Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rules 10.1, 10.2 and 10.3. Rule 10.1
  • Odisha State Medical Corporation Limited Employees' Service Rules, 2017,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • rules 10.1, 10.2 and 10.3. Rule 10.1
  • Odisha State Medical Corporation Limited Employees' Service Rules, 2017,
Smart Summary

Case Summary: W.A. No.2757 of 2023 — Odisha State Medical Corporation & another v. Pravat Kusum Mandal

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal from a judgment of a learned Single Judge dated 5 October 2023 directing regularization of the respondent, Pravat Kusum Mandal. The present judgment was delivered by a Division Bench (Arindam Sinha, ACJ. and M.S. Sahoo, J.) on 20 February 2025 following hearings on 30 January 2025 and 20 February 2025.

Relevant procedural and factual milestones, drawn strictly from the opinion, are:

  • Respondent's appointment: appointment letter dated 10 March 2017; respondent is recorded as joining service on 14 March 2017.
  • Applicable service rules: Odisha State Medical Corporation Limited Employees' Service Rules, 2017 (in force with effect from 22 September 2017). Rules 10.1 to 10.3 (probation and confirmation) are set out in the opinion and form the interpretive focus.
  • Appointment letter clause: Clause 1 of the appointment letter provided the employee would be on probation for one year from date of joining and that probation could be extended; termination during probation could be effected on one month's notice or one month's salary in lieu.
  • Office orders extending probation: there is an office order dated 9 January 2019 (referred to as "disputed") and a later office order dated 12 March 2019 (reproduced in the record) extending probation for one year for a group of employees including the respondent (extension effective 14 March 2019 in the reproduced table).
  • Termination: respondent's services were terminated by office order dated 25 July 2019 while he was still stated to be on probation; the order released one month's salary in lieu of notice.
  • Lower court outcome: Single Judge ordered regularization of the respondent; this appeal challenged that direction.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appointing authority validly extended the respondent's probation under Rules 10.1–10.3 of the Odisha State Medical Corporation Limited Employees' Service Rules, 2017, including whether the statutory requirement to inform the employee of reasons for extension (Rule 10.2) was complied with.
  2. Whether termination of the respondent's services during the extended probation period (by office order dated 25 July 2019) was permissible or whether it was punitive and required remediation (reinstatement/regularization).
  3. What relief, if any, should follow where an employee continued in service on probation beyond the initial period without being informed of reasons for extension and was later terminated.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Odisha State Medical Corporation)

  • Appellants' counsel (Ms. Pami Rath) submitted that the appointment letter and the Rules gave the appointing authority power to extend probation for one year or more "as per satisfaction of authority," and therefore termination during an extended probation was permissible.
  • It was submitted that the termination was carried out under Clause 1 of the appointment letter (i.e., termination during probation on one month's notice or pay in lieu) and thus lawful.
  • Appellants relied on Supreme Court precedent (High Court of M.P. v. Satya Narayan Jhavar (2001) 7 SCC 161 — paragraph 11) for the proposition that where rules or appointment letters confer indefinite extension power without a prescribed maximum period, continuation beyond the prescribed period does not confer confirmation and termination may be effected at any time; and on Registrar, High Court of Gujarat v. C.G. Sharma (2005) 1 SCC 132 (para. 26) for the proposition that automatic confirmation cannot be claimed where confirmation depends on satisfactory performance.

