AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns a civil revision petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging the legality and validity of an order dated 30.12.2020 passed by the learned Commercial Court-cum-XIII Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar. The impugned order returned the plaint on the ground that the suit was not filed within the limitation period, specifically questioning the applicability of Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The suit relates to specific performance of a development agreement dated 25.12.2008 and an alternative prayer for refund of money paid under the agreement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to the suit filed for specific performance and/or recovery of money paid under the development agreement.
  2. Whether the plaint was rightly returned by the learned court below on the ground of limitation without considering the plaintiff's submissions and evidence.
  3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to seek reliefs against certain defendants (Defendant Nos. 6 to 11) who were not parties to the original development agreement but have taken possession of the suit property.
  4. Whether the plaint complies with procedural requirements such as payment of court fee for injunction and filing of a declaration on oath as per Order VI Rule 15A CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Development Agreement dated 25.12.2008 did not make time the essence of the contract and contained no clause for cancellation; the cancellation notice dated 22.04.2015 was void, thus there is a continuous cause of action.
  • Rs.1 crore was paid at the time of executing the Development Agreement and Rs.4 crores as Security Deposit in the Memorandum of Understanding; these amounts are recoverable within 12 years under Article 62 of the Limitation Act, even if specific performance is time-barred.
  • Defendant Nos. 6 to 11 have taken possession of the suit property and are necessary parties for specific performance of the contract; without their joinder, the suit is not maintainable.
  • The plaintiff is entitled to seek distinct reliefs of specific performance and recovery of amounts paid under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963.
  • Separate court fee for injunction has been paid as required under section 26C.
  • A statement of facts cum declaration has been filed as per the prescribed form under Order VI Rule 15A CPC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P. Muthuswamy v. K. Arumugam and others (Madras High Court, 2016-5-L.W.820) Clarification on limitation periods under Articles 54 and 62 of the Limitation Act: Article 54 applies to suits for specific performance (3 years), Article 62 applies to suits for recovery of money secured by immovable property (12 years). The court relied on this precedent to observe that the alternative prayer for refund of advance amount in a suit for specific performance attracts the limitation period under Article 62, thus permitting the suit to proceed on that basis.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court noted that the impugned order returning the plaint on limitation grounds was premature. It emphasized that limitation is a mixed question of fact and law and must be determined after considering pleadings and evidence. The court observed that the plaintiff's submissions, supported by the precedent of P. Muthuswamy v. K. Arumugam, demonstrated that even if specific performance is barred by limitation under Article 54, the alternative claim for recovery of money paid under the agreement falls within the 12-year limitation period under Article 62. The court also noted the necessity of joining Defendant Nos. 6 to 11 as parties for effective relief. Consequently, the court set aside the impugned order and directed the learned court below to admit the plaint and proceed in accordance with law, allowing the defendants to raise their defenses.

Holding and Implications

The civil revision petition is disposed of by setting aside the impugned order dated 30.12.2020.

The learned court below is directed to take on record the plaint and proceed with the suit in accordance with law. The decision allows the suit to continue despite the earlier rejection on limitation grounds, emphasizing that limitation issues require detailed consideration of facts and evidence. No costs were imposed, and pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, stand closed. This ruling does not create new precedent but clarifies the procedural propriety of admitting plaints where limitation is contested and alternative reliefs are claimed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    M/s. VasconEngineers Limited v. M/s Paradigm Corporation Pvt.Ltd

    HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN

    AND

    HONOURABLE DR.JUSTICE C.SUMALATHA

    C.R.P.No.390 OF 2021

    ORDER: (Per Hon'ble Sri Justice Ujjal Bhuyan)

    1. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner.

    2. Having regard to the order that is proposed to be passed and considering the stage at which the impugned order was passed, issuance of notice to respondents may not be necessary.

    3. This civil revision petition has been filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the legality and validity of the order dated 30.12.2020 passed by the learned Commercial Court-cum-XIII Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar.

    4. Impugned order dated 30.12.2020 reads as under:-

    "Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner. Not satisfied about the applicability of Article 62 of Limitation Act as this is not for enforcing payment of money secured by mortgage or otherwise charged upon immovable property. Hence return the suit for not being filed within time".

    5. We find from the documents on record that learned court below had put up six queries to the plaintiff (petitioner herein) which we reproduce hereunder:

    i. As per the legal notice dt.22.04.2015 and office copy of rejoinder notice dated 10.07.2015 vide documents Nos.13 & 15, how this suit is within time.

    1

    ii. As per document No.18 Joint Development Agreement-cum- GPA dated 20.04.2018, how the plaintiff is entitled to seek reliefs against D6 to D11, as prayed in the plaint?

    iii. Explain how the plaintiff is entitled to seek reliefs against D6 to D11, as they were not made parties in Development agreement dated 25.12.2008 (Doc.No.3).

    iv. Explain how the plaintiff is entitled to seek distinct reliefs.

    v. Separate Court Fee for permanent injunction is not paid.

    vi. The plaint shall contain a declaration on oath from the plaintiff in the form of 'Statement of Truth' as set out in the Appendix of Act and as prescribed under Order VI Rule 15A of CPC.

