Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

JC v. PC

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application made by the father of two children seeking orders for their summary return to England from Brazil, where they currently reside. The father's substantive application was issued on 24 March 2021 under section 8 of the Children Act 1989, aiming to regulate the children's future living arrangements and impose an interim prohibition on their removal from the jurisdiction of England and Wales. Parallel proceedings are ongoing in Brazil initiated by both parents, with interim holding orders issued but no substantive resolution. The children's situation is described as unsatisfactory and requiring urgent resolution.

The preliminary issue before the court was whether it had jurisdiction, hinging on whether the children retained their habitual residence in England or had acquired a new habitual residence in Brazil, as claimed by the mother. The mother argued that welfare issues should be determined by the Brazilian courts, now seised of the matter.

Case management directions were made, including the preparation of a CAFCASS report on the children's wishes and feelings, and the matter was listed for a preliminary hearing on jurisdiction, which took place on 4 August 2021. A further hearing was scheduled for 13 and 14 September 2021 to address the substantive issue of the children's summary return if jurisdiction was established.

The court received extensive written evidence, including material from Brazilian proceedings, and heard detailed submissions from counsel representing both parents. The children’s separate representation was postponed. The court did not hear oral evidence due to time constraints but relied on the written material and submissions.

The children, a 13-year-old and a 6-year-old, are dual nationals of Brazil and the United Kingdom. The family’s established habitual residence was London, where the father worked and the children were educated privately. The family had lived in London since 2004 with brief periods abroad. The mother’s health issues and the marital tensions, exacerbated by the Covid-19 pandemic, are part of the background.

The mother traveled to Brazil for surgery in November 2020, initially intending a short stay. The father and children joined her later that month. Due to travel restrictions and the mother’s initiation of divorce proceedings in Brazil without the father's prior knowledge, the family remained in Brazil. The mother claims the relocation became permanent over time, while the father asserts it was a temporary visit disrupted by external factors.

There are two sets of proceedings in Brazil: custody proceedings initiated by the mother in the local State Court and Hague Convention proceedings initiated by the father in the Federal Court seeking the children’s return to England. Interim orders have been made in Brazil, including sole custody for the mother and later provisional custody of the elder child to the father due to emotional harm caused by the parental conflict.

The children currently live separately with each parent in Brazil, attend different schools, and have limited integration into Brazilian life. The father expressed concern about delays in the Brazilian courts and the impact on the children, particularly the elder child’s emotional wellbeing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the English court has jurisdiction to make orders concerning the children based on their habitual residence as of the date of the father's application (24 March 2021).
  2. If jurisdiction exists, whether the court should exercise that jurisdiction or defer to the Brazilian courts.
  3. The determination of the children’s habitual residence, specifically whether it remains England or has changed to Brazil.
  4. The applicability of the 1996 Hague Convention and related provisions, including issues of wrongful removal or retention and the effect of Brazil not being a contracting state.

Arguments of the Parties

Mother's Arguments

  • The relevant date for determining habitual residence should be the date of any given hearing, not the date the English proceedings were issued.
  • By 24 March 2021, both children had acquired a new habitual residence in Brazil.
  • The English court should decline jurisdiction in favor of the Brazilian courts, which are already seised of the welfare matters.
  • Article 7 of the 1996 Hague Convention does not apply as Brazil is not a contracting state, and the burden lies on the father to prove its applicability.
  • The father’s application under the Hague Convention has caused delay in Brazil, and the mother argues the Brazilian proceedings should be allowed to run their course.