Respondent's Arguments (Pravat Kusum Mandal)

  • Respondent's counsel (Miss Deepali Mahapatra) submitted that the respondent had successfully completed the initial one-year probation as required by Rule 10.1, and, on that basis, Rule 10.3 mandated regularization on the basis of ability, suitability and performance by a reasoned/written order.
  • There was no communication indicating that the respondent had been unsuccessful during probation or lacked ability, suitability or performance; the Single Judge correctly concluded the termination was punitive and without proper opportunity to improve.
  • Therefore, the impugned judgment directing regularization should be upheld and not interfered with in the appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
High Court of M.P. v. Satya Narayan Jhavar, (2001) 7 SCC 161 (para. 11) Identifies a line of cases where service rules or appointment letters specify probation and confer power to extend without prescribing a maximum period — continuation beyond prescribed/extended period does not itself confer confirmation; termination can be effected at any time after expiry/continuation of probation in such cases. The court acknowledged this principle but explained it did not aid the appellants because, although implied extension can arise, in the present case the formal extensions were not made in compliance with Rule 10.2 (no reasons were communicated). Thus the Jhavar line did not validate the employer's conduct here.
Registrar, High Court of Gujarat v. C.G. Sharma, (2005) 1 SCC 132 (para. 26) Affirms that even if probation expires and the probationer is allowed to continue, automatic/ deemed confirmation cannot be claimed where the rules make satisfactory work a pre-condition for confirmation; language of rules can exclude deemed confirmation. The court treated this precedent as not materially assisting the appellants because in this case Rule 10.2's mandatory requirement to inform reasons for extension was not complied with; thus C.G. Sharma could not be relied upon to justify termination without the required procedural compliance.
State of Gujurat v. Akhilesh C. Bhargav, (1987) 4 SCC 482 Discusses administrative guidance that it is not desirable to keep a member of service on probation for years (context included rule-based limits and expectations about conclusion of probationary processes). The court referenced this decision for the proposition that keeping a probationer on service for an extended period without proper process is undesirable; while the factual requirement in Bhargav (e.g., final exam within four years) differs, the court drew support from its general guidance to criticize prolonged probation without proper notice or reasons.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeds in a stepwise manner, grounded in the Rules reproduced in the opinion and the documentary record:

  1. Rules and appointment terms: The court first identified the operative provisions — Rules 10.1–10.3 of the OSMC Employees' Service Rules, 2017 and Clause 1 of the appointment letter — and summarized their relevant mandates: initial one-year probation (10.1), power to extend probation for further one-year periods while informing the employee of reasons (10.2), and the requirement of a written order to regularize the employee on successful completion based on ability, suitability and performance (10.3).
  2. Documentary chronology and compliance: The court examined the record of office orders said to extend probation (9 January 2019 — disputed; 12 March 2019 — reproduced in the record). It observed both extension orders were issued long after the initial one-year probation had expired and, critically, neither order furnished the reasons for extension as required by Rule 10.2.
  3. Effect of absence of required notice of reasons: Because the employer did not communicate reasons for the extensions, the court concluded that the extension(s) could not be regarded as duly made in terms of Rule 10.2. Consequently, the respondent had effectively continued in service on probation for approximately two and a half years without being informed of any shortcoming.
  4. Consideration of authorities: The court acknowledged and considered the Supreme Court precedents cited by the parties (including the Jhavar line and C.G. Sharma). It recorded that those precedents recognize that continuation can amount to implied extension and that confirmation is not automatic when rules condition confirmation on satisfactory performance. However, the court found those decisions did not aid the appellants because the mandatory procedural step (informing the employee of reasons for extension under Rule 10.2) was not complied with here.
  5. Policy consideration on prolonged probation: The court quoted and relied on the principle from State of Gujurat v. Akhilesh C. Bhargav cautioning against keeping employees on probation for prolonged periods without proper process, using that to bolster its view that the termination here, after an improperly extended probation, was susceptible to a finding of being punitive.
  6. Remedial conclusion: The Single Judge had directed regularization. This bench agreed that the employer's conduct could not be sustained as a proper exercise of Rule 10.2, but instead of directing unconditional regularization, the Division Bench modified relief to order reinstatement on probation with deemed continuation of service and with an appraisal of the respondent's performance for the purpose of confirmation.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was disposed of with modification of the Single Judge's direction. Instead of unconditional regularization, the Division Bench ordered that the respondent be reinstated on probation with deemed continuation of service and that his performance be appraised with a view to confirmation.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The respondent is to be reinstated on probation and his prior service is to be treated as a deemed continuation for the purposes of appraisal and potential confirmation.
  • The employer's extensions of probation were found to be procedurally defective because the mandatory requirement to inform reasons (Rule 10.2) was not observed; as a result, the termination that followed was addressed by ordering reinstatement rather than direct regularization.
  • The court did not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing Supreme Court authorities and the service rules to the facts; the decision adjusts the relief appropriate to the record rather than establishing a novel legal principle.

