AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    RAJ KUMAR TRIPATHI v. NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ELECTRONICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY

    1

    CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

    PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

    OA No. 2723/2026

    Reserved on: 16.09.2026 Pronounced on: 29.09.2026 Hon'ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J) Hon'ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A)

    RAJ KUMAR TRIPATHI

    Aged about 53 years, S/o Late Shri Mohan Lal Tripathi, R/o A-I/02, Ramkrishan Apartments, Plot No. 12, Sector-23, Dwarka, New Delhi-110077. ... APPLICANT (By Advocates: Mr. A.K. Behera, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Yogesh Kr. Mahur, Mr. Harkesh Parashar, Mr. Suryanarayanan)

    VERSUS

    1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, Government of India,

    Electronics Niketan, 6, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.

    2. The Director General, National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology

    (NIELIT),

    NIELIT Bhawan, Plot No. 3, Headquarters, Sector-8, Dwarka, New Delhi-110077.

    3. The Registrar, National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology

    (NIELIT),

    NIELIT Bhawan, Plot No. 3, Headquarters, Sector-8, Dwarka, New Delhi-110077.

    4. The Chief Vigilance Officer, National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology

    (NIELIT),

    NIELIT Bhawan, Plot No. 3, Headquarters, Sector-8, Dwarka, New Delhi-110077.

    5. The Director-in-Charge, National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology

    (NIELIT),

    NIELIT Delhi Centre, 16/1-2, Pankha Road, Near Sagarpur Police Station, D-Block, Janakpuri, New Delhi-110058.

    2

    6. Shri Madan Mohan Tripathi, Director General, in his personal capacity, National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology

    (NIELIT),

    NIELIT Bhawan, Plot No. 3, Headquarters, Sector-8, Dwarka, New Delhi-110077.

    ... RESPONDENTS

    (By Advocates: Mr. UN Singh, Mr. Saket Suman Assistant Director (Admn.) for Respondents 2 to 6. )

    3

    ORDER

    Per Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A):

    The Applicant, a Joint Director (Finance) in NIELIT, was posted at NIELIT Headquarters, New Delhi in 2022 and was also entrusted with the additional charge of Chief Financial Officer with effect from 31.12.2023. He states that he has an unblemished service record and was assessed as "Outstanding" in his APARs for the years 2020 to 2023. In May 2025, while functioning as CFO-in-Charge, he recorded his dissent in an official matter concerning deduction of tax at source. Thereafter, he was transferred from NIELIT Headquarters, New Delhi to NIELIT Aurangabad by order dated 30.05.2025. He challenged the said transfer before this Tribunal in O.A. No. 2289/2025 and obtained interim protection. During the pendency of the proceedings, the Respondents modified the transfer and, by Office Order dated 16.07.2025, retained the Applicant at NIELIT Delhi Centre, pursuant to which the proceedings were disposed of on 23.07.2025.

    2. On 03.06.2025, the Respondents also constituted a two-member Fact-Finding Committee regarding certain financial transactions. The Applicant raised objections regarding the scope and manner of the inquiry and sought the material relied upon by the Committee. The Committee Report was subsequently stated to have been submitted on 01.04.2026, but the complete report and its supporting material were not supplied to the Applicant. Meanwhile, an exercise regarding manpower requirements of various NIELIT Centres was undertaken and a committee was constituted to assess functional requirements and deployment of employees. Thereafter, on 24.03.2026, the Respondents

    4

    again transferred the Applicant from NIELIT Delhi Centre to NIELIT Aurangabad. Although the order contemplated relieving him by 06.04.2026, he was relieved on 30.03.2026, the same date on which he submitted a representation seeking cancellation of the transfer.

