Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)

Technomed Ltd & Anor v. Bluecrest Health Screening Ltd & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants, collectively referred to as Technomed, brought proceedings against the defendants, Bluecrest Health Screening Limited ("Bluecrest") and Express Diagnostic Limited trading as Cardio Analytics ("Express"), alleging infringement of their database right and copyright in their electrocardiogram ("ECG") analysis and reporting system known as ECG Cloud. The counterclaim for breach of contract by Bluecrest was stayed pending resolution of the intellectual property claims.

Technomed developed ECG Cloud, an internet-based ECG analysis and reporting system, which uses a database ("the Database") containing classifications, options, traffic light risk statuses, and patient explanatory texts ("Patient Definitions"). Technomed contracted with Bluecrest to provide ECG screening services using this system. Subsequently, Bluecrest sought to reduce the contract price and eventually terminated the contract prematurely, transferring ECG screening services to Express, which allegedly replicated the ECG Cloud system.

Technomed claims infringement of database right, copyright in various works including the Database, XML format, explanatory materials, patient definitions, and diagrams (the Two Hearts Diagram and the Wave Diagram). The defendants deny infringement and raise various defences including lack of subsistence of rights and causation.

The trial focused solely on the intellectual property infringement claims, with extensive witness evidence from both parties, including technical experts and medical professionals. The case has a complex procedural history involving transfers between courts and case management adjustments.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Database qualifies as a database under the Database Directive and UK law for the purpose of sui generis database right and copyright protection.
  2. Whether sui generis database right subsists in the Database based on substantial investment in obtaining, verifying, or presenting its contents.
  3. Whether the defendants infringed Technomed’s sui generis database right by extracting and reutilising the Database or substantial parts thereof.
  4. Whether copyright subsists in the Database as a database and/or as a literary work, and in associated works including the XML Format, Explanatory Materials, Patient Definitions, and diagrams.
  5. Whether the defendants infringed Technomed’s copyright in the above works.
  6. The applicability and effect of the defendants’ defence based on causation of loss in relation to infringement claims.
  7. Whether the defendants’ infringement was flagrant, justifying additional damages.
  8. Whether there is a threat of continued infringement by the defendants.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimant's Arguments

  • The Database is a qualifying database under the Database Directive and UK law, comprising independent works arranged systematically and accessible electronically.
  • Technomed made substantial investment in obtaining, verifying, and presenting the Database contents, entitling them to sui generis database right protection.
  • The defendants copied the entire Database and used its contents in their systems and patient reports, constituting infringement.
  • Copyright subsists in the Database as a database and literary work, the XML Format, Explanatory Materials, Patient Definitions, and the Two Hearts and Wave Diagrams.
  • The defendants had access to Technomed’s materials and copied substantial parts, including verbatim reproductions in their reports.
  • The defendants’ infringement was flagrant, demonstrated by their awareness of Technomed’s rights and failure to take steps to avoid infringement.
  • Causation of loss is a matter for a later damages inquiry, not for the liability trial.

