Factual and Procedural Background
This consolidated appeal arises from two decisions made by the Respondents, the Commissioners for Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs (HMRC), against the Appellant, Company A. The first decision, dated 14 May 2014 and upheld on review on 13 October 2014, refused Company A's application to treat its supplies of bicarbonate of soda as zero-rated for Value Added Tax (VAT) purposes under item 1 Group 1 Schedule 8 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (VATA). The second decision, dated 19 December 2014, involved the issuance of a VAT assessment for unpaid VAT totaling £291,526.00 plus interest of £13,568.98 for the periods from January 2012 to June 2014.
The core issue in both appeals is whether the supplies of bicarbonate of soda made by Company A qualify as "food of a kind used for human consumption" and thus are zero-rated for VAT purposes, or whether they attract VAT at the standard rate as contended by HMRC.
Company A registered for VAT effective 1 May 2009 and supplied dried powdered and granular products to food retailers. It purchased bulk bicarbonate of soda from Company B, which sourced it from various manufacturers meeting EU purity regulations for food additives. Company A packaged the bicarbonate of soda into 200g tubs sold under own-brand labels to major supermarkets, including Tesco and Lidl, with packaging indicating use as a baking ingredient.
On 30 April 2014, an HMRC officer conducted a routine visit to Company A's premises, leading to the refusal of zero-rating treatment and subsequent VAT assessment. Company A appealed both decisions, which were consolidated for hearing before the Tribunal.
The hearing involved agreed bundles of evidence, including witness statements from Company A's representatives, suppliers, and supermarket employees, none of which were challenged. Both parties also presented expert evidence from food technology consultants, who gave opposing views on the VAT classification of bicarbonate of soda.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the supplies of bicarbonate of soda made by Company A are "food of a kind used for human consumption" within item 1 Group 1 Schedule 8 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994, thereby qualifying for zero-rating of VAT.
- Whether the intended use and marketing of the bicarbonate of soda affect its VAT classification.
- Whether the presence of nutritional content or the classification as a food additive under EU regulations influences the VAT treatment.
- Whether the VAT classification of a product can vary depending on its intended use or packaging.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The relevant test is the reasonable view of the ordinary person, informed by evidence, on whether the product is food of a kind used for human consumption.
- The product was marketed and packaged as a baking ingredient, sold in supermarkets' home baking sections, indicating its primary intended use as food.
- Although bicarbonate of soda has other uses, the supplies in question were clearly intended for culinary use, distinguishing them from products sold solely for non-food purposes.
- Bicarbonate of soda contains sodium, an essential nutrient, and its nutritional value, even if limited, supports its classification as food.
- The product is an essential ingredient in baking, providing texture critical to palatability, not merely a cosmetic additive.
- The classification as a food additive with an E number under EU regulations confirms safety for consumption but does not preclude zero-rating.
- The fact that the product is not usually consumed in its natural form does not preclude it from being zero-rated as food.
- The purpose of zero-rating food is broad and includes ingredients contributing to food production, supported by relevant case law.
- Comparisons with table salt and baking powder reveal inconsistencies in HMRC's VAT treatment, supporting zero-rating of bicarbonate of soda for culinary use.
Respondents' Arguments
- The nature of the product, not its marketing, determines VAT classification; bicarbonate of soda is a generic bulk chemical with multiple uses.
- The product is added to food for technological purposes as a raising agent, not for nutritional value.
- Supplies made by Company A were bulk chemical packaged into small tubs without change in nature, so standard rating applies.
- The wording "of a kind used" in the legislation refers to the product's nature, not its intended use or marketing.
- Bicarbonate of soda meeting food-grade purity can have non-food uses, including cosmetics and industry.
- Baking powder is distinguished as it is a specific product sold solely for baking, unlike bicarbonate of soda.
- HMRC's guidance and manuals, though not legally binding, consistently classify bicarbonate of soda as standard rated.
- The UK is bound by EU VAT directives limiting zero-rating categories; HMRC cannot extend zero-rating by concession.
