Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Moreston and Craig v. Douglas.

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns disputes involving teinds (a form of tithe or ecclesiastical rent) and related obligations tied to land tenancies and inheritance. In one matter, tenants were found to be permitted to pay their master the rent inclusive of teinds even after citation by the titular, due to uncertainty regarding the portion of rent to retain for teind. Another matter involved executors pursuing the heir of a deceased donatar for restoration of teinds accrued on certain lands, with procedural contentions about the validity and transfer of declarators and the lawful charge of the heir to enter into his father’s rights. The court addressed issues including the necessity of producing sasine (legal possession) as part of the process and procedural rights related to renunciation by the defender.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether tenants could lawfully pay their rent including teinds to their master after citation by the titular, given uncertainty about the portion of rent applicable to teind.
  2. Whether a general declarator obtained by a donatar must be transferred to executors before they can pursue an heir for restoration of teinds.
  3. Whether the heir could be convened as lawfully charged to enter heir for a spuilzie (wrongful dispossession) committed by his father absent a sentence against the father during his lifetime.
  4. Whether production of sasine is required as part of the process when the sasine is the pursuer’s title.
  5. Procedural rights concerning the defender’s renunciation and the pursuer’s right to prove summons or proceed to execution thereafter.

Arguments of the Parties

Pursuer's Arguments

  • The pursuers, as executors dative, contended that the heir was lawfully charged to enter heir and restore teinds or their value for the years libelled.
  • They maintained that the general declarator obtained by the donatar was the foundation for their pursuit and did not require transfer to them.
  • They insisted on the production of sasine as part of the process, since it was their title.
  • They requested the right to prove their summons against the defender if he renounced, or to proceed to execution if he did not.

Defender's Arguments

  • The defender alleged that no process had been pursued upon the summons by the executors until the general declarator was transferred to them, arguing that a general declarator did not need to be transferred absent a sentence against the debtors.
  • The defender argued he could not be convened as lawfully charged to enter heir for a spuilzie committed by his father, since there was no sentence against his father in his lifetime.
  • The defender offered to renounce and sought time for that effect.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
TEINDS No. 1628 (Murray v. Intromitters) Tenants may pay rent including teinds to their master after citation, due to uncertainty in rent retention for teind. The court found tenants could lawfully pay their master inclusive rent even after citation by the titular.
MORESTON and CRAIG v. DOUGLAS No. 1629 Obligations of heirs to restore teinds; procedural requirements for declarators and sasine production; lawful charge of heir for spuilzie. The court rejected the defender’s procedural objections, upheld the need for sasine production, and granted procedural rights related to renunciation and summons proof.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the nature of teind payments and recognized the practical difficulty tenants faced in segregating rent for teind, thereby permitting payment of the full rent inclusive of teinds to the master even post citation. Regarding the executors’ pursuit against the heir, the court rejected the argument that the general declarator required transfer to the executors, emphasizing that no special declarator or sentence against the debtors was necessary for the pursuit. The court also rejected the contention that the heir could not be convened absent a sentence against his father, reinforcing the lawful charge to enter heir for spuilzie. The necessity of producing sasine as part of the process was upheld, reflecting the importance of title proof in such claims. Finally, the court balanced procedural fairness by allowing the defender to renounce with a reserved right for the pursuer to prove summons or proceed to execution, thereby preventing undue delay or prejudice.

Holding and Implications

The court REJECTED the defender’s procedural objections and upheld the pursuers’ rights to proceed with their claims for restoration of teinds. It confirmed tenants’ ability to pay rent inclusive of teinds post citation and enforced the procedural requirements for sasine production and lawful charge of heirs in spuilzie claims. The defender was permitted to renounce with the pursuer retaining rights to prove summons or execute thereafter.

The decision directly affected the parties by clarifying procedural and substantive rights concerning teind payments and heir obligations but did not establish new precedent beyond reaffirming existing legal principles.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Moreston and Craig v Douglas.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Moreston and Craig v Douglas.
(Jul 17, 1629)