Factual and Procedural Background
This case involves a claim for damages brought by the Plaintiff against the Defendant, representing emanations of the UK state, based on an alleged failure by the Court of Appeal in London to refer a question of European Union ("EU") law to the European Court of Justice ("ECJ") in Luxembourg. The Plaintiff's claim arises from the refusal by the Court of Appeal to make such a reference, which the Plaintiff contends deprived him of the opportunity to pursue an unfair dismissal claim against Company A in the UK Employment Tribunal.
The Plaintiff, holding dual Argentine and Italian nationality, sought employment with Company A and was offered a position based in Singapore. After a brief employment period, a dispute arose leading to his dismissal. The Plaintiff successfully pursued a wrongful dismissal claim in Singapore but was denied jurisdiction in the UK Employment Tribunal. Appeals to the Employment Appeal Tribunal and the Court of Appeal were unsuccessful, with the latter refusing to refer the question of EU law to the ECJ.
The Plaintiff then initiated the present damages claim against the Defendant, alleging that the failure to refer by the Court of Appeal constituted a breach of EU law and his rights under the European Convention on Human Rights ("ECHR"). The case proceeded on the Plaintiff's motion for summary decree and the Defendant's motion for dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court of Appeal was obliged under Article 267 TFEU to refer the question of EU law concerning the territorial jurisdiction of the UK Employment Tribunal to the ECJ.
- Whether the Court of Appeal's refusal to make such a reference constituted a sufficiently serious breach of EU law to give rise to state liability under the principles established in Kobler.
- Whether the Plaintiff has sufficiently pleaded and can prove a direct causal link between the alleged breach and the losses claimed.
- Whether the Plaintiff's pleadings meet the required standards of clarity, specification, and fair notice.
- Whether the Plaintiff's claim for damages is sustainable given the facts and legal principles, including the applicability of the CILFIT criteria and the prohibition on discrimination under EU law.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Court of Appeal erred in refusing to refer the question of whether an EU national employed in the same circumstances as a British national has equal access to the UK Employment Tribunal.
- This refusal breached the Plaintiff's rights under Article 6.1 of the ECHR (right to a fair trial) and EU law principles against discrimination on grounds of nationality.
- The Court of Appeal failed to comply with the CILFIT test by not providing adequate reasons based on EU case law for refusing to refer the question.
- The Plaintiff contended that the tests applied by the Employment Tribunal and the Court of Appeal imposed covert residency and pre-existing link requirements that discriminated against migrant EU workers compared to British nationals.
- Relying on Kobler, the Plaintiff argued that the Defendant is liable for damages due to the manifest breach of EU law by the Court of Appeal.
- The Plaintiff claimed various losses including salary, bonuses, share entitlements, and loss of reputation, asserting that these arose directly from the failure to refer and consequent denial of access to the Employment Tribunal.
- The Plaintiff sought a summary decree in his favour and requested the court to refer questions relating to the valuation of damages to the ECJ.
Defendant's Arguments
- The Court of Appeal was not obliged to refer the question under Article 267 TFEU because the question was not relevant to the outcome of the case, applying the CILFIT criteria.
- The territorial jurisdiction issue was a matter of fact and judgment for the Employment Tribunal and appellate courts, which had been correctly applied.
- There was no discrimination on grounds of nationality, as the decision was based on the closeness of the employment relationship, not nationality or residence alone.
- The Plaintiff's pleadings were deficient, lacking proper form, clarity, and specification, making it difficult to identify the legal basis and factual foundation of the claim.
- The Plaintiff failed to demonstrate a direct causal link between the alleged breach and the losses claimed, including a lack of averments that he would have been re-employed by Company A or that reinstatement would have been ordered and complied with.
- The claim was an attempt to circumvent the prescriptive period and introduce new claims via a late Minute of Amendment, which should be refused.
- The Defendant denied any liability, contending the Plaintiff's case was without real prospect of success and the motion for summary decree should be refused.
