Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Mears Ltd v. Costplan Services (South East) Ltd & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The third respondent ("Pickstock") was engaged by the second respondent ("PNSL") under a building contract dated 27 May 2016 to design and build two blocks of student accommodation at a property in The City. Pursuant to an Agreement for Lease ("AFL") dated 20 May 2016, the appellant ("Mears"), a company providing managed student accommodation, contracted with PNSL to take a long lease of the property following completion.

The AFL prohibited PNSL from making variations to the building works that materially affected the size of the rooms, with a reduction of more than 3% deemed material. The court found that some rooms were more than 3% smaller than specified, affecting 56 rooms. Mears contended that any failure to meet the 3% tolerance was a material and substantial breach allowing them to determine the AFL and preventing certification of practical completion. Waksman J rejected these claims in a judgment dated 7 December 2018, refusing Declarations 1-4 but granting Declaration 5 that breaches had occurred. Mears appealed the refusal of Declarations 1-4.

The appeal concerned the construction of the AFL and the circumstances under which practical completion could be certified, noting that the declarations sought were largely theoretical and not tied to the factual dispute over specific performance claims between the parties.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether any failure to construct rooms within the 3% size tolerance set out in clause 6.2.1 of the AFL automatically constituted a material and substantial breach of contract entitling Mears to determine the AFL and preventing certification of practical completion.
  2. Whether the Employer's Agent can validly certify practical completion while there are known material or substantial defects or breaches of the AFL.
  3. Whether irremediable breaches necessarily prevent certification of practical completion.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Mears argued that clause 6.2.1 of the AFL established a contractual red line such that any failure to meet the 3% room size tolerance was automatically a material breach of contract.
  • They submitted that such a breach entitled Mears to treat themselves as discharged from the AFL and prevented valid certification of practical completion.
  • It was further argued that if this interpretation was incorrect, PNSL would be benefiting from their own breach, contrary to the principle in Alghussein v Eton College [1988] 1 WLR 587.
  • On the issue of practical completion, Mears contended that the Employer's Agent was bound by clause 6.2.1 and could not certify practical completion if the 3% tolerance was breached, regardless of whether the breaches were trifling or irremediable.
  • They argued that irremediable breaches should prevent practical completion as a matter of law.

