Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff, a high-profile lesbian radical feminist, journalist, author, and broadcaster, brought a defamation claim against the First Defendant, the publisher of a website referred to as Company A, and the Second Defendant, the Chief Executive of Company A. On 17 May 2020, Company A published an article alleging that the "gender critical" feminist movement is a cult that grooms, controls, and abuses, as recounted by a lesbian who escaped it. The Plaintiff was not named in the article but contended that some readers would identify her. The Plaintiff alleged that the article defamed her both in its natural and ordinary meaning and by innuendo.
The Claim Form was issued on 29 July 2020, with Particulars of Claim following on 13 August 2020 and amended by consent on 10 December 2020. The Defendants had not filed a Defence but sought to postpone doing so while exploring the possibility of a trial of preliminary issues concerning meaning, reference, and whether the article was defamatory. This delay resulted in the Court only being able to case manage the matter after approximately nine months, by which time significant costs had been incurred.
In September 2020, the Defendants proposed a trial of preliminary issues on meaning, reference, whether the words were fact or opinion, and whether the meanings were defamatory, suggesting the use of "deemed facts" to resolve factual disputes. The Plaintiff opposed this proposal, particularly objecting to the exclusion of serious harm as a preliminary issue and the Defendants’ selective use of "deemed facts".
In December 2020, instead of filing a Defence, the Defendants provided a comprehensive Statement of Case on reference and meaning to preserve their ability to make an offer of amends under the Defamation Act 1996, which cannot be made after filing a Defence. This Statement denied that the words referred to the Plaintiff or were defamatory and denied serious harm. The Plaintiff’s solicitors remained unconvinced that a trial of preliminary issues was appropriate due to the complexity and factual disputes involved.
In January 2021, the Defendants issued an Application Notice seeking a trial of the preliminary issues, supported by a witness statement confirming that if the Plaintiff succeeded, the Defendants would not substantively defend the claim, implying an intention to make an offer of amends. The Plaintiff initially sought clarification and later agreed to the proposed trial of preliminary issues. However, the Court refused to direct such a trial without a hearing to consider whether it was appropriate.
The hearing took place on 26 May 2021. Both parties supported the trial of preliminary issues, but the Court raised concerns about the costs, delay, and uncertainty involved. The Defendants sought a discount on damages for any offer of amends made after the trial, while the Plaintiff withdrew support for the application, arguing that the offer of amends regime did not envisage a trial preceding an offer. The Court carefully considered the offer of amends regime and the principles governing trials of preliminary issues in defamation claims before refusing the application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Under what circumstances should the Court order a trial of preliminary issues in a defamation claim?
- How does the offer of amends regime under the Defamation Act 1996 interact with the timing and scope of preliminary issue trials?
- Whether the proposed preliminary issues, involving complex factual disputes, are suitable for determination before service of a Defence.
- What are the proper case management principles guiding the Court's discretion to order preliminary issue trials in defamation litigation?
Arguments of the Parties
Defendants' Arguments
- The Defendants sought a trial of preliminary issues on meaning, reference, whether the words were fact or opinion, and whether the meanings were defamatory, proposing the use of "deemed facts" to resolve factual disputes.
- They contended that resolving these issues in their favour would likely lead to dismissal of the claim, but if resolved against them, they would consider making an offer of amends to dispose of the claim.
- They argued that the offer of amends regime provides an important "exit route" for defendants and protects their Article 10 rights, and the Court should be slow to limit its availability.
- They submitted that a defendant has an entitlement to have "threshold issues" determined by way of preliminary issues prior to filing a Defence to preserve the offer of amends option.
- The Defendants indicated they would seek a discount on damages of up to 30% to reflect the mitigating effect of an offer of amends.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The Plaintiff opposed the proposed trial of preliminary issues, arguing that the issues were too complex and factually disputed to be suitable for such a trial.
- The Plaintiff’s solicitors criticized the Defendants’ use of "deemed facts" as selectively picking from the Plaintiff’s case.
- The Plaintiff emphasized that serious harm was not included as a preliminary issue, which risked overlapping evidence and witness testimony in subsequent trials.
- At the hearing, the Plaintiff withdrew support for the trial of preliminary issues, submitting that the offer of amends regime did not envisage a trial before an offer and that the Defendants sought to preserve an option not available under the regime.