- The Defendant submitted that damages assessment and causation are governed by national law and that the Plaintiff's claim was speculative and insufficiently pleaded.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| CILFIT v Ministero della Sanita [1982] ECR 3415 |
Sets criteria when national courts must refer questions to the ECJ under Article 267 TFEU. |
Applied to determine that no obligation to refer arose as the question was not relevant or was acte claire. |
| Kobler v Republik Osterrich [2004] QB 848 |
Establishes conditions for state liability for breaches of EU law by courts of last instance. |
Used to assess whether the Court of Appeal manifestly infringed EU law and whether the breach was sufficiently serious to incur liability. |
| Lawson v Serco [2006] ICR 250 |
Approach to territorial jurisdiction of UK Employment Tribunal for employees working abroad. |
Applied as correct legal framework for assessing employment relationship closeness with the UK. |
| Ravat v Halliburton Manufacturing and Services Ltd 2012 SC (UKSC) 265 |
Clarifies factors relevant to territorial jurisdiction and employment relationship. |
Referenced in understanding the territorial scope of the Employment Tribunal's jurisdiction. |
| O'Flynn v Adjudication Officer, ECJ Case C-237/94 |
Defines indirect discrimination where conditions affect migrant workers disproportionately. |
Considered in examining whether the Court of Appeal's approach imposed discriminatory conditions. |
| Commission v Belgium ECJ Case C-278/94 |
Prohibits conditions applied equally that are more easily fulfilled by nationals than migrant workers. |
Used to argue that the Court of Appeal's test was discriminatory against non-UK nationals. |
| Ullens v Belgium, ECtHR Case 3989/07 |
Requires national courts to give reasons for refusal to refer questions to the ECJ under Article 267. |
Applied to assess adequacy of reasons given by the Court of Appeal. |
| Dhahbi v Italy, ECtHR Case C-111/91 |
Reaffirms obligation to provide reasons for refusal to refer under Article 267. |
Referenced in evaluating the Court of Appeal's compliance with procedural fairness. |
| Factortame ECR [1996] I-1029 |
Basis for damages arising from breaches of EU law by Member States. |
Invoked to support the claim for damages due to failure to refer. |
| Blackstone's Employment Law |
Authority on employment law principles including reinstatement and re-engagement. |
Used to argue the practicability and obligation of reinstatement in the Plaintiff's employment claim. |
| Duncombe & Ors v Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families [2011] UKSC 14 and 36 |
Confirms approach to territorial jurisdiction and employment rights. |
Referenced in the context of jurisdictional assessments. |
| Walrave & Anr v AUCI and Ors, ECJ Case 36/74 |
EU law on freedom of movement and non-discrimination for workers. |
Considered in relation to the Plaintiff's rights as an EU national worker. |
| Ullah v Special Adjudicator [2004] UKHL 26 |
National courts must keep pace with Strasbourg jurisprudence on Convention rights. |
Applied to assess the Plaintiff's Article 6 ECHR claim. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by examining the procedural and factual background, noting the Plaintiff's claim arose from the Court of Appeal's refusal to refer a question of EU law to the ECJ under Article 267 TFEU. The Court acknowledged the Plaintiff's contention that this refusal deprived him of his right to pursue an unfair dismissal claim in the UK Employment Tribunal.
The court emphasized the importance of proper pleadings, requiring clarity in the legal remedy sought, the factual basis, and the legal propositions linking them. It found the Plaintiff's pleadings deficient, lacking proper form, specification, and fair notice, complicating the Defendant's ability to respond and the court's evaluation.
On the legal issue of whether the Court of Appeal was obliged to refer the question, the court applied the CILFIT criteria, holding that no obligation arose where the question was irrelevant to the outcome or the correct application of EU law was clear. The court found that the territorial jurisdiction question was a matter of fact and judgment concerning the closeness of the employment relationship, not nationality or residence alone, and that the Court of Appeal had properly considered these factors.
Regarding allegations of discrimination, the court accepted that nationality was not a relevant factor in the Court of Appeal's decision and that any consideration of residence was only one element among many in assessing the employment relationship. The court rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the Court of Appeal imposed discriminatory residency or link requirements contrary to EU law.
Turning to state liability under Kobler, the court noted the high threshold for liability, requiring a manifest infringement of EU law by a court of last instance. It concluded that even if an error had been made, it was not manifest, and the Plaintiff had not met the burden of showing a sufficiently serious breach.
On causation and loss, the court held that the Plaintiff must aver and prove a direct causal link between the failure to refer and the losses claimed, including the likelihood of success before the Employment Tribunal and compliance with any reinstatement order. The court found the Plaintiff's averments speculative, lacking specificity and fair notice, and thus irrelevant for proof.
The court also addressed the Plaintiff's reliance on the Singapore judgment, explaining that findings in that case do not automatically apply in this action against the Defendant and that the plea of res judicata was not applicable.
Finally, the court considered the Plaintiff's motion to refer questions on damages valuation to the ECJ, declining to make such a referral at this stage due to procedural and substantive considerations.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision was to REPEL the Plaintiff's pleas in law, SUSTAIN the Defendant's second plea in law, and DISMISS the action. All questions of expenses were reserved for future determination.
This decision directly affects the parties by dismissing the Plaintiff's claim for damages arising from the alleged failure to refer a question to the ECJ. The court found no manifest breach of EU law by the Court of Appeal and insufficient pleading and proof of causation and loss by the Plaintiff. No new legal precedent was established by this judgment.