Respondent's Arguments

  • PNSL contended that clause 6.2.1 deemed materiality only to the reduction in room size, not to the character or materiality of the breach of contract itself.
  • They argued that not every breach beyond the 3% tolerance was automatically material or substantial; materiality was a question of fact and degree.
  • Clause 6.2.3’s inclusion of “or” indicated that a material reduction in size may not amount to a material breach, justifying separate treatment.
  • Clause 15.7 of the AFL assumed practical completion could occur despite breaches or outstanding works, supporting that defects do not necessarily prevent certification.
  • Regarding the Alghussein principle, PNSL denied relying on their own breaches to gain advantage, so the principle did not apply.
  • On practical completion, PNSL argued it was a matter of fact and degree for the certifier, focused on whether the works were fit for their intended purpose rather than absolute compliance with the 3% tolerance.
  • They submitted that whether defects were remediable was irrelevant; what mattered was whether outstanding works were trifling.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alghussein v Eton College [1988] 1 WLR 587 Principle that a party cannot benefit from its own breach of contract. The court found this principle did not apply as PNSL were not relying on their breaches to gain advantage.
Bolton v Mahdeva [1971] 2 WLR 1009 Practical completion can be prevented by patent defects affecting the quality of work. The court cited this to affirm that practical completion depends on quality and extent of defects, not just completion of work.
Jarvis & Sons Limited v Westminster Corporation & Another [1969] 1 WLR 1448 Practical completion means completion for all practical purposes allowing use as intended; not absolute perfection. The court summarized the law on practical completion with reference to this leading authority.
Kaye v Hosier & Dickinson [1972] 1 WLR 146 Practical completion involves absence of patent defects in materials or workmanship. Used to illustrate stricter test of practical completion involving patent defects.
H.W. Nevill (Sunblest) Limited v William Press & Son Limited (1981) 20 BLR 78 Architect’s discretion to certify practical completion despite minor de minimis work outstanding; patent defects prevent certification. Cited to support practical approach to practical completion and the role of certifier’s discretion.
Emson Eastern Limited (in receivership) v E.M.E. Developments Limited (1991) 55 BLR 114 Recognizes practical difficulties of perfection in construction contracts; supports a balanced approach to practical completion. Reinforced the court’s balanced approach between absolute perfection and practical completion.
Walter Lilley & Co. Limited v Mackay & Another (No. 2) [2012] EWHC 1773 (TCC) Applied practical approach to practical completion balancing patent defects and minor outstanding works. Supported the court’s approach to practical completion as a matter of fact and degree.
Mariner International Hotels Limited & Another v Atlas Limited & Another [2007] 10 HKCFAR 1 Practical completion means completion free from patent defects except those trifling enough to be ignored. The court cited this to emphasize the importance of fitness for purpose and the role of patent defects in practical completion.
Menolly Investments 3 SARL v Cereps SARL [2009] EWHC 516 (Ch) Illustrates fact-sensitive nature of practical completion and importance of the scale of defects. Used to highlight that practical completion depends on the significance of defects relative to the contract.
Bovis Lend Lease Ltd v Saillard Fuller & Partners (2001) 77 Con LR 134 Practical completion can be achieved despite some defects if the works are substantially complete and allow possession. The court expressed caution about relying on this authority as a full statement of law but acknowledged its relevance.
Ruxley Electronics & Construction Limited v Forsyth [1996] 1 AC 344 Addresses measurement of loss for defects and confirms practical completion does not require perfection. Referenced to confirm that irremediable defects do not necessarily prevent practical completion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed clause 6.2.1 of the AFL and distinguished between the materiality of the variation in room size and the materiality of the resulting breach of contract. It held that the clause deemed a reduction in room size of more than 3% to be material as to the variation itself, but did not automatically render any breach material or substantial in legal effect. Materiality of breach is a question of fact and degree, not a contractual deeming provision.

The court rejected Mears' argument that any breach beyond the 3% tolerance automatically entitled them to terminate the AFL or prevented certification of practical completion, finding such a construction commercially absurd and unsupported by clear contractual language.

Regarding practical completion, the court confirmed established legal principles that practical completion is a flexible concept involving completion for all practical purposes, allowing the employer to take possession and use the works as intended. Patent defects can prevent practical completion unless they are trifling. The certifier has a professional discretion to determine practical completion, considering the nature and extent of defects and the intended purpose of the building.

The court further held that the irremediable nature of defects is irrelevant to practical completion: whether a defect can be economically remedied does not determine if it prevents practical completion. Instead, the question is whether the defect is trifling or substantial.

The court found that Mears’ declarations 1-4 were drafted in overly broad terms and were not tied to the factual circumstances, making them inappropriate for grant. The factual assessment of whether breaches were material or substantial, and whether they prevented practical completion, remained open for determination outside this appeal.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal against Waksman J’s refusal to grant Declarations 1-4.

The holding clarified that clause 6.2.1 of the AFL does not automatically deem any breach of the 3% room size tolerance to be material or substantial such as to permit termination or prevent practical completion. Materiality of breaches is a matter of fact and degree. Practical completion is a flexible, fact-sensitive concept, and the existence of patent defects or breaches does not preclude certification if they are trifling, regardless of whether they are economically remediable.

The decision leaves open the factual question of whether the breaches identified justify termination or prevention of practical completion, and does not establish new precedent beyond the interpretation of the AFL clauses in this case. The ruling therefore primarily affects the parties’ contractual rights and obligations in this dispute without broader legal innovation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Mears Ltd v Costplan Services (South East) Ltd & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Mears Ltd v Costplan Services (South East) Ltd & Ors
(Mar 29, 2019)