Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 372 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 374(2) Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C. 14.
  • Sections 302, 201, 120B I.P.C., Police Station-
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 372 Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 374(2) Cr.P.C.,
  • Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C. 14.
  • Sections 302, 201, 120B I.P.C., Police Station-
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Rajendra Tyagi v. State Of Up And 4 Others

    Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC:88255-DB

    HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD

    *****

    (Sl No.3102) Court No. 67 Case :- CRIMINAL APPEAL U/S 372 CR.P.C. No. - 63 of 2024

    Appellant :- Rajendra Tyagi

    Respondent :- State Of Up And 4 Others

    Counsel for Appellant :- Anup Kumar

    Counsel for Respondent :- G.A.

    Hon'ble Rahul Chaturvedi,J. Hon'ble Anish Kumar Gupta,J.

    1. Heard Sri Virendra Singh alongwith Anup Kumar, learned counsel for the appellant at length and perused the records.

    2. This is the appeal under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C., assailing the legality and validity of the judgment and order dated 26.10.2023, passed by the Additional District & Sessions Judge, Court No. 3, Ghaziabad while deciding the S.T. Nos.486 of 2008 (State Vs. Manish and others) and S.T. No. 487 of 2008 (State vs. Smt. Pushpa Devi) arising out of Case Crime Nos.345 of 2007, under Sections 302, 201, 120B I.P.C., Police Station- Pilkhuwa, the then District- Ghaziabad at present Hapur, whereby the learned trial judge has acquitted all the accused respondents by giving a benefit of doubt. The case hinges upon the broken legs of circumstantial evidence and the allegations made therein do not generate the requisite amount of confidence in the prosecution story.

    3. Learned counsel for the appellant have assailed the judgement and order of acquittal on the ground that the learned trial judge has not considered the testimonies of PW-1Rajendra Tyagi (first informant), PW-3 Yogesh Tyagi (brother of the deceased) and PW-4 Karan Singh (last seen witness) and PW-

    8 Anju Tyagi (who claims herself to be the eye-witness to the illicit

    1

    relationship between Manish and Manju). In addition to this, it was also argued that the learned trial court has not considered the statement of PW-2 Dr. Vipin Chandra Gupta, who has prepared the autopsy report of the deceased- Sanjay Tyagi, in which it has been clearly mentioned that the cause of death is severe injury. Learned counsel for the applicant has emphatically stated that the learned trial court has not assessed the testimonies of the witnesses in its correct perspective and in a slip short way having recorded the judgement of acquittal. Thus, on this issue it has been argued that though the case of circumstantial evidence, but the evidence on record has sufficiently indicated the involvement of the respondents accused persons in commission of the offence.

    4. In order to appreciate the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant, this Court has carefully gone through the entire impugned judgement to prima facie satisfy ourselves. We have heard at length, the learned counsel for the appellant for his satisfaction and at a considerable length.

    5. To start with it is imperative to give the illicit relationship between the parties, the informant is Rajendra Tyagi and his wife is Anju Tyagi whereas the deceased was Sanjay Tyagi and name of his wife was Manju Tyagi. Thus, the two real brothers namely Rajendra Tyagi and Sanjay Tyagi were got married with two real sisters, Anju Tyagi and Manju Tyagi.

    6. In the light of above, an F.I.R. was lodged by Rajendra Tyagi through Naresh Kumar Tyagi. On 31.07.2007, he has received a call from his cousin Yogendra Tyagi from Gurgaon to know the whereabouts of informant's real brother and his wife who resides at Gurgaon, where the informant discloses the fact that the aforesaid couple has not come to Village- Azamgarh, P.S.- Babugarh. However, on 01.08.2007, to search out his brother Sanjay Tyagi, the informant went to Gurgaon. Even after holding a search both of them were missing. Then, he met Manish s/o Ved Prakash who also resides in Gurgaon. Then, it has come to knowledge that Manish and Manju went to search out Sanjay Tyagi. When informant inquired from Manish and Manju then they told that Sanjay went to Village- Dehpa to fetch money from

