Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6(3) (kha) of the said Rules, 2024
  • provisions of Municipality Act and the Municipal Corporat ion Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 6(3) (kha) of the said Rules, 2024
  • provisions of Municipality Act and the Municipal Corporat ion Act
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SHOBHA JOSHI v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND

    2025:UHC:635

    1

    THE HI GH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND

    AT NAI NI TAL

    THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTI CE ALOK KUMAR VERMA 1 6 th JANUARY, 2 0 2 5

    SPECI AL APPEAL NO.7 OF 2 0 2 5

    Sm t. Shobha Joshi . .…Appellant Versus

    State of Ut tarakhand and Others . .…Respondents Counsel for the Appellant : Mr. K.K. Tiwari, Advocate.

    Counsel for the Respondent : Mr. J.S. Bisht , Standing Nos.1 to 3 Counsel, Mr. Gajendra

    Tripathi, Standing

    Counsel and Mr. Naveen

    Tiwari, Brief Holder.

    Counsel for the Respondent

    No.4 : Mr. Sanjay Bhat t ,

    Advocate.

    Hon'ble Alok Kum ar Verm a,J.

    This Special Appeal is preferred against the Order passed by the learned Single Judge in Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No.3627 of 2024 dated 10.01.2025, whereby the learned Single Judge has dism issed the I nterim Relief Applicat ion of the appellant / writ pet it ioner.

    2 . Mr. K.K. Tiwari, learned counsel appearing for the appellant , has submit ted that the appellant herein

    1

    filed Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No.3627 of 2024 challenging the Not ificat ion No.1536/ I V(3) / 2024-11 (3 fuokZ0) / 2024 dated 23.12.2024, issued by the respondent no.2, whereby the post of Mayor, Nagar Nigam , Alm ora has been reserved/ allot ted for Other Backward Caste Category. The pet it ioner sought a direct ion to declare the post of Mayor, Nagar Nigam, Alm ora as General (Women) .

    3 . Mr. K.K. Tiwari, Advocate, has contended that the appellant is a perm anent resident of Dist r ict Alm ora. She wants to contest the elect ion for the post of Mayor, Nagar Nigam, Alm ora. As per the Municipal Corporat ion (Reservat ion and Allocat ion of Seats and Posts) Rules, 2024, the cr iteria for reserving the seat is populat ion. Rule 6(3) (kha) of the said Rules, 2024 provides that where there is a populat ion less than ten thousand then such category shall be excluded from reservat ion. The populat ion of OBC Category in Nagar Nigam, Alm ora is 2513, the populat ion of the Scheduled Caste Category is 5575 and the unreserved populat ion is 30663 as per 2011 census. The Nagar Nigam, Almora seat in the tentat ive list was kept reserved for General Category (Women) , but , after finalizing the tentat ive list , it has been reserved for

    2

    OBC Category without any basis.

    4 . Mr. J.S. Bisht , learned Standing Counsel for the State, has opposed the said submissions.

    5 . The State Elect ion Com mission has announced the elect ion schedule on 23.12.2024. The Elect ion schedule is as follows: -

    ( i) Nominat ion Date - 27.12.2024 to

    30.12.2024.

    ( ii) Scrut iny of the nominat ion papers - 31.12.2024 to 01.01.2025.

    ( iii) Date for Withdrawal of nominat ion -

    02.01.2025.

    ( iv) Allotm ent of Sym bols - 03.01.2025.

    (v) Date of Vot ing - 23.01.2025.

    (vi) Date of Count ing of Votes - 25.01.2025.

