Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Ms N Clark and Mrs M Bell v Chief Constable of Derbyshire Constabulary and Chief Constable of West Midlands Police and Secretary of State for the Home Department (England and Wales : Disability Discrimination)

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from preliminary hearings before the Employment Tribunal concerning two claimants who brought complaints of disability discrimination under sections 15 and 19 of the Equality Act 2010 (the 2010 Act). The claimants had both been required to retire pursuant to Regulation A20 of the Police Pensions Regulations 1987 and were awarded ill-health pensions and injury pensions under the Police (Injury Benefit) Regulations 2006 (PIBR 2006). The claims relate specifically to the refusal of a disablement gratuity under Regulation 12 of the PIBR 2006. The claimants brought their disability discrimination claims after their employment had ended. The Tribunal was asked to determine its jurisdiction to hear these claims under various statutory gateways within the 2010 Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Does the Employment Tribunal have jurisdiction to hear complaints of disability discrimination brought under sections 15 and 19 of the Equality Act 2010 through the gateway of section 39 of that Act?
  2. Does the Employment Tribunal have jurisdiction to hear complaints of disability discrimination brought under sections 15 and 19 of the Equality Act 2010 through the gateway of section 108 of that Act?
  3. Does the Employment Tribunal have jurisdiction to hear complaints of disability discrimination brought under sections 15 and 19 of the Equality Act 2010 through the gateway of section 61 of that Act?

Arguments of the Parties

Claimants' Arguments

  • The claimants argued that the refusal to pay the disablement gratuity amounted to denial of access to a benefit under section 39(2)(d) and that this conduct arose out of and was closely connected to the previous employment relationship.
  • They submitted that the Police (Injury Benefit) Regulations 2006 (PIBR 2006) constituted an occupational pension scheme under the definition in section 1 of the Pension Schemes Act 1993 (PSA), enabling jurisdiction under section 61 of the Equality Act 2010.
  • The claimants relied on case law supporting a broad and liberal construction of "occupational pension scheme," including Westminster City Council v Haywood, City and County of Swansea v Johnson, and Parlett v Guppys (Bridport) Ltd (No. 2).
  • They contended that PIBR 2006 benefits arise on retirement or termination of employment and should be regarded as pension benefits despite the scheme being non-contributory and separate from the Police Pension Scheme.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents contended that the Employment Tribunal lacked jurisdiction under section 39 because the claimants were no longer employees when the claims were brought.
  • They argued that the section 108 gateway did not apply because the alleged discriminatory conduct arose after the employment relationship ended and was connected to a compensation scheme entered into only after termination.
  • The respondents submitted that PIBR 2006 is not an occupational pension scheme as commonly understood, but a compensation scheme for injury or death, and does not meet the narrower definition in section 1 of the PSA.
  • They noted that the PIBR 2006 includes benefits contingent on death and conditions not normally associated with pension schemes, and that Parliament deliberately adopted a narrower definition excluding such schemes.
  • They relied on previous judicial review authorities and the decision in Curry v Chief Constable of Northumbria Police to support their position that PIBR 2006 is separate from pension schemes and outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction under section 61.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Westminster City Council v Haywood & others [1997] Pens LR 39, Court of Appeal Broad and liberal interpretation of "occupational pension scheme" under the Pension Schemes Act 1993. The court found the severance scheme qualified as an occupational pension scheme; the Tribunal applied this reasoning analogously to PIBR 2006.
City and County of Swansea v Johnson [1999] Pens LR 187, High Court Whether an injury allowance payable on termination of employment is an occupational pension scheme. The court held that compensation schemes payable on termination may fall within the definition, supporting the Tribunal's conclusion that PIBR 2006 qualifies.
Parlett v Guppys (Bridport) Ltd (No. 2) [2000] Pens LR 195, Court of Appeal Encouragement to construe "occupational pension scheme" liberally rather than restrictively. Tribunal relied on this authority to support a wide interpretation of pension schemes including PIBR 2006.
Rhys-Harper v Relaxion Group plc [2003] ICR 867, House of Lords Section 108 of Equality Act 2010 codifies the principle that discrimination claims can arise from a former relationship if closely connected. The Tribunal considered this case when assessing whether section 108 applied, ultimately rejecting its application here.
Ford Motor Company Ltd v Elliott & others [2016] ICR 711 Clarification on the "close connection" test under section 108 for discrimination claims arising after employment. The Tribunal applied the reasoning to conclude the claims did not meet the close connection requirement under section 108.
Curry v Chief Constable of Northumbria Police [2500281/2017], Employment Tribunal PIBR 2006 does not constitute an occupational pension scheme for jurisdictional purposes. The Tribunal adopted the reasoning in Curry to conclude PIBR 2006 is not within section 108 gateway jurisdiction.
Evans and Ashcroft v The Chief Constable of the South Wales Police [2018] EWCA Civ 2107 Injury awards under PIBR 2006 are separate from police occupational pension schemes. The Tribunal noted this authority but found it not directly helpful for the jurisdictional question before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal examined the statutory gateways under which it might have jurisdiction to hear the claimants' disability discrimination complaints. It first considered section 39 of the Equality Act 2010, which applies to employees and applicants for employment. Because both claimants had retired before bringing their claims, they were no longer employees, and thus section 39 did not provide jurisdiction.

