functionality) but concluded these do not alter the settled statutory and case-law boundary excluding program functionality from copyright in source code.
Holding and Implications
STRUCK OUT
Those parts of the Defence and Counterclaim alleging indirect infringement of the literary copyright in the Original Valos Computer Program, the Subsequent Valos Computer Programs and the Valos Coded Prompts (i.e. that the Plaintiff's reproduction of the user-facing steps amounted to indirect copying of the Defendant's source code) were struck out.
Direct effect: the Defendant may not pursue, in this action, the pleaded theory that reproducing the Defendant's functionality/steps constitutes indirect infringement of the Defendant's source code copyright. The decision follows established authorities and applies the idea/expression and substantiality principles to hold functionality is not protected by literary copyright in source code. The opinion notes alternative protection routes but does not create a new form of copyright protection.
Click here to read the full judgment