Factual and Procedural Background
Lehman Brothers International (Europe) ("LBIE") entered administration on 15th September 2008. Prior to administration, LBIE provided prime services to institutional clients, primarily hedge funds, including execution, clearing, settlement of securities and derivatives trades, custody, and portfolio valuation. Hedge funds, lacking substantial back office functions, relied on prime brokers like LBIE for transactional, custodial, and reporting services, often involving secured lending against hedge fund assets.
The services were governed by standard form agreements including International Prime Brokerage Agreements, Master Custody Agreements, Margin Lending Agreements, and Credit Support Annexes to ISDA Master Agreements. These contracts granted counterparties proprietary interests in assets held by LBIE. However, administrators faced significant difficulty in determining entitlement to trust property due to lack of client responses, unreliable LBIE records, and insufficient information from custodians and affiliates.
Early in administration, directions were obtained for administrators to identify trust or proprietary claims over assets. Administrators contacted 1,707 account holders requesting information about claims and asset positions. By May 2009, 950 responses and 1,214 claims were received, some prioritized by a Hardship and Prioritisation Committee.
To resolve uncertainties and facilitate distribution, administrators sought permission to propose a scheme of arrangement under Part 26 of the Companies Act 2006. This scheme would require Scheme Creditors, defined as those with proprietary and pecuniary claims, to release existing claims in exchange for "New Claims" entitling them to pooled distributions of assets. The scheme aimed to enforce releases even against dissenting minority creditors.
Blackburne J ruled that the court lacked jurisdiction under Part 26 to sanction a scheme that varied or extinguished proprietary rights over trust property held by LBIE, prompting an appeal by the administrators.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the court has jurisdiction under Part 26 of the Companies Act 2006 to sanction a scheme of arrangement that affects proprietary rights held by creditors over trust property held by the company.
- Whether a beneficiary under a trust who also has pecuniary claims against the company can be treated as a creditor such that the scheme jurisdiction extends to their proprietary rights.
- The proper interpretation of "creditor" and "arrangement" in the context of schemes of arrangement involving trust property.
- Whether a scheme of arrangement can validly require creditors to release rights against third parties related to their claims against the company.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The scheme jurisdiction under Part 26 extends to all rights of creditors against the company, not limited to pecuniary claims, and can validly include proprietary rights.
- The existence of a trust relationship does not preclude a creditor relationship; claims for damages or equitable compensation arising from breach of trust render beneficiaries creditors in part.
- The scheme jurisdiction has been used to vary secured creditors' rights, including security interests, and there is no principled reason to exclude proprietary rights held by beneficiaries under trust arrangements.
- Precedents such as Re T&N Ltd (No 3) and the Australian decision in Re Opes Prime Stockbroking Ltd support the inclusion of rights against third parties and proprietary rights within schemes of arrangement.
- The term "arrangement" should be given a wide and liberal construction, enabling comprehensive restructuring of rights between the company and its creditors.
Respondents' Arguments
- A beneficiary under a trust is not ipso facto a creditor of the trustee company; proprietary rights are distinct from pecuniary claims.
- The statutory language confines the scheme jurisdiction to arrangements between the company and its creditors, defined as persons owed money by the company.
- Proprietary rights to trust property are rights in rem and do not constitute debts or liabilities of the company; thus, they fall outside the scope of Part 26.
- Allowing schemes to affect trust property would undermine established principles that trust property is excluded from the trustee's estate in insolvency and would be contrary to longstanding legislative and equitable safeguards.
- Cases involving secured creditors are distinguishable because security interests are parasitic on debts, unlike proprietary claims to trust assets.