    6. On 17.12.2020, plaintiff (petitioner) made detailed submissions on the six queries put up by the court. Submissions of the plaintiff (petitioner) read as under:-

    Objection No.1

    Explanation - As per Development Agreement dated 25.12.2008, time was not the essence of contract. Further there is no clause for cancellation of Development Agreement in the said Agreement. Since it is cancelled by Notice dated 22.04.2015 which itself void, there is no need to ask Declaration if the act is itself void. Therefore there is continuous cause of action as far as the enforcement of Development Agreement is concerned. Further at the time of execution of Development Agreement dated 25.12.2008, Rs.1 crore was paid and at the time of execution of Memorandum of Understanding Rs.4 crores were paid as Security Deposit. As per Madras High Court Judgment in Second Appeal No.426/2015 delivered by Hon'ble Justice K.Ravichandrabaabu between P.Muthuswamy v. K.Arumugam and others, Hon'ble Court has observed that even if relief of Specific Performance is out of limitation then also recovery of money paid towards earnest amount can be recovered within 12 years as per Article 62 of Limitation Act, 1963 in suit for specific performance. Now even if, for the sake of consideration it is held that relief of Specific Performance is out of limitation, then as per Article 62 of Limitation Act, 1963, recovery of

    2

    Security Deposit amount can be made within 12 years in suit for specific performance. Therefore suit is very well within limitation. Objection Nos. 2 and 3

    Since Defendant No.6 to 11 have taken over the suit property for development before filing of suit, therefore it is necessary party to suit or else suit will be dismissed for non-joinder of necessary party. For relief of Specific Performance, it is necessary to join Defendant No.6 to 11 as necessary party without which decree would not be enforceable. Further this is not suit simplicitor for Recovery but for Specific Performance, so Plaintiff is entitled to seek relief against Defendant No.6 to 11. At the most Court will come to conclusion that Defendant No.6 to 11 are misjoinder as party to suit. But without Defendant No.6 to 11 suit is not maintainable. Objection No.4:

    Since plaintiff is asking for Specific Performance along with Recovery of amount paid as per Section 20 of Specific Relief Act, 1963, plaintiff is entitled to ask distinct relief of Recovery. Further since Defendant No.6 to 11 has stepped into suit property, without their document be declared null and void as per Section 34 of Specific Relief Act, 1963, decree of specific performance cannot be enforced. Or else plaintiffs suit shall suffer from inadequate prayers. Granting prayers or not is the discretion of court. Objection No.5:

    For the relief of injunction the plaintiff values the suit for Rs.10,000/- and a fixed court fee of Rs.786/- is paid u/s 26C.

    Objection No.6:

    The statement of facts cum declaration is filed. Call on bench for hearing.

    7. Notwithstanding the above, the plaint was returned by the learned court below by holding that it was not satisfied about applicability of Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1963.

    8. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the main prayer made in the plaint is for specific performance of the development

    3

    agreement dated 25.12.2008 and an alternative prayer has been made for refund of money for failure to comply with the development agreement. Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1963, as per which the limitation is 12 years for filing of suit to enforce payment of money secured by a mortgage or otherwise charged upon immovable property and the limitation begins when the money sued for becomes due. He has also referred to a decision of the Madras High Court in P.MUTHUSWAMY V. K.ARUMUGAM and others1.

    9. Submissions made have been considered.

    10. Paragraph 25 of P.Muthuswamy (supra) on which reliance has been placed is extracted hereunder:

    "Perusal of Article 54 and 62 of the Limitation Act would certainly indicate that both are not acting on the same field and on the other hand, they are to be applied only in respect of the suit for which respective Article is meant for. Needless to say that as per Article 54 of the Limitation Act, a suit for specific performance of a contract has to be filed within a period of three years from the date fixed for the performance or if no such date is fixed, from the date of the refusal of such performance. At the same time, it is to be noted that the plaintiff is not precluded from seeking an alternative prayer for refund of the advance amount. Such alternative prayer, certainly, is not a consequential prayer to the other relief of specific performance and on the other hand, such alternative prayer itself will have the character of the main relief, however, alternatively sought for. If such alternative prayer for refund of advance amount is also sought for in a suit for specific performance, certainly, the period of limitation to be considered in respect of that relief is concerned, Article 62 of the Limitation

    1 201 6-5-L.W.820

    4

    Act alone has to be applied and not the limitation period fixed for specific performance. Article 62 of the Limitation Act grants 12 years time for enforcing payment of money secured by a mortgage or otherwise charged upon immovable property".

    11. Upon hearing learned counsel for the petitioner and on going through the materials on record, we are of the view that the plaint submitted by the petitioner may require to be proceeded with by the learned court below, subject, of course, to the defence taken up by defendants in their written statement. It is not a case where the plaint is to be returned at the threshold. Needless to say, limitation is a mixed question of fact and law and the question whether Article 62 of the Limitation Act, 1963 applies to the facts and circumstances of the case would depend upon the pleadings and evidence tendered. Order dated 30.12.2020 appears to us to be premature.

    12. Consequently, we set aside the impugned order dated 30.12.2020 and direct the learned court below to take on record the plaint of the petitioner and proceed with the same in accordance with law.

    13. Civil revision petition is, accordingly, disposed of. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed. No costs. ____________________

    UJJAL BHUYAN , J

    _______________________

    DR. C.SUMALATHA, J

    Date: 25.10.2021. Lrkm

    5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/s. VasconEngineers Limited v. M/s Paradigm Corporation Pvt.Ltd
    (Oct 25, 2021)