Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    PRAGNA HARDIPSINH ZALA v. KRISHNAKUMAR VERISALJI JADEJA

    C/SA/152/2023 ORDER DATED: 01/05/2023

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

    R/SECOND APPEAL NO. 152 of 2023 With

    CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR STAY) NO. 1 of 2023 In R/SECOND APPEAL NO. 152 of 2023

    ==========================================================

    PRAGNA HARDIPSINH ZALA

    Versus

    KRISHNAKUMAR VERISALJI JADEJA

    ========================================================== Appearance:

    MR DAIFRAZ HAVEWALLA(3982) for the Appellant(s) No. 1 for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2

    ==========================================================

    CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJENDRA M. SAREEN

    Date : 01/05/2023

    ORAL ORDER

    1. Present Second Appeal has been preferred by the appellant - original appellant / defendant the concurrent findings of the learned courts below arising out of the suit for recovery of possession and permanent injunction.

    2. Factual matrix of the case is as under:

    2.1. It is the case of the plaintiff that he is the uncle of the defendant no. 1. The mother of the defendant no. 1 was the sister of the plaintiff. The defendant no. 2 is the husband of the defendant no. 1. The plaintiff is the owner of the suit property, which has been purchased by him by his self acquired income. The plaintiff has been residing at Mumbai, and as the suit property was vacant in good faith on humanitarian ground, in the year 2002, without taking any rent or consideration, plaintiff has accommodated his sister Jayaben by permitting her to stay in the suit property.

    Page 1 of 15

    Jayaben expired pm 18.09.2007, and after her demise the appellants herein were not returning back the possession of the suit property. Notice dated 27.11.2014 for vacating the possession was served by the plaintiff upon the defendants, inspite of which the defendants did not hand over the possession. Therefore the plaintiff filed a suit for getting the possession of the suit property. The said Suit was numbered as Special Civil Suit No. 117 of 2015 before the Ld. 5th Addi. Sr. Civil Judge, Ahmedabad (Rural) at Mirzapur, Ahmedabad.

    2.2. In response to the issuance of the summons by the Trial Court, the defendant herein entered an appearance and filed a written statement. The sum and substance of the case of the appellant before the trial court was that the property was originally of the ownership of the opponent no. 1 herein. The same was given to the mother of the appellant herein since the year 1995, and the mother of the appellant herein was regularly paying the rent of the said property. And after the demise of the mother of the appellant, the appellant was regularly paying the rent of the property.

    2.3. In addition to the payment of the rent, the appellant also was undertaking the renovation and other maintenance expenses of the property in question. The opponent no. 1 herein used to consider the same as an amount paid towards the rent of the premises. On many occasions the rent amount was directly deposited by the applicant into the bank account of the opponent. It was also contended that the opponent no. 1 herein came up with a false and

    Page 2 of 15

    concocted story praying for the relief's as were prayed for by him before the trial court.

    2.4. The lawyer appointed by the appellant herein only remained present and submitted a reply before the trial court. Thereafter the concerned lawyer did not remain present before the trial court. Therefore the case of the applicant herein was not properly represented and the same went on practically ex-parte.

    2.5. After and leading the evidence the learned 5the Additional Senior Civil Judge, Ahmedabad (Rural) at Mirzapur, Ahmedabad allowed the suit vide judgment and order dated 09/03/2022, and directed the defendant - appellant herein to return back the possession of suit property to the plaintiff, situated on Block No. 657, Row House No. 17, Aavishkar Bungalows, Bopal, Anmedabad.

    2.6. Against the aforesaid judgement and decree passed by the trial court, the original defendant preferred an appeal before the District Court being Regular Civil Appeal No. 08 of 2023. The 2nd Addl. District & Sessions Judge, Ahmedabad (Rural) at Mirzpur, District : Ahmedabad, after hearing both the sides, dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order passed by the trial court. Hence, against the concurrent findings of facts recorded by both the courts below, the appellants have preferred the present Second Appeal.

    3. Heard Mr.Daifraz Havewalla, learned advocate for the

    Page 3 of 15

    appellant at length.

    4. I have examined the findings of both the courts on the issue raised in the suit. Upon examination of the judgement and order of both the courts below, no infirmity, illegality, perversity or impropriety is pointed out in the concurrent findings of the facts rendered by the courts below by Mr.Daifraz, learned advocate. Not only that, the learned advocate for the appellant is unable to show to this court any finding recorded by the learned courts is without any evidence or there is any illegality in the findings.

    5. In the facts and circumstances of the case, this court does not find any error or law in the concurrent findings of the learned courts below. In exercise of powers under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, jurisdiction is confined to substantial question of law only. Here in this case, no substantial question of law has been raised so as to enable this Court to admit the present appeal.

