ORDER
The petitioner is before this Court calling in question the proceedings in C.C.No.34 of 2017 registered for the offence punishable under Sections 498(A), 306 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. Brief facts as projected by the prosecution are as follows:
A complaint comes to be registered by the mother of the deceased, wife of accused No.1 alleging that petitioner and accused No.1 are responsible for her death. Against accused No.1, the husband, the offence under Section 498(A) of IPC is laid and against the petitioner, the offence under Section 306 of IPC - abatement to suicide is laid. The police after investigation filed a charge-sheet for the
- 3 -
afore-quoted offences against both the accused. Filing of the charge-sheet against the petitioner for offence punishable under Sections 498(A) and 306 of IPC is what drives the petitioner to this Court in the subject petition.
3. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and also the learned HCGP appearing for Respondent No.1.
4. The learned counsel representing the petitioner would submit that a perusal at the complaint or the summary of the charge-sheet would not indicate any ingredients of the offence punishable under Sections 306 of the IPC, which alone can be laid against the petitioner as the petitioner is the friend of the husband of the deceased. Therefore, the offence under Section 498(A) of IPC cannot even get attracted against the petitioner and for the offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC, there are no ingredients and therefore, seeks quashment of the entire proceedings.
- 4 -
5. The complainant though served on 07.06.2020 remains unrepresented.
6. The learned HCGP seeks to refute the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner seeking to contend that the offence alleged is grave as it is the one punishable under Sections 306 of IPC and therefore, the petitioner has to come out clean in the trial. She would seek dismissal of the petition.
7. I have given my anxious consideration to the submissions made by the respective learned counsel and have perused the material on record.
8. The afore-narrated facts are not in dispute. The issue that leads to registration of a crime is a complaint registered by the second respondent, the mother of the deceased. The deceased is the wife of accused No.1, the husband who is not before the Court. The complaint runs as follows:
"ಕಳಂೆಳ ೕ ಾಾ ಸಇ ೆಕ ರವ ೆ
- 5 -
ತುರು ೇಕೆ ಾ ೊ"ೕಕು ದಂ$ನ&ವರ 'ೋಬಳ, ಸಂ)ೆ 'ೊಸಹ+ ಾ,ಮದ, ಕುರುಬ ಜ/ಾಂಗದ, ಾ1ಂ23ನಲ" 5ೆಲಸ 6ಾಡುವ ಸು6ಾರು 48 ವಷ2 ವಯ: ನ /ಾಗಾಜುರವರ 'ೆಂಡ; ಸೋಜ ಆದ /ಾನು =ೈ? 6ಾ$: 5ೊಟ ದೂರು, ಏ/ೆಂದೆ ನಮೆ ಇಬBರು 'ೆಣುDಮಕE+ದುF, Gದಲ/ೇ ಮಗಳH, /ಾಗರತI, ಈ5ೆಯನುI KಕE/ಾಯಕನಹ+ ಾ: ಆನಂದರವ ೆ 5ೊಟು ಮದು ೆ 6ಾ$ದುF ಅವ ೆ ಇಬBರು 'ೆಣುD ಮಕEಳರುಾMೆ. 2 /ೇ ಮಗಳH ಸುNಾಾO @ ೇP ಆQದುF ಈ5ೆಯನುI & ಾ ಾ ೊ"ೕಕು, ಕಳಂೆಳ 'ೋಬಳ, 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ ಾ,ಮದ ಾ: ಅಂಜನಪTರವರ 2 /ೇ ಮಗ ಜಗUೕಶ ಎಂಬುವXೆ ಈ Yೆ 11 ವಷ2ಗಳ Zಂ[ೆ 5ೊಟು ಮದು ೆ ನನI ಅ+ಯ ಮಗಳH ಮದು ೆ\ಾದ ಸ]ಲT ವಷ2 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ ಾ,ಮದ " ಾಸ^ದುF, ಇವ ೆ _ೕವ ಎಂಬ 10 ವಷ2ದ ಮಗXರುಾM/ೆ. ನನI ಆಳಯXೆ GದಲXಂದನೂ ನನI