ORDER DATED 22.07.2021 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE OF THIS COURT IN WRIT PETITION NO.4665/2020 C/W W.P.NOS.25091/2018, 27978/2018, 31635/2019, 31698/2019, 39193/2019 AND W.P.6361/2021 (S-RES).
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR HEARING
INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS
DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
- 39 -
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN) WA No.263/2022 and WA No.757/2022 are the appeals preferred by the Mysore Medical College and Research Institute, Mysore, as against the common judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 22.07.2021 passed in W.P.No.4665/2020 and connected cases. W.A.No.371/2023 is filed by the State of Karnataka against the very same judgment.
2. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellant in the first two writ appeals as well as the learned Additional Government Advocate appearing for the appellant in WA No.371/2023 as well as the learned counsel appearing for the private respondents, who were the petitioners in the writ petitions.
3. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant in the first two writ appeals contends that the private respondents
- 40 -
who had filed the writ petitions were only stipendiary nurses engaged by the Institute for six months as part of their training and that the judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge directing their continuance as well as payment of regular wages to them was completely misconceived. It is contended that the prayer made in the writ petitions was for a mandamus to consider their representations not to terminate their services as stipendiary nurses and to renew their services from time to time as also to grant equal pay for equal work rendered by them.
4. It is contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the learned Single Judge had relied on a Government Order dated 26.02.2019 and has held that the stipendiary nurses who were engaged as trainees are also entitled to minimum wages as provided in the said Government Order. It is contended that the Government Order dated 26.02.2019 did not have any reference whatsoever to stipendiary nurses and the said order specifically provided for payment of equal wages only to contractual employees, who had been engaged by the Institute. It is submitted that since
- 41 -
there was no provision in the Government Order dated 26.02.2019 to pay the wages as provided therein to stipendiary nurses, the reliance on the said Government Order was completely misconceived.
5. It is further submitted that the Government, by the order dated 27.07.2020, had specifically fixed an amount of Rs.12,445/- as monthly payment for stipendiary nurses. It is submitted that thereafter the said amount has been increased to Rs.15,556/- by the Government Order dated 20.05.2026. It is submitted that this was the amount that the stipendiary nurses would be entitled to and the said amount was being paid to them.
6. It is further contended that the direction issued by the learned Single Judge that the writ petitioners are liable to be paid wages in terms of the Government Order dated 26.02.2019 is misconceived and that the further direction that the stipendiary nurses cannot be replaced by another set of contract employees is also not sustainable. It is submitted that since the stipendiary nurses are engaged only as trainees, they are not entitled to the regular pay scale or even to minimum
- 42 -
wages and that their services are also liable to be dispensed after the training is complete.
7. Learned Additional Government Advocate appearing for the appellant in WA No.371/2023 would also submit that from the documents on record, it would appear that the initial engagement of the writ petitioners was on stipendiary basis. It is submitted that the Government Order dated 26.02.2019 specifically addressed the problem of contract appointments in Autonomous Institutions and submits that the benefit of the said Government Order could not be extended to stipendiary nurses. Further, it is submitted that the stipendiary nurses are not entitled to continuance in service and that they cannot hold the posts which are intended to be filled up by regular appointments.
8. Learned Government Advocate would also point out that the direction issued by the learned Single Judge to continue the services of the stipendiary nurses beyond the period for which they were appointed would defeat the rights of the Institutions to train stipendiary nurses for short periods of
- 43 -
time and will result in injustice to nursing students, who relied on such Institutions to complete their training.
9. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents would on the other hand point out that the writ petitions had been filed in the year 2018-19 and 2020-21 and had been pending for a reasonable long period of time. It is submitted that the judgment under appeal was rendered on 22.07.2021. The State as well as the Autonomous Institute, which were the respondents in the writ petitions, had not placed any statement of objections on record before the learned Single Judge. It is submitted that the documents produced along with the writ petitions clearly indicated that the stipendiary nurses were those engaged from 2009 onwards and they were still in service in the year 2019. It is submitted that the experience certificates issued by the Institute showing that certain persons had been engaged in 2013 and were still in service in 2018-19 had also been placed on record before the learned Single Judge. It is submitted that it is on account of the materials placed on record before the learned Single Judge, including Annexure-G, which is a communication dated 03.10.2017
- 44 -
issued by the Institute that the learned Single Judge came to the conclusion on facts that the writ petitioners were not stipendiary nurses but were temporary employees or contractual employees at best.
