Factual and Procedural Background
The claim arises from allegations of copyright infringement and passing off concerning a large wall drawing ("the Work") created in 2017 by the Plaintiff, a visual artist. The Plaintiff assigned copyright in the Work to Company A in 2021. The Defendants comprise Company B, an Argentinian winery producing wine for sale in the United Kingdom, Company C, a UK-based importer and distributor exclusively distributing the Products bearing three different wine labels, and Director D, who manages Company C.
Company C imported and sold wine bearing the three labels in the UK, with Company B producing the labels. The Plaintiff alleges that the first label copies a substantial part of the Work, while the second and third labels are redesigned versions. The Defendants deny infringement and contest liability.
Company B did not attend the trial, and its witness statement was not admitted as evidence. Company C and Director D were represented by Director D himself, who was given assistance to ensure a fair hearing. The trial was conducted over two days, focusing on issues of copyright subsistence, infringement, passing off, and joint tortfeasorship.
Legal Issues Presented
- Does copyright subsist in the Work under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA)?
- Is Company A the owner of the copyright in the Work, and what is the scope of the assignment from the Plaintiff?
- Does the first wine label constitute a copy of the Work or a substantial part of it?
- If yes, have the second and/or third labels been copied from the first label such that they also infringe?
- Does goodwill subsist in the Plaintiff's distinctive artistic style ("The Style") in the UK?
- Is the goodwill owned by the Plaintiff?
- Have the Defendants misrepresented that their goods are connected with the Plaintiff’s business in trade?
- If so, has such misrepresentation caused the Plaintiff damage?
- Are the Defendants or any combination jointly liable as joint tortfeasors for copyright infringement and/or passing off?
Arguments of the Parties
Claimants' Arguments
- The Plaintiff claims copyright infringement and passing off relating primarily to the first label, asserting that it copies a substantial part of the Work.
- The Plaintiff contends that the second and third labels, as redesigned versions, still infringe by reproducing significant elements of her intellectual creation.
- The Plaintiff alleges that the Defendants misrepresented the Products as endorsed by her, damaging her goodwill and endorsement business.
- The Plaintiff asserts joint tortfeasorship against all Defendants for acts committed after notification of infringement.
- The Plaintiff seeks damages and injunctive relief, with additional claims for moral rights infringement and flagrancy damages, though these latter issues were not included in the List of Issues for trial.
Defendants' Arguments
- Company B did not participate in the trial and did not provide evidence.
- Director D and Company C deny knowledge of the Plaintiff or the Work prior to notification and deny infringement by the second and third labels.
- Director D claims no intellectual property clearance was conducted by Company C, relying on the manufacturer (Company B) to handle such matters.
- They assert that the second and third labels are sufficiently different from the Work to avoid infringement.
- Company C and Director D argue that any infringement was innocent and that they ceased dealing with the first label products after notification.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Infopaq International A/S v Danske Dagblades Forening (C-5/08) [2010] FSR 20 |
Definition and test for copying a substantial part of a work, focusing on intellectual creation. |
The court applied the principle that even a small part of a work may be protected if it reflects the author's intellectual creation, assessing whether the first label copied such a part. |
| Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd v Meltwater Holding BV [2011] EWCA Civ 890 |
Qualitative test for substantial part copying, focusing on the expression of intellectual creation. |
Used to support the qualitative assessment of whether the first label copied a substantial part of the Work. |
| Pasternak v Prescott [2022] EWHC 2695 (Ch) |
Summary of copyright principles and the intellectual creation test post-Infopaq. |
Guided the court's understanding of originality and substantial part copying in this case. |
| Designers Guild Limited v Russell Williams Textiles Ltd [2000] 1 WLR 2416 |
Presumption of copying where substantial similarities exist. |
Applied to find that the first label was clearly a copy of a substantial part of the Work. |
| Reckitt & Colman Products Ltd v Borden Inc [1990] 1 WLR 491 |
Elements of passing off: goodwill, misrepresentation, and damage. |
Used to assess the passing off claim based on false endorsement of the first label products. |
| Starbucks (HK) Ltd & Anor v British Sky Broadcasting Group Plc & Ors [2015] UKSC 31 |
Requirement that goodwill must include customers in the relevant jurisdiction (UK). |
Confirmed the Plaintiff's goodwill in the UK for passing off purposes. |
| Irvine v Talksport Ltd [2002] EWHC 367 |
Passing off in false endorsement cases without need for common field of activity. |
