Ravindra Pratap Shahi v. State of U.P. & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The matter arises from Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 2008 pending before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, which was filed by respondent no. 2. The present proceedings before the Supreme Court are Criminal Appeal Nos. 3700–3701 of 2025 (arising out of SLP (Crl.) Nos. 4509–4510 of 2025), instituted by the appellant, Ravindra Pratap Shahi, who is described as the de-facto complainant.
The Appeals before the Supreme Court challenge interim orders dated 28.08.2024 and 09.01.2023 passed by the Allahabad High Court in Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 2008, by which that criminal appeal was not taken up for hearing.
According to the appellant, the criminal appeal filed by respondent no. 2 has been pending since 2008. During this period, the appellant moved the High Court on nine different occasions seeking early listing, hearing, and disposal of the appeal, but no final verdict was delivered. Eventually, a Division Bench of the High Court heard the matter at length and reserved the appeal for orders on 24.12.2021.
On 15.04.2025, the Supreme Court requested the High Court to decide the appeal expeditiously, preferably within three months. When the matter was heard by the Supreme Court on 27.01.2025, it directed the Registrar General of the Allahabad High Court to immediately bring the issue to the notice of the Chief Justice and to submit a report regarding the correctness of the averments made in the Appeals.
The Registrar General submitted a report dated 29.01.2025, confirming that arguments in Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 2008 were concluded and the matter was heard and reserved for orders on 24.12.2021. Since the judgment was not delivered within six months, in light of an administrative order of the Chief Justice dated 07.03.2019, the case was directed to be listed before the Regular Bench as per the roster. The matter was again placed before the Chief Justice on 19.12.2022, whereupon it was directed to be listed as per roster on 09.01.2023. On that date, no one appeared for the appellant, and the appeal was adjourned for hearing on 06.02.2023. Thereafter, on subsequent dates, the hearing did not materialise.
The Supreme Court noted, on the basis of the Registrar General’s report, that the High Court had indeed reserved judgment on 24.12.2021 but failed to deliver it, leading to a direction that the matter be relisted before a Regular Bench. The Supreme Court described it as “extremely shocking and surprising” that the judgment was not delivered for almost a year after the appeal was heard, and referred to a broader pattern of delayed pronouncement of judgments in various High Courts.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether, and how, the Supreme Court should intervene where a High Court has reserved judgment in a criminal appeal and failed to pronounce it for an inordinately long period, despite repeated attempts by the litigant to secure a decision.
- What institutional and procedural mechanisms should be reinforced or introduced, consistent with the guidelines laid down in Anil Rai v. State of Bihar, to ensure timely pronouncement of reserved judgments in the High Courts.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments (De-facto Complainant)
- The criminal appeal filed by respondent no. 2 has been pending before the Allahabad High Court since 2008, without a final decision.
- The appellant has approached the High Court on nine occasions seeking early listing, hearing, and disposal of the appeal, but the matter has remained undecided.
- Although arguments were heard at great length by a Division Bench and the appeal was reserved for judgment on 24.12.2021, no judgment has been delivered to date.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Anil Rai v. State of Bihar, (2001) 7 SCC 31 |
Addressed the problem of High Courts not pronouncing judgments for long periods after reserving them; laid down guidelines regarding timely pronouncement of reserved judgments and monitoring such delays. |
The Supreme Court quoted paragraphs 9 and 10 in detail, reciting the guidelines (including monthly lists of reserved judgments, internal monitoring by Chief Justices, and rights of parties to move applications after specified periods). The Court held that the present situation is not new and emphasized that adherence to Anil Rai is required. It reiterated these directions and supplemented them with additional monitoring directions. |
| State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagdev Singh Talwandi, (1984) 1 SCC 596 |
Deprecation of the practice by some High Courts of pronouncing final orders without immediately delivering a reasoned judgment, thereby depriving aggrieved parties of an opportunity for further judicial redressal; directions were issued against such practice. |
Cited as the leading authority where such objectionable practice was condemned and directions were first issued, which have later been restated on several occasions. |
| Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh & Anr. v. State of Gujarat & Ors., (2004) 4 SCC 158 |
Cited as one of the decisions in which the directions from Jagdev Singh Talwandi regarding pronouncing reasoned judgments were restated. |
Referenced to show that the Supreme Court has repeatedly reaffirmed the directions against pronouncing bare operative orders without timely reasons. |
| Mangat Ram v. State of Haryana, (2008) 7 SCC 96 |
Another judgment where the directions originating in Jagdev Singh Talwandi were restated. |
Used to demonstrate consistent judicial reiteration of the principle that reasoned judgments must accompany or promptly follow final orders. |
| Ajay Singh & Anr. v. State of Chhattisgarh & Anr., (2017) 3 SCC 330 |
Again cited as a decision where the directions from Jagdev Singh Talwandi were reiterated. |
Relied on as part of a line of authority reinforcing the need for timely, reasoned judgments. |
| Balaji Baliram Mupade & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., (2021) 12 SCC 603 |
One of two recent judgments reiterating the earlier directions; it concerned the same issue of delayed or unreasoned judgments. |
Cited to show that even recently the Supreme Court has had to restate these directions; the present Bench notes that one of its members (Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra) was also on that Bench. |
| Ratilal Jhaverbhai Parmar & Ors. v. State of Gujarat & Ors., 2024 INSC 801 |
Another recent decision reiterating the directions against delayed reasoned judgments. |
Referred to as part of the continuing judicial effort to enforce timely pronouncement and reasoned orders. |
| K. Madan Mohan Rao v. Bheemrao Baswanthrao Patil & Ors., 2022 INSC 1025 |
Mentioned in the same context as other decisions restating earlier directions regarding proper pronouncement of judgments. |
Used to reinforce that the Supreme Court has repeatedly addressed and deprecated practices that delay or deny reasoned judgments. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first verified the factual assertions regarding delay by directing the Registrar General of the Allahabad High Court to report on the status of Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 2008. The Registrar General’s report, dated 29.01.2025, confirmed that the appeal was heard and reserved for judgment on 24.12.2021 but no judgment was delivered, and that, pursuant to an administrative order dated 07.03.2019, the matter had to be relisted before a Regular Bench. Subsequent listing orders and adjournments were also documented, with hearings ultimately not materialising.