Father's Arguments

  • The English court has jurisdiction under domestic law (Family Law Act 1986 sections 2, 3, and 7(c)) based on the children’s habitual residence as of 24 March 2021.
  • He contends the mother wrongfully retained the children in Brazil by initiating proceedings without his knowledge and attempting to establish jurisdiction there.
  • The mother’s actions amount to forum shopping to secure jurisdiction favorable to her in Brazil.
  • Article 7 of the 1996 Hague Convention applies by analogy to preserve English jurisdiction despite Brazil not being a contracting state.
  • The children’s habitual residence remains England, as their integration into Brazil was insufficient by the relevant date.
  • The father emphasizes the urgent need for resolution due to his impending return to London and the elder child’s deteriorating emotional health.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A v A [2013] UKSC 60 Test for habitual residence focusing on the child's integration into social and family environment. Used to establish the legal framework and child-centric approach for determining habitual residence.
In re L (A Child) [2013] UKSC 75 Considerations in habitual residence and inherent jurisdiction. Supported the principles applied in assessing habitual residence in this case.
In re LC (Children) [2014] AC 1038 State of mind of the child in habitual residence determination. Referenced in the analysis of children's views and integration.
In re R (Children) [2015] UKSC 35 Habitual residence and child abduction principles. Guided the court’s approach to jurisdiction and habitual residence.
Re B (A Child) [2016] AC 606 Habitual residence as a factual question and child-centric test. Emphasized the importance of a factual and individual enquiry.
Re M (Children) [2020] EWCA Civ 1105 Clarification on the habitual residence test and caution regarding analogies. Used to temper the application of the "see-saw" analogy and focus on the child’s current situation.
Re I (A Child) [2009] UKSC 10 Jurisdiction under Brussels IIA and analogy to Hague Convention Article 7. Supported father's submission by analogy regarding retained jurisdiction.
Re S (A Child) [2018] EWCA Civ 1226 Summary return orders and parallel jurisdiction considerations. Referenced in discussion about parallel proceedings and enforcement issues.
Re N (A Child) [2020] 2 FLR 575 Risks of parallel litigation and conflicting orders. Considered in weighing the propriety of the father's application in England.
K v H [2021] EWHC 1918 (Fam) Undesirability of conflicting orders in different jurisdictions. Noted as relevant but distinguished on facts and jurisdictional basis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first identified the relevant date for determining jurisdiction as the date of issue of the father's English proceedings, 24 March 2021. The court applied a child-centric factual test for habitual residence, focusing on the children's integration into their social and family environment. It rejected the mother's argument that the relevant date was any hearing date and that the children had acquired habitual residence in Brazil by March 2021.

The court considered extensive evidence, including the children's schooling, social ties, possessions, and the parents' intentions. The elder child expressed a clear wish to return to England and maintained strong social and educational ties there. The younger child showed some adaptation to Brazil but had only recently started school there and lacked sufficient integration.

The court found that the children’s stay in Brazil was a prolonged extension of what was intended as a temporary family visit disrupted by Covid-19 restrictions and marital difficulties. The mother’s unilateral steps to initiate divorce and custody proceedings in Brazil without the father's knowledge did not establish a new habitual residence for the children. The family home, schools, social networks, and material ties remained in England.

The court acknowledged the ongoing interim orders in Brazil but respected the English court’s jurisdiction given the children’s habitual residence as of the relevant date. It found no clear case of wrongful removal or retention under the Hague Convention but did not need to decide this issue due to the established domestic jurisdiction.

The court rejected the mother's submission that the English court should decline jurisdiction on the basis of enforceability concerns or to avoid parallel proceedings. It recognized the risk of delay in Brazil and the father's need to return to work in England, especially given the elder child's psychological vulnerability.

Holding and Implications

The court held that, as of 24 March 2021, both children were habitually resident in England and Wales.

Accordingly, the court declared that it has jurisdiction to hear the father's application under the Children Act 1989 and will proceed to exercise that jurisdiction. The substantive welfare hearing remains scheduled for 13 and 14 September 2021. The court emphasized that this decision does not prejudge the outcome of the substantive welfare issues, which will be determined after full consideration.

The direct effect is that the father's application for the children's summary return to England will be heard and determined in England. The court expressly respects the interim orders made by the Brazilian courts and does not seek to undermine their authority but finds compelling reasons to assert jurisdiction in England given the children's habitual residence and welfare concerns.

No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing legal principles on habitual residence and jurisdiction in the context of international family law disputes.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

JC v PC

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

JC v PC
(Aug 9, 2021)