    3. The Applicant approached this Tribunal in O.A. No. 1225/2026. By order dated 08.07.2026, the Tribunal quashed the premature relieving order dated 30.03.2026 and directed the Respondents to consider and decide the Applicant's representation dated 30.03.2026 by a reasoned and speaking order in accordance with the applicable Transfer Policy and rules. The Applicant was protected until such decision, with liberty to avail legal remedies in case of an adverse decision. The Applicant thereafter filed a Review Application No. 88/2026 concerning certain findings relating to the transfer order dated 24.03.2026, which was dismissed by this Tribunal vide order dated 07.08.2026. In the meantime, the Respondents passed the impugned Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 rejecting the Applicant's representation and affirming the transfer order dated 24.03.2026, which has led to the filing of the present OA.

    4. Learned counsel for the Applicant submits that the impugned Speaking Order has not complied with the directions of this Tribunal dated 08.07.2026 requiring an independent, objective and reasoned consideration of the Applicant's representation. Instead, the Competent Authority has treated the transfer as having already been upheld by the Tribunal and has described the Applicant's contentions as insignificant, thereby rendering the directed reconsideration an empty formality.

    5

    5. It is submitted that the Tribunal had interfered with the premature relieving order and had directed consideration of the representation, while expressly preserving the Applicant's right to avail further remedies, and therefore the said order could not have been treated as a final affirmation of the transfer.

    6. Learned counsel further submits that the Applicant was again transferred to the very same station, namely Aurangabad, within approximately eight months of being retained at Delhi pursuant to the earlier litigation, and that the Speaking Authority failed to properly consider the stability and tenure provisions of the NIELIT Transfer Policy, 2022. It is argued that the alleged administrative or manpower requirement at Aurangabad has not been established through any complete or comparative assessment of sanctioned strength, working strength, vacancies or the officers considered for transfer. The records variously refer to a Finance requirement, an Assistant Director (Finance) or above, and a Joint Director (Finance) vacancy, without explaining the precise requirement or the basis for selecting the Applicant.

    7. Learned counsel also submits that the Respondents have relied upon the Fact-Finding Committee Report, particularly paragraph 11 thereof, even though the complete report, its annexures, statements and relied-upon material were never supplied to the Applicant despite his specific requests. It is contended that the Report was submitted only on 01.04.2026, after the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026, and therefore could not have constituted the contemporaneous basis for the original transfer and could not subsequently be relied upon to justify an earlier decision. The Applicant contends that material relied upon adversely

    6

    against him could not have been used without giving him an effective opportunity to respond.

    8. It is further submitted that the impugned Speaking Order is internally contradictory and reflects non-application of mind, as it simultaneously treats the transfer issue as already concluded and claims to have independently considered the Applicant's representation and departmental material. According to learned counsel, the reasons contained in the Speaking Order itself must sustain the decision and the deficiencies therein cannot subsequently be cured by additional reasons in the counter affidavit. Learned counsel accordingly submits that the impugned Speaking Order suffers from failure of independent consideration, non-disclosure of material relied upon, inadequate manpower justification and violation of the applicable Transfer Policy, and consequently the consequential implementation of the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 is liable to be interfered with by this Tribunal.

    9. Learned counsel for the respondents has filed the short counter affidavit and submitted that the present Original Application has been filed by the applicant challenging the Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 passed by the competent authority and that, in substance, the applicant is seeking to reopen the issue relating to the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026, which had already been adjudicated upon by this Hon'ble Tribunal in O.A. No.1225/2026 vide order dated 08.07.2026. Learned counsel submits that this Hon'ble Tribunal, while deciding the earlier O.A., had specifically held that transfer is an incident of service and that an employee holding a transferable post has no vested right to remain posted at a particular station. It was further held that the scope of