On this factual basis, the Court held that the Registrar General’s report supports the averments made in the Appeals: the High Court had indeed heard and reserved the criminal appeal for orders but failed to deliver a judgment, leading to its relisting before a Regular Bench. The Court characterized it as “extremely shocking and surprising” that no judgment was delivered for almost a year after the hearing concluded.
The Court situated this case within a broader systemic concern: it noted that it is “repeatedly confronted” with matters in which proceedings remain pending in High Courts for more than three months, six months, or even years after the conclusion of arguments, without pronouncement of judgments. It also observed that in most High Courts there is no mechanism enabling litigants to approach either the concerned Bench or the Chief Justice to bring such delays to notice, which in turn undermines litigants’ faith in the judicial process and “defeat[s] the ends of justice.”
To address these systemic failures, the Court revisited its earlier decision in Anil Rai v. State of Bihar. It recalled that in that case the Court had already dealt with similar situations where judgments were not pronounced for years after arguments had concluded, and had set out guidelines in paragraphs 9 and 10. The Court reproduced these guidelines in extenso, emphasizing:
- The recognition that, although no statutory time limit is fixed in the Codes of Civil or Criminal Procedure for pronouncement of judgments, justice dispensation requires judgments to be delivered without delay.
- The need for High Courts to maintain columns in judgments noting the dates of reserving and pronouncing the judgment.
- Monthly reporting by Court Officers/Readers to Chief Justices on cases where judgments have been reserved but not pronounced within the month.
- Responsibility of Chief Justices to draw the attention of Benches to judgments not pronounced within two months, and to circulate statements of such cases as needed.
- The right of parties, where judgments are not pronounced within three months from reservation, to apply for early judgment before the concerned Bench.
- The right of parties, where judgments are not pronounced within six months, to move the Chief Justice to withdraw the case and assign it to another Bench for fresh arguments.
The Court then addressed a related practice in some High Courts of pronouncing a final operative order without a reasoned judgment, with the reasons being withheld for a substantial time. Referring to State of Punjab & Ors. v. Jagdev Singh Talwandi, and to subsequent reiterations in Zahira Habibulla H. Sheikh, Mangat Ram, Ajay Singh, Balaji Baliram Mupade, Ratilal Jhaverbhai Parmar, and K. Madan Mohan Rao, the Court reiterated that such practice is improper as it deprives the aggrieved party of timely opportunity to pursue further remedies.
The Court expressly noted that the situation presented in these Appeals is not arising for the first time; directions already exist in Anil Rai. The core deficiency, in the Court’s view, lies in the lack of adherence to those directions and principles. Therefore, rather than formulating an entirely new regime, the Court chose to reiterate the earlier directions and supplement them with an institutional monitoring mechanism.
Accordingly, the Court directed that the Registrar General of each High Court must furnish to the Chief Justice of that High Court a list of cases in which judgments have been reserved but not pronounced within the remaining period of that month, and must continue to do so for three consecutive months. If, despite this, the judgment is not delivered within three months of reservation, the Registrar General must place those matters before the Chief Justice. The Chief Justice is then required to bring the delay to the notice of the concerned Bench, with a direction to pronounce the order within two weeks, failing which the matter is to be assigned to another Bench.
The Court clarified that these new directions are in addition to the guidelines and directions issued in Anil Rai, thereby strengthening, rather than replacing, the pre-existing framework.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court DISPOSED OF the Appeals with observations and directions aimed at ensuring timely pronouncement of reserved judgments by the High Courts. It:
- Reiterated the directions and guidelines previously laid down in Anil Rai v. State of Bihar regarding prompt pronouncement of judgments and mechanisms for litigants to seek relief from delay.
- Issued additional directions requiring:
- The Registrar General of each High Court to submit to the Chief Justice, every month, a list of cases in which judgment has been reserved but not pronounced within that month, continuing this process for three months.
- If a judgment is not delivered within three months of reservation, the Registrar General must place the matter before the Chief Justice.
- The Chief Justice must then bring this to the notice of the concerned Bench with a direction to pronounce the order within two weeks; if this is not done, the matter is to be assigned to another Bench.
- Directed that a copy of this judgment be circulated to the Registrar Generals of all the High Courts for compliance.
Implications: The immediate effect of this decision is to provide an institutional, time-bound mechanism for monitoring and addressing delays in pronouncement of reserved judgments in all High Courts. The judgment reinforces the obligation of Benches to deliver judgments without undue delay after reserving them, empowers Chief Justices to intervene where delays occur, and creates a clear pathway for re-assignment of matters if judgments are still not pronounced. The opinion focuses on systemic procedural reform; it does not set out or decide the substantive merits of Criminal Appeal No. 939 of 2008, and it does not purport to establish any new substantive legal doctrine beyond strengthening compliance with existing directions.
Show full summary ...