Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Director of Public Prosecutions v. M

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an appeal by way of case stated pursuant to section 111 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980 and section 28A of the Senior Courts Act 1981. The Director of Public Prosecutions (Appellant) appeals against the decision of District Judge (Magistrates' Court) Holdham sitting at Wimbledon Youth Court on 4 December 2019 to acquit the Respondent, a 15-year-old boy referred to as M, of charges including possession of a bladed article and possession of Class A drugs (heroin and cocaine). The acquittal was based on the statutory defence in section 45(4) of the Modern Slavery Act 2015 ("the 2015 Act").

On 16 May 2019, M was found in possession of drugs and a hunting knife while in the company of two other 15-year-old males, MP and KM, known to police as gang members and habitual knife carriers. M was arrested and initially gave implausible explanations for possessing the knife but made no comment during police interview. Evidence at trial included police officers’ testimony and an agreed set of facts, including that M had no previous convictions, was regularly missing from home, and had been referred to the National Referral Mechanism (NRM) by social care. The Single Competent Authority (SCA) made a positive conclusive grounds decision that M was a victim of modern slavery and criminal exploitation.

The District Judge considered all evidence, including the SCA decision, and concluded that M had been exploited and that his possession of the knife and drugs was a direct consequence of that exploitation. The prosecution appealed the acquittal, challenging the admissibility and weight of the SCA decision and whether M had discharged the evidential burden under the statutory defence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Respondent (M) discharged the evidential burden required to raise the statutory defence under section 45(4)(b) and (c) of the Modern Slavery Act 2015, specifically:
    • Whether M's offending was a direct consequence of being a victim of slavery or relevant exploitation;
    • Whether a reasonable person with M's relevant characteristics in the same situation would have committed the offence.
  2. Whether the conclusive grounds decision of the Single Competent Authority (SCA) is admissible evidence in criminal proceedings for the purposes of the statutory defence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The District Judge erred in admitting and relying on the SCA decision, which was non-expert opinion evidence and hearsay, lacking proper evidential foundation and not compliant with evidentiary rules.
  • The SCA decision was inadmissible at trial because it was produced by a Home Office employee who was not an expert witness and was based on untested, equivocal facts.
  • The evidential burden on M to establish the statutory defence was not met, especially given the seriousness of the offences involving dangerous drugs and a knife in a public place.
  • The prosecution contended that the statutory defence requires a higher evidential threshold in cases of serious criminality and that M did not provide evidence or explanation to support the defence.
  • The prosecution did not accept the SCA decision as determinative and argued that the criminal acts were not shown to be a direct consequence of exploitation nor that a reasonable person in M’s position would have committed the acts.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The District Judge's conclusion that M discharged the evidential burden was justified based on the circumstantial evidence and agreed facts, including M’s vulnerability, lack of prior convictions, and association with known gang members carrying out criminal activities.
  • There was no requirement for M to give evidence or provide an explanation in interview to raise the statutory defence.
  • The prosecution was able to challenge the nexus between exploitation and offending, but failed to disprove the defence.
  • The admissibility of the SCA decision was not in issue on appeal as it was admitted as an agreed fact under section 10 of the Criminal Justice Act 1967, and even if considered, the judge relied on it as one factor among others.
  • Alternatively, if admissibility was in question, the SCA decision was admissible as expert evidence given the SCA’s expertise and multi-agency information sources, and excluding it would cause unnecessary delays and resource burdens.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R v Joseph and others [2017] EWCA Crim 36 Competent Authority conclusive grounds decision is not binding but courts will generally abide by it absent contradictory or significant unconsidered evidence. District Judge relied on this principle to give weight to the SCA decision unless contradicted by evidence.
R v L(C) [2013] 2 Cr App R 23 Similar principle on the status of conclusive grounds decisions and their evidential weight in abuse of process applications. Referenced to support the approach to the SCA decision’s evidential status.
R v S(G) [2018] EWCA Crim 1828 Admissibility of conclusive grounds decisions as fresh evidence on appeal; unlikely admissible at trial; prosecutorial admissions may resolve evidential issues. Used to explain the uncertain admissibility of SCA decisions at trial and the evidential context.
R v N [2019] EWCA Crim 984 Conclusive grounds decision admissible on appeal to support statutory defence under section 45(1) for adults; no dispute that defendant was a victim. Illustrated admissibility in appeal context; no trial admissibility issue needed to be resolved.
R v DS [2020] EWCA Crim 285 Responsibility for deciding victim status under statutory defence lies with jury; abuse of process jurisdiction no longer fills this gap; admissibility of SCA decision at trial unresolved. Clarified that statutory defence fact-finding is for the jury; admissibility question left open.
MS (Pakistan) v Secretary of State for Home Department [2020] UKSC 9 Tribunals not bound by NRM conclusive grounds decisions; better placed to decide victim status; decision is factual but not determinative. Confirmed that conclusive grounds decisions are not binding but relevant factual determinations.
B v Merton Borough Council [2003] 4 All ER 480 Framework for admissibility of Merton compliant age assessments by trained social workers as evidence in court. Used as an analogy to consider admissibility of SCA decisions as expert evidence.
Bradshaw (1986) 82 Cr App R 79 Expert opinion based entirely on hearsay unsupported by direct evidence may be weak but is not inadmissible. Supported admission of SCA decision despite reliance on hearsay, with weight for the fact-finder to assess.
Brennan [2015] 1 WLR 2060 Expert evidence may be admitted even if based partly on hearsay from a witness who could testify. Reinforced that expert evidence based on hearsay is admissible and can support a defence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first addressed the admissibility of the SCA conclusive grounds decision. It rejected the Appellant’s argument that the decision was inadmissible non-expert opinion evidence. The court held that the SCA is an expert case-working unit staffed by trained officials with access to multi-agency information, and its decision on trafficking and exploitation issues is expert evidence. Although the SCA decision maker does not prepare the decision for trial use, the decision is relevant and probative evidence that the defendant was a victim of exploitation. The weight to be given to the decision is a matter for the fact-finder, not a question of admissibility.