10. It is submitted that the factual situation that the Institute was utilising the services of the stipendiary nurses for years together had been taken into account and the necessity for the engagement of nurses for carrying out of the essential functions of the Institute was also specifically taken note of by the learned Single Judge. It was on the basis of the documents produced that the learned Single Judge came to the factual conclusion that the engagements were actually engagements as against the required cadre strength on contract basis or on temporary basis and were not stipendiary engagements at all. It is submitted that it was on the materials placed on record that these findings were rendered by the learned Single Judge. There is still no material placed on record in either of the appeals, which would controvert the said findings of the learned Single Judge. In the circumstances, it is submitted that there is absolutely no error in the findings rendered by the learned
- 45 -
Single Judge and that the appeals are therefore liable to be dismissed.
11. We have considered the contentions advanced on all sides. We notice that the writ petitioners had specifically pleaded that they were fully qualified nurses who had been engaged by the appellant- Institute on several dates from 2009 onwards. Documents had also been placed on record showing that they were fully qualified nurses having diploma in General Nursing and Midwifery ('GNM' for short) and that they had completed their GNM courses on several dates from 2007 onwards. There were orders of appointment bearing different dates, which were also produced along with the writ petitions. Further, the copies of Certificates issued by the Institute showing that some of the writ petitioners had been working for long period sometimes more than 5 years had also been placed on record before the learned Single Judge.
12. Having considered the contentions advanced, the learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that the nomenclature of "stipendiary nurses" given to the writ petitioners was misleading and that what was actually done
- 46 -
was an exploitation of their services for long years on a contract basis or on temporary basis. It was also found that the Government having considered the demands of staff nurses working on contract or stipendiary basis in all the autonomous teaching Hospitals in the State, had issued the Government Order dated 26.02.2019, which provided for payment of equal wages for the equal work extracted from persons like the writ petitioners. It was found by the learned Single Judge that since the services of the writ petitioners was also being utilised full time, they were also entitled to payment of wages as provided in the Government Order dated 26.02.2019, even if they are called stipendiary nurses.
13. The learned Single Judge had also relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in The State of Punjab & Others
v. Jagjit Singh & Others1, wherein the Apex Court had clearly held that, even if the appointments are made on temporary basis or on contract basis, the person so employed could not be denied equal pay for equal work and that the contract
(2017) 1 SCC 148
1
- 47 -
employees would also be entitled to such wages on par with regular employees, who are made to do the same work.
14. The learned Single Judge had also relied on the decision of the Apex Court in State of Haryana & Others v. Piara Singh & Others2as also the interdictions in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi 3and had come to the conclusion that till regular appointment is made, the stipendiary nurses who are carrying out all the duties of the staff nurses in the Institute are entitled to continue in service.
15. Having considered the contentions advanced on all sides, we are of the opinion that the essential directions issued by the learned Single Judge do not require any interference. However, it is made clear that since the writ petitioners are working as against the regular posts of staff nurses which are required for the manning and the running of the Hospital, the Hospital would be free to make appointments of stipendiary nurses for the limited period of their training, in case such
3
- 48 -
issued by the learned Single Judge will not stand in the way of such short stipendiary engagements being made as trainees in the Hospital. Further, it is made clear that a regular recruitment process on the basis of the Cadre and Recruitment Rules for Staff Nurses shall be carried out at the earliest, without undue delay and when such regular recruitments are being made, the writ petitioners who have been engaged on contract basis shall also be considered for such recruitment in accordance with law, after giving them the benefit of age relaxation in terms of the service that has been rendered by them in the Institution.
16. With the above said modifications, the writ appeals are disposed of.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
Sd/-
(ANU SIVARAMAN)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(T.P.VIVEKANANDA)
JUDGE
PN