AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC
  • Order 1 Rule 3(b) (c) of CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 read with section 151 of CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC (State Amendment)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC
  • Order 1 Rule 3(b) (c) of CPC
  • Order 6 Rule 17 read with section 151 of CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 CPC
  • provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC (State Amendment)
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sheetal Mata Agritech Pvt. Ltd. Through Director Tarun Goyal v. Puran Singh Jatav

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

    AT GWALIOR

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE ON THE 4thOF SEPTEMBER, 2024

    MISC. PETITION No. 4391 of 2022

    SHEETAL MATA AGRITECH PVT. LTD. THROUGH DIRECTOR TARUN

    GOYAL

    Versus

    PURAN SINGH JATAV AND OTHERS

    Appearance:

    Shri Sanjeev Jain - Advocate for the petitioner.

    ORDER

    The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is preferred against the order dated 26.8.2022 passed by the learned Seventh Civil Judge Senior Division Gwalior in Civil Suit No.210A/2015, whereby the application under Order 6 Rule 17 read with section 151 of CPC for incorporating some legal issues in the written statement has been rejected.

    2. The aforesaid order has been assailed on the ground that the para no.1 in the special objection was sought to be incorporated by the petitioner- defendant due to the fact that though the suit preferred by the respondent/plaintiff involved agricultural land and the relief has been claimed against the State, though State was not made a party, therefore, a suit is hit by the provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC (State Amendment) and suffers from mis-joinder of the parties as no notice under section 80 of CPC has been issued to the State prior to filing of the present suit and since there is a legal bar the suit on this count deserves to be dismissed, but learned Trial Court ignoring the very fact that the pleadings which the petitioner wanted to incorporate in the written

    1

    statement were absolutely illegal and rejected the application and had even gone into the merits of the said amendment. Thus, the order impugned is bad in law.

    3. To bolster his submission he has placed reliance in the matter of Ram Singh and others Vs. Shikha Grih Nirman Sahakari Society and others (M.P.No.679/2017 decided on 24.11.2017) , wherein while dealing with the same issue the Coordinate Bench of this Court had held that when the application of the plaintiff under Order 1 Rule 3(b) (c) of CPC has been allowed then defendant is also required to incorporate the said pleadings in respect of the ground raised by them regarding impleadment of State of Madhya Pradesh and thus while allowing the petition the defendants therein were permitted to carry out necessary amendment in the written statement and since the facts of the present case are akin to the said case the application for amendment should have been allowed and petitioner/defendant should have been permitted to carry out said amendment in the written statement.

    4. None for the respondents even after service of notice.

    5. Heard the counsel for the petitioner and persued the impugned order.

    6. By way of the present petition the petitioner/defendant is challenging the order passed by the learned Trial Court whereby his application under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC for impleading certain grounds by way of special objections in the written statement has been denied. For reference the amendment prayed is reproduced hereinbelow:

    १. यह क, करण म ववा दत भूिम िन ववा दत प से कृ ष भूिम है और राज व अिभलेख खसरा म भी कृ ष भूिम के प म दज है तथा वाद गण ारा वादप शासन के व सहायता भी चाह गई है। संशोिधत यवहार या सं हता के विधक आ ा मक ावधान आदेश १ िनयम ३ सीपीसी अनसुार म0 0 शासन को करण म ितवाद प कार के प म संयो जत कया जाना आ ापक है तथा इसके अित र वाद गण ने

    2

    वाद तुित के पवू धारा ८० सीपीसी का कोई सूचना प शासन को े षत नह कया है। इस कारण वाद गण ारा विध के वपर त जाकर वतमान वाद तुत कया है। इस कारण दावा वाद इसी आधार पर िनर त होने यो य है िनर त फरमाया जावे। २. यह क, ता वत संशोधन त य विधक कृित के है जससे करण का व प प रवितत नह होना है और न ह कसी कार वल ब का रत है। करण म यायदान हेतु ितवाद क ओर से तुत ता वत संशोधन त य तकनीक कार है जसके समा व होने से वाद गण को कोई ित का रत नह ं होगी और न ह होने क संभावना है ब क माननीय यायालय को यायदान म सहायता ा होगी। वाद गण ारा इस सबंध म वादप म कोई अिभवचचन नह कये गये थे इस कारण पवू म आप नह ली जा सक थी क तु करण का गहनता से अ ययन करने पर उ त य क जानकार सव थम दनांक - २५.०८.२०२२ को हुई है उस अनसुार यह संशोधन आवेदनप बना कसी वल ब के माननीय यायालय के सम तुत कया जा रहा है। ३. यह क, संशोधन आवेदनप पणूत सदभावना पर आधा रत होने से वीकार कये जाने यो य है।

