Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Plaintiff, was employed by Company A from November 2001 until his dismissal for redundancy effective 18 April 2006. He brought claims to the Employment Tribunal alleging unfair dismissal, race discrimination, and breach of contract. The Tribunal found all claims established against Company A and also found that the second respondent, Defendant, was liable for race discrimination related to the dismissal. Initial brief reasons were given in December 2006, but formal reasons were delayed until August 2007. Remedies hearings concluded in late August 2007, with judgment and reasons sent in November 2007.
The Tribunal awarded Plaintiff compensation of approximately £2,794,962 plus interest, based on the premise that Plaintiff would never again be able to work in his chosen financial services field. The award included compensation for refusal to comply with an order for reinstatement, injured feelings, and a 2% uplift under section 31 of the Employment Act 2002. The Tribunal held that the size of the award was an exceptional circumstance justifying a lower uplift than the statutory minimum of 10%.
Company A appealed both liability and remedy aspects; Plaintiff cross-appealed the limited uplift. The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) rejected the liability appeal but upheld parts of Company A's remedy appeal and dismissed Plaintiff's cross-appeal on uplift, remitting the matter for reassessment of compensation. Plaintiff now appeals the remedies decision, seeking to restore the original Tribunal judgment and challenging the limitation of the uplift to 2%. Company A no longer disputes liability but contends the reassessment should be conducted by a fresh tribunal for fairness.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Tribunal ought to have reduced compensation to reflect the chance that Plaintiff would have been dismissed for redundancy in any event.
- Whether the Tribunal ought to have limited future compensation to the period Plaintiff would have remained employed with Company A.
- Whether Company A should be liable for "stigma" losses caused by third-party employers refusing Plaintiff employment due to his legal proceedings.
- Whether the 2% uplift was consistent with statutory requirements under the Employment Act 2002.
- Whether the matter should be remitted to the same or a differently constituted tribunal.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Damages must represent the full loss flowing from the unlawful dismissal; it is wrong to reduce damages by considering the possibility Plaintiff would have been dismissed lawfully in any event.
- The Tribunal was not entitled to limit the uplift to 2%; it should have been at least the statutory minimum of 10% or higher.
- Stigma loss should be recoverable as a direct consequence of the discriminatory dismissal.
- The matter should be remitted to the same Tribunal for reassessment of compensation.
Respondent's Arguments
- The EAT was correct to apply a "Polkey" or equivalent principle, reducing damages to reflect the chance Plaintiff would have been dismissed lawfully in any event.
- Future loss should be limited to the period Plaintiff would have remained employed with Company A.
- Company A should not be liable for stigma losses caused by third-party employers' unlawful refusal to employ Plaintiff; such losses are too remote and constitute a break in the chain of causation.
- The reassessment of compensation should be conducted by a fresh tribunal to ensure fairness and avoid perceived bias.
- The 2% uplift was appropriate given the exceptional size of the award, avoiding disproportionate penalties.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Co (1880) 5 App. Cas. 25 |
Measure of damages in tort to restore injured party to position before the wrong. |
Used as the classic formulation for assessing compensation flowing directly and naturally from the unlawful act. |
| Essa v Laing Ltd [2004] IRLR 313 |
Confirmed no requirement of reasonable foreseeability in statutory tort; damage must flow directly and naturally. |
Supported the approach that compensation should reflect actual loss flowing from discrimination without adding foreseeability tests. |
| Polkey v A E Dayton Services Ltd [1988] AC 344 |
In unfair dismissal, compensation is reduced by the chance dismissal would have occurred lawfully anyway. |
EAT applied an analogous principle to discrimination claims to assess future loss by factoring in chance of lawful dismissal. |
| Marshall v Southampton and South West Hampshire Area Health Authority [1986] ICR 335 |
EU law principle requiring full compensation for loss flowing from unlawful act. |
Appellant relied on this to argue against reduction of damages for chance of lawful dismissal; court found this consistent with tort principles. |
| Malik v Bank of England (Bank of Credit & Commerce International SA) [1997] ICR 606 |