    7

    judicial review in matters of transfer is limited to cases involving mala fides, violation of statutory provisions, lack of competence or such gross arbitrariness as would offend Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Learned counsel submits that this Hon'ble Tribunal had considered the respondents' case regarding organization-wide manpower rationalization and the acute requirement of experienced finance personnel at NIELIT Aurangabad and had declined to interfere with the transfer order on the ground of mala fides or punitive character. He further submits that the respondents have relied upon various judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, including Shilpi Bose vs. State of Bihar, Union of India vs. S.L. Abbas, Major General J.K. Bansal vs. Union of India, State of M.P. vs. S.S. Kourav, State of U.P. vs. Siya Ram, State of U.P. vs. Gobardhan Lal, Union of India vs. H.N. Kritania, Gujarat Electricity Board vs. Atmaram Poshani, National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. vs. Shri Bhagwan, S.C. Saxena vs. Union of India, Mohd. Masood Ahmed vs. State of U.P., Rajendra Singh vs. State of U.P. and Registrar General, High Court of Judicature of Madras vs. R. Perachi, which lay down the settled principles governing judicial interference in transfer matters. Learned counsel submits that, in view of the aforesaid principles, the Hon'ble Tribunal, while disposing of the earlier O.A., had specifically declined to quash the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 and had only directed the respondents to consider the applicant's representation in accordance with law before giving effect to the transfer, while setting aside the consequential relieving order dated 30.03.2026. It is submitted that the respondents duly complied with the said direction and the competent authority passed the reasoned Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 rejecting the applicant's representation. Learned counsel

    8

    further submits that the Transfer Policy, 2022, notified on 13.09.2022 and clarified subsequently, governs transfers in NIELIT and confers discretion upon the competent authority to deploy officers anywhere in India in public interest. He submits that the applicant had also accepted, at the time of promotion to the post of Joint Director (Finance), the condition that he could be transferred anywhere in India in organizational interest.

    10. Learned counsel further submits that NIELIT is an autonomous scientific society under the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology and operates through a nationwide network of centres, and that, in view of its expanding activities, there was an administrative necessity for rationalization and reshuffling of manpower. Accordingly, an exercise was undertaken by obtaining manpower requirements from various centres, followed by constitution of a Committee vide Office Order dated 17.03.2026 to assess functional requirements, examine manpower deployment and recommend rational reshuffling of officers. Pursuant thereto, the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 was issued whereby thirteen officers were transferred across various centres, including the applicant, who was transferred from NIELIT Delhi to NIELIT Aurangabad. Learned counsel submits that the transfer was made in public interest and administrative exigency and was not directed against the applicant individually. It is submitted that the post of Joint Director (Finance)/Finance Officer at NIELIT Aurangabad had remained vacant since 01.07.2024 and that the said centre caters to several States and Union Territories and was facing an acute shortage of manpower in its Finance Division, while various projects involving substantial financial

    9

    outlay were in progress. The applicant, being a senior finance cadre officer with long experience and having also been entrusted with additional charge of Chief Financial Officer at Headquarters, was therefore considered suitable for deployment at Aurangabad in order to meet the administrative and financial requirements of the centre.

    11. Learned counsel further submits that the allegation of mala fide, colourable exercise of power or punitive intent is wholly baseless and unsupported by any cogent material. He submits that thirteen employees, including the applicant, were transferred as part of the larger administrative exercise, which itself demonstrates that the transfer was not targeted against the applicant. Learned counsel also submits that the fact-finding Committee referred to by the applicant was a general institutional exercise and was not constituted against the applicant individually, and that there was no nexus between the said Committee and the impugned transfer. He further submits that the contention regarding frequent or premature transfer is misconceived, since the applicant had continued at Delhi since 2022 pursuant to an earlier representation seeking retention till completion of his son's Class X Board examination and, therefore, the present transfer cannot be termed premature or frequent.

    12. Learned counsel further submits that other employees who were transferred pursuant to the same administrative exercise had also approached this Tribunal by raising allegations of mala fide, but their respective proceedings were either dismissed as withdrawn/not pressed and the employees thereafter complied with their transfers. He submits that these circumstances further demonstrate that the present transfer

    10

    formed part of a general administrative exercise and was not motivated by any individual or punitive consideration. Learned counsel submits that the judgment dated 08.07.2026 passed in O.A. No.1225/2026 fully governs the controversy and that this Tribunal had already declined to interfere with the transfer itself. According to learned counsel, the applicant is now attempting to convert the limited liberty granted to him to challenge the fresh Speaking Order into an appellate review of the transfer order itself, which is impermissible. He submits that the Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 duly considered the applicant's principal grounds, examined the applicable Transfer Policy, the manpower requirements and the vacancy at Aurangabad, as well as the applicant's experience in the Finance Division, and recorded reasons for rejecting the representation. Learned counsel, therefore, submits that the respondents have acted strictly in accordance with the order dated 08.07.2026 and that no ground has been made out warranting interference with the Speaking Order or the Transfer Order dated

    24.03.2026.