    ४. यह क, शेष त य व तक िनवे दत कये जावेगे।

    7. As per the provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 CPC all persons may be joined in one suit as defendants where any right to relief in respect of, or arising out of the same act or transaction or series of acts or transactions is alleged to exist against such persons, whether jointly, severally or in the alternative and if separate suits were brought against such persons; any common question of law or fact would arise and since the property involved in the present case is an agricultural land, therefore, State was necessary and required to be made a party. Since the plaintiff had not made State as a party, therefore, the application seeking amendment in his written statement in that regard was sought along with contention that prior to institution of the suit no notice under section 80 of CPC was issued to the State, therefore, the plaint deserves to be rejected.

    3

    8. The learned Trial Court in the light of the decision of this Court reported in the matter of Brijrajsingh and others Vs. Bitto Devi (Smt) and another, 1994 (0) MPLJ 192 though held that the State was mandatorily required to be made a party but since had not been made and the provisions of Order 1 Rule 3 CPC mandates for impleading State as a party in every case where land is involved had directed the plaintiff to implead State as a party to the suit, but on the other hand had rejected the application under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC preferred by the present petitioner/defendant.

    9. It is very well settled that whenever any amendment is sought in the written statement the only question to be considered by the Court is whether such amendment would be necessary for decision of the real controversy between the parties in suit and at that stage the Court cannot go into the question of merits of the amendment (Reference be had to a case of Andhra Bank Vs. ABN Amro Bank N.V. AIR 2007 SC 2511).

    10. The purpose and object of the Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC is to allow either party to alter or amend his pleadings in such manner and on such terms as may be just. The power to allow the amendment is wide and can be exercised at any stage of the proceedings, in the interests of justice on the basis of guidelines laid down by this Court as well as the Apex Court. It is also true that the amendment cannot be claimed as a matter of right and under all circumstances. But it is equally true that the Courts while deciding such prayers should not adopt a hypertechnical approach. Liberal approach should be the general rule particularly in cases where the other side can be compensated with the costs, therefore, technicalities of law should not be permitted to hamper the Courts in the administration of justice between the parties and amendments are to be allowed in

    4

    the pleadings to avoid uncalled for multiplicity of litigation.

    11. The Coordinate Bench of this Court in the matter of Ram Singh and others Vs. Shikha Grih Nirman Sahakari Society and others (M.P.No.679/2017, decided on 24.11.2017) has observed as under:

    "From perusal of impugned order, it appears that trial Court has allowed the application preferred by the petitioner under Order 1 Rule 3 (b) (c) of CPC and directed the plaintiff to incorporate the State of Madhya Pradesh as party defendant. Said inclusion is just and proper looking to the amendment in Order 1 Rule 3 of CPC effected by the State Amendment by the State of Madhya Pradesh but when the said aspect petitioners wanted to incorporate into the written statement then trial Court denied the same which appears to be an error apparent on the record because once the application of plaintiff has been allowed then it would be in the interest of justice if the petitioners are allowed to incorporate the said pleadings in respect of grounds raised by them regarding impleadment of State of Madhya Pradesh. It is a pleading which has material bearing over the controversy in question, therefore, needs to be incorporated specially when part of the application is accepted by the trial Court by directing the plaintiff to implead State of Madhya Pradesh, through these pleadings exact course of events would be clear when the proceedings come to an end. Plaintiff is at liberty to cause any consequential amendment if required."

    12. Since in the present matter the learned Trial Court has directed the respondent-plaintiff to implead State as a party but denial to the petitioner/defendant to make amendment in this regard in the written statement appears to be an error apparent on the record as once the plaintiff has been directed to implead the State has party defendant it would be in the interest of justice petitioner/defendant are allowed to incorporate the said pleadings in respect of ground raised by them regarding impleadment of State of M.P. as the pleadings will have material appearing over the controversy in question and therefore, things to be incorporated. In the light of the aforesaid discussion the impugned order dated 26.8.2022 is hereby set aside and the learned Trial Court

    5

    (MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)

    JUDGE

    is directed to allow the petitioner to carry out the necessary amendment in the written statement. The respondent/plaintiff would be at liberty to file an application for consequential amendment, if required.

    13. With the aforesaid direction, the present petition stands disposed of. (aspr)

    6

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sheetal Mata Agritech Pvt. Ltd. Through Director Tarun Goyal v. Puran Singh Jatav
    (Sep 4, 2024)