- Releasing proprietary rights via a scheme would require clear legislative authority, which does not exist; the court's jurisdiction is limited to pecuniary claims.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Re NFU Development Trust Ltd [1972] 1 WLR 1548 |
Definition of "arrangement" requiring give and take between company and creditors/members. |
Confirmed that schemes require an arrangement with creditors or members involving compromise or arrangement. |
| Re Midland Coal, Coke & Iron Company [1895] 1 Ch 267 |
Broad definition of "creditor" including contingent pecuniary claims. |
Supported that contingent claims qualify as creditors for scheme purposes. |
| Re T&N Ltd [2005] EWHC 2870 (Ch) |
Creditors include those with contingent claims for damages; schemes can affect rights against third parties. |
Held that arrangement must be with creditors in their capacity as creditors; rights against third parties can be included if connected. |
| Sinclair v Wilson (1855) 20 Beav. 324 |
Trustee-beneficiary relationship distinct from debtor-creditor; restoration of trust property not a fraudulent preference to creditor. |
Supported distinction between proprietary and creditor rights. |
| Re Empire Mining Company (1890) 44 Ch D 402 |
Debenture-holders are creditors; scheme jurisdiction includes secured creditors. |
Confirmed court's power to bind secured creditors in schemes affecting their security. |
| Re Alabama, New Orleans, Texas and Pacific Junction Railway Company [1891] 1 Ch 213 |
Scheme jurisdiction includes schemes affecting secured creditors' security. |
Rejected argument excluding security alteration from schemes. |
| Webb v Stenton (1883) 11 QBD 518 |
Equitable debts owed by trustee to beneficiary can be subject to garnishee orders. |
Illustrated that some monetary claims arise from trust relationships but are distinct from proprietary rights. |
| Sharp v Jackson [1899] AC 419 |
Beneficiary's claims against insolvent trustee for breach of trust constitute debtor-creditor relationship. |
Distinguished proprietary rights from monetary claims arising from breach of trust. |
| Barclays Bank Ltd v Quistclose Investments Ltd [1970] AC 567 |
Trust property is excluded from the trustee's estate and is held for the beneficiary's benefit. |
Supported the principle that trust property does not form part of the insolvent estate. |
| Re Savoy Hotel Ltd [1981] Ch 351 |
Wide meaning of "arrangement" in scheme context. |
Confirmed liberal construction of "arrangement". |
| Sea Assets Ltd v PT Garuda Indonesia [2001] EWCA Civ 1696 |
Encouraged broad meaning of creditors to facilitate financial rehabilitation. |
Supported wide creditor definition in scheme context. |
| Re Opes Prime Stockbroking Ltd [2009] FCAFC 125 (Australia) |
Schemes can include release of third party claims related to creditors' claims against the company. |
Approved scheme releasing claims against third parties as part of arrangement with creditors. |
| City of Swan v Lehman Bros Australia Ltd [2009] FCAFC 130 (Australia) |
Deed of company arrangement binds only claims against the company, not third parties. |
Distinguished from scheme jurisdiction; more restrictive approach to third party claims. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the statutory framework under Part 26 of the Companies Act 2006, focusing on the meaning of "creditor" and "arrangement" within section 895. It acknowledged the broad and liberal construction historically given to these terms but emphasized that the jurisdiction to sanction a scheme is limited to arrangements between a company and its creditors or members.
The court accepted that creditors include those with contingent pecuniary claims but distinguished these from beneficiaries who hold proprietary rights in trust property. It held that a beneficiary under a trust is not, by virtue of that status, a creditor of the trustee company. The trust property is held separately and does not form part of the company's estate, and the beneficiary's proprietary rights cannot be extinguished or varied under a scheme of arrangement.
While monetary claims arising from breaches of trust may render a beneficiary a creditor in respect of those claims, the proprietary rights themselves are distinct and not subject to the scheme jurisdiction. The court rejected the argument that a person who is both a beneficiary and a creditor could have their proprietary rights included in the scheme by virtue of their creditor status.
The court also distinguished the rights of secured creditors, whose security interests are parasitic on debts, from proprietary claims over trust property. It concluded that schemes of arrangement can vary debts and liabilities owed by the company but cannot extend to property held in trust for the benefit of others.
Precedents from both UK and Australian jurisdictions were considered, with the court noting that while schemes may include rights against third parties closely connected to creditors' claims, this does not extend to proprietary rights in trust property held by the company.
In sum, the court found that the statutory language, historical context, and equitable principles preclude the court from sanctioning a scheme under Part 26 that affects proprietary rights held by beneficiaries over trust property held by the company.
Holding and Implications
The court DISMISSED the appeal, affirming the decision that it lacks jurisdiction under Part 26 of the Companies Act 2006 to sanction a scheme of arrangement insofar as it affects proprietary rights over trust property held by the company.
The direct consequence is that the administrators cannot use the scheme jurisdiction to extinguish or vary proprietary rights of beneficiaries in LBIE's trust assets. The ruling preserves the established distinction between creditors' pecuniary claims and beneficiaries' proprietary rights, maintaining trust protections in insolvency.
No new precedent was established beyond affirming the existing legal principle that schemes of arrangement under Part 26 do not extend to trust property rights. The court suggested that administrators may need to seek relief under the Trustee Acts or equitable jurisdiction to deal with beneficiaries' rights practically and fairly.