    6. The scope of Second Appeal under section 100 is limited. Second Appeal is competent only if it involves, at the stage of admission, substantial question of law. High Court can interfere with the concurrent findings of fact, if the findings are perverse but the perversity should be apparent on the face of record.

    7. Here in this appeal, the question of law raised cannot be said to be substantial question of law and there are question of law but not the substantial question of law.

    Page 4 of 15

    8. In the case of Easwari Versus Parvathi and others,. reported in (2014) 15 SCC 255, it is held that High Court can entertain a Second Appeal on a substantial question of law and it has absolutely no jurisdiction to entertain the Second Appeal on the ground of erroneous findings of fact, however, gross error seems to be looked into. High Court can interfere in the concurrent findings of facts in the Second Appeal if the appellate court has not properly appreciated the evidence on record.

    9. In the case of Samina Khatun, AIR 1995 Gauhati 104, also it is held that High Court can only entertain Second Appeal only on substantial question of law. High Court has absolutely no jurisdiction to entertain Second Appeal on the ground of erroneous findings of fact.

    10. As laid down in the case of State of Haryana Versus Khalsa Motors Limited, reported in (1990) 4 SCC 659, on the basis of evidence on record it is held that the trial court and first appellate court has given concurrent findings of facts and the High Court cannot reverse the said findings under ordinary circumstances.

    11. In the case of C.Doddanarayana Reddy & Ors. Vs. C. Jayarama Reddy & Ors., reported in (2020) 4 SCC 659, the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed and held as under :-

    "25. The question as to whether a substantial

    Page 5 of 15

    question of law arises, has been a subject matter of interpretation by this Court. In the judgment reported as Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Anjuman-E-Ismail Madris-Un-Niswan (1999) 6 SCC 343, it was held that findings of the fact could not have been interfered within the second appeal. This Court held as under:

    "12. This Court had repeatedly held that the power of the High Court to interfere in second appeal under Section 100 CPC is limited solely to decide a substantial question of law, if at all the same arises in the case. It has deprecated the practice of the High Court routinely interfering in pure findings of fact reached by the courts below without coming to the conclusion that the said finding of fact is either perverse or not based on material on record.

    13. In Ramanuja Naidu v. V. Kanniah Naidu (1996 3 SCC 392), this Court held:

    "It is now well settled that concurrent findings of fact of trial court and first appellate court cannot be interfered with by the High Court in exercise of its 8 (1999) 6 SCC 343 jurisdiction

    Page 6 of 15

    under Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code. The Single Judge of the High Court totally misconceived his jurisdiction in deciding the second appeal under Section 100 of the Code in the way he did."

    14. In Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty (1996 6 SCC 166), this Court held :

    "Interference with the concurrent findings of the courts below by the High Court under Section 100 CPC must be avoided unless warranted by compelling reasons. In any case, the High Court is not expected to reappreciate the evidence just to re- place the findings of the lower courts. … Even assuming that another view is possible on a reappreciation of the same evidence, that should not have been done by the High Court as it cannot be said that the view taken by the first appellate court was based on no material."

    15. And again in Secy., Taliparamba Education Soci- ety v. Moothedath Mallisseri

    Page 7 of 15

    Illath M.N. (1997 4 SCC 484), this Court held:

    (SCC p. 486, para 5) "The High Court was grossly in error in trenching upon the appreciation of evidence under Section 100 CPC and recording reverse finding of fact which is impermissible."

    26. In a judgment reported as Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v. Savitkibai Sopan Gujar & Ors.9, this Court held that from a given set of circumstances if two inferences are possible then the one drawn by the lower appellate court is binding on the High Court. In the said case, the First Appellate Court set aside the judgment of the trial court. It was held that the High Court can interfere if the conclusion drawn by the lower court was erroneous being contrary to mandatory provisions of law applicable or if it is a settled position on the basis of a pronouncement made by the 9 (1999) 3 SCC 722 court or based upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence. This Court held as under:

    "5. It is not within the domain of the High Court to investigate the grounds on which findings were arrived at, by the last court of fact, being the first appellate court. It is true that the lower appellate court should not ordinarily reject

    Page 8 of 15

    witnesses accepted by the trial court in respect of credibility but even where it has rejected the witnesses accepted by the trial court, the same is no ground for interference in second appeal when it is found that the appellate court had given satisfactory reasons for doing so. In a case where from a given set of circumstances two inferences are possible, one drawn by the lower appellate court is binding on the High Court in second appeal. Adopting any other approach is not permissible. The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the opinion of the first appellate court unless it is found that the conclusions drawn by the tower appellate court were erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law applicable of its settled position on the basis of pronouncements made by the apex Court, or was based upon in inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence."

