Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Director of Public Prosecutions v. Bussetti

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 14 June 2017, a fire disaster at a tall block of flats in West London resulted in the deaths of 71 residents. On 3 November 2018, the Defendant attended a bonfire night party at a friend's home with approximately thirty attendees. Among the effigies burned was a tall flammable structure depicting the tower involved in the disaster, with the word "Grenfell" at the top and six cut-out figures, including one alleged by the Crown to depict a person in a hijab.

The Defendant filmed the burning of this effigy on his mobile phone and sent the video to two WhatsApp groups with limited membership. The video subsequently spread on social media and attracted national media attention. The Defendant was interviewed by police, admitted filming and sending the video to WhatsApp groups, and was charged with sending a grossly offensive message via a public electronic communications network contrary to section 127(1) of the Communications Act 2003.

The trial before the Chief Magistrate spanned two days. The defence raised a preliminary issue on whether sending a message to a WhatsApp group constituted an offence under the statute, which the Chief Magistrate ruled affirmatively. The parties agreed on formal admissions regarding the Defendant's filming and sending of the video. The prosecution presented witness statements highlighting the trauma caused by the video to members of the affected community.

During the trial, it emerged that another individual had also filmed and posted a similar video, causing uncertainty as to whether the video shown in court was the one sent by the Defendant. The Chief Magistrate acquitted the Defendant, finding the prosecution had not discharged the burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt, particularly due to the inability to confirm the video’s provenance and content definitively.

The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) applied for a case stated for the opinion of the higher court. The Chief Magistrate provided a detailed case stating the factual and legal issues, including the evidential difficulties and the application of the test for gross offensiveness under section 127(1) of the Communications Act 2003.

The appeal was heard by the Administrative Court, which considered the Chief Magistrate's findings, the statutory framework, and relevant case law. The court ultimately allowed the appeal, quashed the acquittal, and remitted the case for retrial before a differently constituted court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the trial court erred in law in acquitting the Defendant on the basis that the prosecution could not prove that the video produced in evidence was the one sent by the Defendant, given the admitted sending of a video from the same event.
  2. Whether the trial court should have held that the video taken by the Defendant was similar in content to the video played in court.
  3. Whether the trial court was required to consider if the content of the Defendant's video was grossly offensive to members of the public or victims of the disaster.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The Defendant admitted filming and sending a video of the effigy burning to WhatsApp groups, and the video shown in court was substantially similar to the one sent.
  • The trial court erred in not giving sufficient weight to the admissions, interview summary, and the Defendant’s own evidence when assessing the similarity of the videos.
  • The offence under section 127(1) does not require the message to be racist; it requires only that the message be grossly offensive, and that the sender intended or was aware that it might be so.
  • The trial court should have considered whether the video content was grossly offensive to members of the public, including victims of the disaster.
  • The acquittal should be quashed and the case remitted for retrial before a differently constituted court.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Crown’s case was fundamentally based on racism as the basis for gross offensiveness, and the trial court properly allowed bad character evidence relevant to intention and awareness.
  • The trial court’s decision to acquit was justified because the prosecution could not prove the video shown in court was the one sent by the Defendant.
  • Even if the cut-out figures depicted the Defendant and his friends, this would constitute a bad taste joke rather than an offence.
  • Any appeal should be dismissed or, if allowed, no further order should be made given the passage of time and nature of the case.
  • The question of whether WhatsApp constitutes a public electronic communications network had not been argued before the appeal court and should be considered in the retrial.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Edwards v Bairstow [1956] AC 14 Standard for appellate review on questions of fact and law; whether a decision was reasonably open. Relied upon by the Appellant to argue the trial court's factual conclusion was not reasonably open.
Director of Public Prosecutions v Collins [2006] 1 WLR 2223 Interpretation of section 127(1)(a) Communications Act 2003; mens rea and gross offensiveness standard. Key authority defining the offence, mens rea requirement, and the test for gross offensiveness applied extensively in the appeal.
Sweet v Parsley [1970] AC 132 Presumption of mens rea where statute is silent; importance of culpable state of mind. Quoted to support the requirement of intention or awareness of gross offensiveness in the offence.
DPP v Kingsley Smith [2017] EWHC 359 (Admin) Mens rea for sending grossly offensive messages under section 127(1)(a). Summarised the requisite mental element: intention or awareness of gross offensiveness.
Chambers v DPP [2013] 1 WLR 1833 Mens rea and assessment of menacing character under section 127(1)(a). Used to illustrate that messages intended as jokes in bad taste may lack the necessary mens rea for conviction.
Alekhina v Russia (2019) 68 EHRR 14 Article 10 ECHR protections and limits regarding offensive speech. Referenced regarding the balance between freedom of expression and offensiveness, particularly concerning racist discourse.
Narinder Malcolm v DPP [2007] EWHC 363 (Admin) Prosecution’s power to seek adjournment to remedy evidential deficiencies. Noted in the case stated regarding the prosecution’s failure to apply for an adjournment after evidential gaps emerged.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court reviewed the evidential record, including formal admissions, the Defendant’s interview, and the video footage. It found that the trial court’s conclusion that it was not sure the video shown in court was the one sent by the Defendant was not reasonably open, given the Defendant’s admission and recognition of the video as his own recording. The court emphasized that the offence under section 127(1)(a) requires that the sender intended or was aware that the message might be grossly offensive, but does not require any racial element.

The court noted that the trial court had not sufficiently addressed the significance of the Defendant’s admissions and the agreed interview summary. It also found that minor differences in video length or audio quality were immaterial to the question of similarity in content. The court held that the trial court was required to consider whether the content of the Defendant’s video was grossly offensive to members of the public, including victims of the disaster.

Applying the principles from the leading case law, especially DPP v Collins, the court reiterated that the offence is complete upon sending a grossly offensive message via a public electronic communications network, regardless of whether the message is actually received or the reaction of the recipients. The court also recognized the importance of applying the standards of an open and just multi-racial society in assessing gross offensiveness.

Given the serious distress caused to members of the affected community and the admitted sending of the video, the court found that the trial court erred in law in acquitting the Defendant without properly considering these factors. However, the court declined to direct a conviction, preferring to remit the case for retrial before a differently constituted court, citing the complexity and the need for further argument on whether WhatsApp qualifies as a public electronic communications network.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed.

The acquittal is quashed.

The case is remitted to Westminster Magistrates' Court for retrial before a differently constituted court. The Defendant is ordered to pay the Appellant's costs in the sum of £6,095 within 28 days.

This decision overturns the previous acquittal and allows the prosecution to retry the Defendant on the original charge. No new legal precedent was established beyond the application and clarification of existing principles regarding the offence under section 127(1) of the Communications Act 2003 and the evidential standards required for conviction.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Director of Public Prosecutions v Bussetti

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Director of Public Prosecutions v Bussetti
(Jul 30, 2021)