AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 KHC 3964
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2025 KHC 3964
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Basavaraddy Venkaraddy Lingadal, a retired Deputy Superintendent of Police, was convicted on 18.02.2020 by the III Additional District and Sessions Judge (Special Court) in Spl.KLA.C.C. No. 04/2013 for offences under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. He was sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for three years and fined Rs.1,00,000 (in default one year RI) and an order was made forfeiting Rs.44,06,882 as alleged disproportionate assets. The prosecution alleged that during the check period 1981–2009 the accused possessed assets valued at Rs.1,10,75,375 against known income of Rs.74,20,354, producing an excess of Rs.78,80,733 (106.20%). The appellant filed this criminal appeal under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C.; the High Court (Dharwad Bench) delivered an oral judgment allowing the appeal, setting aside the conviction and acquitting the appellant.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution established the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable doubt by proving that the accused possessed assets disproportionate to his known sources of income for the check period 1981–2009.
  2. Whether the impugned judgment of conviction passed by the trial Court is legally sustainable in view of the evidentiary record and investigation deficiencies.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Investigating officers admitted they did not calculate income, expenditure and assets for the check period and did not verify genuineness of documents; computerized documents lacked certificates under Section 65B, Indian Evidence Act; conviction based only on charge‑sheet material is arbitrary and unsustainable.
  • DW‑17 (Assistant Director of Agriculture) prepared a report assessing agricultural income at approximately Rs.1,00,00,000, but the prosecution relied instead on PW‑24's lower estimate (~Rs.32,00,000) and did not produce DW‑17's report in its case.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The charge‑sheet material together with testimonies of investigating officers and PW‑24's evidence indicate agricultural income of around Rs.32,00,000 and support the Trial Court's finding of assets disproportionate by 106.20%.
  • Documents produced by the accused do not prove an agricultural income of Rs.1,00,00,000, so the Trial Court's conclusion should be sustained.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court identified the sole issue as whether the prosecution proved disproportionate assets beyond reasonable doubt and whether the conviction is sustainable.
  • Examined competing assessments of agricultural income: PW‑24's report (Exs. P.62–P.64) estimated ~Rs.32,00,000 but PW‑24 conceded he had not considered critical factors (irrigation, soil fertility, crop protocols) and did not perform soil tests or obtain neighbour statements; thus his report lacked evidentiary value.
  • Considered DW‑17's inspection and report (Ex.P.37), which included crop‑cutting experiment, application of APMC rates, soil testing and consideration of irrigation; DW‑17's assessment placed agricultural income at approximately Rs.1,00,00,000 and the report's authenticity was not disputed on cross‑examination.
  • Noted admitted deficiencies in investigation: PW.51, PW.52 and PW.53 conceded they did not calculate income/expenditure/assets, did not verify document genuineness, did not obtain Section 65B certificates for computerized records, and failed to conduct necessary enquiries (site visits, verification of constructions, inquiries with relevant authorities).
  • Concluded that, because an additional Rs.68,00,000 should be credited to the accused's income if DW‑17's assessment is accepted, the accused's total assets fall within his known sources of income; therefore prosecution failed to establish disproportionate assets on a prima facie basis.
  • Held that the Trial Court erred by relying on charge‑sheet materials and the incomplete investigative record instead of legally admissible, corroborated evidence, noting that a charge sheet is not substantive evidence.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal allowed; impugned conviction and sentence set aside; accused acquitted.

Direct effect on parties: The judgment and sentence dated 18.02.2020 are set aside; the appellant is acquitted of the offences; bail bonds, if any, are discharged.

The opinion does not discuss broader legal implications or establish any new precedent beyond the decision in this case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    BASAVARADDY VENKARADDY LINGADAL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

    - 1 -

    NC: 2025:KHC-D:3964 CRL.A No. 100113 of 2020

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH

    DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2025

    BEFORE

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT CHANDANGOUDAR

    CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100113 OF 2020 (C)

    BETWEEN:

    BASAVARADDY VENKARADDY LINGADAL

    AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,

    OCC: RETD DY.SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE,

    R/AT: SAMPIGE NAGAR, 1STCROSS, DHARWAD. …APPELLANT

    (BY SRI. SANDESH CHOUTE, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR

    SRI. B.V.SOMAPUR AND SRI. V.M.BANAKAR, ADVOCATES)

    AND:

    THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

    KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTHA POLICE,

    R/BY LOKAYUKTA SPL.P.P.,

    HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,

    DHARWAD BENCH.