Employer liable for stigma loss arising from dishonesty affecting employee's reputation and employability. |
Distinguished stigma arising from employer's own unlawful acts from stigma caused by third-party employers' unlawful refusal to employ. |
| Kuwait Airways Corpn v Iraqi Airways Co [2002] AC 883 |
Policy judgments on extent of liability for consequences including causation and remoteness. |
Referenced to explain limitations on recovery and remoteness of stigma losses caused by third parties. |
| Redcar and Cleveland Council v Bainbridge [2008] IRLR 776 |
Uplift under Employment Act 2002 as incentive to use statutory dispute procedures. |
Supported the view that exceptional circumstances may justify reducing uplift below statutory minimum. |
| Allied Maples Group v Simmons [1995] 1 WLR 1602 |
Assessment of damages for future loss based on degree of chance, not balance of probabilities. |
Court accepted that future loss should be assessed on chance, but found no material error in Tribunal's approach given facts. |
| Ministry of Defence v Cannock [1994] ICR 918 |
Endorsed chance-based approach to assessment of future loss in discrimination cases. |
Supported the principle that compensation should reflect probabilistic assessment of future events. |
| Vento v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire Police (no. 2) [2003] ICR 318 |
Guidance on assessing compensation for injury to feelings in discrimination claims. |
Referenced to support principles of compensation assessment in discrimination context. |
| Smith v Manchester Corporation [1974] 1 K.I.R. 1 |
Lump sum awards for future disadvantage on labour market in personal injury cases. |
Analogous to awarding lump sum for stigma loss where stigma is a distinct head of future loss. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by affirming that compensation for race discrimination must be assessed on tort principles, focusing on the loss flowing "directly and naturally" from the unlawful act. It rejected the appellant’s argument that damages should not be reduced by considering the possibility that Plaintiff would have been dismissed lawfully in any event. The court held that the correct approach is to assess what would have happened had there been no unlawful discrimination, including the chance of lawful dismissal, and to factor that chance into the compensation calculation.
The court examined the Tribunal’s approach to limiting future loss to the period Plaintiff would have remained with Company A and found this approach erroneous. It emphasized that the discriminatory dismissal altered Plaintiff’s entire career trajectory, not merely his employment with Company A. Therefore, future loss should encompass the broader impact on Plaintiff’s career prospects, including time spent seeking equivalent employment elsewhere.
On the issue of stigma loss caused by third-party employers refusing to hire Plaintiff due to his legal proceedings, the court rejected the EAT’s conclusion that such loss was too remote. It held that stigma loss is recoverable as a direct and natural consequence of the discriminatory dismissal. The court recognized practical difficulties in proving stigma loss but concluded that the original employer remains liable for these losses, including where third parties act unlawfully by victimizing the claimant.
The court also addressed the statutory uplift for failure to comply with dismissal procedures. It agreed that the exceptional size of the compensation award could justify a reduced uplift below the statutory minimum, but noted that if the compensation sum is reduced on remission, the Tribunal may reconsider the appropriate uplift level.
Finally, regarding whether the matter should be remitted to the same or a fresh tribunal, the court found no error in the EAT’s decision to remit to the same Tribunal. It acknowledged arguments both for and against but concluded the decision was within the EAT’s discretion.
Holding and Implications
The court partially upheld the appeal. It held that the EAT erred in limiting future loss to the period Plaintiff would have remained with Company A and in denying recoverability of stigma loss. The court confirmed that compensation must reflect the broader career impact of discriminatory dismissal and that stigma loss caused by third-party unlawful conduct is recoverable from the original employer.
However, the court upheld the EAT’s decision that compensation should be reduced to reflect the chance Plaintiff would have been dismissed lawfully in any event, and that the 2% uplift was a permissible exercise of discretion given the award size.
The case is remitted to the same Tribunal to reassess compensation considering these principles, including the chance of lawful dismissal and the appropriate uplift. The Tribunal may also need to consider further evidence on these issues.
No new precedent was established beyond clarifying the application of existing tort and discrimination compensation principles to stigma loss and the assessment of future loss.