Factual and Procedural Background
This case concerns a claim for damages brought by the Plaintiff against the Defendant, representing certain emanations of the UK state. The Plaintiff's claim arises from an alleged failure by the Court of Appeal in London to refer a question of European Union ("EU") law to the European Court of Justice ("ECJ") in Luxembourg. The Plaintiff contends that this refusal deprived him of the right to pursue an unfair dismissal claim against his former employer, Company B (Standard Chartered Bank), in the UK Employment Tribunal, resulting in losses for which he seeks compensation from the Defendant.
The Plaintiff, who holds dual Argentine and Italian nationality, was recruited for a position in Singapore by Company B following interviews in London. After arrival, a dispute arose leading to the withdrawal of the job offer and subsequent dismissal. The Plaintiff successfully pursued a wrongful dismissal claim in Singapore courts. Separately, he brought claims in the UK Employment Tribunal which were dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. The Employment Appeal Tribunal ("EAT") upheld this dismissal, and leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal was refused, including refusal to make a reference to the ECJ on the relevant EU law question.
The present action followed, with the Plaintiff seeking damages from the Defendant for the alleged failure to refer the EU law question, which he argues caused him to lose the opportunity to have his unfair dismissal claim heard in the UK tribunal system.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court of Appeal was under a mandatory obligation to refer the EU law question raised by the Plaintiff to the European Court of Justice under Article 267 TFEU.
- Whether the refusal to make such a reference constitutes a sufficiently serious breach of EU law to give rise to state liability under the principles established in Kobler.
- Whether the Plaintiff's claim for damages is properly pleaded, including issues of causation and specification of loss.
- Whether the Plaintiff's rights under Article 6.1 of the European Convention on Human Rights (right to a fair trial) were infringed by the refusal to refer.
- Whether the pleadings and evidence support the Plaintiff's claim that the refusal to refer caused him loss, including loss of employment and related benefits.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The Court of Appeal was not obliged to refer the question to the ECJ because the question was not relevant to the outcome of the case, applying the CILFIT criteria.
- The Court of Appeal gave adequate reasons for its decision, including addressing discrimination and residence issues.
- The Plaintiff's pleadings are deficient and fail to provide fair notice or sufficient specification of losses.
- Liability under Kobler requires a manifest breach of EU law, which is not established here.
- The losses claimed are not causally linked to the refusal to refer, and the Plaintiff has not shown he would have been re-employed or successful in the Employment Tribunal.
- The Plaintiff's motion to amend pleadings should be refused as it is out of time and introduces new claims.
- The Defendant is not bound by the Singapore judgment, and no res judicata applies between the proceedings against Company B and the Defendant.
- The question of valuation of damages is premature and should not be referred to the ECJ at this stage.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The refusal by the Court of Appeal to refer the EU law question breached EU law, including the CILFIT test and related ECHR jurisprudence, thus violating his right to a fair trial under Article 6.1 ECHR.
- The Court of Appeal applied a discriminatory test that imposed more onerous requirements on EU nationals than on British nationals, contrary to EU non-discrimination principles such as those in O'Flynn and Commission v Belgium.
- The Plaintiff contends that the test applied by the Court of Appeal required pre-existing links to the UK or employer, which disproportionately disadvantaged migrant workers.
- The Plaintiff relies on Kobler for state liability arising from a manifest breach by a court of last instance, asserting all three conditions are met.
- The Plaintiff claims losses including salary, bonuses, share value, pay rises, and damage to reputation, asserting entitlement to reinstatement or re-engagement under the Employment Rights Act 1996.
- The Singapore judgment is res judicata regarding the facts of wrongful dismissal, supporting the claim for damages.
- The Plaintiff argues the Defendant's defense of impracticability to reinstate is unfounded.
- The Plaintiff requests the court to make a reference to the ECJ on the valuation of damages under EU law.