    …RESPONDENT

    (BY SRI. G.I.GACHCHINAMATH, SPP)

    THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/SEC.374(2) OF CR.P.C.,

    PRAYING TO, CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND TO ALLOW THE

    APPEAL AND SET-ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF

    CONVICTION DATED 18.02.2020 PASSED BY THE III ADDL.

    DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE (SPECIAL COURT FOR KLA/ACT & CBI CASES) DHARWAD IN SPL.KLA. C.C. NO.4/2013 (ANNEXURE-

    A) CONVICTING THE APPELLANT FOR THE OFFENCES P/U/ SEC.13(1)(e) R/W SEC.13(2) OF THE PREVENTION OF

    CORRUPTION ACT, 1988 SENTENCING HIM TO UNDERGO

    RIGOROUS IMPRISONMENT FOR A PERIOD OF THREE YEARS AND

    TO PAY FINE OF RS.1,00,000/-, IN DEFAULT TO PAY THE FINE

    AMOUNT TO UNDERGO RI FOR ONE YEAR VIS-A-VIS THE ORDER OF FORFEITING THE AMOUNT OF RS.44,06,882/- THAT IS ALLEGED

    TO BE DISPROPORTIONATE.

    - 2 -

    THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,

    JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

    CORAM: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT CHANDANGOUDAR

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    The appellant has been convicted of an offence under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and has been sentenced to three years' imprisonment.

    2. The prosecution alleges that during his tenure as a government servant from 1981 to 2009, the accused amassed substantial assets in his name, as well as in the names of his wife, children, and relatives, by engaging in criminal misconduct. The investigating agency valued the properties acquired during the relevant period at Rs.1,10,75,375, while the expenditure incurred during that period was calculated at Rs.42,25,712. The known income of the accused for the same period was determined to be Rs.74,20,354, resulting in an excess of Rs.78,80,733, which amounts to 106.20% more than his known income.

    3. In support of its case, the prosecution examined 53 witnesses (PW.1 to PW.53), produced documents marked Ex.P.1 to Ex.P.162, and identified 37 material objects. In response, the defense examined 22 witnesses (DW.1 to DW.22) and produced documents marked Ex.D.1 to Ex.D.80.

    4. After framing points for consideration and reviewing the evidence on record, the Trial Court held that "the prosecution has established the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable

    - 3 -

    doubt" and passed the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence.

    5. Shri Sandesh Chouta, learned senior counsel for the appellant, argued as follows:

    5.1. The investigating officers, during cross-examination, admitted that they did not calculate the income, expenditure, and assets of the accused for the relevant period, nor did they verify the genuineness of the documents collected during the investigation. Notably, the computerized documents were not supported by a certificate under Section 65(B) of the Indian Evidence Act. Consequently, in the absence of any substantial evidence corroborating the alleged discrepancy between the accused's assets and his known sources of income, the conviction based solely on the charge-sheet material is arbitrary, illegal, and not legally sustainable.

    5.2. Additionally, the learned counsel submitted that DW.17, the Assistant Director of Agriculture, had submitted a report stating that the agricultural income of the accused and his family members was approximately Rs.1,00,00,000. However, this report was not cited as evidence by the prosecution, nor was it produced in court. Instead, the prosecution relied on a report submitted by PW.24, which stated that the agricultural income of the accused and his family members was only around Rs.32,00,000.