    13. Learned counsel for the applicant has filed the rejoinder affidavit and submitted that the Short Reply filed by the respondents is sketchy, selective and evasive and does not specifically traverse the material averments made in the Original Application. It is submitted that the present Original Application does not seek reopening of the earlier Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026, but challenges the subsequent Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 as a fresh and independent cause of action. Learned counsel further submitted that the order dated 08.07.2026 had declined interference with the transfer only "at this

    11

    stage" and had directed the respondents to consider the applicant's representation by passing a reasoned and speaking order before giving effect to the transfer; therefore, the applicant was entitled to challenge the subsequent Speaking Order. It is submitted that the respondents have failed to disclose any objective or comparative manpower assessment showing why the applicant alone, despite being a Joint Director (Finance) and holding the additional charge of CFO for all NIELIT Centres, was selected for transfer to Aurangabad, particularly when similarly placed Finance officers had not been transferred. It was further submitted that the respondents' own records do not establish any sanctioned Joint Director (Finance) post or any objective basis for selecting the applicant. Learned counsel also submitted that the alleged All India Transfer liability has been selectively invoked against the applicant, despite several other Finance cadre officers having remained at their respective stations without being transferred. It was further contended that the mandatory Handing Over/Taking Over procedure was not followed while relieving the applicant and that the complete Fact- Finding Committee Report, upon which reliance has been placed in the Speaking Order, has not been supplied to him, thereby offending the principles of natural justice. Learned counsel submitted that the cases of other transferred officers relied upon by the respondents were disposed of without adjudication on merits and are factually distinguishable. It was also submitted that the pending Review Application filed by the applicant on 16.07.2026 was not considered before passing the Speaking Order on 17.07.2026. Learned counsel accordingly submitted that the Short Reply fails to answer the specific grounds raised by the applicant and that the impugned Speaking Order suffers from non-application of

    12

    mind, procedural irregularity, reliance on undisclosed material and lack of objective and comparative assessment. The applicant therefore seeks directions for production of the relevant manpower assessment, Committee minutes and other material relied upon by the respondents and prays that the Original Application be allowed as prayed.

    14. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the pleadings available on record.

    15. The NIELIT Transfer Policy, 2022, provides that, being an organisation under the Government of India, NIELIT employees are liable for transfer from one Department/Section/Job location within the same Centre/Unit/Office or from one Centre/Unit/Office of NIELIT to another, as required by exigencies of administration. The Policy specifically provides that, considering the organizational requirements, transfer is incidental to the service of NIELIT and is not optional. The Transfer Policy constitutes executive guidelines intended to provide broad guidance while deciding transfers, keeping in view the interest of the organization, location of its Centres, skill and operational requirements and also the interest of the NIELIT staff, and does not vest any right whatsoever in an employee to remain posted at a particular station.

    16. The Policy further provides that transfers are essentially based on administrative exigencies/requirements, including shortage of manpower of a particular category and/or having a particular skill set at a specific location to match with surplus manpower of the same category and/or having the same skill set, specific manpower/skill requirements of

    13

    projects/activities at a particular location, job rotation in the interest of the Organization and Government/Statutory guidelines.

    17. Under the Implementation provisions of the Policy, Headquarters and each Centre of NIELIT are required to prepare a statement of shortage/excess manpower with justification and send the same to NIELIT Headquarters. The Competent Authority is required to analyse the manpower requirements, financial condition of the Centres, experience, capabilities and skill matrix of employees, including Technical and Non-Technical background, and thereafter make an optimal decision.