- The Plaintiff argued that any discount for an offer of amends should be minimal or none, due to the Defendants’ vigorous challenges to the claim.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Abu -v- MGN Ltd [2003] 1 WLR 2201 |
Background and purpose of the offer of amends regime under the Defamation Act 1996. |
Used to explain the regime’s intent as a fair exit route for defendants in libel actions. |
| Milne -v- Express Newspapers [2003] 1 WLR 927 |
Offer of amends regime provides an "exit route" for defendants acknowledging error. |
Supported the understanding of the regime’s conciliatory and procedural purpose. |
| Thornton -v- Telegraph Media Group [2012] EMLR 8 |
Rare instance of a claimant successfully proving statutory malice in an offer of amends case. |
Illustrated the difficulty for claimants in overcoming the statutory defence under s.4. |
| Warren -v- The Random House Group Ltd [2009] QB 600 |
Purpose of offer of amends as a streamlined procedure and an exit route for defendants. |
Emphasized the importance of the regime in reducing delay and expense. |
| KC -v- MGN Ltd [2013] 2 Costs LR 269 |
Offer of amends regime facilitates vindication without litigation and reduces delay and expense. |
Reinforced the regime’s role in balancing claimant vindication and defendant protection. |
| Tesco Stores Ltd -v- Guardian News & Media Ltd [2009] EMLR 5 |
Claimants cannot indefinitely hold off accepting an offer of amends; malice must be proven to overcome statutory defence. |
Clarified the statutory scheme’s disciplinary purpose and the limits on claimants’ conduct. |
| Brown -v- Bower [2017] 1 WLR 4703 |
Offer of amends regime’s primary purpose is swift settlement before litigation; not a fallback after preliminary issues trial. |
Supported refusal to allow trial of preliminary issues as a prerequisite to an offer of amends. |
| Bokova -v- Associated Newspapers Ltd [2019] QB 861 |
Early determination of natural and ordinary meaning in defamation cases is usually efficient and cost-effective. |
Supported the Court’s preference for early resolution of meaning issues without extensive evidence. |
| Morgan -v- Associated Newspapers Ltd [2018] EWHC 1850 |
Early resolution of preliminary issues before Defence is generally beneficial and cost-effective. |
Confirmed the Court’s case management approach favoring early determination of such issues. |
| Steele -v- Steele [2001] CP Rep 106 |
Cost/benefit analysis and factors to consider before ordering trial of preliminary issues. |
Guided the Court’s cautious approach to ordering preliminary issue trials involving factual disputes. |
| Rossetti Marketing Ltd -v- Diamond Sofa Co Ltd [2013] Bus LR 543 |
Warning against the "siren’s song" of preliminary issues, which should normally be resisted. |
Supported the Court’s skepticism of ordering complex preliminary issue trials. |
| Tilling -v- Whiteman [1980] AC 1 |
Preliminary points of law can be "treacherous short cuts" and require caution. |
Reinforced the principle that preliminary issues involving factual disputes are particularly problematic. |
| Hope Not Hate -v- Farage [2017] EWHC 3275 |
Trials of preliminary issues usually limited to those resolvable without disputed witness evidence. |
Supported the Court’s practice of limiting preliminary issues in defamation to narrow factual scopes. |
| McLoughlin -v- Grovers [2002] QB 1312 |
Criteria for ordering trial of preliminary issues: decisiveness, legal questions, agreed facts, prompt trial, and court case management. |
Provided a framework applied by the Court to assess suitability of preliminary issues. |
| Junejo -v- New Vision TV Limited |
Exception to general rule allowing trial of preliminary issues involving disputed facts. |
Noted as a rare example, emphasizing that such cases require clear justification. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by examining the offer of amends regime under the Defamation Act 1996, which was designed to provide defendants with a fair and reasonable exit route from libel claims by admitting liability and making amends early, thereby reducing delay and expense. The regime was not intended to be used after a defendant had contested liability through preliminary issue trials. The Court noted that the regime’s effectiveness had increased following the abolition of jury trials in defamation cases, allowing early determination of meaning and related issues without extensive evidence or witnesses.
The Court then considered the principles governing the trial of preliminary issues. It emphasized that preliminary issues should generally be limited to those that can be decided without significant factual disputes, ideally on questions of law or agreed facts, and that are decisive or potentially decisive. The Court expressed caution about ordering trials of preliminary issues that require disclosure, witness statements, and cross-examination, as such trials risk complexity, delay, and cost, potentially exceeding the benefits.
In this case, the proposed preliminary issues were factually complicated, would require a three-day trial with witness evidence, and did not meet the established criteria for preliminary issue trials. The Court was not convinced that the benefits of such a trial would outweigh the costs and delay, especially given the uncertainty about the scope of further litigation after the preliminary issues and the possibility of appeals on disputed legal questions.
The Court rejected the Defendants’ argument that they had an entitlement to have "threshold issues" determined by preliminary issues before filing a Defence to preserve the offer of amends option. The Court held that no such entitlement exists and that the decision to order preliminary issues lies within the Court’s discretion guided by the overriding objective and case management principles. The Defendants must choose between filing a Defence or making an offer of amends; they cannot preserve both options simultaneously through preliminary issue trials.
The Court also expressed concern about the economic inefficiency of the Defendants’ approach, noting that the costs incurred to preserve a discount on damages through a preliminary issue trial likely exceed any potential savings. Furthermore, the Court highlighted that the Defendants’ vigorous contesting of the claim on several grounds undermines the rationale for a substantial discount under the offer of amends regime.
Finally, the Court addressed a procedural issue regarding the Plaintiff’s Amended Particulars of Claim, noting that the pleading of multiple meanings by way of natural and ordinary meaning and innuendo was unclear and suggested that the Plaintiff should amend the Particulars to clearly separate these claims before the Defence is served.
Holding and Implications
The Court REFUSED to direct a trial of the preliminary issues proposed by the parties.
The direct consequence is that the Defendants must decide whether to file a Defence disputing liability on the full merits or to make an offer of amends without the benefit of a preliminary issues trial. The Court’s refusal preserves the established procedural balance and prevents the creation of a two-stage trial process that would increase complexity, costs, and delay in defamation litigation.
No new precedent was established; rather, the Court reaffirmed existing principles governing the offer of amends regime and the trial of preliminary issues, emphasizing careful case management and the avoidance of procedural shortcuts that risk inefficiency and injustice.