    6. In response, the learned counsel for the respondent (Lokayukta) argued that the charge-sheet material, when

    - 4 -

    considered together with the testimonies of investigating officers and the evidence of PW.24, clearly indicates that the agricultural income of the accused and his family members was around Rs.32,00,000. Based on this evidence, the learned Trial Court rightly concluded that the appellant was in possession of assets disproportionate to his known sources of income by an excess amount of 106.20%. Therefore, the respondent argued that the impugned judgment of conviction is correct and does not warrant any interference.

    6.1. Furthermore, the respondent's learned counsel contended that the documents produced by the accused do not establish that the accused or his family had an agricultural income of Rs.1,00,00,000, thereby supporting the conclusion that the assets were indeed disproportionate to the known income.

    7. After carefully considering the arguments advanced by both parties and thoroughly reviewing the trial Court's records, the sole issue for consideration is whether the prosecution has established the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable doubt and whether the impugned judgment of conviction passed by the trial Court is legally sustainable.

    8. The check period is from the year 1981 to 2009. The prosecution, in its charge sheet, alleges that the accused possessed assets disproportionate to his known sources of income by an extent of 106.20%. This allegation is supported by a detailed schedule of the accused's assets, income, and expenditure for that period.

    - 5 -

    9. The prosecution further contends that the agricultural income of the accused and his family members was assessed at Rs.32,00,000. This figure is based on the testimony of PW‑24 and the report he submitted following his inspection of the agricultural land owned by the accused and his family, as documented in Ex.P.62. During cross‑examination, PW‑24 conceded that if complete information were available regarding the irrigation facilities, soil fertility, and the nature of the crops grown, the quantum of agricultural income might have been higher. He further acknowledged that in order to accurately assess the crop yield, it is necessary to adhere to the "Package of Practice" published by the Agriculture University, Dharwad. Without considering these critical factors, it is not possible to precisely calculate the actual expenditure or income.

    10. PW‑24 has categorically stated that he was not provided with any information regarding the irrigation facility, nor did he conduct a soil test or record the statements of the residents of the adjacent lands. Therefore, the testimony of PW‑24 and the report he submitted in Exs. P.62 to P.64 cannot be given any evidentiary value.

    11. Prior to PW‑24's inspection, D.W.17, who was serving as the Assistant Director of Agriculture at Naragund, conducted an inspection of the agricultural land owned by the accused and his family on the instructions of the Investigating Officer.

    - 6 -

    12. In his examination‑in‑chief, D.W.17 testified that he was requested to furnish an assessment of the agricultural income of the accused for the period from 1981 to 2009. His assessment covered the land measured as follows: Survey No.24/1, comprising 10 acres and 37 guntas; Survey No.181/1, comprising 5 acres; and Survey No.180/1B, comprising 4 acres and 9 guntas.

    13. Furthermore, D.W.17 was also required to assess the additional income from adjacent land owned by the brother-in‑law of the accused, as these adjacent properties potentially contributed to the overall agricultural income. Accordingly, he and his assistant visited the adjacent lands, inquired with the neighboring landowners about the nature of crops grown during the relevant period, applied APMC rates, and conducted a crop-cutting experiment to calculate the yield.

    14. Additionally, D.W.17 stated that for water supply, there was a pipeline from a nearby canal, and he conducted a soil test to evaluate the fertility of the soil. The report submitted as Ex.P.37 indicated that the agricultural income of the accused was approximately Rs.1,00,00,000. However, during

    cross‑examination, no evidence was elicited to dispute the authenticity of this report.

    15. The accused has tendered his income tax returns which clearly indicate that both he and his wife derived agricultural income as well as the annual property returns submitted as Ex.P.114, covering the entire check period.

    - 7 -

    16. In summary, the prosecution has failed to establish that the agricultural income of the accused for the check period is limited to approximately Rs.32,00,000/- as the report submitted by PW‑24 did not consider all relevant factors such as irrigation facilities, soil fertility, and the yield protocols prescribed by the Agriculture University, Dharwad.

    17. In turn, the accused has demonstrated, through the evidence of DW‑17, that the agricultural income for the period is approximately Rs.1,00,00,000/-. Consequently, if the agricultural income is taken as Rs.1,00,00,000/- an additional amount of Rs.68,00,000 must be credited to the income of the accused. This, in turn, establishes that the total assets possessed by the accused are less than his known sources of income.