ಮಗಳH \ಾೊಂUಾದರೂ 6ಾತ/ಾ$ದೆ ಅನು6ಾನ ಪಡುವ`ದು ಅವೊಂUೆ ಸಂಭಂಧ ಕಲT:5ೊಂಡು ಆ5ೆಯನುI 'ೊcೆಯುವ`ದು 6ಾನ:ಕ ಾQ Zಂdೆ Xೕಡುವ`ದು 6ಾಡು;MದFನು, ^eಾರ ಾQ /ಾವ` dಾಕಷು ಾ ನನI ಆಆಯXೆ ಬುUF 'ೇ+[ Fೆವ`, ಆತXೆ ಮಧfಾನ 6ಾಡುವ ಮತುM ಇತೆ 5ೆಟ ಚಟಗಳದುF \ಾ ಾಗಲೂ ಹಣ5ಾEQ ನನI ಮಗಳನುI Hallo 21/1916 )ೕ$ಸು;MದF ಂದ ಮತುM ಾ,ಮದಲ". ಅವ ವರ 6ಾತು 5ೇ+ ನನI ಮಗಳ 1ೕ ೆ ಅನು6ಾನ ಪಡು;MದF ಂದ ನನI ಮಗಳH ೆಂಗಳh ನಲ" ಏ/ಾದರೂ 5ೆಲಸ 6ಾcೋ… ಎಂತ ನನI ಆಲಯ ಮಗ/ೊಂUೆ 'ೋQದುF, ೮ ವಷ2 ೆಂಗಳh ನ " 5ೆಲಸ 6ಾ$5ೊಂ$ದFರು, ನನI ಆಆಯ ಅಲ" ಕಟವರ ಸಹ ಾಸ 6ಾ$ 5ೆಟ 5ೆಟ 5ೆಲಸ 6ಾಡು;MದF ಂದ ಇದ ಂದ ಮುಂ[ೆ ಮಗನ ಭ^ಷf 'ಾRಾಗುತMಂತ ನನI ಮಗಳH ಈ Yೆ 1 ವಷ2ದ Zಂ[ೆ ಮ Mೆ ಾಪ 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ೆ ಬಂದು ಾಸ^ದFರು, ಬಂದ 1ೕಲೂ ನನI ಆಯ ನನI ಮಗ+ೆ ಕು$ದು ಬಂದು ಗ ಾ=ೆ 6ಾಡುವ`ದು ಹಣ ಕೂಡು ಎಂತ )ೕ$ಸುವ`ದು 6ಾಡು;MದFನು, ಈ ಬ Yೆ /ಾವ` dಾಕಷು ಾ ಬುUF 'ೇಳ ;ೕ6ಾ2ನ 6ಾ$[ Fೆವ`. ಈ ಮNೆf ಜjೕXನ " ಪವ ೈ 'ಾದು 'ೋದ ಹಣ 33 ಲk ಬಂUದುF ಈಹಣವನುI ನನI ಅ+ಯ ಮ/ೆಯ " \ಾ ಗೂ 'ೇಳ[ೇ 5ೇಳ[ೇ, ಖಚು2 6ಾ$5ೊಂಡು ಉಳದ ಹಣವನುI ಅ[ೇ ಾ,ಮದ ೋ^ಂದಪT, ಆತನ ಮಕERಾದ ;ಮnಾಜು ಮತುM ರಂಗXೆ dಾಲ ಾQ 5ೊಟದF, ನನI ಅRೆಯXೆ 5ೆಟ ಜನರ ಸಹ ಾಸ^ದುF ಏ/ೋ 5ೆಟ 5ೆಲಸ 6ಾ$ ಹುಬBಳ ೕಸ ೆ :oE: ಬRಾ pೈಲನಲ" 3 ;ಂಗಳH ಇದುF ಈ Yೆ ಒಂದು ;ಂಗಳ Zಂ[ೆ ಮ/ೆೆ ಬಂUದF U/ಾಂಕ:19/10/2015 ರಂದು 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ ಾ,ಮ5ೆE 5ೊಟರುವ ನನI ತಂQ\ಾದ jೕ/ಾkಮn ನನI [ೊಡr ಅಳಯ ಆನಂದ ರವ ೆ sೕ 6ಾ$ XನI /ಾUX tೇP ರವರ ಗಂಡ ಜಗUೕಶ ತನೆ ಹಣ ೋ^ಂಪT ಮತುM ಆತನ ಮಕEಳೆ 5ೊPದF ಹಣವನುI 5ೇಳಲು 'ೋ[ಾಗ ೋ^ಂದಪTನ ಮಗ ;ಮnಾಜು XನI
- 6 -
'ೆಂಡ; ಸ ಇಲ" XನI ಮಗ \ಾ ೆ ಹುಟ[ಾF/ೆಂತ XನI 'ೆಂಡ;ಯನುI 5ೇಳH XನI 'ೆಂಡ; ಇನೂI ಬದುo[ಾFಳ' ಎಂದು ೈಯುf XನI 'ೆಂಡ;ಯನುI ಕೆದು5ೊಂಡು ಾ ಹಣ 5ೊಡು Mೇ ೆ ಎಂದು 'ೇಳ[ಾಗ ಜಗUೕಶ ಮ/ೆಯ ಬಳ ಇ[ೇ Uನ ಾ;, 7- 30 ಗಂ=ೆ ಸಮಯದ " ಬಂದು ೇಜೆ ಾ ೋ^ಂದಪTನ ಮ/ೆ ಬ+ 'ೋQ ಹಣ 5ೇRhೇಣ XನI ಬ Yೆ ಇಲ" ಸಲ"[ಾQ 'ೇ+ ೈuFರುಾM/ೆ. ಎಂದು ಕೆ[ಾಗ ೇP ಜಗUೕಶನನುI Xೕನು ನನIನುI 5ೇಳ ಹಣ 5ೊಟರುವ`Uಲ" Xೕ/ೇ 'ೋQ 5ೇ+5ೋ ಎಂದು 'ೇಳ[ಾಗ ಜಗUೕಶ ೇvೆ ಮಗ _ೕವ ಎದುರ "ೇ ;ಮnಾಜು XನI ಬ Yೆ 'ೇ+ರುವ`ದು ಸತf Xೕನು ಸೂRೆಮುಂcೆ, ನನೆ ಹುಟದವನು _ೕವ, Xೕನು ಸ ಇಲ" Xೕನು ಎಲ"\ಾದೋ 'ೋQ dಾu ಮುಂcೆ ಇನೂI \ಾ5ೆ ಭೂj 1ೕ ೆ ಬದುoUFೕ\ಾ ಎಂತ ಇಾfU\ಾQ ೈಯುಾM 5ೈಗಳಂದ 'ೊcೆದು 5ಾಲXಂದ 'ೊದುF ಮ/ೆuಂದ 'ೊರಟು 'ೋQರುಾM/ೆ, ೇv ಮ/ೆಯ " ಅಳHಾM ತುಂಾ ಮನ: ೆ ೇpಾರು 6ಾ$5ೊಂಡು ಕೂ;ದFಳH. /ಾನು ಮ/ೆೆ 'ೋQ ೇ ೆ ಸ6ಾNಾನ 'ೇಳH;M[ಾFಗ KಕEಮn /ಾನು 1 ಇನುI ಬದುoರುವ`Uಲ" ಎಲ"\ಾದೋ 'ೋQ dಾಯು Mೇ/ೆ. ಇವರ Zಂdೆ ತcೆಯುವ`ದ " ಆಗು;Mಲ". ನನI 1ೕ ೆ ಇಲ" ಸಲ"ದ ಆೋಪವನುI ನನI ಗಂಡXೆ ;ಮnಾಜು 'ೇ+ರುಾM/ೆ. ಆದF ಂದ ನನI ಗಂಡ ಬಂದು ನನI 1ೕ ೆ ಈ ೕ; ಗ ಾ=ೆ 6ಾ$ರುಾM/ೆಂತ 'ೇಳ[ಾಗ /ಾನು ೇvೆ ಮಗX[ಾF/ೆ ಎಲ"ಯೂ 'ೋಗೇಡ ಮತುM dಾಯುವ ಪ,ಯತI 6ಾಡೇಡ ಎಂತ ಬುUF 'ೇ+ ನಮn ಮ/ೆೆ ಾಪ ಬಂUರು Mೇ/ೆ. ನಂತರ ೇRೆ ಮ/ೆuಂದ ಎಲ"ೋ 'ೋQರುಾMR ೆಅಂತ ;+:ದರು. ಎಂತ ನನI [ೊಡr ಆಆಯ ಆನಂದ ನನೆ sೕ 6ಾ$ ;+:ದರು. ನಂತರ /ಾವ` ನನI ಆಯ ಮತುM ನಮn ಮಗಳH /ಾಗರತI ಅ[ೇ Uನ ಾ;, 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ ಾ,ಮ5ೆE ಬಂದು ನನI ಮಗಳH ೇPಯನುI ಎ ಾ" /ೆಂಟರ ಮ/ೆಗಳ " ^eಾರ 6ಾ$ದರೂ, ನನI ಮಗಳH :oEರಅಲ". ಈ Uನ ೆಳ Yೆ 7-00 ಗಂ=ೆಯ "
5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ ಾ,ಮದ Q ಜಮn 5ೋಂ ಜಯಣDರವರು ೋಟದ ಾ^ಯ " ಸುNಾಾO @ ೇvಯ ಶವ ೇಲು;Mರು Mೆ ಎಂತ ಅಂತ ;+:ದರು, ತkಣ /ಾವ` 'ೋQ /ೋಡ ಾQ ಸದ ಮೃತ[ೇಹವ` ನನI ಮಗಳH ಸುNಾಾO ) ೇvಯ[ಾQತುM, ನನI ಮಗಳ dಾ^ೆ ನನI ಆದ ಜಗUೕಶ ಮತುM ಅ[ೇ ಾ,ಮದ ಾ:\ಾದ ;ಮnಾಜುರವರ 'ದುyೇರೆzೕ 5ಾರಣ ಾQರು Mೆ. ಸದ ಯವರ 1ೕ ೆ ಸೂಕM 5ಾನೂನು ಕ,ಮ ಜರುQಸೇ5ೆಂತ 5ೇಳ5ೊಳH Mೇ/ೆ. ಈ ^eಾರವನುI ನಮn ಸಂಬಂ{ಕ ೆ ^eಾರ ;+: ಈಗ ತಡ ಾQ ಬಂದು ದೂರು Xೕ$ರು Mೇ/ೆ.
ತಮn ^[ೇಯಳH
800 498(A) 306, Rlw 34 Ipe olsa
- 7 -
DOB:21/10/2016 ಸ|ಳ: ಕಳಂೆಳ"
9. The police, after investigation have filed a charge- sheet against both the accused, the petitioner and the husband of the deceased. The summary of the charge- sheet as obtaining in Clause 17 reads a follows:
"17. 5ೇ:ನ ಸಂ~ಪM dಾಾಂಶ U/ಾಂಕ:19/10/2016 ರಂದು ಾ;, 7-30 ಗಂ=ೆ ಸಮಯದ , &ಾ ಾ®Æè ಕಳಂೆ¼Àî 'ೋಬ+ 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ಯ ಅಂ_ನಪT v [ೊಡrಯf ರವರ ಜjೕXನ "ರುವ ಆೋ) ಜಗUೕಶ ಮತುM ಮೃೆ ಸುNಾಾO ಾಸ^ದF ಮ/ೆಯ ಮುಂ[ೆ ಈ [ೋyಾೋಪಣ ಪತ, ಅಂಕಣ-12 ರ , ಕಂಡ ಆೋ)-1 ಜಗUೕಶ ರವರು dಾ~- 1 ರವರ ಮಗಳH ಮೃೆ ಸುNಾಾO @ ೇ© ರವರನುI ಮದು ೆ\ಾ[ಾQXಂದಲೂ ಅನು6ಾನ ಪಟು ಮೃೆ ೇೆ ಗಂಡಸರ pೊೆ 6ಾತ/ಾ$ದೆ ಅನು6ಾನ ಪಡುವ`ದು ಅವರ pೊೆ ಸಂಬಂಧ ಕ T: 'ೊcೆಯುವ`ದು ಬ$ಯುವ`ದು 'ಾಗೂ 6ಾನ:ಕ ಾQ Zಂdೆ XೕಡುಾM, ಆೋ)-1 ರವರು ಆೋ)-2, ;ಮnಾಜು 'ಾಗೂ ಆತನ ಮ/ೆಯವ ೆ Xೕ$ದF. dಾಲದ ಹಣವನುI U/ಾಂಕ:19/10/2016 ರಂದು ಸಂpೆ ಸು6ಾರು 6-30 ಗಂ=ೆಯ "
ಆೋ)-1 ರವರ ಮ/ೆಯ ಬ+ 5ಾR ೕೆನಹ+ೆ 'ಾದು'ೋಗುವ ರd Mೆಯ " 5ೇ+[ಾQ ಆೋ)-2 ರವರು ಆೋ)-1 ರವ ೆ XನI 'ೆಂಡ; ಮೃೆ ಸುNಾಾO ಸ uಲ", XನI ಮಗ \ಾ ೆ ºÀÄnzÁÝ/ೆಂತ Xೕನು XನI 'ೆಂಡ;ಯನುI 5ೇಳH XನI 'ೆಂಡ; ಇನುI ಬದುo[ಾFಳ ಎಂದು ಮೃೆಯ ಬ Yೆ ಇಲ"ಸಲ"ದನುI 'ೇ+ ದು? ೆ,ೕರಣ 6ಾ$ದF ಂದ ಆೋ)-1 ರವರು ತನI ಾಸದ ಮ/ೆಯ ಮುಂ[ೆ ತನI 'ೆಂಡ; ಮೃೆ ಸುNಾಾO ರವರನುI dಾ~-5 ತನI ಮಗ _ೕವ ರವರ ಮುಂ[ೆ ಾ ೋ^ಂದಪTನ ಮ/ೆ ಬ+ 'ೋQ ಹಣ 5ೇRhೇಣ, XನI ಬ Yೆ ;ಮnಾಜು ಇಲ, ಸಲnದನುI 'ೇ+ ೈUರುಾM/ೆ ಎಂದು ಕೆzÁಗ ಮೃvÉ ಸಂNಾಾO Xೕನು ನನIನುI 5ೇ+ ಹಣ 5ೊPರುವ`Uಲ", Xೕ/ೇ 'ೋQ 5ೇ+5ೋ ಎಂದು 'ೇ+[ಾಗ Xೕನು ಸ uಲ ಆೋ)-2 XನI ಬ Yೆ 'ೇ+ರುವ`ದು ಸvÀå Xೕನು ಸೂR ೆ ಮುಂcೆ, ನನೆ ಹುPದವನಲ", _ೕವ, Xೕನು ಎ \ಾದರೂ 'ೋQ dಾu ಮುಂಡ ಇನುI, ಏ5ೆ ಭೂj 1ೕ ೆ ಬದುoUFೕ\ಾ ಎಂದು ಇಾfU\ಾQ ೈದು 6ಾನ:ಕ ಾQ Zಂdೆ Xೕ$, 5ೈಗ+ಂದ
- 8 -
'ೊcೆದು 5ಾಲುಗ+ಂದ 'ೊzÀÄ [ೈZಕ Zಂdೆ Xೕ$ದF ಂದ ಮೃತ ಸುNಾಾO ಮನ/ೊಂದು U:19/10/2016 ರಂದು ಾ;, 9-30 ಗಂ=ೆಯ ನಂತರ U:21/10/2016 ರ ೆ+ೆ, 7-00 ಗಂ=ೆಯ ಮNೆf \ಾವ`[ೋ ಸಮಯದ ", ಾ^ಯ Xೕ ೆ vದುF ಮೃತಪಡಲು 5ಾರಣಾQರುಾMೆಂತ ಆೋ)ತರ ^ರುದ ಆೋಪವ` ತXೆuಂದ ದೃಢಪಟ 1ೕೆೆ 1ೕಲEಂಡ ಕಲಂ ೕಾ] ಈ [ೋyಾೋಪಣ ಪತ,.