    2

    Bhura Musalman and has not returned back. On 03.08.2007, the informant again went to Dehpa. Then, it was revealed to him that on 31.07.2007 in a Well near pavement of the graveyard, a dead-body of a person was lying and police has taken away the dead body for conducting the autopsy. On 04.08.2007, the informant with his uncle Jain Prakash, Yogesh, Ramavatar, Satyendra and Sunil and others went to Police Station- Pilkhuva to inquire about the dead body. Where police personnel has shown a photograph and from that photograph he has identified the dead body of his brother Sanjay from the photo and the clothes. Yogendra also informed that Sanjay's wife Manju and Manish were in illicit relationship for last 6 to 7 months and on this score there was deep rooted differences and discord between Sanjay and his wife. On this it is alleged that the informant has got a firm faith that it is Manish alongwith his accomplices, have eliminated the deceased Sanjay.

    7. After lodging the F.I.R. it was argued that admittedly it is a case of circumstantial evidence. There is no evidence to establish that the deceased Sanjay was ever seen in the company of Manish or Manju. During the course of investigation, the name of these two persons, namely Manish and Manju have never figured out. Lately, PW-4 Karan Singh for the first time has disclosed the fact that the deceased was seen in the company of Manish and Manju. So far as the motive is concerned, the alleged illicit relationship between them was prominently highlighted by the sole witness, Yogendra but he has never been produced as a prosecution witness.

    8. When any case hinges upon the circumstantial evidence, then, the burden lies upon the prosecution to establish the case beyond any doubt or suspicion indicting the accused person with reasonable certainty. After reading the material on record, there could not be any other possibility of any other story. The units of the chain should be interwoven in such a fashion that they would indict the accused respondents in such a way that no other interference could be drawn from the material on record.

    9. The interesting feature of the case is that in order to establish the prosecution case, PW-1 Rajendra Tyagi, PW-2 Dr. Vipin Chandra Gupta, PW-3 Yogesh Tyagi, PW-4 Karan Singh were produced by the prosecution

    3

    as witness of fact and they in their respective testimonies have given a very superficial depositions, mainly relying upon gossips, hearse and making a very tentative allegation against the accused respondents. PW-8 Anju Tyagi, the real sister of Manju Tyagi in her testimony revealed the fact that when she was residing in Gurgaon, then, her sister got involved with Manish. She has allegedly caught hold of the couple in a compromising condition and mother of Manish was suggesting her son Manish to eliminate the husband of Manju, so that he may enjoy the company of his wife. This deposition was made by none other than the real sister of Manju, who kept mum for a considerable period and lately discloses this relationship. We do not see Yogesh Tyagi, during his cross-examination, who has denied that he has never seen Manish and Manju in a compromising condition. He has never heard that on this score Sanjay and Manju have ever quarreled and the PW-3 in no uncertain terms has stated that all these materials were furnished by his brother as he is not an eye-witness to the incident.

    10. Lastly, PW-2 Dr. Vipin Chandra Gupta, who conducted the postmortem on 01.08.2007, District Hospital at Ghaziabad, states that he has prepared the autopsy report and by that time no F.I.R. was in existence. On account of the fire arms injuries, parietal and frontal bone was found fractured, the brain was disgruntled and cause of death was severe injury on the vital part i.e., brain. As per the information of the doctor, the deceased has sustained two injuries. The injury no.1 was fire arm injury and injury no.2 could be the wound of exit or by falling down on the hard surface. Except that there were no other injuries.