    Page 9 of 15

    27. In another judgment reported as Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari, this Court held as under:

    "14. A point of law which admits of no two opinions may be a proposition of law but cannot be a substantial question of law. To be substantial, a question of law must be debatable, not previously settled by law of the land or a binding precedent, and must have a material bearing on the decision of the case, if answered either way, in so far as the rights of the parties before it are concerned. To be a question of law involving in the case there must be first a foundation for it laid in the pleadings and the question should emerge from the sustainable findings of fact arrived at by court of facts and it must be necessary to decide that question of law for a just and proper decision of the case. An entirely new point raised for the first time before the High Court is not a question involved in the case unless it goes to the root of the matter. It will, therefore, depend on the facts and

    Page 10 of 15

    circumstance of each case whether a question 10 (2001) 3SCC 179 of law is a substantial one and involved in the case, or not; the paramount overall consideration being the need for striking a judicious balance between the indispensable obligation to do justice at all stages and impelling necessity of avoiding prolongation in the life of any lis."

    28. Recently in another judgment reported as State of Rajasthan v. Shiv Dayal11, it was held that a concurrent finding of the fact is binding, unless it is pointed out that it was recorded de hors the pleadings or it was based on no evidence or based on misreading of the material on records and documents. The Court held as under:

    "When any concurrent finding of fact is assailed in second appeal, the appellant is entitled to point out that it is bad in law because it was recorded de hors the pleadings or it was based on no evidence or it was based on misreading of material documentary evidence or it was recorded against any provision of law and lastly, the decision is one which

    Page 11 of 15

    no Judge acting judicially could reasonably have reached. (see observation made by learned Judge Vivian Bose,J. as His Lordship then was a Judge of the Nagpur High Court in Rajeshwar Vishwanath Mamidwar & Ors. vs. Dashrath Narayan Chilwelkar & Ors., AIR 1943 Nagpur 117 Para 43)."

    29. The learned High Court has not satisfied the tests laid down in the aforesaid judgements. Both the courts, the trial court and the learned First Appellate Court, have examined the School Leaving Certificate and returned a finding that the date of birth does not stand proved from such certificate. May be the High Court could have taken a different view acting as a trial court but once, two 11 (2019) 8 SCC 637 courts have returned a finding which is not based upon any misreading of material documents, nor is recorded against any provision of law, and neither can it be said that any judge acting judicially and reasonably could not have reached such a finding, then, the High Court cannot be said to have erred. Resultantly, no substantial question of law arose for consideration before the High Court.

    12. In the recent decision in the Case of Kapil Kumar Vs.

    Page 12 of 15

    Raj Kumar reported in (2022) 10 SCC 281, the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed and held as under :-

    "10. At the outset, it is required to be noted that as such there were concurrent findings of facts recorded by the learned trial court as well as the learned first appellate court on execution of pronote by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff. The said findings were on appreciation of entire evidence on record. Therefore, unless the findings recorded by the courts below were found to be perverse, the same were not required to be interfered with by the High Court in exercise of powers under section 100

    CPC.

    11. Even the substantial question of law framed by the High Court cannot be said to be as such a question of law much less substantial question of law. From the impugned judgement and order passed by the High Court, it appears that as such no specific substantial question of law seems to have been framed by the High Court. However, it appears that what was considered by the High Court was whether the plaintiff proves the execution of pronote and the receipt by leading cogent evidence."

    Page 13 of 15

    13. Having heard the learned advocate for the appellant and considering the judgements of both the courts below, it appears that though opportunity was given to the appellant for cross examination of the plaintiffs, the opportunity was not availed. It is to be noted that the suit has not been decreed ex-parte but it was bi-parte. The appellant was having opportunity to place cogent and convincing documents on record substantiating his claim being a tenant and claim of renovation work for the maintenance of the property. However, no such evidence has been brought on record by the appellant. The learned trial court appreciating the evidence on record has rightly decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff and the appellate court, after re-appreciating the evidence on record has also rightly dismissed the appeal. The contentions raised by the learned advocate for the appellant is not sustainable.

    14. This appeal, as stated above, is devoid of any substantial question of law. Both the courts have rightly decided the issue between the parties in the right perspective. The trial court and the first appellate court has dealt with issue involved in the suit. The plaintiff has placed on record cogent and convincing evidence to justify his claim. The appellant - original defendant has failed to prove his case before the trial court as well as the appellate Court. This Court does not find any substance in the present

    Page 14 of 15

    Second Appeal as the same is devoid of any merits both on facts and law and hence the same is dismissed at admission stage.

    On dismissal of the main Second Appeal, the Civil Application No.1 of 2023 for stay stands rejected.

    (RAJENDRA M. SAREEN,J)

    R.H. PARMAR

    Page 15 of 15

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PRAGNA HARDIPSINH ZALA v. KRISHNAKUMAR VERISALJI JADEJA
    (May 1, 2023)