- Previous tribunal decisions support that edibility and nutritional content alone do not determine zero-rating.
- Cases cited by the Appellant are distinguishable on facts and do not establish a general principle for zero-rating bicarbonate of soda.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Customs and Excise Commissioners v Ferrero UK Limited [1997] STC 881 |
Approach to determining if a product is food of a kind used for human consumption by reference to the view of the ordinary person informed by evidence. |
The court adopted the multifactorial assessment approach, emphasizing overall impression rather than itemized weighting of factors. |
| HMRC v Procter & Gamble UK Limited [2009] EWCA Civ 407 |
Reasonable view test for VAT classification, focusing on all facts and circumstances surrounding the product. |
The court endorsed a practical, overall assessment rather than detailed scientific balancing of factors. |
| Customs and Excise Commissioners v Macphie & Co (Glenbervie) Ltd [1992] STC 886 |
Food does not need to be sold in a form consumable without preparation to qualify as food for VAT purposes. |
The court confirmed that ingredients contributing to food qualify for zero-rating even if not consumed as sold. |
| EC Commission v UK Case 416/85 [1988] STC 456 |
Ingredients contributing to food production can qualify for zero-rating under VAT law. |
The court recognized that zero-rating can apply to supplies used in food manufacture, not only final food products. |
| Devro Limited (VAT Decision No. 7570) |
Nutritional value is not determinative for zero-rating; single-use integral products can qualify. |
Used illustratively to show that limited nutritional content does not preclude zero-rating where product is integral to food. |
| Gas & Chemicals Limited (VAT Decision No. 18160) |
Distinguished cosmetic or technological additives from essential food ingredients for VAT purposes. |
Referenced to contrast with bicarbonate of soda's essential role in baking texture. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal approached the issue by applying the test endorsed in Ferrero and Procter & Gamble, assessing whether an informed ordinary person would regard the bicarbonate of soda supplied by Company A as food of a kind used for human consumption. The analysis involved a multifactorial assessment considering the nature of the product, its packaging, marketing, intended use, and relevant statutory and regulatory definitions.
The Tribunal accepted the unchallenged evidence that the bicarbonate of soda was sold primarily as a baking ingredient, packaged in small tubs with labeling consistent with culinary use, and sold to supermarkets for placement in home baking sections. Although the product has multiple uses, the Tribunal found that the reasonable view based on the facts was that the typical consumer would purchase it for baking.
The Tribunal acknowledged the product's chemical nature and multiple uses but held that the intended use, as objectively evidenced by packaging and marketing, is a relevant factor in classification. It rejected the Respondents' argument that classification cannot vary by intended use, clarifying that the test requires consideration of all facts and circumstances, including likely use by a typical consumer.
Regarding nutritional value, the Tribunal found that while bicarbonate of soda contains sodium, an essential nutrient, its nutritional contribution is limited and not the basis for classification. However, its critical role in providing texture, an important attribute of food, supports its classification as food. The Tribunal distinguished bicarbonate of soda from purely cosmetic or technological additives, emphasizing its essential function in baking.
The Tribunal also considered comparisons with table salt and baking powder, noting inconsistencies in HMRC's VAT treatment. It found no satisfactory justification for treating bicarbonate of soda differently from baking powder when both are used as baking ingredients, nor for the differential treatment of salt based on intended use.
In conclusion, the Tribunal determined that bicarbonate of soda supplied by Company A in the form and for the purpose described qualifies as food of a kind used for human consumption under item 1 Group 1 Schedule 8 VATA.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal ALLOWS the appeals.
The Tribunal holds that the supplies of bicarbonate of soda made by Company A, when supplied in a form primarily intended for use as a baking ingredient, are food of a kind used for human consumption and therefore qualify for zero-rating under item 1 Group 1 Schedule 8 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994.
The direct effect is that the VAT assessment issued by HMRC is set aside in respect of these supplies. No new legal precedent is established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts of this case. The decision clarifies that intended use and marketing can be relevant in VAT classification where a product has multiple uses, provided the assessment is based on an objective view of the typical consumer.