Factual and Procedural Background
These connected writ petitions concern recruitment to 150 posts of Motor Vehicle Inspectors under the notification dated 04.02.2016. The petitions challenge orders of the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal (KSAT) concerning candidates’ work-experience certificates and appointment. [1][2]
Earlier, in Sri Lokesh V.R. and Others v. State of Karnataka and Others, this Court directed the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC) to consider candidates’ experience certificates under the 2016 recruitment notification and applicable rules. The KPSC thereafter issued a Revised Final Selection List dated 26.10.2023 and forwarded certificates for verification. [3][4][5][6]
The present batch includes the State’s challenge to a KSAT order holding that aggregate experience from two automobile workshops could satisfy the one-year requirement, and candidates’ challenges to rejection of their applications or non-issuance of appointment orders. [1][7][8]
The petitions were heard and reserved on 31.08.2026, and judgment was pronounced on 06.10.2026. [9][10]
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether aggregate or combined experience obtained in two or more automobile garages or workshops satisfies the prescribed one-year work-experience requirement. [11][12]
- Whether candidates could be denied appointment because their experience certificates did not show experience repairing heavy goods vehicles or heavy passenger vehicles fitted with petrol engines. [12][13]
- How candidates whose certificates were rejected following adverse verification reports should have their candidatures reconsidered. [14][15]
Arguments of the Parties
State of Karnataka and Transport Authorities
- The State contended that the applicable rules required one year’s experience in every prescribed category or class of vehicle. [7][16]
- It argued that granting relaxation would create uncertainty because candidates might have shortfalls in different vehicle categories, and that the authorities had uniformly interpreted the rules. [16][17]
- It relied on R. Vijiyaraj and Others v. D. Gautham and Others to submit that statutory requirements could not be reduced or added to except by the rule-making authority. [17][18]
Candidates
- The candidates contended that the rules did not require one year’s experience separately in each vehicle category or class. [18]
- They argued that combined experience across the prescribed categories was sufficient. [18]
- They relied on Rejanish K V v. K. Deepa and Others concerning the objective of securing the best and most suitable persons through public-service selection. [18][19]
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Sri Lokesh V.R. and Others v. State of Karnataka and Others |
The 2019 amendment removing the one-year experience prescription could not operate retrospectively against the 2016 recruitment process. |
The Court followed the earlier directions requiring consideration and verification of experience certificates under the original recruitment notification and applicable rules. [3][4][5] |
| R. Vijiyaraj and Others v. D. Gautham and Others |
Statutory qualifications must be strictly followed; requirements cannot be reduced or added to without amendment by the rule-making authority. |
The State relied on this decision, but the Court distinguished the situation by finding ambiguity in the relevant experience provision. [16][17][18] |
| Rejanish K V v. K. Deepa and Others |
The selection process should secure the best and most suitable person for public service; experience may be considered in combination where the rules so provide. |
The candidates relied on this principle in support of treating their combined experience as sufficient. [18][19] |
| Parvaiz Ahmad Parry v. State of Jammu and Kashmir and Others |
Where an advertised qualification is ambiguous or vague, the benefit should be given to the candidate rather than used to reject the candidature. |
The Court applied this principle and held that combined experience from workshops dealing with all three prescribed vehicle types could satisfy the requirement. [20][21][22] |
| In Re Presidential Poll |
The maxim lex non cogit ad impossibilia: the law does not compel performance of an impossible requirement. |
The Court held that candidates could not be rejected for lacking experience with petrol-powered heavy goods or heavy passenger vehicles when such vehicles had not existed in India for decades. [23][24][25] |
| W.P. No. 1232/2025 |
Where verification of a workshop is inadequate, the Deputy Commissioner may revisit the premises and submit a fresh report. |
The Court directed similar fresh verification in cases where supporting documents were not found during physical inspection. [26][15] |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first examined the wording of the experience requirement and found ambiguity. It held that the provision could not reasonably be read as requiring one year’s experience separately for each of the three vehicle categories. [11][20]
The Court noted that the authorities accepted a candidate who worked for more than one year in a single workshop handling all prescribed vehicle types, without requiring daily work on every type. It therefore held that combined experience from multiple workshops could satisfy the requirement where, in aggregate, the workshops dealt with all three types of vehicles and the experience exceeded one year. [20][22]
Applying the principle that ambiguity in a qualification should benefit candidates, the Court upheld the KSAT’s conclusion regarding aggregate experience. [21][22]
The Court next considered certificates referring to petrol-powered heavy goods and heavy passenger vehicles. It found that such vehicles had not existed in India for several decades and described certificates from State transport corporations asserting such experience as false and unacceptable. Conversely, candidates should not be rejected merely because their certificates truthfully omitted experience with such vehicles. [27][28]
Relying on the principle that the law does not compel the impossible, the Court held that the authorities could not insist on experience that could not realistically have been acquired. It consequently held that rejection on this ground constituted a travesty of justice. [23][25][29]
For candidates rejected after adverse verification, the Court directed reconsideration in light of its findings. Where necessary, Deputy Commissioners were required to revisit the workshops, ascertain the true facts, and submit fresh reports for consideration by the Commissioner. [14][26][15]
Holding and Implications
W.P. No. 126/2025 was dismissed. The Court thereby upheld the KSAT’s conclusion that aggregate experience could satisfy the prescribed requirement. [30]
W.P. Nos. 5483/2025, 5701/2025, 16415/2025, 27642/2025, 4958/2026 and 21767/2026 were allowed. The challenged KSAT orders were quashed and set aside where candidates had been rejected for lacking experience with petrol-powered heavy goods or heavy passenger vehicles. [31]
Where candidates appeared in the Revised Final Select List dated 26.10.2023, the Commissioner was directed to issue appointment orders, including consequential benefits and seniority in accordance with law. W.P. No. 25888/2025 was also allowed, with a direction to appoint the concerned candidate. [31][32]
Appointment orders were directed to be issued as expeditiously as possible and within two months of receiving a certified copy of the order. All pending interlocutory applications were disposed of. [33]
Show full summary ...