Defendant's Arguments

  • The defendants deny subsistence of the claimed rights, arguing the works are generic, commonplace, or lack originality.
  • They deny infringement, contending that any similarities arise from use of standard medical terminology and concepts.
  • They raised a causation defence, submitting that the alleged infringement was not the cause of any loss suffered by Technomed.
  • Initial defences on qualification, ownership, joint tortfeasance, and implied licence were abandoned before trial.
  • One defendant’s expert evidence was discredited due to conflicts of interest and improper instructions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Justice Companie Naviera SA v Prudential Assurance Co Limited (The "Ikarian Reefer") [1993] 2 Lloyd's Rep 68 Expert witness independence and duties Used to assess the independence and reliability of an expert witness whose company had undisclosed commercial interests with a party.
Football Dataco Limited v Sportradar GmbH [2013] EWCA Civ 27 Interpretation of database right and copyright originality Adopted to confirm the protection of databases involving substantial investment and the low originality threshold for copyright in databases.
Forensic Telecommunications Services Limited v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police [2011] EWHC 2892 (Ch) Principles of database right and copyright subsistence Referenced for principles of interpretation of UK database right and copyright legislation.
Fixtures Marketing Limited v Organismos Prognostikon Agonon Podosfairou (OPAP) C-444/02 [2004] ECR I-10549 Definition and scope of "database" under Directive 96/9/EC Applied to confirm a wide and functional interpretation of database, encompassing collections of independent materials systematically arranged and accessible.
SAS Institute Inc v World Programming Limited C-406/10 [2012] RPC 31 Copyright protection for computer programs and related works Considered regarding copyright subsistence in XML formats as literary works, not as computer programs.
Baigent v The Random House Group Limited [2007] EWCA Civ 247 Scope of copyright protection and substantial part copying Used to clarify that copyright does not protect general ideas or commonplace concepts, but protects substantial reproduction of original expression.
USP Plc v London General Holdings Ltd [2005] EWCA Civ 931 Role of causation in copyright infringement damages Discussed causation as a damages inquiry issue, not a preliminary liability issue.
Work Model Enterprises Limited v Ecosystem Limited and Clix Interiors [1996] FSR 356 Damages inquiry and causation in copyright infringement Confirmed that damages and causation are matters for inquiry after liability is established.
The Governors and Company of the Bank of Ireland and Anor v Watts Group PLC [2017] EWHC 1667 (TCC) Assessment of causation and reliance in professional negligence Referenced post-trial but distinguished as not assisting causation argument in intellectual property liability trial.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the nature of the Database, finding it to be a collection of independent works arranged systematically and accessible electronically, thus qualifying as a database under the Database Directive and UK law. The court accepted that Technomed made substantial investment in obtaining, verifying, and presenting the Database contents, satisfying the requirements for sui generis database right subsistence.

The defendants were found to have copied the entire Database and used it in their systems and reports until November 2016, constituting infringement of the database right. The court also found copyright subsisted in the Database both as a database and as a literary work, as well as in the XML Format, Explanatory Materials, Patient Definitions, and the Two Hearts and Wave Diagrams.

The originality threshold for copyright was applied as a low hurdle, requiring only that the works be the author’s own intellectual creation involving more than trivial effort. The court rejected the defendants’ arguments that the works were generic or commonplace, finding sufficient intellectual effort in their creation.

Infringement of copyright was established by evidence of exact or substantial reproduction of the works in defendants’ documents and reports, with no credible explanation of independent creation. The court discredited the defendants’ claim of independent rewriting for a later version of classification documents, finding it to be a derivative work based on prior infringing versions.

The court found the defendants’ infringement of certain works (Explanatory Materials and diagrams) to be flagrant, based on their awareness of Technomed’s rights and failure to take reasonable steps to avoid infringement, despite having the opportunity and knowledge to do so.

The defendants’ causation defence was rejected at this stage, with the court holding that causation is a matter for the damages inquiry, not the liability trial. The court noted that a sufficient causal link between infringement and potential loss exists for the purposes of establishing liability.

Regarding expert evidence, the court found one defendant’s expert compromised by undisclosed conflicts of interest and improper instructions, leading to his evidence being given no weight.

Finally, the court found no realistic threat of continued infringement as the defendants had ceased the infringing activities.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision is summarized as follows:

  • Sui generis database right subsists in the Database and was infringed until November 2016.
  • Copyright subsists in the Database as a database and as a literary work and was infringed until November 2016.
  • Copyright subsists in the XML Format as a literary work and was infringed until at least 11 December 2015.
  • Copyright subsists in the Explanatory Materials and was infringed until mid-November 2014.
  • Copyright subsists in the Patient Definitions individually and in combination with associated Classifications and Options, and was infringed until November 2016, except for certain definitions which did not infringe from March 2014.
  • Copyright subsists in the Two Hearts Diagram and the Wave Diagram as artistic works and was infringed until 11 November 2014.
  • The defendants’ infringement of the Explanatory Materials and the diagrams was flagrant under section 97(2) of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
  • There is no realistic threat of further infringement.

Implications: The judgment establishes liability for infringement of both database right and copyright in multiple works related to the ECG Cloud system. The court’s findings confirm the protection afforded to databases and associated materials involving substantial investment and intellectual effort. The defendants are liable for past infringement, with the issues of damages and any account of profits reserved for subsequent inquiry. No new precedent was set beyond application of established principles to the facts. The counterclaim remains stayed and will be progressed separately.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Technomed Ltd & Anor v Bluecrest Health Screening Ltd & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Technomed Ltd & Anor v Bluecrest Health Screening Ltd & Anor
(Aug 24, 2017)