- The Plaintiff challenges the Defendant's procedural objections, including the timing of amendments and adequacy of pleadings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| CILFIT v Ministero della Sanita [1982] ECR 3415 |
Criteria for mandatory reference under Article 267 TFEU; exceptions where reference is not required. |
The court applied the CILFIT test to determine that no mandatory reference was required as the question was not relevant to the outcome. |
| Kobler v Republik Osterrich [2004] QB 848 |
Conditions for state liability arising from decisions of courts of last instance breaching EU law. |
The court held that liability arises only in exceptional cases of manifest breach; found no manifest breach here. |
| Lawson v Serco [2006] ICR 250 |
Approach to territorial jurisdiction of Employment Tribunal under ERA 1996. |
The court found the territorial jurisdiction test correctly applied by lower courts. |
| Ravat v Halliburton Manufacturing and Services Ltd 2012 SC (UKSC) 265 |
Consideration of territorial limits and connection in unfair dismissal claims. |
Referenced to support the approach that employment relationship closeness determines jurisdiction. |
| O'Flynn v Adjudication Officer, ECJ Case C-237/94 |
Prohibition of indirect discrimination against migrant workers. |
The court found that the test applied by the Court of Appeal risked indirect discrimination contrary to this precedent. |
| Commission v Belgium ECJ Case C-278/94 |
Prohibition of discriminatory conditions more easily met by nationals than migrant workers. |
The court held that the test imposed by the Court of Appeal was akin to residency requirements forbidden by this case. |
| Ullens v Belgium, ECtHR Case 3989/07 |
Requirement for national courts to give adequate reasons when refusing to refer questions to ECJ. |
The court concluded the Court of Appeal gave adequate reasons, rejecting the Plaintiff's claim of breach. |
| Blackstone's Employment Law (2012) |
Practical guidance on reinstatement and re-engagement under ERA 1996. |
Used by Plaintiff to argue reinstatement was practicable and mandatory. |
| Factortame [1996] ECR I-1029 |
State liability for breaches of EU law affecting individual rights. |
Referenced as a foundation for damages claim arising from failure to refer. |
| Dhahbi v Italy, ECtHR Case C-111/91 |
Standards for national courts' obligation to refer questions to ECJ. |
Referenced to support Plaintiff's argument on Article 6 ECHR rights. |
| Ullah v Special Adjudicator [2004] UKHL 26 |
National courts' duty to keep pace with Strasbourg jurisprudence. |
Used to support Plaintiff's argument on fair trial rights. |
| Lawson v Serco and Duncombe & Ors v Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families [2011] UKSC 14 |
Tests for territorial jurisdiction and employment connection. |
Applied by the court to assess the jurisdictional issues in the Plaintiff's claim. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by examining the procedural and factual background, noting the complex and improperly structured pleadings filed by the Plaintiff, which rendered the case difficult to assess. The court emphasized the necessity of proper pleadings to give fair notice of the legal and factual basis of the claim.
Regarding the obligation to refer under Article 267 TFEU, the court accepted that the Court of Appeal's decision was a final judgment potentially engaging this duty, but held that no mandatory reference arose because the question posed was not relevant to the outcome of the case, applying the CILFIT criteria. The court found that the question of territorial jurisdiction under section 94(1) Employment Rights Act 1996 was a matter of fact and judgment for the Employment Tribunal, the EAT, and the Court of Appeal.
The court rejected the Plaintiff's argument that the Court of Appeal's decision was discriminatory, noting that nationality was not a material factor in the decision and that the test applied focused on the closeness of the employment relationship rather than residence or nationality. The court found that even if some weight was given to residence, it was not determinative, and no manifest breach of EU law had occurred.
The court addressed the state liability claim under Kobler, emphasizing the high threshold requiring a manifest infringement of EU law by a court of last instance. It found the Plaintiff had not demonstrated such a manifest breach.
On causation and loss, the court found the Plaintiff's averments lacking in specification and failed to establish a direct causal link between the refusal to refer and the claimed losses. The court noted that the Plaintiff did not aver he would have been re-employed or that the Employment Tribunal would have ordered reinstatement or re-engagement. The Singapore judgment was not binding on the Defendant, and the plea of res judicata did not apply between different parties and jurisdictions.
The court also considered the Plaintiff's motion for a reference to the ECJ on the valuation of damages and refused it, citing procedural impropriety and the availability of well-developed national law principles to assess damages.
Overall, the court found the Plaintiff's case was irrelevant and without real prospect of success, justifying dismissal.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision was to repel the Plaintiff's pleas in law, sustain the Defendant's second plea in law, and dismiss the action. All questions of expenses were reserved meantime.
The direct effect of this decision is the dismissal of the Plaintiff's claim for damages against the Defendant arising from the alleged failure to refer the EU law question to the ECJ. The court did not find any manifest breach of EU law or violation of the Plaintiff's rights sufficient to impose state liability. No new legal precedent was established; the decision reaffirms the application of existing principles regarding the obligation to refer, state liability under Kobler, and the requirements for pleadings and causation in damages claims.