18. \ಾ2{ಯ 1ೕ ೆ /ೋPೕ pಾ 6ಾಡ ಾQ[ೆzೕ : No DD: 09/12/2016
00:00:00
19, ವೃತ,X ೕkಕರ ಷಾ ಮತುM /ಾf\ಾ{ೕಶ ೆ ಕಳHZ:ದ U/ಾಂಕ :
Signature of the Investigating Office ¸À»/-
¥ÉÆÃ°¸ï ¸À¨ï E£Àì¥ÉPÀÖgï
PÀ¼ÀîA¨É¼Àî ¥ÉÆÃ°¸ï oÁuÉ.
A perusal at the complaint and the charge-sheet and then being read in juxtaposition would clearly indicate that the allegation against the petitioner is that he had abutted commission of suicide of the daughter of the complainant, wife of accused No.1 making allegations on her character. Insofar as the offence under Section 498(A) of the IPC is concerned, they, at the outset, cannot be laid against the petitioner who is not a member of the family but only a friend of the accused No.1. The only offence therefore, is the one punishable under Section 306 of IPC. For an offence to become punishable under Section 306 of IPC,
- 9 -
the ingredients as obtaining under Section 107 of IPC is imperative. Section 107 of IPC deals with abatement. Any of the ingredients that are of Section 107 of IPC being present in a crime, then, it would become a matter of trial for the offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC.
10. A perusal at the complaint or the summary of the charge-sheet as obtaining in Column No.17 would not meet any of the ingredients that is necessary to prove an offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC. Abatement as is necessary for an offence under Section 306 of IPC is not present in the case at hand. Therefore, the trial, if permitted to be continued, it would definitely not end in conviction of the petitioner due to the lack of ingredients. Reference is being made to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of KANCHAN SHARMA Vs. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH AND ANOTHER1, in the circumstances, becomes applicable. The Apex Court has held as follows:
- 10 -
"9. Having heard learned counsel on both sides, we have perused the impugned order and other material placed on record. Except the self-serving statements of the complainant and other witnesses stating that deceased was in love with the appellant, there is no other material to show that appellant was maintaining any relation with the deceased. From the material placed on record it is clear that on the date of incident on 04.05.2018 deceased went to the house of the appellant and consumed poison by taking out from a small bottle which he has carried in his pocket. Merely because he consumed poison in front of the house of the appellant, that itself will not indicate any relation of the appellant with the deceased. 'Abetment' involves mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, no one can be convicted for offence under Section 306, IPC. To proceed against any person for the offence under Section 306 IPC it requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide, seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide. There is nothing on record to show that appellant was maintaining relation with the deceased and further there is absolutely no material to allege that appellant abetted for suicide of the deceased within the meaning of Section 306, IPC. Even with regard to offence alleged under Section 3(2)(v) of the Act it is to be noticed that except vague and bald statement that the appellant and other family members abused deceased by uttering casteist words but there is nothing on record to show to attract any of the ingredients for the alleged offence also. This Court in the case of Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi)1 had an occasion to deal with the aspect of abetment. In the said case this Court has opined that there should be an intention to provoke, incite or encourage the doing of an act by the accused. Besides, the judgment also observed that each person's suicidability pattern is different from the other and each person has his own idea of self-esteem and self-respect. In the said judgment it is held that it is impossible to lay down any straightjacket formula dealing with the cases of suicide and each case has to be decided on the basis of its own facts and circumstances. In the case
- 11 -
of Amalendu Pal Alias Jhantu v. State Of West Bengal . Bengal2 in order to bring a case within the purview of Section 306, IPC this Court has held as under:
"12. Thus, this Court has consistently taken the view that before holding an accused guilty of an offence under Section 306 IPC, the court must scrupulously examine the facts and circumstances of the case and also assess the evidence adduced before it in order to find out whether the cruelty and harassment meted out to the victim had left the victim with no other alternative but to put an end to her life. It is also to be borne in mind that in cases of alleged abetment of suicide there must be proof of direct or indirect acts of incitement to the commission of suicide. Merely on the allegation of harassment without there being any positive action proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused which led or compelled the person to commit suicide, conviction in terms of Section 306 IPC is not sustainable.