    11. After assessing the entire circumstances, it is established that the case is hangered upon the scattered piece of circumstantial evidence and if the units are aligned they are not going to indict the accused with reasonable amount of certainty. Almost, all the testimonies either are belated one or collected by on a hearse evidence. This is a risky piece of evidence which if at all be relied should be taken with the pinch of salt. The theory of illicit relationship goes hereby that it does not find any reference in the F.I.R. The informant is the husband of PW-8, Smt Anju Tyagi, who claims herself to be the eye

    4

    witness of illicit relationship between Manish and her sister Manju. But, instead of sharing this information with her husband, she maintains her silence and did not disclose the fact to her husband, Rajendra Tyagi, the informant, and thus cannot be read upon. Since, the basic motive of illicit relationship is ignored and brushed aside and therefore, the entire prosecution case goes to shambles as there is no sufficient material on record indicating the accused respondents with reasonable amount of certainty and thus the learned trial judge has rightly recorded the acquittal order of the accused respondents which does not call for any interference in exercise of power under Section 372 Cr.P.C.

    12. Recently, Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgement of Mallappa v. State of Karnataka, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 130 has held as under:-

    37. Our criminal jurisprudence is essentially based on the promise that no innocent shall be condemned as guilty. All the safeguards and the jurisprudential values of criminal law, are intended to prevent any failure of justice. The principles which come into play while deciding an appeal from acquittal could be summarized as:

    (i) Appreciation of evidence is the core element of a criminal trial and such appreciation must be comprehensive - inclusive of all evidence, oral or documentary;

    (ii) Partial or selective appreciation of evidence may result in a miscarriage of justice and is in itself a ground of challenge;

    (iii) If the Court, after appreciation of evidence, finds that two views are possible, the one in favour of the accused shall ordinarily be followed;

    (iv) If the view of the Trial Court is a legally plausible view, mere possibility of a contrary view shall not justify the reversal of acquittal;

    5

    (v) If the appellate Court is inclined to reverse the acquittal in appeal on a re-appreciation of evidence, it must specifically address all the reasons given by the Trial Court for acquittal and must cover all the facts;

    (vi) In a case of reversal from acquittal to conviction, the appellate Court must demonstrate an illegality, perversity or error of law or fact in the decision of the Trial Court.

    13. Assessing the aforementioned analysis and evaluation of the evidence with the aforesaid guidelines given by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgement of Mallappa(supra), we are of the considered opinion that the learned trial court has taken legally plausible view, which favours the accused and thus it does not deserves any interference by this court in exercise of powers under Section 378 (3) Cr.P.C.

    14. We have considered the submissions of the learned A.G.A for the State and have perused the record.

    15. Before proceeding further, it would be appropriate to take note of law with regard to Government Appeals.

    16. In the case of Bannareddy v. State of Karnataka, (2018) 5 SCC 790, in paragraph 10, the Hon'ble Apex Court has considered the power and jurisdiction of the High Court while interfering in an appeal against acquittal and in paragraph 26 it has been held that "the High Court should not have reappreciated the evidence in its entirety, especially when there existed no grave infirmity in the findings of the trial Court. There exists no justification behind setting aside the order of acquittal passed by the trial Court, especially when the prosecution case suffers from several contradictions and infirmities".

    17. In Jayamma v. State of Karnataka, (2021) 6 SCC 213, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has been pleased to explain the limitations of exercise of

    6

    power of scrutiny by the High Court in an appeal against an order of acquittal passed by a Trial Court.

    18. In a recent judgment of this Court in Virendra Singh v. State Of U.P., 2022 (3) ADJ 354, the law on the issue involved has been considered.

    19. Similar view has been reiterated by Hon'ble Apex Court in Rajesh Prasad v. State of Bihar, (2022) 3 SCC 471.

    20. Therefore, we are in full agreement with the findings recorded by the trial court and accordingly we do not find any good reason to take a different view in the matter. Therefore, the instant appeal the application for leave to appeal under Section 372 Cr.P.C., is hereby rejected and consequently, this instant criminal appeal is dismissed.

    Order Date :- 5.3.2024 Shubham Arya

    (Anish Kumar Gupta, J.) (Rahul Chaturvedi,J.)

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajendra Tyagi v. State Of Up And 4 Others
    (Mar 5, 2024)