Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
- LORD MACMILLAN
- LORD THANKERTON
- LORD PORTER
- LORD ROBERTSON
- LORD JOHNSTON
- LORD KINNEAR
- LORD JAMIESON
- LORD MACKAY
- LORD JUSTICE CLERK
- LORD ATKIN
- LORD ORDINARY
- LORD RUSSELL
- LORD WRIGHT
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
Bourhill v. Young
Smart Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff, a fish trader who was eight months pregnant, disembarked from a tram on The Road on 11 October 1938. While she was lifting a heavy basket from the driver’s platform, a motor-cyclist (the “Motorcyclist”) travelling at excessive speed passed the stationary tram and collided with a motor-car that was turning into a side street. The impact occurred approximately 45–50 feet from the Plaintiff; she neither saw the impact nor was in its line of danger but heard the sound and later observed blood on the roadway. She alleged nervous shock, a wrenched back, and the still-birth of her child.
The Plaintiff sued the Defendant, the Motorcyclist’s executor, for negligence. Judge Robertson (Outer House) dismissed the action, holding that no duty of care was owed to the Plaintiff. The Second Division of the Court of Session affirmed that decision by majority, with Judge Aitchison dissenting. On further appeal, the House of Lords (comprising Judge Thankerton, Judge Russell of Killowen, Judge Macmillan, Judge Wright and Judge Porter) dismissed the appeal and ordered the Plaintiff to pay the Defendant’s costs of the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, in Scots (and by analogy English) negligence law, a motor-cyclist owes a duty of care to a bystander who suffers nervous shock unaccompanied by physical impact and who was outside his field of vision at the time of the collision.
- Whether the Plaintiff’s injuries were within the range of reasonable foreseeability or were too remote to attract liability.
- Whether Scottish and English authority on nervous-shock liability are consistent, and if the decision in Hambrook v. Stokes Brothers remains good law.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments
- The Motorcyclist’s excessive speed breached the standard of reasonable care, thereby creating liability for all resultant injury, including nervous shock.
- Precedents such as Dulieu v. White & Sons and Hambrook v. Stokes Brothers demonstrate that shock without physical impact is actionable.
- The “neighbour principle” from Donoghue v. Stevenson supports a wide ambit of duty covering persons foreseeably affected by negligent driving.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The Plaintiff was neither seen nor reasonably foreseeable; she was shielded by the tram and situated outside the area of potential danger.
- Shock caused merely by hearing a collision, without reasonable fear of personal injury, is too remote.
- Authorities such as Smith v. London & South Western Railway Co. and Gilligan v. Robb require proximity; therefore no duty arose.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Kemp & Dougall v. Darngavil Coal Co. Ltd. (1909 S.C. 1314) |
Need for a definable duty in negligence. |
Quoted to emphasise that without a duty the question of negligence does not arise. |
| Heaven v. Pender (11 Q.B.D. 503) |
Foreseeability as basis of duty of care. |
Used to support the “reasonable anticipation” test. |
| Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932 A.C. 562) |
Neighbour principle; persons closely and directly affected. |
Adopted as the primary test of proximity. |
| Dulieu v. White & Sons (1901 2 K.B. 669) |
Actionability of nervous shock arising from reasonable fear of personal injury. |
Discussed; House declined to treat the “personal fear” limitation as universal. |
| Hambrook v. Stokes Brothers (1925 1 K.B. 141) |
Liability for shock through fear for children when negligence admitted. |
Distinguished: admitted negligence there; here duty to Plaintiff denied. |
| Owens v. Liverpool Corporation (1939 1 K.B. 394) |
Mental shock to mourners observing damage to a hearse. |
Viewed sceptically; Judges doubted existence of any duty in such facts. |
| In re Polemis & Furness, Withy & Co. (1921 3 K.B. 560) |
Foreseeability relevant to breach, not to measure of damages. |
Considered but found irrelevant because primary issue was duty, not damages. |
| Smith v. London & South Western Railway Co. (L.R. 6 C.P. 14) |
Reasonable foreseeability central to determining negligence. |
Cited by Judge Wright to illustrate general principles. |
| Haynes v. Harwood (1935 1 K.B. 146) |
“Rescue” doctrine; duty extends to foreseeable rescuers. |
Used to illustrate how ambit of duty may expand when danger foreseeable. |
| Chester v. Waverley Corporation (62 C.L.R. 1) |
Australian authority on nervous shock and proximity. |
Mentioned as persuasive but not decisive. |
| Wilkinson v. Downton (1897 2 Q.B. 57) |
Intentional infliction of mental distress actionable. |
Differentiated as intentional, not negligent, conduct. |
| Janvier v. Sweeney (1919 2 K.B. 316) |
Liability for deliberate deception causing nervous shock. |
Referenced to contrast intentional liability with negligence. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The House held that liability in negligence depends on the existence of a duty owed to the particular claimant and that such duty is confined to persons whom the wrong-doer could reasonably foresee as being within the area of potential danger. Applying that test:
- The Motorcyclist owed a duty to road users who might come into his path; his excessive speed breached that duty to the on-coming driver, but not to the Plaintiff who was behind a stationary tram and invisible to him.
- The possibility that the sound of a collision, absent any reasonable fear of personal injury, would cause physical illness to someone 45–50 feet away was too remote to be within his contemplation.
- Therefore, no duty of care existed toward the Plaintiff; without duty, there could be no breach nor liability, rendering discussion of remoteness of damage or quantum unnecessary.
- The Court reviewed English and Scottish precedents and concluded that the principles of proximity and reasonable foreseeability are common to both jurisdictions; the decision does not overrule Hambrook v. Stokes because negligence toward the claimant was admitted in that case, unlike here.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED – JUDGMENT BELOW AFFIRMED.
The Plaintiff failed because the Motorcyclist owed her no duty of care. The decision re-affirms that liability for nervous shock without physical impact requires proximity and reasonable foreseeability; mere auditory awareness of an accident will not suffice. The ruling aligns Scottish and English doctrine and places practical limits on claims for psychiatric injury, but it does not establish a new legal test.
Click here to read the full judgment