Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institution Employees Contributory Provident Funds Insurance Pension Rules, 1964,
  • U.P. State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules 1964.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institution Employees Contributory Provident Funds Insurance Pension Rules, 1964,
  • U.P. State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules 1964.
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of U.P. And 3 Others v. Mahaveer Singh Yadav

    1

    Chief Justice's Court Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL DEFECTIVE No. - 560 of 2016

    Appellant :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others Respondent :- Mahaveer Singh Yadav Counsel for Appellant :- Rama Nand Pandey Counsel for Respondent :- Awadh Narain Rai

    AND

    Case :- SPECIAL APPEAL DEFECTIVE No. - 561 of 2016

    Appellant :- State Of U.P. And 3 Others

    Respondent :- Mahesh Prasad Srivastava

    Counsel for Appellant :- Rama Nand Pandey

    Counsel for Respondent :- Awadh Narain Rai

    Hon'ble Dilip B. Bhosale,Chief Justice Hon'ble Yashwant Varma,J.

    (i) Order on the delay condonation applications:

    These applications seek condonation of delay of 2 years 121 days in filing the Special Appeals. Since sufficient cause has been shown in the affidavit filed in support of the delay condonation applications and no objection has been raised on behalf of the respondent to the said applications, the delay in filing the Appeals is condoned. The applications stand disposed of.

    (ii) Order on the appeals:

    Heard Sri R.N. Pandey, learned Standing Counsel for the appellants and Sri Awadh Narain Rai for the respondents. The State is in appeal questioning the correctness of a judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge on 18 April 2014 in terms of which the writ petition preferred came to be disposed

    2

    of finally permitting the petitioners therein to deposit the management contribution within a period of six weeks so as to avail benefits under a pension scheme.

    The learned Single Judge while disposing of the writ petitions has taken note of the judgment in Smt. Shanti Solanki Vs. State of U.P. and others1as also a subsequent judgment rendered by a learned Single Judge in Buddhiram Vs. State of U.P and others2.

    The issue itself arises and is centered upon the right of the petitioners to be granted the benefits of a pension scheme brought into force in respect of educational institutions in terms of the U.P. State Aided Educational Institutions Employees Contributory Provident Fund Insurance Pension Rules 1964. The original petitioners claimed to have been duly appointed as Assistant Teachers in institutions which were administered by the U.P. Basic Education Board, Allahabad. These institutions are stated to have been taken on the grant-in- aid list by the State Government on dates subsequent to the appointment of the original petitioners.

    A learned Single Judge in Smt. Shanti Solanki had while noticing the provisions of the 1964 Rules struck down the cut off date prescribed by the State Government for depositing the management contribution component. Consequent to the coming into force of a new pension scheme on 1 April 2005, the view taken in Smt. Shanti Solanki came to be reiterated in

    Buddhiram. The bone of contention inter partes appears to be as to whether the period of service spent by an Assistant Teacher in an

    1 . Writ Petition No. 75746 of 2005 decided on 6.9.201 6.

    2 . 2 013 (1) ADJ 2 54

    3

    institution prior to it being taken on the grant-in-aid list is liable to be included while computing qualifying service for the purposes of grant of pension and other benefits.

    The views expressed in Smt. Shanti Solanki and

    Buddhiram again fell for consideration in U.P. Senior Basic Shikshak Sangh Sindhi Vidyalaya Vs. State of U.P. And others3. A Division Bench of the Court after noticing the two decisions referred to above, held as under:-

    "14. The learned single Judge in the said decision has also traced the entire legislative history governing the contributory provident funds and pension scheme applicable in Stated aided educational institution including Junior High Schools as presently involved. We may mention here that the respondent - State has also brought on record Chapter VIII of the old education code that existed prior to the Uttar Pradesh State Aided Educational Institution Employees Contributory Provident Funds Insurance Pension Rules, 1964, and have also brought on record the subsequent Government Orders continuing the 1964 Rules and it's implementation. It is, therefore, not necessary to reproduce the said legislative history at all. Suffice it to say that the applicability of the old scheme was clearly dependent upon the institution being on the grant-in-aid list. The learned single Judge has categorically held that the 1964 Rules are not applicable or attracted when the Institution in question is not on the grant-in-aid list and the same would be applicable if the institution is brought under the grant-in-aid list. Admittedly those teachers, who have been appointed and confirmed prior to 1.4.2005 in an unaided Institution, did not have the benefit of 1964 Rules and, as such, these teachers cannot as a matter of right claim that they should be covered by old Rules and extended the benefit thereof by further depositing of contributory provident funds as was done previously under the new scheme.

    xxx xxx xxx

    17. It is for this reason that the new scheme which has been introduced under the policy dated 28.3.2005 w.e.f. 1.4.2005 also recites that it will apply to State aided Educational Institutions which clearly means that those institutions, which were brought under the grant-in-aid list thereafter, would only be entitled to the benefit under the new scheme and not of the benefits of the earlier scheme. Thus, if the 1964 Rules provide for extending of benefits to only State aided Institutions, then a

    3 . 2016 (1) ADJ 667 (DB) (LB)

    4

    mandamus cannot be issued to modify the same to apply it to unaided institutions."

    .

    The Division Bench in the judgment aforementioned has proceeded to hold that teachers appointed prior to 1 April 2005 in unaided institutions would not be entitled to avail the benefits of the 1964 Rules. It has proceeded to hold that such teachers cannot, as a matter of right, claim to be extended the benefits of depositing the contributory provident fund. It has further observed that the 1964 Rules provided for extension of benefits to only such institutions which were State aided. The view as expressed by the Division Bench in U.P. Senior Basic Shikshak Sangh Sindhi Vidyalaya, which has duly explained both Smt. Shanti Solanki and Buddhiram would, in our considered opinion, warrant reconsideration of the judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge in terms of which the original petitioners have been permitted to deposit the management contribution. This direction has come to be issued based upon the assertion of the original petitioners that the service rendered by them prior to the institutions being taken on the grant-in-aid list was also liable to be taken into consideration. This assertion on the part of the original petitioners merits reconsideration in light of what has been authoritatively pronounced upon and held by the Division Bench in U.P. Senior Basic Shikshak Sangh Sindhi Vidyalaya.

    We accordingly allow these special appeals and set aside the judgments and orders of the learned Single Judge dated 18 April 2014 in Writ A No. 22313 of 2014 (Mahaveer Singh Yadav Vs. State of U.P. And others) and Writ A No. 22314 of 2014 (Mahesh Prasad Srivastava Vs. State of U.P. And others) and restore to the board of the learned Single Judge the

    5

    writ petitioners aforementioned for a decision afresh and in light of what has been observed hereinabove. The parties shall be at liberty to move the learned Single Judge for expeditious disposal of the said writ petitions.

    Order Date :- 22 September 2016

    nethra

    (Dilip B. Bhosale, CJ) (Yashwant Varma, J)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P. And 3 Others v. Mahaveer Singh Yadav
    (Sep 22, 2016)