Supported the claim that the Defendants misrepresented endorsement without requiring shared activity. |
| Fenty v Arcadia Group Brands Ltd [2015] EWCA Civ 3 |
Clarification of passing off principles and damage causation. |
Applied to confirm the elements required for passing off and their satisfaction here. |
| Lifestyle Equities CV & Anor v Ahmed & Anor [2024] UKSC 17 |
Accessory liability/joint tortfeasorship requires actual or constructive knowledge of essential tort facts. |
Guided the court's approach to joint liability of the Defendants post-notification. |
| Wade v Singh [2024] EWHC 1203 (Ch) |
Adverse inferences for failure to disclose documents. |
Considered but declined to draw adverse inference against Company B due to lack of relevant acts in UK. |
| Ebofi v Royal Mail Group Ltd [2021] UKSC 33 |
Adverse inference principles in disclosure. |
Referenced in context of disclosure failures but not applied to alter findings. |
| Original Beauty Technology Company and Ors v G4K Fashion Limited and Ors [2021] EWHC 3439 (Ch) |
Principles on flagrancy damages in copyright infringement. |
Applied to reject claim for flagrancy damages as infringement was not flagrant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by confirming copyright subsistence in the Work under the CDPA, based on the Plaintiff’s British citizenship and US residence, and accepted the assignment of copyright to Company A.
In assessing infringement, the court applied established principles from leading cases emphasizing qualitative assessment of whether a substantial part of the Work was copied, focusing on the expression of intellectual creation.
The first label was found to be a clear and substantial copy of the Work, reproducing key original features, despite some modifications. The second and third labels, although copies of the first label, were found to have moved sufficiently away from the Work not to infringe, lacking critical elements such as humanoid faces and the absence of perspective characteristic of the Work.
Regarding the acts of infringement, Company C was liable for issuing copies to the public, importing, possessing, and selling the first label products. Liability under some provisions depended on knowledge of infringement, which Company C acquired shortly after notification by the Plaintiff on 13 April 2020. Prior to that date, liability for some acts was negated by lack of knowledge.
Company B and Director D were not primarily liable for copyright infringement as they did not perform relevant acts in the UK. However, the court found them jointly liable as accessory tortfeasors post-notification, having knowledge of infringement.
The court declined to determine moral rights infringement and flagrancy damages as they were not included in the List of Issues and it would be unfair to introduce new issues at trial without permission. Nevertheless, the court noted that the moral rights claim would have succeeded on the facts had it been properly pleaded.
On passing off, the court found that the Plaintiff had goodwill in her artistic style in the UK and that Company C misrepresented the first label products as endorsed by the Plaintiff, causing damage to her endorsement business and the distinctiveness of her style. Company B was not liable for passing off as it undertook no relevant acts in the UK.
The court rejected passing off claims relating to the second and third labels due to insufficient similarity and lack of evidence of consumer confusion.
Regarding joint tortfeasorship for passing off, the court found no liability for Company B or Director D, as there was no evidence they had knowledge of the Plaintiff's goodwill or essential facts of the tort prior to the relevant dates.
The court emphasized that accessory liability requires actual or constructive knowledge of the essential tort elements, consistent with recent Supreme Court authority.
Finally, the court noted inaccuracies and unreliability in the Defendants’ sales records but found these did not materially affect the liability findings. The court also stressed the importance of adhering to the List of Issues in IPEC proceedings to ensure fairness and proportionality.
Holding and Implications
The court held as follows:
- Company C is liable for copyright infringement of the Work in relation to the first label products, specifically for issuing copies to the public, importing, possessing, and selling such products from shortly after 13 April 2020.
- Company C is liable for passing off of the first label products as endorsed by the Plaintiff.
- Company B and Director D are jointly liable as accessory tortfeasors for copyright infringement concerning the first label products dealt with after notification.
- No liability is found for any Defendant regarding the second and third labels for either copyright infringement or passing off.
The implications are that Company C must cease dealing with infringing products and may be subject to injunctions and damages determined at a subsequent hearing. Company B and Director D are liable only as joint tortfeasors post-notification and not as primary infringers. No new legal principles were established; the court applied existing law to the facts. The case underscores the importance of clear issue management in IPEC trials and the strict approach to accessory liability requiring knowledge of tortious conduct.