The court noted the ambiguity in the admission of the SCA decision under section 10 of the Criminal Justice Act 1967 but concluded that the decision was properly admitted as evidence that M was trafficked and exploited.

Regarding the evidential burden under section 45(4) of the 2015 Act, the court found that M had discharged it. The evidence showed that M was a vulnerable missing child with no prior convictions, found in the company of known gang members with criminal histories, in possession of items (knife and drugs) that the gang members did not have. This gave rise to an inference that M’s offending was a direct consequence of exploitation. The prosecution failed to disprove this inference.

The court rejected the Appellant’s contention that the evidential burden was not met due to the seriousness of the offences, emphasizing that for a child under 18 the statutory defence applies differently than for adults, with less emphasis on compulsion and more on characteristics such as age and vulnerability.

The court also found that the District Judge properly considered whether a reasonable person of M’s age and characteristics would have committed the acts, taking into account all evidence, and was entitled to conclude that the evidential burden was satisfied.

The court declined to decide on the admissibility of the SCA decision as definitive expert evidence but held that it was admissible and that the District Judge was entitled to rely on it alongside other evidence in reaching her decision.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision is to UPHOLD the District Judge’s ruling that the Respondent (M) discharged the evidential burden under section 45(4) of the Modern Slavery Act 2015 and that the prosecution failed to disprove the statutory defence. Consequently, the acquittal stands.

The direct effect of this decision is to confirm that a young person who is a victim of modern slavery and exploitation may successfully raise the statutory defence without giving evidence or providing explanation at trial, relying on circumstantial evidence and the conclusive grounds decision of the SCA as admissible expert evidence. The court’s analysis clarifies the evidential framework for applying the statutory defence under section 45(4) and confirms the admissibility and probative value of SCA decisions in criminal proceedings.

No new precedent was established beyond the considered application of existing case law and statutory provisions. The court also granted an order for indefinite anonymity of the Respondent in the interests of justice and to protect his privacy given his vulnerability and age.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Director of Public Prosecutions v M

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Director of Public Prosecutions v M
(Dec 15, 2020)