AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises from an appeal against an order dated 30/09/2003 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nagpur, in Special Civil Suit No. 557/2003. The trial court rejected the plaintiff's application for a temporary injunction (Exh. 98). The plaintiff filed this appeal challenging that rejection. The appeal was admitted on 22/11/2007, and no interim order was passed by this Court. The matter remains fixed for evidence before the trial court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the application for injunction filed by the plaintiff before the Civil Judge, Senior Division, was maintainable given the administrative transfer of the suit from the Junior Division to the Senior Division Court.
  2. Whether the orders passed by the competent court before the administrative transfer continue to hold legal effect.
  3. Whether the trial court was correct in rejecting the fresh application for injunction on the ground that the previous order rejecting injunction was still in force and unchallenged.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondents' Arguments

  • The trial court's order rejecting the injunction application is valid and the application is not maintainable due to administrative transfer of the suit.
  • The transfer of the suit from the Junior Division to the Senior Division was administrative and not jurisdictional, hence previous orders remain effective.
  • The interim order passed by the Junior Division Court remains in force until set aside, and the plaintiff has not demonstrated otherwise.
  • The fresh application for injunction is improper and lacks legal basis as the earlier order rejecting injunction was not challenged and continues to hold.
  • The matter is fixed for evidence and no interference with the trial court's order is warranted.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the maintainability of the plaintiff's injunction application in light of the administrative transfer of the suit from the Civil Judge, Junior Division to the Senior Division. It held that the transfer was purely administrative and did not affect the jurisdiction or the validity of previous orders. The court emphasized that orders passed by a competent court before such transfer remain enforceable unless set aside. The trial court's rejection of the injunction application was based on this principle, noting that a prior similar application was rejected and that order was not challenged. Consequently, the court found no legal or procedural impropriety in the trial court's refusal to grant a fresh injunction. Given that the matter was scheduled for evidence, the court declined to interfere with the trial court's order.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is that the trial court's order refusing to grant the injunction application stands affirmed. The plaintiff's fresh application for injunction is deemed improper and without merit. No interim relief will be granted, and the case proceeds to evidence. The court did not establish any new legal precedent; rather, it reaffirmed the principle that administrative transfer of suits does not invalidate prior competent court orders unless set aside.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SHIV SHAKTI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY v. M/S SWARAJ DEVELOPERS THR.ITS REP. & 8 OTHERS

    1

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    NAGPUR BENCH, NAGPUR

    APPEAL AGAINST ORDER NO. 7/2004 Shiv Shakti Co-operative Housing Society, Nagpur, through its President Nathuram Lahanuji Zade, Nagpur. APPELLANT

    ...VERSUS...

    1. M/s. Swaraj Developers, through its representative

    2. Shri Developers through its Proprietor.

    3. Waman Ganesh Ambekar (Deleted as per Court's Order dt. 9.10.07)

    4. Prakash Wamanrao Ambekar

    5. Vilas @ Vyankatesh Wamanrao Ambekar,

    6. Pradip Wamanrao Ambekar,

    7. Anant Wamanrao Ambekar,

    8. Smt. Swati w/o Laxmikant Bhale

    9. Smt. Shantabai wd/o Narayan Ambekar RESPONDENTS

    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    None for the appellants.

    Mr. A.A.Naik, advocate h/f Shri S.V.Manohar, Advocate for respondent Nos. 1 & 2. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    CORAM: R. K. DESHPANDE, J.

    DATE : 15 th NOVEMBER, 2010.

    ORAL JUDGMENT

    1] This appeal against order challenges the order dated

    1

    30/09/2003 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nagpur, in Special Civil Suit No. 557/2003. By this order, the application (Exh. 98) filed by the plaintiff has been rejected. Hence, the plaintiff has preferred this appeal.

    2] The appeal was admitted on 22/11/2007. There is no interim order passed by this Court in this appeal. The trial Court has rejected the application for grant of injunction. Shri Naik, the learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.1 submits that the matter is fixed before the trial Court for evidence. He further submits that the trial Court has recorded the finding that the application is not maintainable. He has invited my attention to the relevant portion of the order impugned in this appeal, which is contained in paras 3 and 4 of the judgment of the trial Court, which is reproduced below.

    "3............ Therefore, it cannot be said that the plaintiff has been returned and the suit has become a fresh suit. Initially also, the suit was filed before Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nagpur, and it was registered as Regular Civil Suit on the file of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nagpur, but it was allotted to the Court of Civil Judge, Junior Division, Nagpur, for disposal. Therefore, the transfer of the suit from that Court to this Court is not on any jurisdiction ground but on an administrative ground. Therefore, the ratio in the cases relied by the learned counsel for the plaintiff do not come to help of the plaintiff. So far as the interim order passed by the Civil Judge, Junior Division when the suit was regular civil suit, they were passed by the Court competent, and when a competent court passed certain order it remains in force till it is set aside. The plaintiff

    2

    has not shown that because of such transfer of the suit on administrative ground of mere change of the number due to change in pecuniary jurisdiction, the orders passed by the Court before change of the number of the suit stood vanished. Therefore, I find that the orders of the Court of Civil Judge, Junior Division, passed on the applications (Exh. 5 and 62) still hold good and they are enforced. It shall be proper to mention that the order passed by the Civil Judge, Junior Division, Nagpur (on Exhibit 5) in this suit was challenged upto the Supreme Court. But the same has been maintained for whatever may be the reason.

    4. It shall be p[roper to mention that the application (Exh. 62) was filed by the present plaintiff for temporary injunction before the Civil Judge, Junior Division, on the same ground of changing circumstances as reiterated in the present application. That application has been rejected by Civil Judge, Senior Division, Nagpur. It is not the case of the plaintiff that that order has been challenged. Therefore, that order passed by Civil Judge, Senior Division is still in force and therefore, appears no propriety or legality in moving this fresh application and therefore, there is no ground for this Court to pass any order thereon. Therefore, I have answered point No. 1 in the negative."

    3] In view of the aforesaid finding, no fault can be found with the order passed by the trial Court refusing to grant injunction. As has been informed by Mr. Naik, the learned counsel for the respondent, the matter is already fixed for evidence. Hence, no interference is called for in the present appeal against order. Hence, the appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    JUDGE

    Rvjalit

    3

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SHIV SHAKTI COOPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY v. M/S SWARAJ DEVELOPERS THR.ITS REP. & 8 OTHERS
    (Nov 15, 2010)