Next, the Tribunal analysed section 108, which addresses discrimination connected to a former employment relationship. The Tribunal reviewed statutory provisions and relevant case law, including Rhys-Harper and Ford Motor Company, to apply the "close connection" test. It concluded that the refusal to pay the disablement gratuity arose from the administration of a post-employment compensation scheme and was not sufficiently connected to the prior employment relationship. The Tribunal adopted the reasoning in Curry, which held that claims arising solely from post-employment schemes do not fall within section 108 jurisdiction.

Finally, the Tribunal considered section 61, which relates to non-discrimination rules in occupational pension schemes. The critical question was whether the PIBR 2006 constituted an occupational pension scheme under the Pension Schemes Act 1993. The Tribunal undertook a detailed statutory interpretation exercise, considering the definitions and legislative history, including the Finance Act 2004 and the separation of injury benefits from pension schemes to avoid tax charges.

The Tribunal found persuasive the authorities supporting a broad and liberal construction of "occupational pension scheme," notably Westminster City Council v Haywood, City and County of Swansea v Johnson, and Parlett v Guppys. It rejected the respondents' narrower interpretation, which emphasized the compensatory nature of PIBR 2006 and its separation from pension schemes. The Tribunal concluded that PIBR 2006 falls within the statutory definition of an occupational pension scheme since benefits arise on retirement or termination of service, and the scheme provides benefits payable on termination of employment.

Accordingly, the Tribunal held that it has jurisdiction under section 61 to hear the claimants' disability discrimination complaints.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Employment Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear the claimants' complaints of disability discrimination under sections 15 and 19 of the Equality Act 2010 through the gateways of sections 39 or 108 of that Act. However, the Tribunal does have jurisdiction to hear the complaints through the gateway of section 61.

Implications: This decision permits the claimants to pursue their disability discrimination claims under the non-discrimination rules applicable to occupational pension schemes, specifically under section 61 of the Equality Act 2010. The ruling clarifies the scope of jurisdiction in cases involving police injury benefits and confirms that the PIBR 2006 qualifies as an occupational pension scheme for these purposes. No broader precedent beyond the immediate effect on the parties was established.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Ms N Clark and Mrs M Bell v Chief Constable of Derbyshire Constabulary and Chief Constable of West Midlands Police and Secretary of State for the Home Department (England and Wales : Disability Discrimination)

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Ms N Clark and Mrs M Bell v Chief Constable of Derbyshire Constabulary and Chief Constable of West Midlands Police and Secretary of State for the Home Department (England and Wales : Disability Discrimination)
(Dec 1, 2021)