Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

London College of Business Ltd v. Tareem Ltd & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, a college of further and higher education, has occupied office premises at Monteagle Court, Barking, Essex since 2006. The premises were owned by the first Defendant, Company A, and managed for much of the period by the second Defendant, Company B, now dissolved. The Plaintiff's principal is Doctor A. The Plaintiff previously offered validated degrees but following allegations of immigration rule breaches in 2012, lost its validation and suffered suspensions of its licence to sponsor overseas students, limiting its course offerings since 2014.

The Plaintiff's occupation was governed by a series of agreements purporting to create a licence, though there was dispute as to whether the relationship was that of licensor-licensee or landlord-tenant. In 2014, a dispute arose over payments due, culminating in Company A changing the locks on the premises, excluding the Plaintiff for three days. The Plaintiff obtained an injunction to regain access and claimed damages for wrongful exclusion, initially valuing the claim near £1,000,000 but later reducing it to £189,415 based on expert evidence.

The issues include the nature of the Plaintiff's occupation, the legality of Company A's resumption of possession, the financial accounts between the parties, and potential damages for the lockout.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Plaintiff's occupation of the premises constituted a licence or a tenancy.
  2. If a tenancy, whether Company A was entitled to forfeit the tenancy by peaceable re-entry in September 2014.
  3. The proper state of account between the parties as at the date of the lockout and subsequently.
  4. The quantum and basis of damages, if any, recoverable by the Plaintiff for wrongful exclusion.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The 2012 Agreement and preceding agreements expressly created a licence, not a tenancy.
  • The express wording of the agreements, including provisions for management control and rights of entry, supported a licence relationship.
  • There was flexibility in occupation of different units and no repairing obligations, indicating a licence.
  • Company A relied on clause 10 of the 2012 Agreement, which provided for termination on 14 days' notice for non-payment of licence fees, to justify re-entry.
  • The Plaintiff was in arrears of licence fees and service charges, entitling Company A to retake possession.
  • The service charge demanded was based on budgeted figures for the year ahead, which the Plaintiff disputed.
  • The state of account as at July 2017 showed sums owed by the Plaintiff to Company A.
  • Damages claimed by the Plaintiff were overstated and unsupported by reliable evidence.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The Plaintiff contended that the relationship was effectively a tenancy, granting exclusive possession.
  • The re-entry by Company A was wrongful and a breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment.
  • The Plaintiff disputed the arrears claimed and contended that no valid notice to terminate was given in respect of the arrears at the time of lockout.
  • The Plaintiff claimed substantial damages for loss of profit and goodwill resulting from the wrongful exclusion.
  • The Plaintiff presented expert evidence estimating lost students and reputational damage, though the expert's independence was questioned.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Arnold v Britton [2015] AC 1619 Principles of contractual construction focusing on objective intention and contextual interpretation. The court applied conventional principles to construe the 2012 Agreement, focusing on the language in its documentary, factual, and commercial context.
Street v Mountford [1985] 1 AC 809 Exclusive possession is key to determining whether an occupier is a tenant or licensee. The court used this precedent to assess whether the Plaintiff had exclusive possession, concluding that the 2012 Agreement created a tenancy despite its wording.
Errington v. Errington and Woods [1952] 1 KB 290 Exceptional categories where exclusive possession may not create a tenancy. The court found no basis for the Plaintiff to fall within exceptional categories; thus exclusive possession indicated tenancy.
Addiscombe Garden Estates Ltd. v. Crabbe [1958] 1 Q.B. 513 Substance over form: documents must be given effect according to the actual rights and obligations conferred. The court emphasized substance over labels, treating the 2012 Agreement as a tenancy despite its title as a licence.
Clear Channel UK Ltd v Manchester City Council [2006] 1 EGLR 27 Reluctance to disregard express terms of agreements negotiated by parties of equal bargaining power. The court noted the parties did not have equal bargaining power; thus was willing to look beyond express terms.
Parabola Investments Ltd v Browallia Cal Ltd [2011] QB 477 Assessment of damages involving hypothetical loss and loss of chance. The court applied principles allowing reasonable estimation of loss despite uncertainty, but requiring evidential foundation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first analysed the nature of the Plaintiff's occupation by construing the 2012 Agreement objectively, applying the principles in Arnold v Britton. Despite the agreement's express language describing it as a licence and its provisions granting management control and rights of entry to Company A, the court found that the substance of the arrangement conferred exclusive possession on the Plaintiff. This was supported by the Plaintiff's factual exclusive occupation and the absence of genuine commercial reasons for Company A to exercise control rights.

The court also considered the parties' relative bargaining power, accepting evidence that the Plaintiff was not in a strong position to negotiate terms and did not take legal advice, thus justifying looking beyond the written label.

Consequently, the court held that the Plaintiff was a tenant under a business tenancy governed by the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954. The court then examined whether Company A's re-entry in September 2014 was lawful. Clause 10 of the 2012 Agreement allowed termination on 14 days' written notice for unpaid fees, but the court found no valid notice had been given in respect of arrears that arose in June 2014. Earlier notices were waived by acceptance of payments in 2014. Therefore, the lockout was unlawful and breached the implied covenant for quiet enjoyment.

Regarding damages, the court critically assessed the Plaintiff's expert evidence, noting conflicts of interest and lack of evidential foundation for claims of lost students and goodwill. The Defendant's expert evidence suggested no significant adverse financial impact from the lockout. Applying the principles from Parabola Investments Ltd v Browallia Cal Ltd, the court acknowledged the difficulty in quantifying hypothetical loss but required a reasonable evidential basis which was lacking.

The court awarded limited damages reflecting the short deprivation of use, disruption, reputational damage in context, and possible minor loss of prospective students, totalling £25,104.

Finally, the court addressed the state of account between the parties as at July 2017, resolving disputes over the construction of earlier agreements and accounting for service charges and payments. After adjustments, the court found the Plaintiff owed Company A £30,545.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the Plaintiff occupied the premises under a tenancy governed by the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954.

Company A's re-entry onto the premises in September 2014 was unlawful due to the absence of valid notice and constituted a breach of the covenant for quiet enjoyment.

The Plaintiff was awarded damages of £25,104 for the wrongful exclusion.

The state of account as at 26 July 2017 was declared to show that the Plaintiff owed Company A £30,545.

The court noted that Company A had served a section 25 notice and that the question of renewal of tenancy was subject to separate proceedings. No broader precedent was set beyond the facts of this case. Issues such as interest and costs were to be dealt with later if not agreed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

London College of Business Ltd v Tareem Ltd & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

London College of Business Ltd v Tareem Ltd & Anor
(Mar 7, 2018)