Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation & Ors v. Sky UK Ltd & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants, members of an international motion picture association holding copyrights in numerous films and television programmes, sought an order under section 97A of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988, commonly known as a website blocking order. The defendants are the principal internet service providers (ISPs) in the United Kingdom, who did not oppose the orders sought. The proceedings were initiated by a Part 7 claim on 23rd December 2014, with an application notice filed the same day to bring the matter before the court. Typically, once a section 97A order is granted, the proceedings conclude.

The court referenced a series of prior High Court judgments that established the jurisdiction and considerations for granting such orders, including cases concerning streaming and BitTorrent websites. The current application involved blocking access to nine different websites, categorized into streaming sites, BitTorrent sites, and a third category referred to as "Popcorn Time" type sites, which operate differently from the former two.

While the ISPs did not oppose the application, the court determined that the issues raised by the Popcorn Time sites were novel and required a hearing rather than being dealt with on paper. The hearing clarified technical aspects of these sites and their operation, revealing complexities not previously addressed in similar cases.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court has jurisdiction under section 97A of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 to make the website blocking order against the target websites.
  2. Whether the operators of the target websites infringe copyright through (a) communication to the public, (b) authorisation of infringement, or (c) joint tortfeasance.
  3. Whether the operators of the target websites use the services of the ISPs to commit copyright infringement.
  4. Whether the proposed blocking order is proportionate and appropriate in the exercise of the court’s discretion.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimants' Arguments

  • The claimants argued that the operators of the target websites infringe copyright through three legal bases: communication to the public, authorisation, and joint tortfeasance.
  • In relation to communication to the public, the claimants submitted that the operators of all target websites facilitate access to copyrighted works by cataloguing and indexing infringing content, similar to previous cases involving streaming and BitTorrent sites.
  • Regarding authorisation, the claimants contended that the operators of the Popcorn Time application supplier sites (PTAS and SUI) authorise infringement by enabling users to access protected works hosted on other sites.
  • They further submitted that the operators of the Popcorn Time sites are jointly liable as tortfeasors with the operators of the host websites that actually communicate the infringing content.
  • The claimants sought a blocking order aimed at both preventing users from downloading the Popcorn Time application and interfering with the operation of already downloaded applications.

Defendants' Position

  • The ISPs did not oppose the application or the form of the order sought and did not attend the hearing.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp v British Telecommunications plc [2011] EWHC 1981 (Ch) Principles for granting s97A website blocking orders and liability of site operators for copyright infringement. Used to establish the jurisdiction and legal framework for website blocking orders and to compare the current sites with previously adjudicated sites.
Dramatico Entertainment Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2012] EWHC 268 (Ch) Application of copyright infringement principles to BitTorrent sites and authorisation liability. Referenced to illustrate how BitTorrent sites facilitate infringement and the operators’ liability.
EMI Records Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 379 (Ch) Communication to the public and authorisation in the context of website blocking. Applied to affirm infringement by operators of BitTorrent sites and streaming sites providing access to infringing content.
Football Association Premier League Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 2058 (Ch) Infringement by streaming sites and use of ISPs’ services for infringement. Used to analyze streaming sites’ liability and the role of ISPs in facilitating infringement.
Paramount Home Entertainment International Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 3479 (Ch) Application of s97A and principles of communication to the public, authorisation, and joint tortfeasance. Provided guidance on blocking orders and liability of streaming sites and operators.
Case C-466/12 Svensson v Retriever Sverige AB [2014] EU:C:2014:76 Interpretation of "communication to the public" under EU copyright law. Considered in relation to the operation of Popcorn Time sites and their classification under communication to the public.
CBS v Amstrad [1988] AC 1013 Principles of authorisation liability in copyright infringement. Applied to assess whether operators of Popcorn Time supplier sites authorise infringing acts by users.
20C Fox v Newzbin [2010] EWHC 608 (Ch) Communication to the public and joint tortfeasance in copyright infringement. Used to compare and analyze the liability of operators providing access and indexing to infringing content.
L'Oreal v eBay [2009] EWHC 1094 (Ch) Limits on joint tortfeasance liability for website operators. Referenced to clarify the threshold for joint tortfeasor liability.
Football Dataco v Stan James [2013] EWCA Civ 27 Joint tortfeasance and common design in copyright infringement. Considered in determining joint liability of Popcorn Time site operators with host website operators.
UPC v Constantin Case C-314/12 Use of ISP services in infringement and scope of liability. Applied to affirm that ISPs provide essential services facilitating infringement.
LSG v Tele 2 Case C-557/07 Role of intermediaries in infringement under EU law. Considered in the context of ISP liability and blocking orders.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by confirming the jurisdiction under section 97A of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988, noting that the ISPs are service providers, and that the methods of putting them on notice had been established in prior cases. The main issues concerned whether the operators of the target websites infringe copyright and whether they use the ISPs’ services to do so.

Regarding infringement, the court analyzed three legal bases: communication to the public, authorisation, and joint tortfeasance.

For communication to the public, the court distinguished the Popcorn Time sites from previously litigated streaming and BitTorrent sites. Unlike those sites, Popcorn Time applications operate on users’ computers, presenting catalogued content via the application itself rather than the websites. The court found that the PTAS websites merely provide the application as a tool and do not themselves communicate copyrighted works. Similarly, SUI sites provide index data but do not communicate directly to the public. Therefore, the court was not satisfied that these operators commit acts of communication to the public.

On authorisation, the court acknowledged that the Popcorn Time application suppliers provide a tool that inevitably facilitates infringement, retaining control over indexing and updates, and taking no steps to prevent infringement. However, the claimants did not establish a case that these suppliers authorise the infringing acts of host website operators. The relationship between Popcorn Time suppliers and host website operators was insufficiently evidenced to prove authorisation liability.

On joint tortfeasance, the court found that the suppliers of Popcorn Time applications act jointly with the operators of the host websites. The application is the key means by which users access infringing content, and the suppliers knowingly and intentionally facilitate this. The court concluded that the suppliers share a common design with host website operators to infringe copyright and are jointly liable.

Concerning use of the ISPs’ services, the court relied on previous authorities establishing that target website operators use ISP services to infringe copyright. The same reasoning applied to the Popcorn Time sites, whose operators use the ISPs’ infrastructure to carry out infringing acts.

Having established jurisdiction and liability, the court considered proportionality and discretion. It found no general difficulty in granting the blocking order. A specific issue was clarifying that the order should both prevent users from obtaining the Popcorn Time application and interfere with existing applications’ operation. The court was satisfied the order would achieve both objectives.

The court also addressed the form of the order, allowing the claimants to update IP addresses and URLs subject to limitations, reflecting the dynamic nature of the Popcorn Time ecosystem. Confidential aspects of the order were acknowledged but not detailed in the judgment.

Holding and Implications

The court GRANTED the application for a website blocking order under section 97A of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988.

The order requires the ISPs to block access to the specified target websites, including both the Popcorn Time application supplier sites and associated update index sites, as well as host websites facilitating copyright infringement. The order permits the claimants to update the list of blocked IP addresses and URLs within defined limits to address the evolving nature of the infringing services.

The direct effect of this decision is to impose technical measures on ISPs to restrict access to infringing content and tools facilitating infringement. The court emphasized that the Popcorn Time application has no legitimate purpose and that the blocking order is a proper exercise of the court’s powers. No broader legal precedent beyond the application of existing principles to the novel Popcorn Time context was established.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation & Ors v Sky UK Ltd & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation & Ors v Sky UK Ltd & Ors
(Apr 28, 2015)