Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)

Edwards v. Ashik

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant, Plaintiff, appeals an order made by Her Honour Judge Faber at the Central London County Court on 23 January 2014. The order arose from a trial of preliminary issues concerning liability in a claim for rescission of a lease, mortgage, and sale agreement (collectively "the Contract") dated 8 November 2010. The Contract related to the sale of a nightclub business operating from certain premises in The City, with the Defendant as the vendor and Plaintiff as the purchaser. The claim alleged fraudulent misrepresentations made in replies to pre-contract enquiries ("the Replies") concerning the Premises and business. Plaintiff completed the purchase and occupied the Premises pursuant to the Lease.

The preliminary issues directed for trial were:

  1. Whether there were actionable misrepresentations as pleaded;
  2. Whether Plaintiff was induced by and relied upon any misrepresentations in entering into the Contract;
  3. Whether Plaintiff lost any right to rely on the misrepresentations, including by affirmation;
  4. The legal effect of any actionable misrepresentation in light of findings on the above issues.

The Defendant pleaded affirmation by continuing to trade from the Premises with knowledge of the right to rescind.

The trial judge found that Defendant made fraudulent misrepresentations in the Replies, deliberately concealing known complaints and recommendations by the local authority relating to the Premises. Defendant did not appeal these findings.

The judge then considered whether Plaintiff was induced by the misrepresentations, applying the presumption that Plaintiff was influenced by the fraudulent statements and placing the burden on Defendant to rebut this presumption. The judge identified as critical the hypothetical question of whether Plaintiff would have proceeded with the purchase had he been told the truth about the complaints. The judge found on the balance of probabilities that Plaintiff would have proceeded regardless, concluding the Replies played no part in Plaintiff’s decision.

Accordingly, the judge held that Plaintiff lost the right to rescind by affirming the Contract through continued use of the Premises. Plaintiff appealed the findings on inducement and affirmation with permission granted.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the judge erred in treating inducement as dependent on what Plaintiff would have done if told the truth about the complaints;
  2. Whether Plaintiff was in fact induced by Defendant's fraudulent misrepresentations;
  3. Whether Plaintiff lost the right to rescind by affirming the Contract through continued use of the Premises;
  4. The legal effect of any actionable misrepresentation (not addressed by the trial judge).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The judge misdirected herself by focusing on the hypothetical "what if" scenario rather than on whether there was positive evidence that Plaintiff was not materially induced by the misrepresentations.
  • Given the presumption of inducement arising from fraudulent misrepresentation and clause 10.3 of the Contract, the dishonest replies were a material cause of Plaintiff entering into the Contract.
  • The judge was wrong to hold that Plaintiff’s continued use of the Premises amounted to unequivocal affirmation of the Contract, especially given contemporaneous correspondence alleging fraud and threatening legal proceedings.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Plaintiff had no knowledge of the Replies and thus could not have been induced by them.
  • The judge should not have allowed Plaintiff to rely on inducement via solicitor’s advice, as this was not pleaded.
  • Defendant disproved inducement by admissions made by Plaintiff during cross-examination.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dadourian Group International Inc v Simms [2009] EWCA Civ 169 Presumption of inducement arising from fraudulent misrepresentation and burden of proof shifting to representor to rebut presumption. The court confirmed the presumption applied and that Defendant bore the burden to prove the misrepresentation did not play a real and substantial part in Plaintiff’s decision.
Barton v County Nat West Limited [1999] Lloyds Rep. Banking 408 Clarification on the nature of the presumption of inducement and how it may be rebutted; the presumption alters the burden of proof but remains unless rebutted. The court relied on this analysis to reject the judge’s approach focusing solely on the hypothetical "what if" question and emphasized the need for positive evidence to rebut inducement.
Downs v Chappell [1997] 1 WLR 426 In fraudulent misrepresentation claims, the representee need only prove reliance on the misrepresentation to establish deceit; hypothetical questions of whether they would have proceeded if told the truth are irrelevant. The court noted this case supports the Appellant’s position on inducement but distinguished it as relating to the plaintiff’s burden rather than the representor’s rebuttal burden.
Strover v Harrington [1988] Ch 390 Knowledge of a party’s solicitor is imputed to the party in conveyancing transactions. The court applied this principle to impute the solicitor’s knowledge of the Replies to Plaintiff, rejecting the argument that Plaintiff’s lack of direct knowledge negated inducement.
Peyman v Lanjani [1985] Ch 457 Test for affirmation: whether there was an unequivocal act demonstrating election to affirm a contract. The court applied this test and found the trial judge erred in concluding continued use of the Premises amounted to unequivocal affirmation given ongoing correspondence indicating intent to rescind.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by affirming the trial judge’s finding of fraudulent misrepresentation and the resulting presumption of inducement, placing the burden on Defendant to rebut. The judge’s approach focused on a hypothetical inquiry into whether Plaintiff would have proceeded if told the truth, concluding Plaintiff would have proceeded regardless, thus rebutting inducement. The court found this focus misplaced.

Drawing on Barton v County Nat West Limited, the court explained that the presumption is one of fact and shifts the burden of proof to the representor, who must produce positive evidence that the representee was not materially induced. A mere hypothetical finding that the representee would have acted the same way is insufficient to rebut inducement without positive evidence that the representee was not influenced by the misrepresentation.

The court rejected Defendant’s argument that Plaintiff’s lack of direct knowledge of the Replies negated inducement, holding that knowledge of Plaintiff’s solicitor is imputed to Plaintiff. The solicitor’s communication to Plaintiff that "it was okay to proceed" effectively conveyed the effect of the Replies, and Plaintiff’s reliance on his solicitor was presumed.

Regarding Plaintiff’s admissions in cross-examination, the court found they did not amount to a clear and unqualified admission that Plaintiff did not rely on the solicitor’s advice. The court emphasized that a misrepresentation can induce a passive reliance, such as proceeding with a purchase without independent investigation, which was consistent with Plaintiff’s evidence.

On the affirmation issue, the court considered whether Plaintiff’s continued use of the Premises after knowledge of the right to rescind constituted an unequivocal election to affirm. Although continued use alone might ordinarily amount to affirmation, the court held that the contemporaneous correspondence from Plaintiff’s solicitors alleging fraud and threatening proceedings rendered the continued use equivocal. The objective effect was that Plaintiff was reserving his right to rescind, not affirming the Contract.

The court noted the trial judge did not provide reasons for her conclusion on affirmation and that the primary facts were undisputed. The court found that the judge erred in concluding that continued business use amounted to unequivocal affirmation.

Because the trial judge did not address the fourth preliminary issue on the legal effect of any actionable misrepresentation, the court noted this issue remains to be determined at trial or by agreement.

Holding and Implications

The court allowed Plaintiff’s appeal on the issues of inducement and affirmation. The core rulings are:

  • The presumption of inducement arising from Defendant’s fraudulent misrepresentations was not rebutted.
  • Plaintiff did not lose the right to rescind the Contract by affirmation through continued use of the Premises, given the equivocal nature of that use in the context of ongoing fraud allegations and correspondence.

As a result, Plaintiff’s fraudulent misrepresentations were a material inducement to enter into the Contract, and Plaintiff retained the right to elect rescission, which was validly exercised by letter dated 27 March 2012.

No new precedent was established; the decision clarifies the application of existing principles concerning inducement, burden of proof, and affirmation in the context of fraudulent misrepresentation claims. The unresolved issue concerning the legal effect of any actionable misrepresentation will require further determination.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Edwards v Ashik

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Edwards v Ashik
(Jul 24, 2014)