    ODISHA STATE MEDICAL CORPORATION v. PRAVAT KUSUM MANDAL

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

    W.A. No.2757 of 2023

    Odisha State Medical Corporation …. Appellants and another

    -Versus-

    Pravat Kusum Mandal …. Respondent Advocates appeared in this case:

    For Appellants : Ms. Pami Rath, Senior Advocate For Respondent : Miss Deepali Mahapatra, Advocate

    CORAM:

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM SINHA,

    ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

    AND

    THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.S. SAHOO

    J U D G M E N T

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dates of hearing: 30th January, 2025 and 20th February, 2025

    Date of Judgment: 20th February, 2025 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    ARINDAM SINHA, ACJ.

    1. Ms. Rath, learned senior advocate appears on behalf of appellants. She, on 30thJanuary, 2025 had submitted, impugned is judgment dated 5thOctober, 2023 of the learned single Judge directing regularization of respondent, who was appointed on

    1

    probation. Odisha State Medical Corporation Limited Employees' Service Rules, 2017, which came into force with effect from 22ndSeptember, 2017 was applicable to the parties. Rule 10 deals with probation and confirmation. The relevant rules 10.1 to 10.3 are reproduced below.

    "10.1 All the employees directly recruited by the Corporation shall be on probation for one year from the date of joining.

    10.2 The appointing authority may extend the period of probation for a further period of one year at a time considering the ability, suitability and performance of the officer and inform the employee concerned the reason for such extension.

    10.3 The appointing authority shall regularize the employee concerned in the post on successful completion of probation period on the basis of his ability, suitability and performances by a written order."

    (emphasis supplied)

    2. Respondent was appointed on letter dated 10thMarch, 2017. There was no controversy between the parties regarding applicability of the rules that had come into force later, as aforesaid on 22ndSeptember, 2017. The learned single Judge

    2

    recorded as much in impugned judgment. That position continues in appeal.

    3. She had relied on 1stterm and condition in the appointment letter, reproduced below.

    "1. The appointment is purely temporary. You will be on probation for one year from the date of joining. The probation period can be extended a further period of one year or more as per satisfaction of authority. During the period of probation, your services can be terminated by the Appointing Authority on payment one month's notice or in lieu of the same with one month's salary. Depending on satisfactory performance and conduct during the probation period, your continuance and regularization in the post will be decided. The probation period will be counted towards normal annual increment, leave and seniority. On successful completion of probation, you will be confirmed in the concerned post." (emphasis supplied)

    She submitted that her client could extend the period of probation for a further period of one year or more as per its satisfaction. Furthermore, during period of probation, the service could be terminated on one month's notice or in lieu of the same with one month's salary. Going back to rules 10.2 and 10.3 she submitted,

    3

    regularization of respondent in the post could only be by a written order. Facts in the case did not proceed to that stage. Prior thereto, during extended continuation of the probation period, respondent's service was terminated. She added, it was a simple termination without stigma.

