Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Miah & Ors v. Revenue and Customs (INCOME TAX/CORPORATION TAX : Assessment/self-assessment)

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from notices issued under Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008 to three appellants concerning their income tax affairs. On 19 January 2016, Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs (HMRC) opened a tax enquiry under section 9A of the Taxes Management Act 1970 (TMA) into one appellant's 2013-14 self-assessment return. Subsequently, HMRC issued Code of Practice 9 (COP9) letters to all three appellants, informing them of investigations into suspected tax fraud and offering a limited-time opportunity to enter a Contractual Disclosure Facility (CDF) to avoid criminal prosecution. The appellants did not respond to the CDF offer within the stipulated period, leading HMRC to issue formal Schedule 36 notices requiring information and documents to verify their tax positions.

The appellants' accountant challenged the issuance of the Schedule 36 notices, arguing they were unreasonable and unjustified, and applied for closure of the COP9 enquiries. HMRC maintained that the requests were reasonably required due to suspected under-declaration of income and prior non-compliance. The First-tier Tribunal (FtT) directed that the appeals and closure application be heard together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the First-tier Tribunal has jurisdiction to order the closure of a COP9 enquiry.
  2. Whether the information and documents requested by HMRC under Schedule 36 were reasonably required for the purpose of checking the appellants' tax positions.
  3. Whether the Schedule 36 notices issued to the appellants should be confirmed, varied, or set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants contended that the COP9 enquiries lacked a proper basis and that HMRC had not provided sufficient information about the alleged wrongdoing.
  • They argued that HMRC failed to comply with the statutory 12-month enquiry window applicable to self-assessment returns and that no valid discovery enquiry under section 29 TMA had been initiated.
  • The appellants claimed the Schedule 36 notices were unreasonable, requesting information outside the enquiry window and for periods where returns were not yet due.
  • The appellants asserted that HMRC had not issued informal requests before resorting to formal notices, which they considered an inappropriate approach.
  • They challenged the allegation of serious tax fraud, noting no opportunity was given to respond to such accusations.
  • The appellants questioned the relevance and reasonableness of the information requested, particularly as some records were held by a third-party accountant inaccessible to them.
  • They suggested HMRC's investigations were an abuse of power, possibly motivated by prior settlements and personal animus.

Respondents' Arguments

  • HMRC maintained that the Schedule 36 notices were issued lawfully and that the information requested was reasonably required to verify the appellants’ tax positions.
  • They explained that no informal request was necessary before issuing formal notices, especially given the appellants’ history of non-compliance and failure to respond to prior notices.
  • HMRC emphasized that the COP9 enquiry and Schedule 36 notices were separate matters and that the appellants had been given an opportunity to make a full disclosure under the CDF, which was declined by non-response.
  • HMRC clarified that the enquiry window argument was not applicable to the Schedule 36 notices, which relate to checking tax positions including past, present, and future liabilities.
  • HMRC asserted that the First-tier Tribunal lacked jurisdiction to order closure of COP9 enquiries, which fall under the remit of the Administrative Court via judicial review.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hok v HMRC [2012] UKUT (TC) Establishes that the First-tier Tribunal has no judicial review jurisdiction. Confirmed that the FtT cannot supervise or order closure of COP9 enquiries, which are subject to judicial review in the Administrative Court.
HMRC v Noor [2013] UKUT 071 (TCC) Supports the principle that judicial review jurisdiction lies outside the FtT. Reinforced the FtT's lack of jurisdiction over COP9 enquiry closure requests.
HMRC v Tager [2015] UKUT 0040 (TCC) Clarifies that the burden of proof regarding whether information is reasonably required rests on the taxpayer. Applied to confirm that appellants must demonstrate that the Schedule 36 notices were unreasonable; the tribunal found they did not meet this burden.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal first addressed its jurisdiction, concluding that it has no power to order the closure of COP9 enquiries because such powers rest with the Administrative Court through judicial review. This conclusion was supported by relevant case law establishing the limits of the FtT's jurisdiction.

Regarding the Schedule 36 notices, the Tribunal analysed the statutory framework and HMRC guidance, focusing on whether the requested information was reasonably required to check the appellants' tax positions. The Tribunal noted the appellants’ history of non-compliance and failure to respond to prior notices, justifying the immediate use of formal powers without prior informal requests.

The Tribunal found that the information sought was relevant to verifying multiple strands of income, including rental properties and directorships, and was therefore reasonably required. It rejected the appellants’ argument about the enquiry window, explaining that Schedule 36 does not limit requests to periods within the 12-month enquiry window applicable to self-assessment enquiries. The statutory definition of "tax position" includes past, present, and future liabilities, supporting the reasonableness of the information requests.

The Tribunal also dismissed the appellants’ allegations of improper investigation, finding no evidence to support claims of mala fides or abuse of power. It emphasized that the appellants had been given a clear opportunity to disclose under the CDF, which they declined.

Consequently, the Tribunal confirmed the Schedule 36 notices and required compliance within 30 days, emphasizing that its decision is final with no further appeal.

Holding and Implications

The Tribunal’s final decision was to DISMISS the appeals against the Schedule 36 notices and to REFUSE the application for closure of the COP9 enquiries.

The Tribunal confirmed that it has no jurisdiction to order the closure of COP9 enquiries, directing the appellants to seek judicial review if they wish to challenge those investigations.

The Schedule 36 notices were upheld as lawful and reasonable, requiring the appellants to comply by providing the requested information within 30 days. The decision does not establish new legal precedent but reinforces existing principles regarding the scope of Schedule 36 powers and the limits of the FtT's jurisdiction over COP9 enquiries.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Miah & Ors v Revenue and Customs (INCOME TAX/CORPORATION TAX : Assessment/self-assessment)

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Miah & Ors v Revenue and Customs (INCOME TAX/CORPORATION TAX : Assessment/self-assessment)
(Oct 19, 2017)