    18. The Policy further provides that whenever a transfer order is issued, the concerned employee and the relieving authority shall comply with the order. However, the employee is entitled to make a representation, with justification, to the Competent Authority against the transfer order within seven days from receipt thereof. In the event the transfer order is not stayed, modified or cancelled within fifteen days from the date of the written representation, the concerned employee and the relieving authority are required to comply with the order in accordance with the applicable rules.

    19. The aforesaid provisions of the Transfer Policy are relevant for examining whether the impugned transfer of the applicant from NIELIT Delhi to NIELIT Aurangabad was made on the basis of the administrative exigency and manpower requirements contemplated under the Policy and whether the representation of the applicant was duly considered by the Competent Authority in accordance with the said Policy.

    14

    20. The principal grievance of the applicant is against his transfer from NIELIT Delhi to NIELIT Aurangabad vide Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 and the consequential Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026.

    21. In the present case, the respondents have placed on record that an exercise for assessment and rationalization of manpower requirements at various NIELIT Centres was undertaken and a Committee was constituted for examining the functional requirements and deployment of manpower. The applicant has not been able to demonstrate that the decision taken pursuant to such exercise was actuated by any extraneous consideration or was wholly unrelated to administrative requirements. On the contrary, the material placed before us indicates that NIELIT Aurangabad had expressed a requirement for finance personnel. Significantly, even the applicant, in his earlier representation, himself stated that he was remotely overseeing the work of NIELIT Aurangabad. Further, the email dated 23.03.2026 addressed from the Aurangabad Centre records that, to ensure the smooth functioning of the office, it was requested that one regular officer at the level of Assistant Director (Finance) or above and one regular officer at the level of Scientist-D may be deputed. Thus, the requirement of strengthening the financial and administrative functioning of the Aurangabad Centre cannot be said to be wholly without basis. The fact that the requirement was expressed in terms of an officer at the level of Assistant Director (Finance) or above cannot, by itself, render the subsequent decision to deploy a Joint Director (Finance) illegal, particularly when the competent authority was required to determine the appropriate deployment having

    15

    regard to the organizational requirements and the availability and suitability of officers.

    22. We are also unable to accept the contention that the transfer can be interfered with merely because the applicant was earlier retained at Delhi or because he was again transferred to Aurangabad. The Transfer Policy itself does not create an indefeasible right to a particular station or prescribe an absolute immunity from transfer after a particular period. The applicant had accepted the liability attached to his post of being transferred in accordance with the organizational requirements of NIELIT. The consideration whether a particular Centre requires a particular category or level of officer, and which officer is best suited to meet such requirement, primarily falls within the domain of the administration and the Committee constituted for the said purpose. This Tribunal, exercising judicial review, cannot substitute its own assessment of administrative requirements for that of the competent authority or step into the shoes of the expert/administrative Committee.

    23. The contention regarding mala fides also does not persuade us. Mala fides cannot be inferred merely from the fact that the applicant has been transferred to the same station earlier proposed for him or from the fact that Respondent No.5 was associated with the decision-making process. The material on record shows that the decision was not the individual decision of Respondent No.5 alone but was taken by a duly constituted Committee consisting of more than one member, and the decision of the Committee was unanimous. In such circumstances, the allegation that the transfer was the result of the personal mala fides of Respondent No.5 alone cannot be sustained in the absence of specific

    16

    and cogent material demonstrating that the other members of the Committee acted at his instance or that the unanimous decision of the Committee was vitiated by any extraneous consideration. The fact- finding proceedings relied upon by the applicant also do not, by themselves, establish any nexus between the said proceedings and the impugned transfer, particularly when the transfer formed part of a wider exercise involving several officers.

    24. We are conscious of the submission that the applicant has an otherwise unblemished service record and that he had been assessed highly in his APARs. However, such considerations, though relevant to his service career, do not confer a right to remain posted at a particular place. A transfer is ordinarily an incident of service, and unless the order is shown to be contrary to a statutory provision, issued by an incompetent authority, vitiated by established mala fides, or so arbitrary as to warrant judicial interference, the Tribunal would not substitute its own view for that of the administrative authority. The applicant has not been able to establish any such circumstance in the present case.