    4. She relied on judgment of the Supreme Court in High Court of M.P. v. Satya Narayan Jhavar, reported in (2001) 7 SCC 161, inter alia, paragraph-11. She demonstrated from the paragraph, there were three lines of cases discussed. She relied on the first line of cases, said to be where in the service rules or in the letter of appointment, a period of probation is specified and power to extend the same is also conferred upon the authority without prescribing any maximum period. If the officer continued beyond the prescribed or extended period, he cannot be deemed to be confirmed. This line was approved by the Supreme Court in saying, in such cases there is no bar against termination at any point of time after expiry of the period of probation. She reiterated, the termination was during extended period of probation. The extension though happened after two years, no dispute was and cannot be raised regarding continuance of it at the time of termination.

    4

    5. She relied on one more judgment of the Supreme Court in Registrar, High Court of Gujarat v. C.G. Sharma, reported in (2005) 1 SCC 132, paragraph-26. The proposition is that even if period of probation expires and the probationer is allowed to continue, automatic confirmation cannot be claimed as a matter of right because in terms of the rules, as in that case, work had to be satisfactory, which is pre-requisite or pre-condition for confirmation. The Supreme Court went on to say that language of the rules itself excluded any chance of giving deemed or automatic confirmation.

    6. Today Miss Mahapatra, learned advocate appearing on behalf of respondent draws attention to impugned judgment and submits, the declarations of law made by the Supreme Court on the point of probation and confirmation were duly considered by the learned single Judge. Facts in the case were appreciated and are that her client successfully completed probation period of one year as required under rule 10.1. On having done so the appointing authority was mandated by rule 10.3 to regularize her client in the post on basis of his ability, suitability and performance, by a reasoned order. Her client was entitled to this. There was no communication to indicate her client was

    5

    unsuccessful in completing the period of probation or that he lacked ability, suitability or performance.

    7. She draws attention to several paragraphs in impugned judgment to demonstrate that this was taken note of by the learned single Judge. There is nothing on record to show her client was ever noticed on performance. Hence, irresistible conclusion drawn by the learned single Judge was, the severance was punitive. This cannot be as the Supreme Court in very many cases has declared that there must be opportunity given for a probationer employee, to improve on performance. She submits, impugned judgment is good. There be no interference in appeal.

    8. Question to be answered in this appeal turns on interpretation of rules 10.1, 10.2 and 10.3. Rule 10.1 says, employees directly recruited shall be on probation for one year from the date of joining. There is no dispute respondent was directly recruited and had to undergo probation for one year from his date of joining. Moving on to rule 10.2, thereby is permission for the appointing authority to extend the period of probation for further period, of one year at a time, considering the ability, suitability and performance of the officer. There is further requirement to inform the employee concerned, the reasons for

    6

    such extension. On query Miss Mahapatra submits, the first extension was by office order dated 12thMarch, 2019. Text of the order is reproduced below.

    "OFFICE ORDER The probation period of the following employees of Odisha State Medical Corporation Ltd. is hereby extended for a further period of one year in terms of the provision laid down in their appointment letters.

    Sl No. Name of the employee Designation Date of joining OSMCL Due date for completion of probation period Date from which probation period will be extended
    1 Shri Soumyakanta Samal Sr. Manager-IT 14.03.2017 13.03.2019 14.03.2019
    2 Shri Tapas Ranjan Kar Sr. Manager- Equipment 14.03.2017 13.03.2019 14.03.2019
    3 Shri Pravat Kusum Mandal Manager- Procurement (D & S) 14.03.2017 13.03.2019 14.03.2019
    4 Ms. Biswajita Pani Manager- Procurement (Eqp.) 17.03.2017 16.03.2019 17.03.2019
    5 Shri Biswajit Jena Asst. Manager- Procurement (Eqp.) 14.03.2017 13.03.2019 14.03.2019

    "

    Ms. Rath submits, there was earlier office order dated 9th January, 2019. She draws attention to pages-48 and 49 in the appeal brief to demonstrate existence of the office order and relevant page in peon book bearing signature, said to be of respondent, acknowledging receipt thereof. On query made Ms. Rath submits, counter was filed but the documents were not disclosed. Text of the office order is reproduced below.