    6 . Learned Single Judge, after considering Art icles 243T, 243(2) , 243(S) , 243(U) , 243(V) , 243ZA, 243ZG of the Const itut ion of I ndia and the judgments of the Hon'ble Suprem e Court in "Boddula Krishnaiah and Another vs. State Elect ion Com m issioner, A.P. and Others", ( 1 9 9 6 ) 3 SCC 4 1 6 , "Mohinder Singh Gill vs. Chief Elect ion Com m issioner", 1 9 7 8 ( 1 )

    3

    SCC 4 0 5 , "Elect ion Com m ission of I ndia Vs. Ashok Kum ar", ( 2 0 0 0 ) 8 SCC 2 1 6 , "Union Terr itory of Ladakh and Others Vs. Jam m u Kashm ir Nat ional Council", 2 0 2 3 SCC OnLine SC 1 1 4 0 , "State of Goa Vs. Fouziya I m t iaz Shaikh and Another", ( 2 0 2 1 ) 8 SCC 4 0 1 , "Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam ( DMK) vs. Secretary, Governor's Secretariat", ( 2 0 2 0 ) 6 SCC 5 4 8 and "Anugrah Narain Singh & Others Vs. State Of U.P.", 1 9 9 6 ( 6 ) SCC 3 0 3 , observed, in the bunch of the writ pet it ions: -

    "4 9 . Since the issue is only confined to the impugned not ificat ion dated 23.12.2024, which pertains to the allotm ent of seats, but what would be the im pact of the im pugned not ificat ion to the Elect ion Not ificat ion this aspect cannot be overlooked. Therefore, at this juncture, if this Court scrut inises the decision for determ inat ion of allotm ent of seats, even for one const ituency, then it will certainly affect the other const ituencies. No doubt , the m andate of Art icle 243(T) of the Const itut ion of I ndia is to follow the roster of reservat ion and even if while determ ining the allotm ent of seats, the roster in respect of som e of the const ituencies have not been followed which are disputed by the State as well as by Elect ion Com mission, any interference with the impugned not ificat ion will certainly effect the elect ion of other

    4

    const ituencies in respect of which there is no challenge to the allotm ent of seat . I n other words disturbing one seat certainly will affect the other const ituencies, therefore, as a whole, any interference at this juncture in respect of the impugned not ificat ion will am ount to an interference with the elect ion process at this stage, part icularly when the elect ion has already been not ified.

    6 0 . Therefore, due to lack of pleadings at this juncture, this Court is keeping all these pet it ions pending and invit ing counter affidavit from the State as well as from the State Elect ion Com mission to exam ine the validity of im pugned not ificat ion by fram ing an issue "what would be the im pact of impugned not ificat ion if the elect ions are concluded, after declaring the result of the returned candidate and whether the non- com pliance of Const itut ional provision as well as non-com pliance with the provisions of Municipality Act and the Municipal Corporat ion Act as well as Rules of 2024 can be a subject mat ter of elect ion pet it ion or not ," and this issue will be decided later on but that too after the elect ion are over, otherwise any interference at this stage am ounts to an interference with the on going elect ions, which is against the m andate of set t led principle of law."

    7 . I n the facts and circumstances of the case, I

    5

    am of the considered view that the learned Single Judge has not erred in passing the impugned order. I do not find any perversity and infirm ity in the impugned order warrant ing interference. This Court does not find any m erit in the present appeal. Special Appeal is liable to be dism issed at the admission stage.

    8 . I n the result , the Special Appeal is dism issed.

    _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

    ALOK KUMAR VERMA, J.

    Vacat ion Judge

    Date: 16.01.2025 Pant /

    PANKAJ

    KUMAR PANT

    Digitally signed by PANKAJ KUMAR PANT DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF

    UTTARAKHAND,

    2.5.4.20=9bb5448b4a92c65bab85a1384e98c8e23962296e78d4821a6ec01b40 8aa193c8, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,

    serialNumber=4FA443614ABEBC1A2C417A645E31B2B4B9D897811D160D334 C31AA4BA6D48D32, cn=PANKAJ KUMAR PANT

    Date: 2025.01.16 19:23:34 +05'30'

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SHOBHA JOSHI v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
    (Jan 16, 2025)