    25. The reliance placed by the applicant upon the alleged deficiencies in the manpower assessment also does not warrant interference. The Court or Tribunal is not required to undertake a comparative assessment of the manpower requirements of every NIELIT Centre or to determine whether Delhi or Aurangabad requires a Joint Director (Finance) as against an Assistant Director (Finance). Such an exercise is essentially administrative in nature and falls within the competence of the organization and the Committee constituted for assessing functional requirements and manpower deployment. So long as the decision is

    17

    founded upon a discernible administrative requirement and is not shown to be a colourable exercise of power or actuated by mala fides, the Tribunal cannot sit as an appellate authority over such administrative assessment. In the present case, the requirement of finance personnel at Aurangabad is supported by the communication dated 23.03.2026, and the applicant himself had acknowledged that he was remotely overseeing the work of the said Centre.

    26. As regards the order dated 08.07.2026 passed in O.A. No.1225/2026, it is evident that the Tribunal had declined to quash the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 and had interfered with the consequential relieving order dated 30.03.2026, while directing consideration of the applicant's representation in accordance with the Transfer Policy. The respondents thereafter considered the representation and passed the Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026. The present proceedings cannot be converted into an appeal over the administrative decision taken pursuant to the said direction. The limited judicial scrutiny available at this stage is to examine whether the competent authority acted within the framework of the applicable policy and whether the decision suffers from such illegality, mala fides or patent arbitrariness as would justify interference. We find no such infirmity established on the material before us.

    26. As regards the prayer of the applicant for production of the complete Fact-Finding Committee Report and the material relied upon by the respondents, we are not inclined to call for the same in the facts of the present case. The controversy before us essentially relates to the transfer of the applicant, which is an incident of service, and the

    18

    respondents have placed on record the administrative basis and manpower requirement for his deployment at NIELIT Aurangabad. In these circumstances, for examining the validity of the transfer, we do not consider it necessary to call for the complete Fact-Finding Committee Report, particularly when no disciplinary action against the applicant is the subject matter of the present proceedings.

    27. It is also relevant to note that, in W.P.(C) No. 12160/2026, the Hon'ble High Court, vide order dated 08.09.2026, clarified that while adjudicating the subsequent O.A. pending before the Tribunal, the Tribunal shall proceed uninfluenced by any observations adverse to the petitioner contained in the orders dated 08.07.2026 passed in O.A. No. 1225/2026 and 07.08.2026 passed in R.A. No. 88/2026. The Hon'ble High Court further made it clear that it was not expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, which were left open for consideration by the Tribunal holistically.

    28. The allegation that the respondents have selectively invoked the All India Transfer liability against the applicant also does not, by itself, establish mala fides. The fact that other officers may not have been transferred cannot create a vested right in favour of the applicant to remain at Delhi. Administrative authorities are required to consider the functional requirements of different Centres, the nature of duties, availability of personnel and organizational exigencies at the relevant point of time. The applicant has not placed sufficient material to establish that the decision to transfer him was wholly unrelated to such considerations.

    19

    29. We therefore find that the impugned Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026 was issued in the context of an administrative exercise for rationalization and deployment of manpower, that the requirement at NIELIT Aurangabad had contemporaneous administrative basis, and that the applicant has failed to establish mala fides, colourable exercise of power, violation of any statutory provision or such patent arbitrariness as would justify interference by this Tribunal. The mere fact that another view of the administrative requirement may be possible is not a ground for this Tribunal to substitute its own assessment for that of the competent authority or the duly constituted Committee. The transfer being an incident of service and there being an established administrative exigency, we see no justification to interfere with the impugned Speaking Order dated 17.07.2026 or the Transfer Order dated 24.03.2026. Accordingly, the Original Application is dismissed. Pending MA(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.

    (Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)

    Member (A) Member (J)

    /lg/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RAJ KUMAR TRIPATHI v. NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ELECTRONICS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
    (Sep 29, 2026)