    7

    "OFFICE ORDER The probation period of Sri Pravat Kusum Mandal, Manager, Procurement (Drugs & Surgical), Odisha State Medical Corporation Ltd. is hereby extended in terms of the provision laid down in his appointment letter no.3232/OSMC/HR/2017, dated 10.03.2017."

    Since we are dealing with the writ petition in appeal, on affidavit evidence, it will be better not to solely rely on this office order dated 9thJanuary, 2019 even though we notice, in paragraph-9 of the counter affidavit there is reference to it.

    9. It will appear from contents of both, the disputed office order as well as office order dated 12thMarch, 2019, there was no indication informing the employees concerned, reason for such extension. We may add that the disputed office order is dated 9th January, 2019 and following office order dated 12thMarch, 2019. Respondent joined service on 14thMarch, 2017. Thus, both office orders extending the probation period came long after initial probation period of one year.

    10. Subsequent fact is, respondent's service was terminated by office order dated 25thJuly, 2019. Text of the office order is reproduced below.

    8

    "OFFICE ORDER In pursuance to the terms & condition laid down in clause no.1 of the appointment letter no.3232, dated 10.03.2017 issued, the services of Shri Pravat Kusum Mandal, Manager-Procurement (D & S) who is under probation, is hereby terminated with effect from 25.07.2019 (FN). One month salary in lieu of notice period of one month be released to Shri Pravat Kusum Mandal."

    The termination must be seen as done in terms of clause (1) in the appointment letter.

    11. Judgments relied upon by the parties and duly considered, as reflected from impugned judgment, are of the Supreme Court declaring the law that an employee continuing beyond the period of probation must be seen as a situation, where the employer has impliedly extended it. In the case at hand, rule

    10.2 permits the employer to extend the period of probation for further periods, one year at a time. In the circumstances, the belated extension, if it can be said so, must be seen as permissible by the employer.

    12. However, we do see that there has been infraction of the rule by the employer in having thus extended the probation. No

    9

    information was given to respondent on the reason for the extension. As such, the extension therefore cannot be seen as duly made. So, the situation becomes one of respondent having been appointed on 10thMarch, 2017 and continued to serve as in probation till his termination on 25thJuly, 2019. He thus had put in approximately two and half years of service on probation, without information had on any shortcoming in respect thereof.

    13. In State of Gujurat v. Akhilesh C. Bhargav, reported in (1987) 4 SCC 482 the Supreme Court had occasion to consider administrative instruction issued by the Ministry indicating guidelines to be followed regarding it being not desirable that a member of the service should be kept on probation for years. In the case considered there was requirement for the probationer to take final examination within four years of probation. Said requirement is not there in the present case. However, we do have facts where respondent continued in service initially beyond requisite one year probation period and till he was terminated, without information on reason for belated extension of probation. It follows, the learned single judge concluded the termination to be punitive. As we see things, we do not have reason to interfere. High Court of M.P. (supra) does

    10

    not come to aid of appellant because we cannot quarrel with the declaration of law, of an employee continuing in service while in probation, to be on implied extension of it. We have arrived at finding that the extension of probation was not in terms of rule

    10.2 on no information given to respondent, for reason of it. In the circumstances, C.G. Sharma (supra) is of no aid to appellants.

    14. The learned single Judge by impugned judgment directed regularization of respondent's service. The direction is modified to be that respondent is to be reinstated on probation with deemed continuation of service and for appraisal of his performance on expectation to be confirmed.

    15. The appeal is disposed of.

    (Arindam Sinha) Acting Chief Judge (M.S. Sahoo) Judge

    Jyostna Signature Not Verified Digitally Signed Signed by: JYOSTNARANI MAJHEE Reason: Authentication Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT Date: 24-Feb-2025 17:49:24

    11

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    ODISHA STATE MEDICAL CORPORATION v. PRAVAT KUSUM MANDAL
    (Feb 20, 2025)