13. In order to bring a case within the purview of Section 306 IPC there must be a case of suicide and in the commission of the said offence, the person who is said to have abetted the commission of suicide must have played an active role by an act of instigation or by doing certain act to facilitate the commission of suicide. Therefore, the act of abetment by the person charged with the said offence must be proved and established by the prosecution before he could be convicted under Section 306 IPC."
10. In the judgment in the case of S.S. Chheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan3 this Court reiterated the ingredients of offence of Section
306 IPC. Paragraph 25 of the judgment reads as under:
"25. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. The
- 12 -
intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section
306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide."
11. In the judgment in the case of Rajiv Thapar v. Madan Lal Kapur4 this Court has considered the scope of the provision under Section 482, Cr.PC and has laid down the steps which should be followed by the High Court to determine the veracity of a prayer for quashing of proceedings in exercise of power under Section 482, Cr.PC. Paragraph 30 containing the four steps read as under:
"30. Based on the factors canvassed in the foregoing paragraphs, we would delineate the following steps to determine the veracity of a prayer for quashment raised by an accused by invoking the power vested in the High Court under Section 482 CrPC:
30.1. Step one: whether the material relied upon by the accused is sound, reasonable, and indubitable i.e. the material is of sterling and impeccable quality?
30.2. Step two: whether the material relied upon by the accused would rule out the assertions contained in the charges levelled against the accused i.e. the material is sufficient to reject and overrule the factual assertions contained in the complaint i.e. the material is such as would persuade a reasonable person to dismiss and condemn the factual basis of the accusations as false?
30.3. Step three: whether the material relied upon by the accused has not been refuted by the prosecution/complainant; and/or the material is such that it cannot be
- 13 -
justifiably refuted by the prosecution/complainant?
30.4. Step four: whether proceeding with the trial would result in an abuse of process of the court, and would not serve the ends of justice?
30.5. If the answer to all the steps is in the affirmative, the judicial conscience of the High Court should persuade it to quash such criminal proceedings in exercise of power vested in it under Section 482 CrPC. Such exercise of power, besides doing justice to the accused, would save precious court time, which would otherwise be wasted in holding such a trial (as well as proceedings arising therefrom) specially when it is clear that the same would not conclude in the conviction of the accused."
12. By applying the aforesaid ratio decided by this Court, we have carefully scrutinized the material on record and examined the facts of the case on hand. Except the statement that the deceased was in relation with the appellant, there is no material at all to show that appellant was maintaining any relation with the deceased. In fact, at earlier point of time when the deceased was stalking the appellant, the appellant along with her father went to the police station complained about the calls which were being made by the deceased to the appellant. Same is evident from the statement of S.I. Manoj Kumar recorded on 05.07.2018. In his statement recorded he has clearly deposed that the father along with the appellant went to the police post and complained against the deceased who was continuously calling the appellant and proposing that she should marry him with a threat that he will die otherwise. Having regard to such material placed on record and in absence of any material within the meaning of Section 107 of IPC, there is absolutely no basis to proceed against the appellant for the alleged offence under Section 306 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the Act. It would be travesty of justice to compel the appellant to face a criminal trial without any credible material whatsoever.