    18. PW.51, the investigating officer who conducted the investigation from 25.05.2009 to 28.09.2010, admitted during cross‑examination that he neither calculated the income, expenditure, nor the assets of the accused for the relevant check period, nor did he compare the copies of documents with the originals to verify their authenticity and accuracy. He further acknowledged that he had not obtained certificates under Section 65(B) of the Indian Evidence Act in respect of the computerized documents.

    19. Similarly, PW.52, who conducted investigations from 25.10.2010 to 31.07.2012, categorically admitted in cross‑examination that aside from merely receiving documents

    - 8 -

    from various departments, he did not conduct any further inquiry into those documents. He further stated that, for verifying the correctness of any document, evidence must be provided by the officer who originally issued it. This admission emphasises the fact that PW.52 did not undertake any detailed calculation or verification regarding the income, expenditure, and assets of the accused or his family members.

    20. In addition, PW.53 - another investigating officer, testified that he did not verify the authenticity of the computerized documents received in this case. He further admitted that he failed to collect the commencement and completion certificates for the construction of a building located at Ramdurga, nor did he obtain any documents indicating the year of construction, except for a valuation report provided by an engineer. PW.53 did not conduct any supplementary investigation with respect to the construction details of the building.

    21. PW.53 also acknowledged that he did not visit the properties bearing Survey Nos. 180/1B and 24/1, situated at Hirekoppa village; instead, he merely relied on someone showing him the lands without verifying their actual extent. Moreover, he did not make any inquiries with the Assistant Executive Engineer of the Malaprabha Sub-Division regarding the water sources for the property bearing Survey No. 24/1, nor did he correspond with the income tax or commercial tax authorities to obtain information about the income of the appellant's brother-in-law.

    - 9 -

    22. Furthermore, PW.53 admitted that, except for receiving documents marked as Exs. P.103 to P.104, he did not collect any additional documents or conduct any further investigation.

    23. Collectively, the investigating officers PW.51, PW.52, and PW.53 have categorically admitted that they did not verify the genuineness of the documents, nor did they calculate the income, expenditure, and assets of the accused and his family members. They also failed to obtain the necessary certificates under Section 65(B) of the Indian Evidence Act for the computerized records.

    24. As a result, the prosecution has failed to establish, on a prima facie basis, that the accused was in possession of assets disproportionate to his known sources of income. Despite this, the Trial Court, rather than appreciating the deficiencies in the evidentiary record, relied on the charge-sheet materials and reached a conclusion that the accused's assets were disproportionate to his income.

    24.1. In particular, the statements annexed to the charge sheet (Exs. A to C) lack evidentiary value since the investigating officers have unequivocally admitted that they did not undertake the necessary calculations or verification of the documents.

    25. A charge sheet is a formal document prepared by the investigating agencies after completing their investigation. It contains allegations, witness statements, collected evidence, and the legal provisions under which the accused is charged. However, as per established legal principles, a charge sheet itself does not

    - 10 -

    constitute substantive evidence and cannot be the sole basis for conviction. The prosecution must prove the allegations beyond a reasonable doubt through legally admissible evidence presented before the court.

    26. In the absence of any reliable documentary or oral evidence demonstrating that the accused is in possession of the assets disproportionate to his known source of income, the impugned judgment passed by the Trial Court is legally unsustainable.

    27. Accordingly, I pass the following:

    ORDER

    a) Appeal is allowed.

    b) The impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 18.02.2020 passed by the III Additional District and Sessions Judge (Special Judge for KLA/ACB and CBI Cases in

    Spl.KLA.C.C.No.04/2013 is hereby set-aside;

    c) The appellant/accused is acquitted of the aforesaid offences.

    d) The bail bonds, if any, stand discharged. Sd/-

    (HEMANT CHANDANGOUDAR)

    JUDGE

    AC,

    List No.: 1 Sl No.: 123

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    BASAVARADDY VENKARADDY LINGADAL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
    (Feb 27, 2025)