- 14 -
13. In view of the same, we are of the view that the High Court has committed error in rejecting the application filed by the appellant by merely recording a finding that in view of the factual disputes same cannot be decided in a petition under Section 482, Cr.PC." (Emphasis supplied)
The same judgment is followed by the Apex Court even in 2023 in the case of KASHIBAI VS. STATE OF KARNATAKA2 wherein the Apex Court considers the interplay between Sections 107 and 306 of IPC to hold that unless the ingredients of Section 107 of IPC are found, no offence under Section 306 of IPC can be laid. The Apex Court in the case of KASHIBAI has held as follows:
"8. From the bare reading of the said provisions, it clearly transpires that in order to convict a person for the offences under Section 306 IPC, the basic constituents of the offence namely where the death was suicidal and whether there was an abetment on the part of the accused as contemplated in Section 107 IPC have to be established.
9. In M. Mohan v. State Represented by the Deputy Superintendent of Police1, this Court has elaborately dealt with the provisions contained in Section 306 read with Section 107 IPC, and after discussing various earlier decisions has observed as under:—
"41. This Court in SCC para 20 of Ramesh Kumar, [(2001) 9 SCC 618 : 2002 SCC (Cri) 1088] has examined different shades of the
- 15 -
meaning of "instigation". Para 20 reads as under :
(SCC p. 629)
"20. Instigation is to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite or encourage to do 'an act'. To satisfy the requirement of instigation though it is not necessary that actual words must be used to that effect or what constitutes instigation must necessarily and specifically be suggestive of the consequence. Yet a reasonable certainty to incite the consequence must be capable of being spelt out. The present one is not a case where the accused had by his acts or omission or by a continued course of conduct created such circumstances that the deceased was left with no other option except to commit suicide in which case an instigation may have been inferred. A word uttered in the fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow cannot be said to be instigation."
In the said case this Court came to the conclusion that there is no evidence and material available on record wherefrom an inference of the appellant-accused having abetted commission of suicide by Seema (the appellant's wife therein) may necessarily be drawn.
42. In State of W.B. v. Orilal Jaiswal, [(1994) 1 SCC 73 : 1994 SCC (Cri) 107] this Court has cautioned that (SCC p. 90, para 17) the Court should be extremely careful in assessing the facts and circumstances of each case and the evidence adduced in the trial for the purpose of finding whether the cruelty meted out to the victim had in fact induced her to end her life by committing suicide. If it appears to the Court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and difference in domestic life, quite common to the society, to which the victim belonged and such petulance,
- 16 -
discord and difference were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the Court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged of abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty.
43. This Court in Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), [(2009)
16 SCC 605 : (2010) 3 SCC (Cri) 367] had an occasion to deal with this aspect of abetment. The Court dealt with the dictionary meaning of the word "instigation" and "goading". The Court opined that there should be intention to provoke, incite or encourage the doing of an act by the latter. Each person's suicidability pattern is different from the others. Each person has his own idea of self-esteem and self-respect. Therefore, it is impossible to lay down any straitjacket formula in dealing with such cases. Each case has to be decided on the basis of its own facts and circumstances.
44. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained.
45. The intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court are clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and this act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he/she committed suicide."
10. In view of the above, it is quite clear that in order to bring the case within the purview of 'Abetment' under Section 107 IPC, there has to be an evidence with regard to the instigation, conspiracy or intentional aid on the part of the accused. For the purpose proving the charge under Section 306 IPC, also there has to be an evidence
- 17 -
with regard to the positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid to drive a person to commit suicide."
(Emphasis supplied) In the light of the afore-narrated facts, which are undisputed and the judgments of the Apex Court (supra), permitting further proceedings to continue against the petitioner would run foul of the judgments rendered by the Apex Court as quoted supra and result in miscarriage of justice.
11. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
i) The petition is allowed.
ii) The entire proceedings in C.C.No.34 of 2017 pending on the file of the Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Sira, Tumkur are quashed, qua the
- 18 -
Section 306 of IPC. The findings will not be applicable to the accused No.1. The concerned Court shall not be swayed or bound by the observations made in the course of this order.
Sd/-
JUDGE
DH